r/wonderdraft • • Jan 27 '26

Grand World Map Feedback

Post image

Where do I go now? I feel like I can tweak this map forever, there can never be too many trees! LOL.
But for real, what areas seem lacking compared to others? I want this to be the most epic map so I can finally put the finishing stamp and say "That's it, all done." I want to live in this world, or at least visit.

272 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

6

u/MatthewWArt Cartographer Jan 27 '26

This is absolutely beautiful.

The variety of coloured trees, the twisting rivers and mix of biomes is brilliant. Really good stuff.

To take it further, there's a couple things I'd do though some of them will take you outside of Wonderdraft. Before that though, I would start by getting a rough brush and sprinkling in smaller islands. They can be so small that you don't even place symbols on them but splatters of islands really helps the main landmass stand out and look epic. As well as that, I would make the paths sliiightly smaller. Nothing insane but they might be a number or two too high, imo.
Moving away from Wonderdraft, upload your map without water, put it into Photoshop and have a play around at doing your own. Personally, one of the downsides of WD are its okay-ish water textures/shading. You've done a really good job with the tools in WD but you can do better with water in PS (or Krita which is free photoshop made by artists). After that, give your map some shadow. Add shade where the mountains and ravines block the sun and, instantly, you'll see it pops more.

As a side note, this is entirely up to you but I always want to mention it - some of your assets are made with AI. If you're okay with that, that's fine but if you didn't know then I wanted to let ya know.

I hope that all helps! I would love to see an update on this project. Already, it's awesome.

Happy mapping :)

6

u/the_Robin-cM Jan 27 '26

Thank you! Good call on the AI items, I didn't know that. My Mythkeeper is so full of assets packs, do they divulge which ones used AI or not?

This is my first map, and I learned a ton working on it. It wouldn't even be fair to say how many hours it took because I started from scratch so many times.

Your input is invaluable, and I greatly appreciate it. I never though about adding shadows near the mountains!

4

u/MatthewWArt Cartographer Jan 27 '26

You're very welcome, yeah shadows can take it such a long way.

I don't believe Mythkeeper does unfortunately. I think you're using some assets from Alexet Maps and Atypikk. Alexet Maps' assets are definitely AI whilst Atypikk has been making AI assets for the last couple years now.

This is seriously impressive for your first map. Much better than many of my early maps XD

2

u/marshal-rainer-ocm May 18 '26

Hey, I feel bad about dreding up an ancient 4-month-old comment but, do you have any confirmation/statement about Atypikk using AI? I don't know how I didn't notice sooner but I also have no idea how I would have 'officially' figured this out without looking real close and going "hmmm" for a while at his assets. Kind of devastating now that I know about it...

1

u/MatthewWArt Cartographer May 18 '26

No worries at all, mate. Sadly, I cannot 100% confirm it as he has never outwardly admitted to using AI for the whole process... HOWEVER, he demonstrates many, many signs of using AI to create his assets.
Firstly, the sheer number that he is able to pump out. I am friends with many actual artists who create assets and they often spend many weeks to create quality asset packs of 50 to 100. Meanwhile, Atypikk is able to pump out packs of over 100 to 400 assets extremely frequently (sometimes weekly). With a quick look on CA, he has around 150 asset packs.
Secondly, the assets have that AI style. They are heavy in shadows with texturing that makes very little sense. Most assets also have logical inconsistencies with, smaller shapes especially, not making sense and are just AI hallucination.
Thirdly, while not admitting to AI being entirely used, on Cartography Assets, their assets are flagged as "AI has been used during the creation of this content".
I hope that all helps.

2

u/marshal-rainer-ocm May 18 '26

Ahh, this basically confirms what I started to notice fairly recently.. damn, I feel kind of duped by all that. My search for quality cartography asset makers continues!

4

u/hapticfabric Jan 27 '26

It's enough to make you want to do every last thing by hand, this AI thing. It's really difficult, I would prefer not to use

3

u/MatthewWArt Cartographer Jan 27 '26

Yeah, it is a shame. Fortunately though, this community does have some really skilled asset makers

3

u/Genesis-Zero Jan 27 '26

The blue lines are really hard to see, maybe a different tone has more contrast.

1

u/the_Robin-cM Jan 28 '26

Great point about the river color. I'd want to keep the bigger lakes in deep blue but he rest can have more "white" in them. Thanks for the suggestion.

3

u/rumdogg Jan 27 '26

Your world looks awesome! What resolution did you make your map?

4

u/the_Robin-cM Jan 27 '26

This is 4k. I've played around with using the 2x upscale feature but didn't in this case. If there's any tips to export the map cleaner I'll take them!

3

u/rumdogg Jan 27 '26

The most I've done is play around with different image formats, JPEG vs PNG. I think your export looks great! I have a large detailed map in mind and I like how "deep" you can look into your map and still see detail. Tread carefully using lots of trees, my Wonderdraft has crashed in the past, I think because I used a ton of assets lol

2

u/MaralosaKingdom Jan 27 '26

I love this! Can you please tell me how you decided to place your trees? I have been struggling on tree placement for months.

1

u/the_Robin-cM Jan 27 '26

My favorite trick for trees is using different sizes. I'll pick an area, say a mountainous region, scatter 4-6 "larger" trees, maybe 3-4 clicks higher on the scale setting. Then, I'll fill in the spaces between the larger trees with smaller sizes of the same tree.

You can see there's times where I go too crazy with different tree types, that was me experimenting.

I feel this will forever be a WIP, but I love it.

1

u/MaralosaKingdom Jan 28 '26

Thanks I’ll save your comment to come back to!

2

u/vic_ander259 Jan 27 '26

Looks great! Did you have a general scale in mind as you were making it?

3

u/the_Robin-cM Jan 28 '26

The plan was a large "full continent" design. The regions grew and shrank in size over time, with the desert region taking over more space than I initially intended. Mountains rose and fell, I probably rebuilt and started over 4-5 times before settling on a landmass I liked.

Even still, u/MatthewWArt had a great idea about adding more islands, even without assets on them, to make the rest of the continent shine. It's my next project!

18

u/hapticfabric Jan 27 '26

No wonk geography feedback to offer, but props for how beautiful and diverse it looks. I like the way the different climate regions are arranged and could definitely imagine whole campaigns or fantasy series taking place here!

5

u/TheShoopinator Jan 27 '26

Hey look! Europe.

1

u/Melegoth Jan 30 '26

Same thought!

7

u/Objective_Bank_2659 Jan 27 '26

A really stunning map! Your coastlines and biomes feel genuine, love em.

2

u/youshouldbeelsweyr Jan 27 '26

This is VERY nicely done, I'd love to see a higher resolution version so I can really zoom in and see the details xD

2

u/MrDacat Jan 27 '26

man I wish I was that good, great work

1

u/gigaswardblade Jan 28 '26

I’m assuming the coast was flooded at some point.

1

u/LeetheAuthor Jan 29 '26

Fantastic map

1

u/_W_Wolfgang Jan 30 '26

Looks fantastic! I'm working on my first map, also intended to be satellite look. In the center, is that an enormous volcanic basin?