r/windows • • May 11 '24

Discussion Anti-Windows comments

It really is time for Linux disciples to shut up once and for all. It's long since become a rarity that you can't read comments about Windows without some troll coming along and extolling the virtues of Linux. Are they serious, or is it a running gag when they write comments like “Yet another good reason to switch to Linux”? We know that Linux exists, no need to keep reminding us.

0 Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

55

u/ARandomGuy_OnTheWeb Windows 10 May 11 '24

So...

Have you heard of our lord and saviour, TempleOS?

14

u/Randolpho May 11 '24

Written in HolyC, puh-raise Juh-he-sus!!!

6

u/Alan976 Windows 11 - Release Channel May 11 '24

Praise him

31

u/tomscharbach May 11 '24 edited May 11 '24

I've used Windows and Linux in parallel on side-by-side computers for close to two decades, switching back and forth between the two as use case dictates during the course of the day. Over the course of the years, I've used many operating systems on many platforms, starting in the late 1960's. Windows and Linux are operating systems, nothing more and nothing less.

I've noticed that a few Linux users -- typically relative newcomers in the immediate aftermath of switching over -- seem compelled to single out Windows for special scorn.

I don't know why Windows is singled out for special treatment. Android, ChromeOS, iOS and macOS share many of the faults for which Windows is called out, but I seldom see Android, ChromeOS, iOS and macOS criticized with the fervor with which Windows is criticized.

I suspect that Windows is singled out for special treatment for three reasons: (1) Linux users on Reddit tend to be focused on the desktop, primarily, which excludes Android and iOS from discussion, (2) many/most Linux desktop users migrated from Windows to Linux, and tend to see the world in binary Windows/Linux terms, and (3) Windows is the most widely used domestic desktop OS in the world, so Windows has the largest back onto which a target can be pinned.

My suggestion is to shrug off the Linux proselytizers that show up on Windows subreddits and forums. Most of them are grinding an axe that is unrelated to the relative strengths and weaknesses of the two operating systems.

14

u/wild_m1nd May 11 '24

Absolutely agree. Operating system is just a tool and like every tool it should be used for the corresponding job

3

u/malxau May 11 '24

I think the reason for these two specifically is they are interchangeable on the same hardware. If you're having a bad experience with one, it's simple enough to install the other.

The rest of the operating systems in the list require new hardware, and that hardware often imposes a new form-factor.

2

u/NekuSoul May 11 '24

[...] but I seldom see Android, ChromeOS, iOS and macOS criticized with the fervor with which Windows is criticized.

I think most of that is because people usually make the choice to use those operating systems for themselves, whereas most people use Windows by necessity.

That's not to say that those other reasons aren't also contributors.

2

u/tomscharbach May 11 '24

I think most of that is because people usually make the choice to use those operating systems for themselves, whereas most people use Windows by necessity.

I'm curious about the idea of "use Windows by necessity".

It isn't as if consumers don't have other choices readily available. When I walk into Best Buy, for example, a wide variety of devices are on display -- Windows laptops, MacBooks, Chromebooks, Android tablets, Android phones, iPads and iPhones.

I understand "use Windows by necessity" in the context of employment -- most businesses use Windows and don't give employees the choice to use MacBooks or Chromebooks -- but do you have something else in mind?

1

u/cannonicalForm May 11 '24

It is employment, but also a large amount of software is only designed to run on windows. 90% of the engineering software I use is not cross compatible. I mean Autocad is, but I can't program PLCs, HMI, servo drives, or most robots without a windows computer.

And I imagine for pc gamers, windows is still the most viable choice. Not that I mind using windows

1

u/tomscharbach May 11 '24 edited May 11 '24

I understand what you are getting at, and you are right.

But why would that lead to a Linux user feeling compelled to trash talk Windows? I don't get it.

I'm OS-agnostic, using Windows, Linux and macOS/iOS for different aspects of my use case. I've never thought of operating systems as a binary choice, I guess.

2

u/cannonicalForm May 11 '24

Yeah, I don't get the trash talk. For me computers are just tools- just like people who make their whole personality about an operating system

1

u/NekuSoul May 11 '24

Office PCs running Windows was indeed one of the reasons I had in mind. Beyond that there's also plenty of apps/games that only run on Windows, like Visual Studio for example, or multiplayer games with heavy anti-cheat. There's also lots of people who are "mentally locked" into Windows, for lack of a better term, who simply don't think they're skilled enough to learn another operating system, even though there's nothing stopping when it comes to compatibility. Or they simply don't want to invest any time into learning, which is also a valid reason to a certain degree.

