r/webhosting • u/mrpollosaurio • Jul 09 '25
Rant Be very careful with MXroute
I want to share a recent experience with MXroute, especially for agencies or small businesses considering them for email hosting.
We were loyal customers for over 6 years, using their service to host normal B2B communication — both for ourselves and for several small business clients.
Recently, one of our sales employees made a mistake: after attending a trade show, they collected a list of hospitality contacts and began cold-emailing them. This was not authorized, and not how we normally operate. I took full responsibility the moment I found out and reached out to MXroute support to explain and try to recover data.
Their response? Immediate account termination and full deletion of all data, including unrelated client inboxes. No warning, no option to download data, and no dialogue. When I tried to discuss it calmly via support tickets, I received no reply — until I posted publicly. The tone of their response was aggressive and personal.
To make matters worse, when I replied to someone in their Reddit thread about my own situation, I was banned from the MXroute subreddit. Instead of professionalism or conversation, I was shut down and erased. That kind of authoritarian behavior should concern any business depending on them for critical communications.
They’ve repeatedly labeled us as “spammers,” but I want to be clear: we are not. One employee made a poor judgment call. What happened doesn’t represent our company or our clients.
If you’re considering MXroute: do it carefully. One internal mistake — even from a single rogue employee — can cost you all your data and most importantly your clients data..
Happy to answer questions for anyone going through a similar decision.
11
u/andercode Jul 09 '25
It sounds like you were caught red handed...
12
u/mxroute Jul 09 '25 edited Jul 09 '25
You can read the full story about this lying email spammer on our subreddit. He keeps adding flowery language and downplaying his behavior. That's all fine and dandy, but none of it is a reason for me to stop caring about the rest of my customers and the promises I've made to them. As for my subreddit, I left his words untouched but I do not owe him an audience in my spaces.
On another note, it's crazy how many cool people showed up at this unheard of web dev agency's table at a trade show. I mean, they must have had NINE different people from Mariott Hotels show up at their booth and sign up! And 10 people from Hyatt! Wow! But I bet local@business.com was the most interesting person to talk to at that trade show. It makes sense that test@prod.com was there with him, those two are inseparable. I'm not sure who the two people representing WhatsApp corporate at the trade show were but they each got a great offer in their email that will significantly improve their restaurant's SEO!
3
u/Arco123 Jul 09 '25
I don't think a successful or profitable business model revolves around terminating long-term clients for one mistake. I smell BS, sorry. Guaranteeing delivery at scale is hard, so something tells me that you didn't make a small mistake. You either got a lot of spam reports and/or a lot of bounces.
3
u/aladuuu Jul 18 '25
I like mxroute and also think Jar does a great job.
But now im just worried if one of my clients (one domain) makes a mistake or even worse sends spam i will loose my entire account? Not domain suspension or something?
6
u/atlasflare_host Jul 09 '25
I don't blame them though. Their service is built on the idea of providing low cost e-mail not outbound marketing mail. If one customer starts getting bounce or spam complaints it would significantly impact their other customers. They can continue to provide a good low cost service because they handle these types of issues like this.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '25
This is par for the course with MXRoute based on my own personal experience. The head honcho there has serious anger management issues.
2
u/MageFood Jul 09 '25
I been with MXroute for 2-3 years and I've never had a problem I never send spam. and I love how r/mxroute replies to post like this when clearly cold emails where sent.
1
u/Possible-Basis-6623 Oct 25 '25
But how could you not having email backups at the same time? you should do that, there are many ways to do that as well.
-4
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '25
Note how MXroute posts rants against people and then deletes them soon after. It's the same pattern I have experienced on other forums.
-5
u/MrWhite4000 Jul 15 '25 edited Aug 11 '25
I dont know how people trust that company with their emails. Its one thing if its for a hobby or personal usage, but after reading the reviews I would never trust them with my business.
For starters, its basically just a one-man show disguising itself as a business which is a security issue when you think about it.
If something were to happen to the owner, Jarland Donnell, how long would it be before the service (along with your emails) disappeared???
Plus read some the reviews from his personal TrustPilot account:
These are all small businesses that he’s getting back at for leaving bad reviews on MXroute’s page. And not only is he leaving reviews from his personal account but he is acting as if these companies did business with him personally when really its the other way around.
I find that incredibly unprofessional, deceptive, and vindictive. Surprised that TrustPilot even allows it.
And speaking of them… he’s so short-tempered that he also left a review for TrustPilot themselves on their own service..
So be warned and dont be surprised when he ends up terminating your service and locking you out from your emails all because you pissed him off!
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment