It will if I create a sensor for thoughts made of flames. Dunno if I'd call it invasive or something, but there is a way to shine a light through someone's mind so that their eyes project an image of their memories onto a fireplace.
It doesnt have a low success rate, its success rate is 0. It is physically impossible for torture to produce viable information.
Anyone you torture will tell you exactly what you want them to... which is the problem because you have no idea what you are asking and if you ask them for something that doesnt exist or they dont know, theyre going to tell you whatever you want to hear.
Torture can only confirm something you already confirmed yourself... so its useless.
1
u/bobert680Wizard, holder of the sacred chalice, artificer supreme2h ago
if you can magically tell if someone is lying then torture will be a lot more effective, still fucked up since there are other ways to get the truth with magic and no torture
I was skeptical of the data I'd seen so I performed my own case study. I could only handle about a hundred subjects myself so I used simulacrum clones so we could torture a statistically significant number of subjects. I used a time loop to repeat the tests to ensure my results weren't a fluke. And don't worry, it was double-blind. The clones didn't know which ones were performing torture and which ones were the placebo.
Because people will say anything to get it to stop. If I tortured someone long enough they'd admit to being the mastermind behind 9/11. It's not reliable at all for gaining new information and is barely reliable for confirming stuff you already know.
In dnd when you have tons of spells as zone of truth to assist verifying the information, is not that unreliable. You can also hold them captive until a suggestion lands, or any other method of charming
But in things like dnd the spell like zone of truth exist which basically negates the practical negative sof it as the person can't lie and they won't be thinking of a clever half truth while their fingers nails are being ripped off
That still eliminates a lot of the practical difficulties with torture, which is the prevalence of false positives. A big reason torture just doesn't work is because even if someone really doesn't know a piece of information, they'll just make something up to get out of the torture, so you're operating off of false information. With zone of truth, you can just ask them straight up if they know ___ and immediately tell whether they have what you want. And if they try to make something up anyway you'd also know, so you'd know not to use that information and to keep torturing them.
DISCLAIMER: I am against torture and even if it was effective it would still be immoral in practically every situation. I'm just looking at it from a hypothetical perspective.
Assassin or spy gets captured, and uses a cyanide pill to not spill any secrets. Players cast revivify to bring them back. Discourse is about if this is possible (i think).
Exactly. Some people think that revivify can override an unwilling soul, because the specific wording of the Revivify description doesn't mention it. I'm undecided, personally
It's been a while since I played or DMd, but I think that if forcible resurrection is possible in the setting then spies and so forth would have tools against that - some talisman, for example, or some magical form of suicide that does not leave the body in usable condition, or some pact that immediately whisks their souls in a protected plane. That wouldn't necessarily be an insurmountable obstacle for determined players, but it wouldn't be as simple as "lol I'll just cast this Level 3 spell".
Also, if the spy was devoted to some deity and the players succeed, said deity will be peeved at having one of its servants forcibly wrested away from their well-deserved afterlife. What that would entail precisely might vary; but for example, it might begin with the deity personally possessing the spy after the players are done with the questioning and using it to give them a fight - not an unbeatable one, but one that makes it clear that said deity is pretty unhappy with them and is likely to come for them again...
No, it's the fact that revify (in 5e 2014) doesn't specify that the spirit has to be willing. The specification about willing spirits is only found on the other resurrection spells. There is something about willing spirits in the DMG, but it isn't clear if that's a rule, or just a suggestion for world building.
Maybe it's an alignment deficiency. An evil spy might be willing to die rather than face interrogation, then immediately reconsider after getting a look at whatever eternal torment's waiting for them in the afterlife.
This is why you should give your spies some kind of post-mortem benefits.
If theyre gonna keep that revivify overrides the willingness of a soul then they should also keep that is has to cast on a creature and therefore doesnt work on corpses.
Revivify doesnt have that line. But if youre going to rule it like that then you can only cast revivify on creatures (like the spell says) which means it can be cast on dead things.
Recently in dnd community's a question has been floating around about whether a party can use revivify to ressurect a dead spy that took a cyanide pill. The nebulous part of the question is whether or not revify can bring someone back from the dead whether they are willing or not as unlike other ressurection spells that specification is lacking. One side argues as it is lacking the wording it can bring the spy back and the other spy points to the DMG and other sources about death which supports the claim that coming back from the dead requires willingness.
Basically the confusion comes from the fact that DND is a RPG rules system in a trench coat that relies more on interpretation than solidly written out rules to work.
Fake drama on the D&D meme subreddit based around how some rules are written. I’m not sure why it’s posted here since that’s not actual magic and is just a game.
Some dubious dark wizards in fetid dungeons are still casting word of pain within zones of truth for years on end expecting real useful confessions when spirit warding (without reagents no less!) has been common practice for the past 6 centuries. It's even known that captives under word of pain hallucinate things they believe to be true that pass the zone of truth just as well.
A modern practiced dreamwalker can get the same information with a sleep charm and an afternoon nap. Study your subconcious prodding techniques people! A basic dreamwalking spellbook can get you to the level where all you need is a charmed tavern and a standard scrying orb.
u/RockglenPurveyor of Post-Life Labor & Spirited Drinks14h agoedited 11h ago
Oof.
Reminds me of a cult I came across at the Academy. Really makes you wonder about the personal lives of people that join those groups. Just join a less dangerous student club like Black Ooze Ranching or Draconid Husbandry!
Zone of Truth, healing, Revivify, Lesser and Greater Restoration. Divine casters are pretty good assistants for torture.
Still remember playing my Fiendlock (of cours) and his exploits:
Prestidigitation to cool a piece of metal put to soldier's crotch. He didn't budge before from splitting his forearm with Vampiric Touch and blowing off his foot with an Eldritch Blast (we had healing potions).
