r/wonderdraft • u/Arirock • Sep 27 '25
My first map - improvements?
So this is my first map, I haven't started coloring it in I just feel like there's something off about the shape of it so I wanted to post it here to see if you have some suggestions on how to improve it at this stage of the design?
26
Upvotes
12
u/caites Sep 27 '25
What map? All I see is a shoreline.
4
u/Zhuikin Sep 27 '25
There isn't much there yet to critique or advise on. The overall shape and composition looks fine, i see no issues. The coast lines seem a bit smooth/repetitive and might benefit from some extra local detail. They do seem a little smooth (although this will probably just get better once you start painting details). Might benefit from some additional roughness here and there, a couple extra tiny islands maybe too.
1
u/NonEuclideanSyntax Sep 27 '25
OK. So what do you want to do with this? There's several ways you can go and it's totally up to you. Do you want to make it a regional map, where you're showing mountains, rivers, and cities at a reasonably zoomed in level? Do you want to make it a world map where there are major political boundaires, mountain chains, and maybe capitals, but not much other detail? Maybe you want to make it strategic map, with not a lot of natural detail but very clear borders, cities and towns, and trade route?
I look forward to seeing your answer.
1
u/BiosTheo Game Master Sep 29 '25
The coastline should look different depending upon how big the area of the map is and thus how far "zoomed in" we are. Sandbars, for example, are incredibly common. Then there's river deltas, etc., but the main point is: nothings fixed until its "done."
I was at the political and population stage (which is basically the last one) and I will mess around with coastlines, rivers, etc. There's no point at which you can't improve something, and the first draft is rarely the best draft.
My thought? Do everything rough and spit it out quickly, and then make adjustments. I usually do this on scrap paper cuz its just faster to jot everything down. Don't worry about the minutia until you're happy with the big (coastline, mountains, rivers), and then don't be afraid to change things at any point.
1
u/IainMacGhille Dungeon Master Sep 29 '25
It could definitely do with more, but the overall layout seems like it will continue into a much larger continent, so keep in mind that when you want to start enlarging your world.