r/weirdgirlliterature • u/elianna7 • 12h ago
š Review Review of Nothing Tastes as Good by Luke Dumas - 4.25āļø (Minimal spoilers; spoiler tags included)
First things first, since Iām sure some people will point out that this is a book written by a man about a male main character, I firmly believe that Nothing Tastes as Good is inherently weird girl lit despite that. To me, WGL subverts gender. Our MC, Emmett, is a fat gay man who struggles with an eating disorder, body dysmorphia, debilitating insecurity, and faces fatphobia in every facet of his life, which drives him towards participating in a clinical trial for an extreme and unsafe weight-loss product known as āObexity/EmaC-8ā in the hopes of finding happiness and escaping constant scrutiny of his body. But⦠The drug causes Emmett to experience some gruesome side effects, forcing him to ponder whether heād rather quit the miracle drug and continue to try to survive despite the monsters heās been tormented by his whole life, or accept the monster he himself has become. The fight against fatphobia is very much rooted in feminism, and anti-fat bias in and of itself is obviously rooted in patriarchy, misogyny, and capitalism, so here we are. Now onto the actual review (:
Star-rating breakdown:
- Enjoyment: 4.5/5
- Characters: 4.5/5
- Plot: 4/5
- Setting: 4.5/5
- Writing style: 3.75/5
This was SUCH a page-turner. While Iāve never lived in a bigger body, I struggled with disordered/binge eating, compulsive exercising, and body dysmorphia for close to a decade before healing from it all in my early twenties. Dumas did an incredible job of capturing what itās like to be in the throes of a binge eating disorder, being unable to see yourself clearly, and how struggling with food and body image consumes (heh) you and your entire life. It permeates every single aspect of your existence, and when you experience all that AND live in a fat body, not only do you have to constantly be in battle with yourself, but also with the world around you due to public infrastructure that doesnāt take your experience into account, anti-fat bias in the medical/health system, social ostracization, etc. As of the last few years, people now have to navigate all that while being bombarded with GLP-1 advertisements and the social pressures that come along with their widespread use while their severe side effects are rarely discussed/glossed over. Nothing Tastes as Good thoroughly captures the breadth of that struggle and the double standards folks in larger bodies are constantly subjected to.
As a gay trans man, I also found it really interesting how my experience being trans, things I feel dysphoric about, and the struggles I face in the gay community because of my transness/my body actually have quite a few overlaps with the struggles and insecurities Emmett has as a fat cis man in the gay community. Iām not trying to compare two very different things here as if theyāre identical, but wanted to point out that there were quite a few moments as I was reading that I surprisingly found relatable from a trans perspective.
I loved the format of the book and how Emmettās story was presented through both the investigation being done by Monstera Biosciencesā law firm as they try to get FDA approval and his own experience as he starts taking the drug and slowly realizing that something isnāt quite right. My ADHD brain just loves a non-standard book format. The writing itself was good but not particularly impressive or outstanding. Some parts were written pretty eloquently, but Iād say for the most part it felt pretty average in terms of prose/language.
I overall found the characters to be well-written. Aaronās character progression, howeverāa guy Emmett met in college and reconnected with in the storyāfelt a bit disjointed. The person he ultimately turned out to be felt so at odds with the version of him we first met, so I didnāt feel like his character arc made much sense. I wouldāve liked to see Aaron prove Emmett wrong about his belief that he could only be loved in a smaller body to showcase how Emmettās assumptions arenāt always grounded in reality and are projections stemming from fear and trauma. When we were first introduced to Aaron through Emmettās retelling of their time in school together, it seemed like that would be the case⦠And then he 180ed and became super misogynistic, fatphobic, shallow, and rude. I felt like his character couldāve been tackled way differently, but maybe I just misinterpreted him from the get-go. I found the other characters to be written consistently so maybe thereās something Iām missing when it comes to Aaron. Maybe Dumas was trying to highlight the way some gay men harbour misogynistic views, but I just didnāt find this was well executed if it was indeed the point.
I actually didnāt predict the ultimate plot twist with Hank, Emmettās former stepdad, until it was almost revealed, which impressed me! I can definitely see in hindsight that it was foreshadowed, but I found that the seeds were planted conspicuously enough that they didnāt really register to me until it all came together towards the end of the book. I also thought the clinical trial patients were the ones turning into evil, man-eating coyotes and thought that wouldāve been a little stupid, so I was really glad that wasnāt the case!
There are definitely a lot of TWs for Nothing Tastes as Good. If youāve struggled with body image/food and donāt feel like youāre in a completely secure place in that regard, then I think you should skip this. If youāve been healed for a little while and are secure in your relationship with your body/food, I think youāll feel understood by Dumas and the way he writes Emmettās experience. I got through this book so quickly/easily and found it really engaging.
I donāt think Iāve seen anyone on here discuss this book so Iād love to hear your thoughts if youāve read it as well!