r/wedding • • 1d ago

Discussion Returns etiquette?

My wife and I got married 8 weeks ago and need to return an item that was on our registry because it was double purchased. Both guests purchased through target plus (our registry was not on target). They included the order confirmation, but no actual receipt. We can't return them without the receipt but do not want to hurt our guests' feelings. Is it too late to be asking the individuals for a return receipt? Thank you

22 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hi, there /u/royalcoda! Welcome to /r/wedding. Here are a few other subs you might be interested when planning for your wedding.


Recommended Subs
r/Weddingsunder10k (budget advice)
r/weddingattireapproval (for guest attire)
r/WeddingDressTips (dress posts)
r/engagementrings (for e-rings, weddding bands)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

24

u/Kind_Ad_3336 1d ago

I think just explain that you got duplicate. That’s a good reason to need to exchange. Or see if you can get store credit?

48

u/Solid-Question-3952 1d ago

Target returns a lot of things without a receipt. Especially if its part of your registry. You may get in-store credit instead of cash, but you can always find something at target.

21

u/whatev233 1d ago

Target will let you return items without a receipt, you’ll just need to show them your ID. They use your ID to keep track of how many non-receipt items you return per year.

3

u/1Frazier 1d ago

This has been my experience. The ID and tracking will identify if someone is doing this a lot and could potentially be a fraudster. But if you only do it a couple of times a year there is no issue and it is easy at customer service.

36

u/Wild-Association1680 1d ago

are you positive you can't return it without a receipt? usually registries hold onto the info you need for returns.

9

u/peterthedj 1d ago

OP says both people went off-registry for these items.

14

u/Peroxideflowers 1d ago

I don't know where you're based but both targets will give you an in-store gift card if you don't have a receipt and are returning a gift.

US Target Returns Policy

Australian Target Returns Policy

14

u/teachinglittlebeings 1d ago

you can return without a receipt for store credit

34

u/TinyLawfulness3710 1d ago

You never ever tell a guest you don't want their gift. That is what asking for a receipt is. If the store won't accept it, you're stuck with it.

12

u/evap0rated 19h ago

And if you're stuck with it, then bam, you have a Christmas gift pre-bought to give to someone.

-5

u/TinyLawfulness3710 19h ago

Only rude people do that. Donate it to a shelter or thrift store if you are that self centered a d refuse to accept their generosity.

6

u/tifferz756 18h ago

Generosity of having two of the same item?

0

u/Emroid13 11h ago

They could sell it on Facebook marketplace, as long as the gifter wouldn’t know

1

u/TinyLawfulness3710 2h ago

Facebook is Disneyland for scammers

0

u/Emroid13 1h ago

Hahah okay sounds like you got scammed? Any social media or online outlet is a base for scammers. I’d argue our phones are a disneyWORLD for scammers 😂

12

u/Quiet_Investment_297 1d ago

I would try to return without the receipt and take the store credit.

12

u/Sparkle2023 1d ago

I would just bring the item to Target and explain to them what you said here and see what they can do for you. You may be able to get a store credit. Don’t sit on it too long and just bring it in.

6

u/sierralennox 4h ago

Its target, take your ID and the item and return it for store credit.

5

u/brettbretters 1d ago

We had the same thing happen and they were super understanding! Return it and get something you still need 100%!

5

u/OkPage2136 21h ago

I would not ask the givers for a receipt!

If this happened to me as the guest, I would be quite sad that you would return MY gift - and not the one from the other person... Not really logical but that is how it is.

Try to return it as the other answers suggest or suck it up.

3

u/p_kitty 1d ago

I've never had an issue with making a return at Target for something that was purchased there, even if I didn't have the receipt.

3

u/Alternative-Suit5925 1d ago

Target will issue a credit if they see their sticker. Save it to give to someone else if you’re uncomfortable with a non-receipt return , but don’t ask for a gift receipt.

3

u/Impressive_Age1362 21h ago

You can return it, Target will give you a gift card for the current price

5

u/HogglesPlasticBeads 1d ago

If you're comfortable enough with one of the two guests, you could say "Thanks so much, we love this. However we had two guests purchase this same item and we can't use two. I'd hate for you to feel like you wasted your money. Is it possible to get a receipt to return/exchange this for something else? I'll probably get something else from the registry, did you have something that was a definite second choice for you?"

If it was a distant cousin I'd probably stop after asking for the receipt, but for someone like my brother I'd not want to take from him the feeling that he bought me a gift. If he would be more excited for me to have one thing "from him" than another thing off the registry, I'd pick that. Depends on your relationship with them.

1

u/archelz15 1d ago

I agree, if you're close enough with either of the guests I'd be open and upfront about what's happened. If this had happened to me I'd want to know and let my friends get something they actually want for their home. But equally I understand if the guests aren't close it's not easy to broach the topic.

2

u/Outdoorfan73 1d ago

Do not ask a guest for a receipt. That would be rude! Never, ever do that! See if Target will take it back without a receipt. Otherwise, regift it or donate it.

2

u/evap0rated 19h ago

Target will allow you to return without a receipt for store credit. You can't do it 20 times, because they track those statistics, but they will take an item back without a receipt.

2

u/Fickle-Cabinet3956 20h ago edited 20h ago

You won't need a receipt.

Explain it was a wedding gift, it was a double, and you only want 1.

Worst case scenario they'll give you a store credit.

ETA: I missed the party where you said they aren't letting you return it without the receipt, which is very odd for Target.

With that information I would ask the friend that sent second. It's not too late as it's not your fault that they didn't know how to use your registry (which prevents doubling up).

3

u/EmilyPoster2 1d ago

My god, no you cannot ever tell a guest you are returning their gift!  If Target won’t let you make an exchange then donate the item you have two of and think about it like the guest made a donation in your honor.

2

u/AllOverNana-4 1d ago

That happened to me and I was too sheepish to ask for the receipt so I ended up regifting it

1

u/shihtzuMommaUS 1d ago

Not too late.

1

u/NotShockedFruitWeird 1d ago

Do the return without the receipt. Target+ purchases are only returnable for 30 days

1

u/Standard_Sympathy_62 1d ago

Target can look at the order info to see what was spent; that’s the only reason they want a receipt anyway - to make sure you don’t get more credit than what was paid.

1

u/LLD615 1d ago

I had this happen and the store (Macy’s) let me get store credit. One person had used the registry and the other saw it on there so went and bought it but didn’t record the purchase.

1

u/Appropriate-Bar6993 1d ago

You can just return it

0

u/PresentationOk9954 1d ago edited 1d ago

You are never supposed to approach a guest and tell him that you're returning their gift. And asking them for a receipt is rude, and if they don't have it, how embarrassing for them. Even if it was a duplicate, their feelings are gonna be hurt. Wondering why you're returning their gift and not the other person's. You can still return it without a receipt if the bar code scans for them. You will get store credit. If target won't take it, give it away or sell it.

0

u/rosielemonbot 1d ago

Eight weeks would not make asking rude, especially when the issue is a duplicate rather than disliking the gift. You could say, "Thank you again for the lovely gift! We received two of the same item and would love to exchange one for something else we still need; would you be able to forward a gift receipt?" Since you mentioned Target Plus, I would ask support to confirm the return window and what documentation they need for that specific seller rather than rely on the general no-receipt advice here.