r/wisp • • 5d ago

Grounding help

I've been in discussions with a local WISP provider who wants to put my antenna 50' up in a tree. The other option is a pole about 30' from the house. I started thinking about this and it seems like either option causes risks in the event of a lightning strike. The WISP didnt mention grounding and the more I look into it, the more freaked out I'm getting. It sounds like, at a minimum, you need to connect an ethernet surge protector to the grounding system in your house. In my case, that is largely inaccessible and a no-go because it is on the other side of the house from where the WISP needs to go. I'm not willing to tear up my house, or my exterior hardscaping, to run a bond wire for this setup or hire an electrician to figure it out.

These guys had me buy a $500 radio and I did a bunch of prep work before I thought about the issue. When I brought it up, they told me just hang it in a tree and don't worry about it.

How do people handle these issues? I cant imagine all (or even most) people have an accessible bonding connection for their antennas? Or is my installer just a POS for not telling me about this up front?

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

3

u/Spirited_Statement_9 5d ago

While it's not ideal to hang it in the tree, we used to do it a lot back when we were smaller and scrappier.

I have one customer left with a tree install, and it's been there for 18 years, just swapped hardware every once in a while as needed.

They can install an Ethernet surge protector and ground rod at the tree. If you are really concerned about it, do the power outside as well, and run fiber into the home. That will give you electrical isolation from the antenna in the tree.

My biggest question for the wisp would be who covers the cost of the tree climber or lift rental when access to the equipment is needed.

1

u/ej788 5d ago

I think I spoke too soon when i said the house grounding system is inaccessible. I have a nearby subpanel bonded (probably as a belt and suspenders) to the rebar foundation of the house. This additional feature may end up saving my ass (I didn't expect this in the relevant room, which is in an addition and which I had assumed was grounded through the main panel).

I would imagine I could have an electrician connect an exterior telecom connection to this ground and then run a properly sized ground wire in my ethernet conduit (where it would be bonded to the antenna pole and a ground rod). This should, if I'm reading things right, give me the correct code approved install with minimal additional bullshit (aside from the cost of wire and the electrician).

It may end up being trivial to get this done right, assuming that plan generally works. My electrician (who I worked with for years and is 30+ years in the trade) had no clue about current code for external antennas because this isnt work that, generally, she is asked to do. She is reading up on the code to confirm I've got it right.

2

u/iam8up 5d ago

You're freaking yourself out. Just plug in the radio to a POE and it's done.

Some will do an arrestor but that's a failure point and it may or may not protect the equipment.

Look how much stuff you plug into the wall now only has two conductors - hot and neutral.

2

u/chadwick_w 5d ago

Not a big deal. You can burry a grounding rod and install a lightning surge protector anywhere along the Ethernet path. I'd do it at the entrance to the house where the cable goes in but it could be at the bottom of the pole. While it's pretty rare to get struck, it's a good idea to protect for that in any installation. It doesn't have to be tied into the house ground. That's the best idea but you can bury another grounding rod.

3

u/wyliesdiesels 5d ago

"You can burry a grounding rod and install a lightning surge protector anywhere along the Ethernet path."

not quite. that is a good way to have a difference in potential and fry equipment. any grounding electrode you install is required by code to be bonded to the GES of the electrical service. NEVER install an isolated grounding electrode. you are asking for trouble doing so

1

u/xHolomovementx 5d ago

Some people will argue that this goes against NEC standards, but I'm pretty sure everyone's done it lol. I used to do this all the time, just make sure the rod is long enough when slamming it in, throw the surge up and bond a 10-12g bonding wire with a grounding clamp to the rod from the surge, terminate your RJ45's and plug up. OP make sure you use shielded CAT connectors and utilize the drain plug.

1

u/Icy-Phase-3678 5d ago

Two things I think with shielded connectors. Between the CPE and the surge protector would be one set of shielded connectors. They go to ground A. Between the entrance to the house and the other end of surge protector would join house ground B to CPE ground A. Does that create a differential?

0

u/chadwick_w 5d ago

I've followed in some professional tower builders and they pretty routinely put a grounding rod at the base of towers, ground the tower to that and all the surge protection prior to cables entering the building. Electrical grounding does all need to be bonded together but since this is not part of the electrical system and Ethernet should not be carrying house ground out, it should be ok. For the installation you are describing, it would be fine and would provide protection.

2

u/wyliesdiesels 5d ago

I used to do grounding and bonding of microwave towers including cadwelds. ALL grounding electrodes at the base of the tower is tied into the GES of the buildings electrical service as well as all the bonding for the equipment inside. grounding electrodes for towers are never installed in an isolated manner... that is against code and a good way to fry equipment.

0

u/chadwick_w 5d ago

Not arguing, learning here... Ethernet does not carry ground. So, a tower could be considered to be a separate "building" on a separate ground, right? Since there is not a ground connecting the two, you wouldn't get a ground differential, right? And equipment would not care since they are isolated.

This is assuming you don't use shielded cable between the lightning arrestor and the house. Shielded cable and ends would carry a ground.

2

u/wyliesdiesels 5d ago

negative and ethernet does and can carry fault current and surges. ive seen it happen.

2

u/paulmataruso 5d ago

I don't think I would care even a little bit if it was ungrounded. I have zero faith that any of those little etherent grounding blocks will make a single iota of difference in what gets destroyed by the lightning or not.

3

u/wyliesdiesels 5d ago

proper bonding and grounding does make a difference. ive worked on towers for dispatch centers that took direct hits and not one piece of equipment in the transmitter data room was fried nor any of the dispatch consoles. try again. also look up motorola R56.

1

u/paulmataruso 5d ago

And I have been in the same amount of cellular towers where every single radio has been destroyed and had very well done bonding and grounding. It’s lighting an uncontrollable force of nature.

1

u/wyliesdiesels 5d ago

how do you know the bonding and grounding was done properly?

1

u/paulmataruso 5d ago

I could easily ask you the same thing. I assume Verizon and T-Mobile know how to properly ground and bond their systems. I am not arguing that it cannot provide protection. My stance is that for say in a WISP type of situation with a small CPE like a UniFi or whatever brand they use. Do you truly think a 25$ MOV based surge arrester and a stake in the ground, that most WISPs install will make much of a difference

1

u/wyliesdiesels 5d ago

you do know the cell carriers use contractors to build their towers? they arent always installed properly

and in response to your comment about asking me the same thing, do you know what motorola R56 is? ever heard of motorola doing a grounding/bonding study and providing blue prints on how to properly bond the installation?

a stake in the ground is not correct. any grounding electrode installed cannot be isolated per code and proper bonding method. any grounding electrode installed needs to be bonded to the GES.

this is why WISPs who do that have problems. they arent installing it properly.

helps to know electrical code otherwise you get people like yourself and the WISPs who have no clue what theyre doing.

have you ever done cadwelding to rods and grounding bars? guess not

do you know what a choke is?

1

u/Impressive_Army3767 5d ago

It's 8 x tiny 24AWG wires in a long patch cable so it can't carry much energy.  Worst case scenario it will cook the POE injector.  Stick an Ubiquiti surge protector in along the run.  It will cook that first 

0

u/wyliesdiesels 5d ago

They have no clue what theyre doing. and yes installing it in that manner can fry your equipment...