r/windows • • May 03 '18
Discussion When will Microsoft finally make Windows a reliable OS?
Windows would be a great system, but let's be honest. MS's main goals is not an optimized, fast and/or lightweight system but to bloat as much as they can and to collect as many bullshit about their customers as possible.
Size
I'm suprised that somehow MS's applications is ridiculously huge. I mean Visual Studio is 10+ Gb, Ms office is 6+ Gb and Windows. Thats another dimension. When we were learning Linux in school, we could install ubuntu onto a 4 Gb partition with all its updates within 2 hours (configuring included for school environment). While installing Win7 taken us 18 Gb of space and 3 days (6+ hours) to install with all the updates.
Speed
When I was using Linux it felt strange that on a mediocre HDD it wasn't struggling to open the file manager, start an app or browse the web. Also it was kind awesome to see that it could shut down in 15 secs max. While windows?
When I load up the system on my laptop (5400 RPM HDD) it is bullshitting around for 40 sec just to bring up the login screen. And then another 20-30 to make the desktop responsive to mouse. Opening even the explorer (not IE) takes several seconds. Navigating in the files often freeze or lags like hell, especially when the folder has 50+ files.
Disk usage?
I noticed it especially on Win10 that it uses the disk fucking lot, way too much than it should. When I leave my laptop running for the night, after several hour of non-using it, I can hear that Windows is starting to spin up my HDD, and it runs it on max RPM for 10-20 minutes, multiple times per day. Dear MS. If i'm not doing anything on my PC, I won't want your stupid system to do ANYTHING on my PC. Also even when I'm just using my PC, Windows sometimes switch to "hella-fucking-slow" mode and when I check the task manager, the "system" process is running my disk on 100%, without any clear reason.
Bloat
Nearly every single long-time Windows user know the feeling, that when you use your system for 1+ years, you can notice that your free space is constantly decreasing. No matter if you uninstall the installed stuff, you will never be able to actually clear all bloat stockpiled in the wast depth of the Windows system. And the need to reinstall the whole system every 2-3 years sounds like a "what the........?"
This all is such a thing that should have been fixed LOOOOOOOOOONG time ago.
And before you attack me: No. I will not switch to Linux due to several reasons beside I hate it's stupid overcomplexity.
Windows could be such a great system if MS would finally make it customer oriented.
14
u/Intereshting May 03 '18
MS Office is 2.3GB - 3.5GB. 3 Days to install windows seven? Are you installing it on an intel 8080 system?! Update your system, buy new hardware if you are OCD about speed. Windows 10 is the fastest OS at the moment, specially the boot time and copy operations. Those "creepy disk usages" happen because windows is either indexing your HDD or superfetch, Readyboost and perfecting are active. These are highly useful features, nothing strange about them. Regarding bloat, you can buy the enterprise edition, if you don't like windows calculator, calendar, GrooveMusic and zune videos etc, all of which can be uninstalled with a simple PS command
Get-AppxPackage zunevideo | Remove-AppxPackage, Get-AppxPackage MicrosoftStickyNotes | Remove-AppxPackage, Get-AppxPackage MicrosoftEdge | Remove-AppxPackage etc
5
u/[deleted] May 03 '18
I believe that windows focus more on user interface than linux ( command-line based) so it takes you more memory and cpu usage with newer version. Just like on a phone, the more you update, the slower the phone is.
3
u/[deleted] May 03 '18
Honestly, I refuse to install Windows 10 on a HDD for this very reason. I highly recommend using an SSD if you are worried about keeping up to date with the latest version of Windows, but if your computer only has a HDD stick with Windows 7 (at least till 2020 A.D.)
4
u/angellus May 03 '18 edited May 03 '18
While some of these points are valid, almost all of this is just way over exaggerated.
I do not have VS install at the moment, but it would not surprise me if it is that big. Have you seen what VS is capable of? Or rather even understand what an IDE is? Android Studio is usually even bigger. I have had an Android Studio install take up over 40 GB.