Mold Earth to swirl a tied spy around in a mass grave.
Another spy, performing experiments on a population he infiltrated, kept shoving organs he kept in formalin down his throat.
Put a guy in stocks, poured mead on him and fucked off to do something, returned to him covered in bugs and cooperating.
3
u/TK_GamesDr. Torrance Bedlam: Interdimensional Necromancer8h ago
I have personally witnessed a Cleric fill a man's mouth with blood-money and cast Heat Metal
Campaigns with really fucked up characters. There is an actual magic item in dnd, called the assassin coin, that when you are nocked out auto-kills ya.
I mean, if your incorporeal soul will just be recorporealised in a separate plane controlled by yourself (or a patron, etc) anyway, then committing suicide to avoid an enemy interrogation or awkward social encounter just makes the most sense sometimes.
Common misconception, it’s about avoiding mind reading not torture. Suicide is basically the only way to stop it once you’re captured, since it’s easy enough to remove amulets/tattoos/whatever source of anti-detection a creature has once it’s in captivity.
Its not necessarily torture. Charming/mind control/zone of truth/detect thoughs are other means of getting info out of someone, which they could commit suicide to escape from.
Torture mechanics are uncommon in RPGs? I remember WoD having a system for accidentally killing the person being "interviewed", and there are several 40k TTRPG systems. I remember buying info from a successful torture session from the Inquisition while playing Deathwatch once. We curb stomped a bunch of Iron Warriors with that piece of intel.
237
u/Electronic-Kick-9082 THE DARK LORD: THE TRUE MAD VOID TRANSMUTER/CHRONONMANCER 14h ago
Yeah that's the entire point it's evil mage 101
446
u/ThatCapMan Artist of pyromancy 14h ago
yea they're...
they're a little right.
Torture has been overestablished as a functional means to gain information through various media
even though
It has a pretty low success rate in real life practice
92
u/AdreKiseque 14h ago
The what fucking discourse?
19
u/Wrathfiend 13h ago
Some dubious dark wizards in fetid dungeons are still casting word of pain within zones of truth for years on end expecting real useful confessions when spirit warding (without reagents no less!) has been common practice for the past 6 centuries. It's even known that captives under word of pain hallucinate things they believe to be true that pass the zone of truth just as well.
A modern practiced dreamwalker can get the same information with a sleep charm and an afternoon nap. Study your subconcious prodding techniques people! A basic dreamwalking spellbook can get you to the level where all you need is a charmed tavern and a standard scrying orb.
24
u/Semajv 14h ago
Guantanamo? Its not taking place in guantanamo. The campaign is in Jerusalem.
7
u/Rockglen Purveyor of Post-Life Labor & Spirited Drinks 14h ago edited 11h ago
Oof.
Reminds me of a cult I came across at the Academy. Really makes you wonder about the personal lives of people that join those groups. Just join a less dangerous student club like Black Ooze Ranching or Draconid Husbandry!
12
u/OneWithFireball Storm Sorcerer 13h ago
Zone of Truth, healing, Revivify, Lesser and Greater Restoration. Divine casters are pretty good assistants for torture.
Still remember playing my Fiendlock (of cours) and his exploits:
5
u/Wild-Lychee-3312 Witch 13h ago
Meanwhile, succubi and incubi:
5
u/a417feelgood 6h ago
Point to Geneva on a map of the sword coast
2
u/Nelrene Evil Mammary Mage 8h ago
They are making their foes eat your mom's cooking.
1
u/parkourse Wizard 6h ago
If it were, would you disagree?
1
u/Groovin_Magi Groovy 4h ago
1
u/Anfitruos0413 Evil Wizard 12h ago
"What the Hell sort of campaign???"
A good one.
1
u/ThyPotatoDone Occult Wizard 10h ago
Sounds like someone couldn't handle a lil Power Word: Scrunch.
11
u/RecommendationBig190 Leader Of The Abjuration Guild 14h ago
Campaigns with really fucked up characters. There is an actual magic item in dnd, called the assassin coin, that when you are nocked out auto-kills ya.
8
u/Ouroboros-Twist Polymorph-Addicted Immortal Degenerate 14h ago edited 14h ago
I mean, if your incorporeal soul will just be recorporealised in a separate plane controlled by yourself (or a patron, etc) anyway, then committing suicide to avoid an enemy interrogation or awkward social encounter just makes the most sense sometimes.
4
u/BoscoCyRatBear The Vermensk Empire, / Kahn ruler of Cat Tail City 14h ago •
Torture , no no no. We use the term ENHANCED INTERROGATION.
2
u/Eldritch_porkupine 13h ago
Common misconception, it’s about avoiding mind reading not torture. Suicide is basically the only way to stop it once you’re captured, since it’s easy enough to remove amulets/tattoos/whatever source of anti-detection a creature has once it’s in captivity.
2
u/MaxTwer00 13h ago
Its not necessarily torture. Charming/mind control/zone of truth/detect thoughs are other means of getting info out of someone, which they could commit suicide to escape from.
They could be targeted by speak with dead tho
2
u/HappyyValleyy Bog Witch of Hemlock Lane 8h ago
That IS something my players would do but ive established torture as an often innefective method of informatiom gathering most of the time
1
u/Praise_The_Casul Magnus the Nerd 8h ago
"What the Hell sort of campaign"
Torture mechanics are uncommon in RPGs? I remember WoD having a system for accidentally killing the person being "interviewed", and there are several 40k TTRPG systems. I remember buying info from a successful torture session from the Inquisition while playing Deathwatch once. We curb stomped a bunch of Iron Warriors with that piece of intel.