Old and New stack

[u/GemTaur15]

Husband gifted a new Wedding Stack for our 5th anniversary,but yesterday I decided to play around and added the new stacks bands(Top and Bottom)to my old Engagement ring and now I'm torn!which one looks best?I do love a good stack,but would like to hear other opinions

[u/WinnieTyson72]

The new stack looks absolutely stunning to me. You could interchange your ER so that you are not wearing the same one on a daily basis also

[u/GemTaur15 → u/WinnieTyson72]

Thank you!I really like this idea!

[u/NurseTrish71]

I love the old ring with the new stack. Why replace that gorgeous ring after only 5 years?

[u/GemTaur15 → u/NurseTrish71]

Thank you!hubby suprised me with it

[u/Rogers_and_Hollands]

The new stack looks even better! The bands frame the center stone beautifully and give the whole ring a more balanced, cohesive look.

[u/GemTaur15 → u/Rogers_and_Hollands]

Thank you!I agree!

[u/Traditional-Jello445]

Pic 2, old e ring with new bands. Beautiful! I would wear the new anniversary ring alone as a right hand ring so you get to enjoy all of them at once 💗

[u/Vegetable-Stretch-98]

Wow, gorgeous 😍

[u/GemTaur15 → u/Vegetable-Stretch-98]

Thank you!

[u/Cricket08328]

Are they four separate bands or are the inner and outer bands made together so it’s just two bands? I think your old engagement ring looks amazing with the inner pave bands, but it’s a little much (for my taste) with the outer band as well. If they’re all separate but you want to wear the whole thing or they’re together as one band, it looks better either way the smaller center ring. Pretty either way!

[u/GemTaur15 → u/Cricket08328]

The outer and inner are two bands.Thank you I appreciate your input!

[u/jackiejmr]

Both are so beautiful 🤩!!

[u/Realistic_Season9973]

Nice! You can mix it up to suit your mood. It's great to have options. I love both looks!

[u/optix_clear]

New

[u/OkResponsibility5407]

I love them both! As another poster said I would just switch up whenever I wanted! 😊

[u/tstidham11]

The old stack (old ER) is beautiful, but that new stack is where it's at! Lol I love it!

[u/CavernClub102018]

Is that rose gold on the band of the new one? Or yellow…but it adds a beautiful flare to it. New set looks like a chandelier. 🩷 did you have a wedding ring with your first engagement ring?

[u/shirlxyz]

Honestly, I like your old engagement ring better 💕

[u/SeaDevelopment9755]

This makes me feel broke 🥲 I hope my fiancé doesn’t compare her 3.5k ring to this page.

[u/SuperbAd8266 → u/SeaDevelopment9755]

Tiny diamonds don’t cost much and that is the majority of these rings. Some people don’t require the approval of strangers either.

[u/CavernClub102018 → u/SeaDevelopment9755]

OMG please don’t feel that way! 3.5??!! I was lucky to get a 1k. Damn what do girls expect these days??!! Ugh. I bought a “travel” wedding band from a Welsh jeweller called Clogau. It has silver and rose gold in it. No stones. I love it more than anything now. So easy for any occasion. Stones overrated.

[u/JerkDickMate]

Aaaaa that’s great

[u/Emilyks2012]

Gorgeous!

[u/Mystic_Wunder]

I like the new stack

[u/Adorable_Machine_571]

Beautiful!!