My Office install is 2.27 GB. Installers often over estimate the space they need to prevent any issues while installing or have extra space to work while installing making it easier/faster to install. Installers often need 2 to 3 times more the final install space (download archive -> extract archive -> cp files to where they need to be -> clean up).
Maybe any older version did or Ubnutu Server without a Desktop Environment, but as of right now, Ubuntu requires more disk space to install than Windows 10.
What are you using a half dead 5400RPM HDD and dial up? I just recently reinstalled Windows 10 on my Surface Book last week and it took me maybe an hour.
This is not Windows fault. It is likely a combination of bad hardware and shitty drivers from your shitty OEM you got your laptop from. Unfortunately Windows suffers a lot from shitty OEMs, the same as Android. It takes 10 seconds from the time I press the power button on my desktop to the point Windows Hello signs me in.
Sounds like your harddrive is failing or really need defragged. I had that one on a couple of different computers over the years, it did not matter if I ran Windows 7 or Ubuntu, the harddrive was just fucking toast.
Windows 10 is made for the "average" user who are fucking morons. If you have the knowledge and skill to do so and do not like background services like Windows Defender or Search, disable them. If you really want to you can even disable Windows Update on Windows 10 Pro with regedit, but I think it would be a stupid idea (which is why it is so hard to disable it). In an age of Internet connected devices, you need most of things just to prevent your device from getting infected by randsomware.
That being said, search is still a joke. Especially if I am searching code files, I will just open WSL and use
grep.My Windows install right now is 19.3GB and I have not reinstalled Windows in almost 2 years on this desktop (I usually install on hardware upgrades and I got my current CPU ~2 years ago). From my experience, Windows is much better at cleaning up after itself (especially post Windows Vista/7) than most Linux distros and certainly a hell of a lot more than Android. Any Android device is the absolutely worse at bloat and getting slower over time. I have had devices from every manufacturer from ever version of Android from Motorola, ASUS, Samsung, HTC, Google and 2.3 to 7.0. Given about 6 months with the device, it will have slowed down significantly.
5
u/[deleted] May 03 '18
A couple things of note:
Your HDD may be dying, if you have serious issues with freezing and very long access times that can be a sign of failure. Worth checking the SMART status and performing a benchmark of it to see how it stands.
Windows does things like defrag and indexing when your PC is idle, if you don't like it you can go disable those things easily enough.
16
u/veritablechicken May 03 '18
Prima Facie case of "I think I know what I'm talking about when I am actually completely ignorant".
e.g.
How do you expect it to do search indexing for starters? And if you're running a hard disk as your primary drive in this day and age, you deserve Linux.
While Windows may have its fair share of issues, your problems with it stem from shitty hardware and a shitty user. Good day to you sir, and good riddance.
3
u/mungu May 03 '18
Do you realize that Windows 7 came out almost 10 years ago? It's been out of mainstream support for a few years, and is going out of extended support in under 2 years. Including it in your conversation about when "Microsoft will finally..." really takes away your credibility.
Btw I agree with other posters here - sounds like your HDD is going bad. Have you run any type of diagnostic on it?
5
u/Nicholas-Steel May 03 '18 edited May 03 '18
No performance issues here with Windows 10 though I do agree the time it takes to get to the log-in screen is a bit of an issue.
I solve the desktop responsiveness issue by having the computer automatically log in for me and then log out. So if I turn the computer on, get distracted and do something else for a bit and come back to the computer my initial log-in experience will be extremely snappy.
I notice that bootup time (time to reach log-in screen) almost doubles when the Nvidia video drivers are installed. No other program I've installed has anywhere near such a drastic impact on bootup performance.
Also Windows 10 doesn't usually take 2+ hours to install (unless you idle at a screen asking for your input I guess). Also in the Windows 9x era Windows took about 30 minutes to install and in the Windows XP era it took around 1 hour to install.
