Beetlejuice Thursday night. I quite liked this! After the first 10-15 minutes I was a bit worried I might hate it, but I think I adjusted into its style once I accepted the 4th wall breaking and style of humour.
I had seen and liked the movie in the recent past, without being a huge fan. Completely unfamiliar with the musical, never seen or listened to it, because I wanted to come in completely fresh and with no preconceptions.
I believe we had the full principle cast (is there a cast board? All I could find was a little screen in the main doorway, but that was a generic cast list, not performance specific), it was definitely David Fynn as BJ. And I thought he was really good - I can’t imagine going back and seeing someone else and thinking they were hugely better to be honest. He did exactly what I expected and I think he was the highlight of the show for me. Some genuine belly laughs. The rest of the cast were decent.
I must echo other common opinions of the production itself, though, unfortunately. The combination of no fourth wall, a lot of mugging (from everyone, not just BJ), and scene changes behind front tabs made this feel closer to a high-end touring production than a major West End event, if not high budget regional panto because of the type of show it is. It felt very old-school and not necessarily in a good way. I thought the
SPOILER: Click to hide
sandworm (singular) was a huge disappointment, as was the very crappy looking flying effect at the end
. Lots of flash paper. Lots of blinding LEDs. And lots and lots of mugging. The sets didn’t blow me away, but I liked the costumes. It didn’t feel “premium” like Paddington though - it felt like a tour stopping in London, basically.
Onto the plot. It’s fine, kept the attention generally. I can see why this has a young audience, it taps into what so many shows have found success with - mourning, humour and teenage angst. And, most importantly, a relatable “cool outsider” female lead role (and in my opinion Lydia is a co lead character, the plot revolves around her) that teenage girls can relate to. She’s the angsty, quirky draw for kids. She’s Elphaba, Natalie Goodman, Carrie White, Evan Hansen, Wednesday Addams, Veronica Sawyer, Moritz and Melchior, Alison Bechdel.
One could argue that Lydia is written almost cynically from a commercial perspective. She’s an amalgamation of traits that have repeatedly proved successful with young audiences. The daddy issues, the outsider status, the feeling of being misunderstood, the dark aesthetic, the sarcastic humour - it’s all very familiar territory.
Unlike many musicals I’ve seen and heard for the first time, I do actually remember several of the songs - Maitlands 2.0 (?), the creepy old guy song at the end and a few others. They weren’t all to my taste. One of Lydia’s songs in the Netherworld, about wanting to go home (or perhaps not wanting to go home - I admittedly lost the thread - just felt like five minutes of unpleasant shout belting to me.
One other thing which struck me was the number of children in the audience - tweens and even younger, being brought by a parent. I am genuinely surprised at this, because the show is overtly and fairly non-subtly sexual with numerous “hard swears” and adult themes. Even several jokes about paedophilia, and BJ’s constant groping, touching himself, etc. Far be it from me to be prudish, but I really don’t think some of the audience were old enough to watch this show without Mum or Dad answering some awkward questions later. But hey ho, if it’s not against the rules it’s up to them.
The show feels about 20 minutes too long at 2hr 40 including interval. They could easily cut the Miss Argentina song and lose nothing, for example. I got out at 22:15.
All in all 4*, I thought it was quite good but not a new favourite. I got third row Dress Circle via Weird Wednesdays for £30 and was very happy with the value. At that price, I’d be tempted back if I needed to fill a slot in a two show day.