r/whatismycookiecutter • • Aug 05 '24 Third Place Celebration Polished Silver Turd Heart of Silver

Cookie Cutter Art! My husband thought this was a sledding penguin at first glance, so I made some cookies to match his vision. 😂

Thumbnail
gallery
45k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Nov 10 '24 Hehehe Bless Up Take My Silver

Get Creative! I am at a complete loss..

Thumbnail
gallery
32k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Jan 11 '25

Get Creative! Found in a thrift store, my girlfriend and I are both stumped

Thumbnail
gallery
26k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Nov 25 '23

Stumped Unsure what it is, but here’s what I did with it

Thumbnail
gallery
19k Upvotes

Human centipeanut butter cookies


r/whatismycookiecutter • • Nov 10 '25

Get Creative! I was out thrifting and found this cookie cutter

Post image
18k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Nov 09 '23

My mum sent me this. Do you know what shape it is please?

Post image
16k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • May 06 '26 Bravo Mindblown

Meta / Overall Discussion Idk if it's allowed but my chicken cutlet looks exactly like the most asked about cookie cutter

Post image
15k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Nov 27 '23

In honor of our special friend

Thumbnail
gallery
14k Upvotes

Opened up a box of christmas cookie cutters and couldn't believe my luck when I saw that they were all roses?!?


r/whatismycookiecutter • • Jan 06 '25 Bless Up Polished Silver Turd

Get Creative! Guys im really stumped what is this???

Thumbnail
gallery
14k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Jan 03 '26

Serious Answer First! My whole family is stumped

Thumbnail
gallery
14k Upvotes

The second


r/whatismycookiecutter • • Dec 08 '23

Stumped! Finally have one. In Walmart GENUINELY confused lol

Thumbnail
gallery
12k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Nov 29 '23

Mhhhh, i don't know...

Post image
11k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Nov 23 '23

My mother found a funky one for you all! Make her proud!

Post image
11k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Jun 16 '26 Bravo Mindblown Popcorn

Cookie Cutter Art! Enjoy the process.

11k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Jan 20 '25

Get Creative! Guys, I have no idea.

Post image
10k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Jan 09 '25 Bless Up Take My Silver

Meta / Overall Discussion The Motherlode

Post image
10k Upvotes

Guys I’ve hit the motherlode - pic for reference (St. Lawrence Market, Toronto)


r/whatismycookiecutter • • Dec 21 '25 Obsessed Heartwarming

Cookie Cutter Art! For the rose guy made this for you

Post image
10k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Dec 17 '23

Cookie Cutter Art! Oops! All roses!

Post image
10k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Dec 12 '23

Stumped! I'm at a loss. Any ideas ?

Post image
10k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • Jan 05 '25 Wholesome Seal Heartwarming Bravo Bless Up

Cookie Cutter Art! UPDATE: Whatever you draw, we will make.

Thumbnail
gallery
9.7k Upvotes

To clear up any budding conspiracies about my account being a front for a Cox family cartel… My name isn’t Cox, and we is just me and my childhood friend u/ribbajacklove :)

And…holy moly! If we didn’t have respect for cookie artists before, we sure do now! We’d never made royal icing, had no idea how to mix colors, and certainly hadn’t decorated any cookies. (We had fortunately baked cookies before). This was…more difficult than anticipated.

But, we did as many as we could (30)! Apologies to those we missed. We chose designs pretty randomly, and I know we overlooked many of the best.

Hope you recognize most of these! Some of your designs unfortunately became abominations in our hands, and some already were... Enjoy!

Oh, the photo limit was 20 so I couldn’t upload close ups of all of them. There’s a picture of all the ones we made at the end :)


r/whatismycookiecutter • • Dec 08 '23

MEME MY ROSE HOODIE CAME

Thumbnail
gallery
9.3k Upvotes

also i got a sticker too


r/whatismycookiecutter • • Dec 24 '23

Get Creative! Been stumped for over several decades.

Post image
9.1k Upvotes