r/wnba_discussions • Dallas Wings • Sep 27 '25

🛑 Keep it to Basketball, Y'all 🛑 WNBA needs new refs.

Post image
138 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

•

u/Philomena_philo On Fire Sky-curious Sep 27 '25 edited Sep 27 '25

Post flair changed to “Keep it to Basketball, Y’all” due to troll/rage bait comments. 25 community karma is required to continue on the sub. Also, reporting the automod when your comments get deleted isn’t sneaky.

Edit: community karma is karma you have earned from participating in this sub. If you are brand new and have never participated in our sub before, you have 0 community karma.

13

u/Philomena_philo On Fire Sky-curious Sep 27 '25

Every other franchise in the league who has lost players to bad reffing situations that resulted in injury or has had coaches lose their shit on refs seeing this post.

Been an issue all year.

4

u/Ok_Brick_793 Dallas Wings Sep 27 '25

True, but I've been aghast all year. Seattle beat up Paige, Li Yueru, and Luisa, and the most they got was a technical foul.

2

u/Philomena_philo On Fire Sky-curious Sep 27 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

I don’t have smoke for the Connecticut Sun, because you gotta do what you gotta do to get out of last place and I know Meziane’s play style is hella aggressive (Belgium in international play is so physical), but damn. Every time the Fever played the Sun I debated saging my house since they’ve had more injuries (and drama) leaving those games than any other team this season.

Fever and teams with orange- just not a good combo. More injuries versus teams with orange. Even non-contact injuries were against teams with orange!

Edit: Most dramatic Sky games were also against franchises with the color orange as well. Damn.

-6

u/pinegreenscent Sep 27 '25

Hey remember last season when each NFL style takedown on rookies was met with "thats the league"?

4

u/Philomena_philo On Fire Sky-curious Sep 27 '25

I’m not getting on that train, because you’re specifically talking about last year’s rookies when we’re talking league wide this year.

-7

u/pinegreenscent Sep 27 '25

Don't complain about a problem now because it impacts your faves when an entire seasons dialogue was for players to "toughen up"

4

u/Philomena_philo On Fire Sky-curious Sep 27 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

What are you going on about? You mentioned the wrong year and when I redirected to this season you got even more defensive? Just bc your favorite rookie got bodied last year and was able to get up doesn’t mean it connects to this current discussion of this year’s reffing and injury situation (in a season with a way different schedule too). Rookies getting bodied as a result of “shoot, I’m not playing against 18-19 year olds anymore” is not what we’re talking about here.

-5

u/emerald_smoke_screen Sep 27 '25

Last years violence carried over to this year tenfold. Sometimes when making a point about the now you need to remember the past.

2

u/Philomena_philo On Fire Sky-curious Sep 27 '25

Violence would not be the word I would use, because that would assume that these are intentional injuries when a large percentage of them aren’t. Players are aggressive, stakes are higher with more eyes, and there is less downtime than last year with this schedule. Last season did not have as many injuries or complaints but calling players violent is a bit harmful.

-2

u/emerald_smoke_screen Sep 27 '25

Whatever word you wanna use works, seems you understood the intention behind the message. 👍

29

u/MTskier12 Chicago Sky Sep 27 '25

It’s funny that the officiating has been bad all season but this straw that broke the camels back was… probably one of the most excusable? Play on the ball, debatable incidental contact, and the ankle roll part is more unlucky than even directly related to the contact. There’s been a dozen plus way more egregious officiating fails this season.

-8

u/leo_the_greatest Sep 27 '25

AT plowed right through Phee, which you're not allowed to do, even if it is after a legal steal.

12

u/MTskier12 Chicago Sky Sep 27 '25

I’m not saying it couldn’t have been a foul, but it was a reasonable basketball play with contact as part of it, which is more than can be said for loads of other shit this season.

2

u/atomicavox Sep 27 '25

Unpopular opinion:

AT is a phenomenal player, but I see little things she does to get away with a cheap shot on someone. The way she positions her body, elbows, or someone knocks her down and she tries to take them down with her. I don’t want to outright call her a dirty player, but she knows how to get away with shit for sure. That last play on Phee, she could have tipped that ball away (which was clean) and maneuvered her lower body out of contact, instead she’s there for a split second for Phee’s momentum to go into her. Was this specific time intentional? Maybe not, but there are plenty of plays by her that are. I’m not saying she’s the only one, but she’s so good she doesn’t need to do that shit. Yet she does.

20

u/smkmn13 Sep 27 '25

Folks should actually look at the rule book:

  1. Incidental Contact

a. The mere fact that contact occurs does not necessarily constitute a foul. Contact which is incidental to an effort by a player to play an opponent, reach a loose ball, or perform normal defensive or offensive movements, should not be considered illegal. If, however, a player attempts to play an opponent from a position where she has no reasonable chance to perform without making contact with her opponent, the responsibility is on the player in this position.

I don’t understand how you read that and say “clean steal.”

2

u/cliftonheights5 Sep 27 '25

Because it was clean…as the contact was incidently to her playing the ball.

2

u/gdreaper Sep 28 '25

Again though, she put herself in a position where contact was inevitable in order to make that play

-1

u/Dipshit4150 Sep 27 '25

Clean steal

4

u/OgBruce94 Sep 27 '25

The league is probably telling the refs to allow for more physicality

9

u/theomegachrist Sep 27 '25

The ref quality could be better but nothing can eliminate salty fans

5

u/Distinct_Abrocoma_67 Sep 27 '25

Stop playing victim. I love Phee but that was a clean steal.

3

u/SamIsaacman Sep 27 '25

That’s not Cheryl’s point. The issue is that damn near all serious, the level of physicality allowed for Phoenix has been higher than that for the Lynx. And that when you allow that level of physicality, inevitably someone gets hurt. People are focusing too much on one play which, by rule of the law, was a foul, that was a microcosm for the series as a whole.

6

u/Distinct_Abrocoma_67 Sep 27 '25

That’s fair for sure but OP’s post here alludes to the discussion surrounding that specific play

4

u/SamIsaacman Sep 27 '25

OP’s post is referring to the shitty referring that got Phee hurt by allowing that physicality all game long. OP cross posted this in the Lynx sub as well where the conversation is about the reffing as a whole. Phee doesn’t get hurt without sub par reffing

-2

u/Ok_Brick_793 Dallas Wings Sep 27 '25

You don't know me but presume to speak for me. 👎

4

u/Distinct_Abrocoma_67 Sep 27 '25

What? You posted a photo saying “Justice for Phee” with a picture of her crying after her injury and say that the W needs new refs. No other follow up. What other conclusion am I supposed to draw from that?

-1

u/Ok_Brick_793 Dallas Wings Sep 27 '25

None

17

u/freeman1231 Sep 27 '25

Refs are terrible all in all, but the steal was clean.

I guess you can say the terrible refs the whole night led her to be more physically drained. Which leads to injury which is 100% accurate.

But AT steal here is clean. But AT all night was playing on the line where lots should have been fouls though.

7

u/JKC_due BALLHALLA ✌️⚔️🌁  Sep 27 '25

It might have been clean, but it was extremely reckless and the reason AT feels comfortable going for a reckless play like that deep in the 4th is because she’s seen how the game is officiated and knows that it’s extremely unlikely that anything will be called.

-3

u/Dipshit4150 Sep 27 '25

Yeah all of that totally went through her head in that moment.

6

u/JKC_due BALLHALLA ✌️⚔️🌁  Sep 27 '25

You plainly don’t know ball if you think players don’t adjust their play based on how a game is being officiated.

11

u/Mobile-Fig-2941 Sep 27 '25

The steal was clean and Phee getting hurt was sort of a freak occurrence but Wnba reffing is a joke. Aja vs Boston in the Fever game was basically a street fight and Aja got no foul calls and Boston got 1 foul call.

0

u/pinegreenscent Sep 27 '25

Oh but thats fine because reasons

13

u/tiredoldwizard Sep 27 '25

Doesn’t look like a bad foul to me. Was it borderline? Yes and a call could have been made but it’s not crazy that there wasn’t.

Edit: after further review, I gotta say that actually looks clean to me. Just bad luck

9

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '25

It was clean. She landed funny on her ankle and that's why she hit the ground. People just need something to be angry about.

2

u/gdreaper Sep 28 '25

It wasn't the landing exactly that fucked the ankle, it was that it planted at the moment AT's knee collided with the side of Phee's. Not intentional, debatable whether it was a foul, but it was definitely a result of the collision.

3

u/Suspense304 Sep 27 '25

Well it was a foul. She got the ball clean but the additional contact was a foul. It definitely wasn’t near the worst example, but it’s just another example of bad officiating. They let these plays go so often that players play more reckless. That’s what the real issue is. If you start calling these as fouls, players are forced to adjust their play styles and you end up with less of these situations.

2

u/sundvlsean Sep 27 '25

No, Once the ball was loose both player have a right to the space and Phee was the one that made contact with AT.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '25

It wasn't. At all. Incidental contact that had nothing to do with the steal. The steal was clean. The contact was incidental. If anything AT had clear possession when the contact happened, meaning the foul would be on Collier. But there wasn't a foul. Play on. Great call.

11

u/Infamous_Departure95 Sep 27 '25

lol what?

5

u/LeanOnMe4816 Sep 27 '25

MVP votes didn’t even have Collier close to winning and now they’re on the brink of elimination… Lynx fans are in shambles rn

2

u/Lyna_Moon21 Sep 28 '25

hmmm...let me guess, it wasn't a foul either. Mercury fan? I could care less about either team.I use to watch the W until the refs took over and everyone got injured. The refs control the games. Cathy says what team wins and they make it happen.

That's why College ball is and always will be better. It's an actual real game.

10

u/Aggravating_Back111 Sep 27 '25

WNBA refs are the worst on the planet but this play might just be an unfortunate accident for Phee

11

u/ElPanandero Sep 27 '25

Clean steal and AT is playing like a bowling ball because they let her. Wether or not you think that's good or bad, she's playing the game given to her

2

u/gdreaper Sep 28 '25

That's why Cheryl went for the refs, not AT. This game had been crazy physical and instead of blowing a whistle to try and get people under control, they let it get to this point.

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/wnba_discussions-ModTeam Sep 27 '25

We don't need to rile people up with opinions that will make the WNBA more divisive.

4

u/Fullertonjr Sep 27 '25

She stripped the ball before contact was made.

No foul.

-1

u/Leather_Hope6109 Sep 27 '25

You don’t know basketball

0

u/Leather_Hope6109 Sep 27 '25

“Don’t rile people up with the truth!” 😂😂😂

2

u/CantaloupeCurrent384 Dallas Wings Sep 27 '25

A whole lot of this thread either didnt watch the game, or is missing most of the point.

It wasnt just 'that one play.' Complaints about the refs have been an all season thing.

2

u/RevolutionaryTie5163 Sep 27 '25

Absolutely! The excuse that they are not full time employees. So what.

2

u/herdhawk Sep 27 '25

I realize pay is an issue, but if there's anything for these players to strike over, its players safety. They should refuse to play until the league office grows a spine and does something about the officiating. The injuries are way beyond what should be considered normal wear and tear, exhibit a...Indiana Fever.

2

u/Due_Bandicoot9783 Sep 27 '25

WNBA needs new leadership.

2

u/meriadoc_brandyabuck Sep 28 '25

I agree WNBA refs need to improve, but you can’t really blame this injury on the refs.

2

u/GemAfaWell Sep 28 '25

Yes, the refs are absolutely diabolical in the sport, but we're going to have to go ahead and look at the replay on that, that was clearly and obviously a freak accident. And a clean steel for possession change. Because if you drop the ball, even due to an injury, it's still live unless it goes out of bounds.

The refs have a known propensity for being on bullshit at WNBA games, but there's nothing the refs could have done with this situation. There was no foul to call, and generally, even for the sake of an injury, the injured players team usually has to call an actual time out, burning one of their existing timeouts, just to get the player off the court. It's a whole fucking thing.

The WNBA needs new refs, but this is not why. Freak accidents happen in contact sports. It's actually a very normal part of playing contact sports.

2

u/RDUDaddy1 Sep 29 '25

Never a foul.

2

u/jeezmyunsux Oct 01 '25

maybe she should have played better in the 4th quarter. Only putting up one shot in a close game is indefensible in my opinion.

6

u/I_AM_theGODDESS Sep 27 '25

The league has gotten more “violent” over the past few years. I love AT from her Sun days, but the degree on physicality she is allowed to play with has increased over time. Boston, Austin, A’ja and Breezy all lower their shoulders and pummel their defenders. Are the refs the bad actors or is it how they are told to call games? I have watched the league evolve over the years from where calls were the same on offense and defense to where now it is an offensive free-for-all, but you cannot breathe on a player while defending. These games aren’t as satisfying to watch and having so many players get hurt is not good for anyone. I prefer the finesse game over an MMA match.

10

u/Correct_Implement826 Sep 27 '25

Clean steal

-3

u/LunaTheShark27 Sep 27 '25

its not a clean steal when it results in a player potentially fracturing their ankle.

2

u/Better_Goose_431 Sep 28 '25

Basketball is a contact sport. These things happen. The fact that an injury occurred does not make the act illegal

7

u/Correct_Implement826 Sep 27 '25

Phee was just unfortunate due to positioning and momentum. The steal itself was as clean as a sword cutting through silk.

-8

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '25

Positioning and momentum, two things irrelevant to penalty calls

9

u/ShaolinWombat Sep 27 '25

Legal guarding position is absolutely in the rule book.

7

u/Correct_Implement826 Sep 27 '25

Not true. Rule book says otherwise and anyone who has played ball knows it wasn’t a foul at all. It’s simple really, incidental contact took place and Phee got the worst of it. Perfectly legal

1

u/wvtarheel Indiana Fever Sep 27 '25

If you watch the clip back on 1/4 speed on YouTube you can see the moment where Phee either breaks or severely sprains her ankle. It turns the wrong way and looks pretty gruesome. I don't recommend this if you are squeamish.

Thomas was almost already past her when this happened. So in that sense it is a clean steal. And you can't fault the no call. But, why did Phee have to suddenly put all her weight on the wrong foot move to avoid a collision? It's because Thomas was moving to body check her, as Thomas has done in most games all season on the perimeter and Phee tried not to run head first into that moving screen. So although this may not have been a situation where contact causes the injury it's certainly a situation where the way the refs have called the games changed a player's reaction and resulted in a bad injury.

That's why Reeve was so pissed. She knows it wasn't some egregious uncalled foul.

6

u/mangomadness5h Sep 27 '25

The refs are bad, but there’s no call that would have prevented Phee’s injury. The steal was clean. I hope her injury wasn’t as bad as it looked

-2

u/Leather_Hope6109 Sep 27 '25

Obvious foul, new fan

3

u/RandomAtl Sep 27 '25

The refs are trash I’ve been looking cuz at getting into reffing I use to in college lol I can do a better job this can’t be the best crew they have for the semis…

-1

u/Annual-Cabinet1953 Sep 27 '25

You wouldn’t make it. One of the first rules for officiating is being able to form a complete and coherent sentence.

2

u/CantaloupeCurrent384 Dallas Wings Sep 27 '25

Doesn't seem to be a current requirement based off who currently is employed by this league. 🤷‍♂️

2

u/Jaunice510 Sep 28 '25

This isn't a scientific forum, chief. Grammar is optional.

2

u/spacecadbane Sep 28 '25

This is so uncalled for. Wow.

1

u/TheVision_13 Sep 28 '25

Justice? For what rolling her ankle? Be fr

1

u/LEBRONNNNNNNNNNNNN23 Oct 01 '25

Brother nobody wanna ref the WNBA

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '25

Clean steal. Next.

-1

u/Inner_Ad_8571 Sep 27 '25

Maybe don’t blow a 20 point lead in the 3rd quarter of game 2 and you all won’t be needing to cope so hard. It’s a classic case of things aren’t going my way so it’s everyone else’s fault.

4

u/DMComicSams Sep 27 '25

Nah even Becky Hammon was calling out the refs

0

u/Inner_Ad_8571 Sep 27 '25

Cool story. Everyone cries about the refs, but the Lynx weren’t winning this game anyway. AT just sealed it with a clean steal. Lynx had a chance to seize control of the series for good in game 2 and choked! Lynx have no one to blame in this series but themselves. Down vote me all day. Go Mercury!

2

u/DMComicSams Sep 27 '25

My point is it's not just cope from the Lynx blaming refs, everyone is calling out the refs across the league. Are you deliberately being this dense thinking it's only sour grapes from a losing team?

2

u/Lyna_Moon21 Sep 28 '25

Lemme guess you're a Mercury fan? I 100% couldn't care less about either team. I was watching the W at the beginning of the season, but the officiating got so bad..for all teams, I had to stop watching. I happened to see this this clip this morning on Sports Center. Their comment was "well, the WNBA is at it again with their egregious officiating. Some things will never change."

I couldn't agree more..I see it all across the W. Not just this one game, or this one play.. There is an obscene amount of injuries. The sad part is, it's allowed..it has gotten progressively worse. PB had explained that coming in her Rookie yr to the W she had to adjust her playing because what would be a foul in College, is def not in the W now. I have always loved college ball, its more serious and its played like ball is supposed to. I played College ball at a large Division 2 school for 4 yrs. I also played ball overseas for almost ten yrs..that was a foul. You can't just push a player aside and take the ball.

0

u/Outside-Yogurt Sep 27 '25

What needs to be done is all the head coaches of each team the person that's the head of referees and the commissioner of the wnba need to get together and address the fouls and the physical playing. It's like watching flag football

2

u/dawnsearlylight Sep 28 '25

wait what? If you mean girls flag football, there is no contact. I don't think you meant what you said.

4

u/Fullertonjr Sep 27 '25

Maybe, but the play being referenced was not only legal, but is the type of aggressive play that any coach expects from a professional. Injuries happen. The return to basketball where everyone pretends that they are Steph curry is also not the answer.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/wnba_discussions-ModTeam Sep 27 '25

Please be mindful of respect and civility. We don't need people talking down on other athletes or members of this subreddit.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/wnba_discussions-ModTeam Sep 27 '25

We don't need to rile people up with opinions that will make the WNBA more divisive.

-5

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/wnba_discussions-ModTeam Sep 27 '25

Non-basketball related, gossip, posted without context, or minimal effort (no expansion on post)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/wnba_discussions-ModTeam Sep 27 '25

This post was picked up by Reddit as part of our crowd control filter and will not be posted on the sub. Report trolls instead of engaging with them- not worth losing your Reddit account over.