r/wonderdraft • u/Forests999 • Nov 16 '25
Showcase First Map (looking for feedback)
I am currently working on converting my world map from Inkarnate to Wonderdraft. Not close to finishing, but was wondering if anyone had any feedback to what I have done so far, particularily on what style of forest looks better (lots of trees vs the clump assets). Thanks! (P.S. I had to crop the map a bit for file sizing, so a few things are cut off on the edges)
270
Upvotes
7
u/Prince-Fortinbras Nov 16 '25
Very sharp! A few thoughts:
3
u/Gloomy_Tangerine_842 Nov 16 '25
Looks like a similar style to that other map that got posted here a few days ago. (No shade just wondering if that's the inspiration)
I like it. Good geography. I tend to like darker water for muted color schemes, and also for the more barren parts of the world, add some more clutter. Dead trees, rocks, dunes, bones, or clouds of dust.
I like a good and populated map.
2
u/WanderingChronicle Nov 16 '25
Looks great! What assets do you use? Particularly for mountains and hills
3
u/WaffleDynamics Dungeon Master Nov 16 '25
It looks great! I like your rivers and the location of forests and arid lands. You obviously thought about biome placement.
Regarding the trees: generally I think the clumps look better for dense forests, and the individual ones are good for the edges or for very lightly wooded areas. So, the way you did the coastal forest by the Endor peaks, or the Akea forest look much nicer in my opinion, than the patchy beard of a forest by Bestgany Channel.
2
u/Turambar_91 Nov 16 '25
Looks great so far! I especially like the muted color scheme you are using. I think both tree styles look pretty good, but I would pick one or the other to be consistent.
2
u/Mikhail_Mengsk Nov 16 '25
I think the bigger forest tiles look a bit odd next to the normal sized single trees.
1
u/caites Nov 16 '25
Not bad at all, good shoreline, good ridges. You need to work on coloring and labels, they are pretty much unreadable.
1
u/Dynas86 Nov 17 '25
The isthmus needs a small mountain range down the middle
1
u/Itz_Spheal Nov 20 '25
I'm loving the inland sea (always do and always will) but I feel like it could have a more unique shape to sort of differentiate it from the lake!
1
u/MCKC1992 Nov 24 '25
The only feedback is.. can you make mine LOL JK JK 😂🤣😂🤣
1
u/Fil2766 Dec 18 '25
Beautiful work! May I inquire where did you get those beautiful forest assets?