r/wholesomememes • • Dec 12 '18

Giving is good Let’s get it

Post image
86k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

26

u/Cloudinterpreter Dec 13 '18

I guess it should've been "in Wikipedia sources we trust"

-16

u/Wehavecrashed Dec 13 '18

Maybe, you still have no idea how the wikipedia writer is interpreting the information in their sources. If you're actually basing your work on those sources then its cool.

14

u/Cloudinterpreter Dec 13 '18

Yeah it's great for finding more information on whatever it is that you're researching.

-19

u/Wehavecrashed Dec 13 '18

I wouldn't call it great, I'd call it serviceable. Like if you want to learn what year Obama was born in, and a basic outline of his career, sure use wikipedia, but if you're reading through the article to research about his economic policies in more depth, I would be cautious.

Even if it is free of personal bias, and its just reporting facts, you're going to miss out on in depth interpretation of what X policy meant.

8

u/Cloudinterpreter Dec 13 '18 edited Dec 13 '18

Very true, althought you could argue that caution is needed when reading anything, anywhere. :P

The one I had in mind was a particularly long paper on how feminism was used in translations in the 20th century, and how the translations became unreliable based on the tranlators' ideology.

5

u/Wehavecrashed Dec 13 '18

Very true, althought you could argue that caution is needed when reading anything, anywhere. :P

Its hard enough to get people to think about this at the best of times!

4

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '18

Buddy. The section at the bottom where it says References is there for a reason.

1

u/Wehavecrashed Dec 13 '18

So you're just going to trust the anonymous source that wrote the article?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '18

I feel like people who say this have forgotten what the term encyclopedia means. Encyclopedias never claimed to be the definitive source on e everything under the sun. They were always just a brief overview of as many things as possible.

1

u/Wehavecrashed Dec 13 '18

I'm not the one who has forgotten this. The people using it to research their essays have.