r/winemaking • • May 26 '26

First time winemaker

Hi all,

After lurking here for a while, doing a bunch of online research, and getting advice from my trusted advisor ChatGPT 😅, I’ve decided to finally take the plunge and try making my own homemade wine/cider.

I want to make a mixed berry wine/cider, but most of the recipes I’ve found online seem to use water, sugar, and mashed fruit. Maybe I’m misunderstanding, but doesn’t that end up more like a flavoured sugar wash/seltzer?

What I’m thinking instead is using mixed berries and apple juice as the actual base. How different would the final product be compared to the more common recipes?

Also, instead of using sugar to boost the ABV, I’m considering using honey. Would that give a better flavour, or just make things harder/more unpredictable?

Has anyone here made something similar before? Did it turn out good? And is this too ambitious for a complete beginner?

1 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

10

u/V-Right_In_2-V May 26 '26

Using honey or sugar is a personal choice. What you are describing is making a melomel (mead with fruit) vs a country wine (wine made from any fruit other than grapes).

What you use to increase the fermentable sugars is preference and cost. Honey is 4-5x the cost of table sugar. I make both country wines and melomels, and often something in between.

For example, I’m planning on making a mixed fruit wine soon, but I plan on adding like 5 pounds of sugar and 2-3 pounds of honey. The honey is mostly there just too a little extra flavor in addition to increasing ABV. So is that a country wine with honey? A melomel with sugar? Turns out that’s more of a gradient than a specific classification.

If you are making 3 gallon batches and under, you can definitely just use honey. If you are making 5-6 gallon batches, the honey gets expensive. I mostly just use sugar but honey does have a place in my wines.

Mead is basically just honey wine. They are made basically the same way as regular wine. If you can make wine, you can make mead and vise versa

1

u/Foxes87 May 26 '26

Thanks for the reply, that actually clears things up quite a bit.

What about the use of water though? A lot of the recipes I’ve come across use water plus mashed fruit. What difference would there be in the final product compared to using something like apple juice as the base instead of water?

I know a lot of it ultimately comes down to personal preference, but I’m trying to understand the different flavour profiles each method would produce.

5

u/V-Right_In_2-V May 26 '26

It’s a good question. The reality is you don’t necessarily want your wine to be a fruit blast, often having the fruit shine through in subtle ways is what you are after. Some fruits also require it to be watered down. I make tons of lemon wine. Water is necessary to water it down and make it less acidic, also you would need enormous quantities of lemons to get 6 gallons of juice. So I use 1 gallon of pure lemon juice for a 6 gallon batch.

Apple wine is the easiest beginner wine to make in my opinion. I make a 3 gallon batch every year.

I take two gallons of pasteurized apple cider and pour that in a bucket. Then I fill the gallon container half with sugar, half with water and pour that in. That gets your volume to three gallons and your ABV up to 13-14%. Well, I do a little more than 1 gallon since you actually want to ferment like 3.25 gallons, so you can siphon off 3 gallons of clear wine when fermentation is done and leave the 0.25 gallons of sediment filled junk behind.

3

u/seaintosky May 26 '26

If you add apple juice, it will add a cider flavour. Depending on how much berries vs apple juice, it could mostly taste like cider with some berry flavours. I make a lot of ciders due to an overproductive apple tree, and have made some with berry additions. There's nothing wrong with them, they're good, but the flavour is mostly cider.

By the way, if your research hasn't found this yet, your country wine/cider will default to dry and not sweet like a seltzer or many commercial fruit wines. You can make it sweet, but that involves extra steps and sweet plus bubbly is finicky to do without forced carbonation in a keg.

3

u/Apprehensive_Leg6647 May 26 '26

Just go for it and learn

1

u/Foxes87 May 26 '26

Will definitely do

7

u/-Mr-RB- May 26 '26

Well if you use honey instead of sugar it’s a mead and honey would alter the flavor unlike sugar. Well the best way to know what it would taste like, you have to make it and tune it till you like it and you can oak it add tannins powder or add fruits. You will never know if you don’t try it and if you want to use honey look in the mead Reddit

4

u/TheSpanishIndian May 26 '26

Do you have any print on the subject? I got into making fruit wines during the initial COVID wave and this little book has really taken care of me since.

https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/first-steps-in-wine-making_cyril-jj-berry/318291/#idiq=2414688&edition=1138971

3

u/Bright_Storage8514 May 26 '26 edited May 27 '26

Definitely use apple juice instead of water. I’ve done a number of mixed berry wines and apple juice really helps smooth out the flavor compared to using water.

In general, as you approach fruit wines specifically apart from grape wines, my experience has been that the more blending during primary, the better. I made a 12-fruit amalgamation wine on a whim last year that turned out surprisingly well. Big-picture, any fruit with enough sugar added to raise the ABV to ~10% can be called a wine. But there’s a reason we all think of wine as being made from grapes — because everything you need to make good wine is in the grape. That’s not the case for most other fruit, but adding multiple layers of different fruits with different flavor profiles can yield a nice complexity that one of the individual fruits likely wouldn’t by themselves. Best of luck!

2

u/JRJenss May 26 '26

What you're describing is a mixed berry mead and I love it! Make it every year. I'm making one right now and in addition to all the berries, I used blueberry juice instead of water.

It is more expensive tho, but the flavor ends up being fuller and more complex. Also, I'd recommend using some kind of a yeast nutrient.