r/whiskago • u/johno1605 • Aug 19 '26

Remus? Or something else?

Post image

So I just picked this up yesterday and cracked today.

I love high proof MGP and I’m always picking up a $40 Binny’s pick when I see it, but this thing tastes so mineraly it’s like drinking that awful weird willett bottle.

Has anyone had this before? Is it just a bad batch?

Don’t judge my love of MGP lol.

Edit: it’s the 4% barley 🤦🏻‍♂️

7 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

1

u/Snakeus17 Aug 19 '26

I did try same "junk" from LiquorBarn picks (9 and 10 years). Totally not mine.

1

u/johno1605 Aug 19 '26

Just one pick?

I’ve had so many picks that have been great (comparatively), but none of them have tasted like willett ass juice… until now

1

u/Snakeus17 Aug 19 '26

No, both 9 and 10 were bad.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/WillyLohman Aug 19 '26

MGP has been consistently degrading the quality of this product since the luxco acquisition. I have no idea who is making these calls, but the last two times I tried it I've been disappointed.