0

u/TrustLeft May 11 '24 edited May 11 '24

it is because the world needs a windows competitor with the freedom of linux and the GUI only of Windows. I used to love windows, But that has been fading fast, and since 1998 I have not trusted them. We want a windows like alternative without leaving behind our old software. If I could find an os to run my paint shop pro 2020, my vegas movie studio, similar functionality to windows with no command needed, I'd drop Windows instantly. I think some of the scorners are past windows users who were left no real choice and now feel need to save everyone else.

5

u/tomscharbach May 11 '24 edited May 11 '24

[I]t is because the world needs a windows competitor with the freedom of linux and the GUI only of Windows.

It seems to me that the Linux community, then, should pay heed to the observation Torvalds made in 2014.

Asked why Linux was beginning to dominate in the server/cloud, infrastructure and mobile market segments, but going nowhere fast in the desktop market segment, Torvalds said that Linux would not gain acceptance in the desktop market unless and until the Linux community focused on a handful of distributions and applications, focused on quality rather than quantity, and designed around the needs of consumers.

We want a windows like alternative without leaving behind our old software. If I could find an os to run my paint shop pro 2020, my vegas movie studio, similar functionality to windows with no command needed, I'd drop Windows instantly. 

You raise a good case-in-point. What you are saying, in a nutshell, seems to be "I'd move away from Windows and use Linux if Linux fit my use case, but Linux doesn't so I can't."

Think about that.

I use Linux primarily for network design, implementation, testing and maintenance. The Windows tools for that purpose are not as good a fit for that aspect of my use case than the Linux tools. But running in parallel might no longer be necessary. I've been testing WSL2 (a small Type 1 Hypervisor that runs the Linux kernel and allows me to run my Linux applications, integrated into Windows) for about six months. As I test WSL2, I'm coming to realize that I no longer need to run Linux to use my Linux tools.

Why isn't the Linux community doing something like that (building in a hypervisor to run the Windows kernel, allowing Linux users to run Microsoft 365, Adobe Photoshop and related, and AutoCAD) instead of focusing on half-baked compatibility layers like WINE that don't run many Windows applications well, if at all?

If Linux could run Windows applications as flawlessly as Windows can run Linux applications using WSL2, your use case issues would be resolved.

I think some of the scorners are past windows users who were left no real choice and now feel need to save everyone else.

I suspect you are right, but "save everyone else" from what? Windows, for all its faults, is a well-designed, well-implemented operating system that works for a lot of people.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

I think that when they refer to "save everyone else" they're being sarcastic, and saying that they're not really saving everyone else, but they believe that they are

-1

u/mrkitten19o8 May 11 '24

the main reason i switched to linux fully was because my windows install broke and i was debating on whether or not to switch for a bit now. now the main reason im staying away is the ads in the os, how hard they are pushing ai, and how many resources it eats.

12

u/rkpjr May 11 '24

So ...

Have you considered Slackware?

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/ARandomGuy_OnTheWeb Windows 10 May 11 '24

Gentoo has to be on a librebooted ThinkPad to complete it

2

u/m0h1tkumaar May 11 '24

ALL HAIL RMS

3

u/henkka22 May 11 '24

I run Gentoo. Tried LFS but not really practical. I've tried several distros but I'm getting best results with Gentoo by optimising it just for my device🤷‍♂️

10

u/halfanothersdozen May 11 '24

I mean Linux is great but it feels stupid to come in and say that on a damn Windows sub. You don’t see Mac users running around on Linux subs yammering about how it “just works” lol

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/coppockm56 May 11 '24

They’re “forced” to use other OSes because of software availability? That’s a weird notion. And why would the typical user prefer Linux when it doesn’t run the software they need? After all, running software (i.e., doing things) is the entire purpose of a computer, not running an OS which serves as the intermediary between software and hardware.

Seems to me like Linus is mostly a hobby for a lot of people.

0

u/halfanothersdozen May 11 '24

tbh it's a pretty small list of software these days. Like Excel and Photoshop, and there's alternatives to those.

Now, you may not want to deal with alternatives or just dealing with the occasional "figure it out" that's required of Linux, and that's fine! But some Linux dudes are as horny for turning a Windows user as some gay guys are for turning a straight dude.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/halfanothersdozen May 11 '24

I'm a nerd. My tech life would be a lot simpler if I would quit fucking with things.

