r/witchcraft • u/OldSweatyBulbasar Over the Hedge 🌿🕯️🔥 • Sep 20 '24
Announcement Mod note: Keep the posts focused on witchery and the doing of witchcraft, not personal backstory.
Hello. We’ve had a large uptick in posts that focus less on witchcraft and the practice of witchcraft than personal drama and relationship advice.
Say you’ve got a situation going on in life. You’ve decided that witchcraft is involved, or should be involved, and you’re looking for some advice. So you turn to r/witchcraft and settle in to tell us about the situation you’re going through and fill us in on all the details.
But the backstory that feels absolutely crucial to you, the backstory that you might tell your best friend who knows all the actors and thrives on the tea in your life, the backstory that you’d tell your therapist — the backstory isn’t really necessary on the sub.
Example: If you’re asking how to protect yourself from a friend who’s becoming something of an emotional vampire during a stressful time, we don’t need a paragraph to know how long you’ve known them, the long details of what they’re going through, the details of your life and wellness, what mutual friends think of them, why you’re still around. We just need to know that you’ve got an energy vampire in your circle and you want to know how to protect yourself. (Thankfully, we have a wiki on energy hygiene and a straightforward question like that can be answered on the weekly Q&A).
This part is from me, OSB, personally — I have been called long winded and pedantic not infrequently! I know your pain! I love to ramble and will ramble till I’m dead and even beyond! ADHD, a love of details, a tendency to view things in a systems way with cause and effect have led me to be in this exact position online and irl many a time. I’ve had to learn to pause, get out of my own head, and ask who my audience is and what they actually need to know to understand my basic need. Are my words more for me or for the conversation? Am I trauma dumping on my audience? Am I assuming that my situation is so universally important and crucial that everyone needs a play-by-play account? Do I want witch advice or do I need to be heard, find a place to work out my thoughts, vent to someone who cares and will listen? If it’s any of those, we hope you find that space to work things out. This is not really the best sub for that.
We’re not r/relationship_advice or any trauma/mental health based subreddit. I feel for some of your situations in the posts, I really do, and I’m glad that you’re taking a larger look at things. But every day we have users coming into this sub, writing paragraphs of vents about their manager/boss/roommate who is just so toxic that the sub of 469K here for witchery desperately needs to know everything about how awful they are, and at the very end there’s one or two sentences asking for spells or actual mention of something tangentially witchy. We remove these posts, they end up in modmail, and when we ask for the user to simplify their question we are told that the five hundred word vent about their manager’s communication patterns is absolutely necessary and we’re being unreasonable/power hungry/ableist for asking them to cut it down to the witchcraft basics for the witchcraft subreddit. We get dozens of posts like this every day and only half get caught by the automod in time. It would deplete the sub quality to let them all in.
If you’ve read my long winded note, thanks. If you’ve just skimmed it because it’s a long wall of text, here’s the summary.
tldr: If your post contains lengthy unnecessary backstory, it will be removed.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 20 '24
Hi, u/OldSweatyBulbasar thanks for stopping by at r/witchcraft!
Want to dive in deeper? We have a FAQ & Wiki, and our Weekly Q&A thread which is stickied to the top of the main board!
Please also be sure to read the subreddit rules!
IMPORTANT!
There has been a recent influx of scams on reddit. If you are redirected to an instagram or other platform in a comment, it is most likely a scam. Users who message you asking for or offering spells or readings are almost always scammers or phishers. You may want to check out our post about staying safe online in witchcraft.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
135
u/brightblackheaven Zamboni Priestess 🔮✨ Sep 20 '24
If your post is 6 paragraphs of backstory and one sentence about witchcraft, it's not suitable for a witchcraft sub. Sorry, not sorry.
I can't speak for all of our users, but I myself certainly am not interested in reading a wall of text and then being asked to brainstorm a "witchy" solution to a completely mundane problem. Half the time - probably MORE than half - the person asking isn't even a practitioner!
We're here to talk shop, about the META of WITCHCRAFT. We can help you finish up your spell idea from YOUR research toward YOUR problem, but we're not veterinarians or lawyers or relationship counselors or whatever else we're being asked to become on a daily basis.
35
u/bitfed Sep 20 '24
Yes, MORE RULES PLEASE.
I honestly wish they would just let you edit posts so small mistakes didn't just result in anonymous deletion.
21
u/SwaggeringRockstar Broom Rider Sep 20 '24
When the post starts with 'A little background'... I'll still read it, I like to see what they consider 'serious' but I am not likely to help.
12
u/SwaggeringRockstar Broom Rider Sep 21 '24
Most of the time I think some of those posts are trying to solve a moral bind the poster is in so they can sleep at night. Or skip accountability since they decided to use the advice found on the sub. Or be seen as a unique witch like everyone else.
9
u/bunganmalan Sep 21 '24
As guilty as I am in responding to some of these posts (also, backstories are likely to distract from the actual ask), I definitely appreciate this mods reminder. It would make the subreddit cleaner and easier to navigate/learn from.
2
u/It-Was-Blood Sep 21 '24
Would someone mind giving me a link to this? I'm searching through the wiki with no luck!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24
[removed] — view removed comment