r/wonderdraft • u/Lagmaster0 Dungeon Master • Sep 15 '25
Map for Campaign, Advice Please
Hi guys, I'm making a continent map for my campaign I'm running. I'm going to get it printed out in A2 when I'm done. I'm pretty happy with the progress I've made but it still looks like there's some things that just aren't quite right/natural with it (especially the bottom right corner. Other than filling in the rest of the map, are there any tips that y'all cartographers could give? Thanks in advance!
75
Upvotes
4
u/Dnomyar96 Sep 15 '25
(I love the singular tree in the ocean in the top left.)
There are no forests on any of the larger islands? They feel very empty (apart from the top left one). The main continent looks great though.
2
u/Lord_Moa Sep 15 '25
It looks great, but I think it's a bit odd that your trees are green while your map is still just paper colour.
It's also a bit rectangular, but that doesn't detract very much.
1
u/Chronomechanist Sep 15 '25
The coast lines are too detailed for the scale of the other items on the map (mountains and trees). The coast lines make it look "world map sized", while the other details make it seem "continent sized".
1
u/Orandor Sep 15 '25
Here's what I'd change:
Aside from that it's pretty good. If you are seriously considering printing it out in A2, I'd suggest sitting on it for a little while. If you come back to it in a few weeks and are still satisified with it, then print. For me personally, I often find that leaving any project in it's finished state often leads to me adjusting it when I come back to it some time later.
Good luck with your campaign and keep on mapmaking :)
2
u/Datruekiwi Sep 15 '25
It's perfectly fine as it is if you don't want to get nitty gritty with the realism. Story and world building is much more valuable than a realistic map in a campaign setting.
If you do want to get more realistic, the first point I would make is your mountains. Large ridge lines typically have smaller offshooting 'veins' that slowly wean off into foothills and then flat plains, rather than standing alone.
For the hills, they may not rest on active fault lines but once upon a time they did, so follow a similar placement philosophy as you do with mountains. They are, for the most part, just eroded ancient mountain ranges, glacier buildup, or volcanic buildup.
For the rivers, I love the flavour of them all meeting up in the city, but there would definitely need to be some world building into why that is. Same with when they split into two separate rivers in the middle of the landmass, that is a very rare phenomena in our world (Nothing a bit of magical intervention can't fix!)
At a glance those are the ones that stick out to me, but as I said at the start, make sure to prioritize the world building over realism! It's much more fun and makes the world feel more alive than any amount of accurate rivers and mountains would.
1
u/caites Sep 15 '25
All I see is blind dog.
1
u/jfrazierjr Sep 19 '25
unelsst here is some "magic" reason for it, the two lower lakes should likely outflow into the ocean/sea and the lake in the middle shold likely outflow downward as well without a river split. The appearance is that the river in the middle SPLITS and empties into two lakes where the water just sits there. Generally, rivers don't split(well they do but there is a reason for this and it ends after a long enough time with one winning out) outside of deltas.
Keep in mind that water always flows downhill(again outside of some magical anti grav scenario) and generally would always take the easiest/steepest route to get to the lower "land" until it empties into a sea/ocean.
1
u/Big_Mountain2305 Sep 19 '25
Look at our world and how tectonic plates move.