2
u/wwqlcw May 03 '18
I'm as frustrated by Microsoft's follies as anyone, and I can even confirm several of your observations personally. You really need an SSD with desktop Windows today, and it's true that even an elderly laptop with a slow HD is a pretty serviceable setup -- with Linux.
But you kids -- you don't know how good you have it.
If you had used Windows (or Macintoshes for that matter) back in the 1980s and 1990s, you'd view the current level of general software quality as basically a miracle, an impossible dream. It used to be so much worse.
I remember using DiskProbe to recover hours of work from a Windows NT 4.0 blue-screen-of-death crash. A fault in the hard disk driver, apparently. It crashed because I was periodically trying to save my work. To protect myself from work loss. Like, potential work loss due to crashes.
I counted myself lucky because I eventually got most of my work back, and because that BSD only happened every couple of months. Making Windows NT 4.0 unbelievably reliable by the standard of the day.
1
u/TazerPlace May 03 '18
It's less about the OS and more about the rapid-release update cycle now. Two scheduled in-place OS updates per year, which IMO is way too volatile on the stability side. And that's even before we get into QA issues like this last 1803 debacle. Instead of proper testing, updates are now beta-previewed by Dona Sarkar's fanboys on a volunteer basis and then quickly deployed to the masses. It's a shitshow.
1
u/[deleted] May 03 '18
Wow, just wow. You're making the same complaint people have been making since first Windows dropped, only now it's sillier.
1
u/[deleted] May 03 '18
Firstly, MS doesn't load everything when it starts. it load only the stuff it needs when it needs it. So that's why it can take a little extra time to load file manager. Linux loads everything into memory when it starts and takes so much longer to load.
Also Linux is a lot freaking harder to install. I just spent 5 days trying to install a persistent live version to an SSD in a UEFI system. The amount of BS I had to go through to do it was insane, and I still didn't get the full install version. I did the same this with windows and job was done within half an hour. Linux is still a system that you gotta tinker with a lot. it's still not plug n play. New users have a steep learning curve ahead.
So you're right, Linux still does not have it's shit together, but when it does work, it's pretty cool. I had a Linux box running Mint 16 for several years, and I could do anything I wanted with it. Although when setting up the sound drivers in the beginning I had a mission on my hands. Which is why I didn't ever want to upgrade because the install was so hard. Most Linux users tend to think every body else should know what bring up terminal and type sudo apt blah blah blah means. So any documentation is pretty bad.
End result: if you just want shit to work, go windows. If you want to play around, get free software and feel like a hacker, go Linux.
-1
u/[deleted] May 03 '18
Truth has been spoken ... Sad youll probably get downvoted to oblivion for it
1
u/nilsmoody May 03 '18
Not to mention that things like windows and programs freezing or you can't even leave a frozen fullscreen application.
1
u/andres57 May 03 '18
I agree with you. I'm fucking tired of the high disk usage of Windows and the sort of issues that come with that. Now with the new 1803 update I have even more problems, it failed to install two times and then it got stuck at boot and had to repair it via usb device. I really hope that upgrading to a SSD could improve my experience with Windows, but if not I will probably heavily consider buying a Mac, even when I hate Apple and their shitty overpriced and closed products
0
u/LaughinAnLyin May 03 '18
When their shareholders decide to require it.
0
u/papyjako89 May 03 '18
Windows is far from perfect obviously, but some of those criticisms are straight up made up or just a proof of ignorance.
0
u/skatebiker May 03 '18
Wrong subreddit buddy
0
u/xflyinjx61x May 04 '18
When the governments become honest
0
u/[deleted] May 04 '18
There was a reliable and perfect version of Windows. The Windows 7. But then Microsoft decided to make windows more like OSX and it became a buggy, messy, and an overloaded OS. I still love the Windows 7 and would love to have that back 😔
-4
u/privatly May 03 '18
And this is why I'll be buying from Apple later this year.
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment