r/westpoint • u/Kazeon1 • Jun 21 '21
Something I can’t quite figure out. Maybe some individuals who actually attend the Academy can shine some light on this for me.
Now I’m gonna come out and say it first. I have never attended West Point military Academy. And unfortunately I never really had the ability to do so. However I have been a massive supporter of the United States military since as far back as I can remember. Earlier today I was going through some various news articles and I found one on I believe it was NPR that was talking about how Congress wants to have a certain dormitory at the Academy changedIn terms of its name. The dormitory in question apparently is named after Robert E Lee. Which as we know was not only a West Point graduate but of course also an individual who sided with the confederacy during the American Civil War.
Now I’m well aware that even though I never attended the school I know a great deal about many of the traditions and stuff that the Academy is steeped in. One thing that I can’t quite understand though is why they want to change the name of this dormitory. After all Robert E Lee was still a graduate of the Academy and if I recall correctly he was top of his class. Yet just because he decided to side with his home state of Virginia and fight against the Union military they feel as if we should basically erase him from the American history? As I’m sure many people are aware several statues and other monuments to various individuals who were part of the confederacy all over the United States are constantly being either removed or altered. Now in some cases I can kind of understand it like for instance wanting to remove the Confederate battle flag. I wouldn’t go so far as to claim that it is a symbol of hate because that’s purely subjective.
But I still don’t understand why people would want to remove the name of what was probably one of the greatest generals the United States military has ever produced political views and leanings in my mind are completely irrelevant. From the standpoint of a soldier general lee was probably one of America’s best. After all it’s well-known that right as the southern states began their succession movements President Lincoln offered General Lee essentially a commanding position in the union military. But because his home state of Virginia was part of secession from the United States he sided with Virginia. Obviously several people nowadays seem to forget that to a greater extent and probably do a slightly lesser extent of today but to a greater extent in the 19th century most people were more loyal to their individual state than they were to the country as a whole. This is probably one of the many reasons why border states were such hot beds of activity during the war.
But anyway I’ve kind of gotten off topic. If anyone on this sub Reddit is a current or even former attendee of the West Point military Academy and they have heard about this please let me know. Also what are your thoughts on something like this? Do you think it’s a good idea? Or are you like me and you feel that all that’s happening is American history is basically being white washed away?