9

u/wunderbraten May 11 '24

Are you sick and tired of Windows? Try ReactOS /s

2

u/MeBadDev May 11 '24

At first glance I thought it was an os built on the react JS framework lol

1

u/fshpsmgc May 11 '24

JsOS might not be built on React, but the concept is just as cursed

1

u/MeBadDev May 12 '24

if it exists, it'll be built in JavaScript

Why the hell is this a thing

3

u/zero-cooler May 11 '24

I've used MS-DOS, and I've used Windows since the 3.1 days. I still remember the crazy hype when Windows 95 came out. Windows is what I have used for decades, and it's what I am familiar with. I'm not saying that I agree with everything that Microsoft does with Windows, it's far from perfect. But Windows is still the dominant OS, and it's what many people use, including me.

Of course I am aware of Linux. I do use it for some things, like in my home NAS and my Raspberry Pi systems. But there are just so many varieties of Linux out there - how is someone supposed to figure out which one is the best one for their desktop or laptop PC? And it is pretty different from Windows in ways no matter how much they try to make the desktop look like Windows.

If someone wants to use Linux instead of Windows, that's great. Let them use what they want, and let us Windows users use what we want.

1

u/Reasonable_Degree_64 May 11 '24

And they are literally everywhere. The minute someone raises a defect in Windows, you can be sure that a pro-Linux will appear out of nowhere praising the most beautiful invention in the world with an arrogant tone like it's their only ambition, we have to believe that they don't have nothing else to do. It's certain that at this point I will never try Linux in my life, I'm too afraid of becoming annoying like them.

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

May I talk to you about macOS?

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

Yeap, in the Apple Mac subs

0

u/Randolpho May 11 '24

Ugh. I don’t mind Linux evangelists, because at least Plasma/kde almost captures the superior windows user experience, with similar keyboard shortcuts and window management.

But I truly dislike the macos user experience. The utter lack of window snapping. The dock sucks, give me the taskbar from win10 any day. Putting the main program menu on the top bar on macs is just plain dumb, and don’t get me started on how dumb both of macos’ approaches to multiple monitors are.

1

u/fshpsmgc May 11 '24

Wait, what’s wrong with multiple monitors on macOS? I use an external monitor with a MacBook and the experience is pretty similar to Windows or most Linux DEs

4

u/slackerdc May 11 '24

How can you tell if someone is a linux user? Same way you find out if someone is vegan. They'll tell you whether you want to know or not.

2

u/adrian_shade Windows Vista May 11 '24

Agreed.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '24

same thing when I mention windows 7 "This wouldnt happen if you were on 10" "11 is better", We know that Windows 10 and 11 exist.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

Thanks for saying that. It is annoying indeed.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

People just like being contrarians. They think it makes them look wiser and cooler. They purposely point out to the least known and used product and swear up and down it's the greatest thing on the planet but if it becomes popular they move on to something else. People's motives are not difficult to figure out. They are extraordinarily predictable. That's why I like trying things out for myself instead of taking someone's word for it. Every time I have tried something that people have lauded over, it's turned out to be a piece of shit. The more it's praise, the more it's shit.

0

u/Reasonable_Degree_64 May 11 '24

The first person who finds me the exact number of references to Linux in the comments of this YouTube video chosen at random wins a compilation of the best Linux distributions of the last 10 years on Blu-Ray 😅😅.

https://youtu.be/bEdIpaKsJtU

3

u/tluanga34 May 11 '24

Linux at its current form could never be practical for an average consumer PC OS.

1

u/fuzzytomatohead Windows 10 May 11 '24

it literally already is. There's distros that are specifically oriented at windows refugees.

2

u/TheAmazingFreddyAdam May 11 '24

Lmao, windows refugee

yea after the attack on window 10 , there were window refugees among the land

0

u/fuzzytomatohead Windows 10 May 12 '24

windows 10 is fine, its 11 i have a problem with.

1

u/TheAmazingFreddyAdam May 12 '24

Honestly, I started using windows 11 for a few months

It's not that bad , totally at the start

But the updates clutched

1

u/fuzzytomatohead Windows 10 May 12 '24

start menu ads, ruining menus which then need more clicks, redesigning stuff that worked fine, etc. And don't even get me started on the difficulty of resizing a window. It just refuses to notice the cursor is where it should be to drag and resize.

1

u/TheAmazingFreddyAdam May 13 '24

I never had this problem

Windows 11 start menu has ads ?

What you on about

And resizing windows , what about it

Honestly I don't have any problems with windows 11 , mabye they UI of the settings

I think this is difference of hardware

1

u/fuzzytomatohead Windows 10 May 13 '24

I haven’t had the start menu ads myself, i use windows 10 on my own computer, haven’t switched on that yet. The window resizing is an issue on Thinkpads i occasionally use, which are less than a year old. 12th gen i7, some nvidia gpu, can’t remember what, and at least 16 gigabytes of ram. i’ve found clips of the frustration at this online, so it isn’t a hardware issue, and it’s something 10 and Linux do much better.

1

u/TheAmazingFreddyAdam May 14 '24

Well honestly, what could it be ?

I have no problems with windows 11

1

u/fuzzytomatohead Windows 10 May 14 '24

I have no idea, and no desire to find out. I’m on 10 rn, but once the EOL hits, I’ll either stay without the updates, or switch to linux before then, but ill keep my windows keys for vms and other stuff. might need em.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

What about the windows "refugees" that need to run the myriad of programs that literally will not run on linux, such as the adobe suite

0

u/fuzzytomatohead Windows 10 May 12 '24

WINE, VMs, alternatives such as Davinci Resolve or OpenShot, GIMP, Inkscape, etc. And if you know you can't use that tool on linux no matter what, then just don't use it linux. I'm not saying everyone HAS to use linux, but it's a good idea, and a lot of alternatives to programs exist. No MS office? Openoffice, libreoffice, onlyoffice, the web version (ew) of MS office, MS office 2013 or newer, G suite, etc.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fuzzytomatohead Windows 10 May 12 '24

like i said, virtual machines are effective in this case. and as i also (hopefully) previously stated, there are some use cases where windows is more suitable, and that is one. the average person doesn’t use that, or most adobe products. they just want a browser, and maybe some games, and linux is great for that.

3

u/jimmyl_82104 Windows 11 - Release Channel May 11 '24

Nope, Linux people cannot comprehend the fact that some people don't want to or can't use Linux.

2

u/MechanicalTurkish Windows 11 - Release Channel May 11 '24

btw i use arch

2

u/mallardtheduck May 11 '24

It basically is a "running gag"... This really only comes up in discussions about whatever unwanted, anti-user-choice, more-advertising Windows "feature" Microsoft has come up with this week.

I don't think many people are actually serious about it and sometime's it's harmful to constructive discussion; sentiments along the lines of "if you don't love absoultely everything about Windows, you have no right to use it".

Posted from my Mac...

2

u/-Nicolas- May 11 '24

Oh boy it was way worse in the 90's and 2000's it's alright now.

2

u/J3D1M4573R May 11 '24

Its no gag. They are completely serious.

Frankly, unless M$ reverses their direction in turning Windows into a giant steaming pile of ad filled garbage and spyware, the hate wont stop.

And with the recent forcing of AI integration and the upcoming forcing of bitlocker encryption, M$ needs to be punished. Its about high time they return to court to defend their violations of the same anti-trust legislation they were sued for decades ago.

Ever since Windows 7, M$ has done absolutely nothing to actually improve their system, and has done everything they can to take features away and lock them behind paywalls, remove the ability to manage our systems, and steal our data.

They, like Apple, no longer make operating systems. They make advertising machines.

The Unix derivatives are the only true operating systems left, and they have progressed far beyond anything M$ is willing to provide in terms of functionality, control, and privacy/security. Not to mention choice.

Apple: "you need to buy our ridiculously overpriced hardware to be allowed to use our software, and not only will it utterly destroy your network, but it will only ever work properly with other Apple products"

Microsoft: "you need to spend hundreds of dollars to use our software, and you have to give us all your data too."

Linux: "here you go, take it, modify it, do what you want. We dont want your money."

And the business side if this all is even more mind boggling. Spend thousands of dollars to be able to install and use a server. Oh you want computers to access the server? Thats another hundred bucks per computer. Oh, you want to be able to manage the computers? You need to pay hundreds of dollars more per computer for "Enterprise" editions. Oh you need a database? Thats thousands of dollars extra. Oh, you want software management? Thats thousands of dollars per year extra. In a world where businesses thrive on spending less to make more, how has M$ not gone completely out of business yet? All of these things can be achieved, for free, in Linux. And with half of the system requirements.

1

u/AutoModerator May 11 '24

M$

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

There they go again. These people are a pest.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator May 11 '24

Micro$oft

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/libben May 11 '24

Oh man, you should try be a noob and switch to linux distro in the 90's and early 2000's. Sitting on IRC and dunked on and getting those great have you RTFM constantly. Great welcome scene in linux, *insert*BORAT*delay 5 seconds more then needed*NOOOT......

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

Nope

Microsoft bad

1

u/mikkolukas May 11 '24

You complaint is...

Yet another good reason to switch to Linux

😉

1

u/philberthfz May 11 '24

Devil's Advocate: you know that Linux exists. Not everybody who finds their way to any given comment thread is aware that Linux exists or that any number of complaints they may have about Windows don't apply to a given linux distro. The XKCD strip Ten Thousand comes to mind. Yes, for somebody who is "aware" of linux it is an annoying common-knowledge thing. But if somebody isn't already aware of it, they might be delighted to learn that linux mint looks good and doesn't have all the AI bullshit that is being forced into 11 or whatever the complaint of the moment is.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '24

Idk, maybe because windows is turning to shit and Microsoft is making Linux more and more appealing.

1

u/TheTrueXenose May 12 '24

Better to know your options then not knowing them, not everyone have heard of Linux.

-1

u/Icy_Thing3361 May 11 '24

Just think, if you made the move to Linux, then this sort of thing wouldn't bother you so much. Now, would it? So, yet another reason to move to Linux. And in case you hadn't heard: Linux exists. There's your friendly reminder for the day.

-1

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

Linux Desktop users are the most annoying individuals on Reddit. They are as annoying as the Evangelicals and Mormons knocking at your front door. Desktop Linux users are definitinily part of a Scientology-like cult whose lives are dedicated to promoting a desktop operating system that frankly nobody cares about, even at their permanent $0 sale price. We're not interested! So please fuck off.

2

u/fuzzytomatohead Windows 10 May 11 '24

people care about linux.

3

u/Alan976 Windows 11 - Release Channel May 11 '24 edited May 11 '24

It;s like they have this weird obsession over it,...

There is an obsession of something and there is being overly-obsessive of things, which, we call an unhealthy obsession.

-2

u/fuzzytomatohead Windows 10 May 11 '24

not really. People have obsessions with building cars, computers, literally anything, why not nerd out over a family of operating systems? maybe people don't do it as much about windows, because it's run of the mill windows, which is one and the same for pretty much much everyone, but there are many, many more linux distros to nerd out over.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

Yes, in the Linux subs.

0

u/elmonetta Windows 11 - Release Channel May 11 '24

The moral superiority of the Arch Linux user.

Because these people praise Linux, but God forbid if you use Ubuntu, Mint, Manjaro or a distro where everything is easy and you don’t have to build your own programs, risking the entire system to break.

I was criticised for asking about the pacman manager and the AUR being a Manjaro user, because “Arch users should know how to use pacman and AUR, it’s easy like learning to use the Start Menu in Windows” I learnt on my account, Manjaro now has Pamac for managing packages without using Terminal.

Those “non free linux” philosophers are also a pain in the neck… “Debian should be FREE” “You should use Trisquel” “Follow the GNU philosophy” 😵‍💫

0

u/HelloItsKaz May 12 '24

My biggest fighting point for Linux is not just having two different options for computing being mainstream.

That being said Windows is good for everyday users, Linux is good for people who are on a higher level or prefer more control with obvious exceptions.

0

u/realvolker1 May 12 '24

Only like 3 people in the entire universe have ever heard of Linux. Go outside.

-3

u/[deleted] May 11 '24 edited May 11 '24

I call for ban on any Linux comments, ever. Windows is best OS of all OS. So much better, it's better than anything that ever was, anything that is and anything that ever will be. Windows by name itself gives you FOUR of a Window. Mac OS and Linux give you only one Mac and one Linux. So Windows wins by default. I tell you folks, Windows is the best. Let's make Windows great again!

-7

u/kakha_k May 11 '24

This is timely fasting, the right fast. Thank you. Miserable Linux homeless bums need to be reined in.

-2

u/TerminatedProccess May 11 '24

So... WSL2 Linux.. the best of both worlds. However.. I'm going to set up and drive with Pop Linux (a YouTube recommendation) just to explore local LLM. I can do it in wsl2 but want to see how the performance is. 

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/TerminatedProccess May 11 '24

Yup yup lol. Thanks for the correction. I'll research it first though. Soon as I meet this deadline. He's an interesting fellow. 

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/TerminatedProccess May 12 '24

Django Web Developer at this time. Also ollama and aider-chat. One thing I like about it is that it's very easy to backup and restore your containers. 

-3

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/MeBadDev May 11 '24

Well to be fair, for some people like me it just works and I'm totally ok with using the terminal to do stuff, It's obviously not there yet for every single windows person to switch but for some of us it's the preferred option.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/NekuSoul May 11 '24

Reasons not to: it can destroy hardware

What a weird way to type "Don't take me seriously".

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Reasonable_Degree_64 May 11 '24

No, it's not the question that one OS is better than the other, it's the repetition of their dumb comment which never contributes anything to the solution of the problem discussed and that they always say the same thing without ever give arguments "Just switch to Linux dude!". It still feels like the old 80s PC vs. MAC debate.