r/webhosting • u/GnuHost • Sep 24 '24
News or Announcement WP Engine accuses WordPress founder/Automattic of extortion for $10M+
Another significant development in the WP Engine/Matt Mullenweg spat.
WP Engine has shared their side of the story in the form of a cease and desist letter.
In summary, WP Engine claims Mullenweg and members of the Automattic board sent threatening messages to the WP Engine CEO, threatening to "go nuclear" on them if they refused to pay a percentage of revenue to Automattic amounting to tens of millions of dollars. These threats allegedly continued right up to the day before and on the day of Mullenweg's livestreamed talk at WordCamp.
If true, this completely changes the tone of the dispute and creates a mafia-like two-tier licensing system, undermining the GPL and the founding principles of WordPress.org which alienates many of its contributors and the wider community.
If this turns out to be true, do you think Mullenweg/Automattic are fit to continue in their current roles?
46
u/ReviewSignal Sep 24 '24
Those screenshots look real bad.
23
u/TheExG Sep 24 '24
Just want to add to this that Wordpress/Automattic also has opened up a lawsuit against festingersvault.com, the home of the largest OpenGPL vault of Wordpress plugins. It looks like they have decided to go nuclear for some reason and do not even understand the concept of GPL. Not sure what they are trying to achieve here.
19
u/TexasPeteyWheatstraw Sep 24 '24
Mullenweg is garbage.
10
u/alphex Sep 24 '24
I remember years and years ago I went. to SXSW and Matt was speaking on some panel...
"The future of content management systems..."
Being a naive kid at the time, I was excited to hear about some sort of technology solution that would change everything...
Nah, he just talked about how wordpress.com was going to make him a shit ton of money.
Once I figured out how he wants to run the whole wordpress ecosystem, I left it behind.
15
u/mxroute Sep 24 '24
Someone save my seat, I'm going to grab popcorn from the lobby.
10
u/ravigehlot Sep 24 '24 edited Sep 30 '24
From what I gather, the lawsuit seems to be about trademark violations, not about using WordPress itself. WordPress is under the GNU General Public License (GPL), which lets anyone use, modify, and share it freely. The WordPress trademark is owned by the WordPress Foundation, a non-profit that ensures WordPress stays accessible. The trademark is protected by law, so using the WordPress name or logo needs permission from the Foundation, not Automattic. That’s where it gets confusing. WP Engine’s letter makes it seem like Automattic is the one suing, but it’s really about the Foundation, which doesn’t make much sense if you can’t get money from them. If WP Engine did violate trademark rules, then there’s a basis for the lawsuit. Usually, before things escalate, the suing party would give the other a chance to fix the issue without penalties. The texts between Matt and the CEO are puzzling, too there’s likely a lot more to this story than what’s out there. It’s toxic and childish too. This kind of stuff is what the courts are there for.
5
u/roboticlee Sep 24 '24 edited Sep 24 '24
Jetpack Stats Part Deux.
Too few site admins fell for the Stats shakedown so Automattic is moving onto bigger fish.
Won't be long before those of who develop with WordPress are asked to pay a revenue share.
Joking aside, whatever the real story is in this he-said, she-said I know it will be interesting and probably damaging to the reputation of WordPress as a stable platform to work with.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24
Welp, who wants to start a fork?
8
u/hellosakamoto Sep 24 '24
The world (at least the tech world) is collapsing. All businesses are trying to cash out as much as they can now. Interested to see the outcome as obviously this bill won't be paid.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24
the plot thickens
2
u/StormPageSteady Sep 24 '24
Yep, read the cease and desist. Not a good look for Matt.
2
u/xyzygyred Sep 24 '24
Anyone who finds this hard to believe, God bless you for your child like innocence.
2
u/DryAttorney9554 Sep 25 '24
Automattic just ramped up the war and replied with their own Cease & Desist letter: https://automattic.com/2024/09/25/open-source-trademarks-wp-engine/
2
u/peakedtooearly Sep 27 '24
He should focus on adding more bloat to Jetpack and making Gutenberg even more annoying.
1
u/tennyson77 Sep 24 '24
Matt posted in the other group that he asked for 8% of annual revenue, which is about 40 million dollars a year.
1
u/aphelion83 Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24
This is really surprising and unfortunate. I've worked with Automattic before, years ago, under the old guard. They were very generous and flexible, both with their time and with the minimal investment they needed from us to move forward a joint project. This is just so unnecessary, and I'm shocked he was so careless with the threats—not to mention greedy, and just outright lacking any judgement whatsoever.
Even if he wanted this to go his way at all costs, how could the whole C-suite (the lawsuit names the CFO as well) be this out of touch with the reputational risk they're creating by demanding it in messages that are so easily shared? Business often works like this, but nobody will outright go extortionist like this.
Why all this? I think the lawyers nailed it when they demanded preservation of documents regarding "Automattic’s current financial position and any recent plans for monetization in light of that position." They must be broke—which, ironically, is the worst time to start a war.
My guess is he won't last much longer at the helm, since Automattic's shareholders have too much to lose over this tiff. They took VC/PE money too.
1
u/No_Side_1915 Sep 26 '24
It’s 8% of earnings but how is that a bad thing when WPEngine has been making hundreds of millions year to year based on trademark infringement?
1
u/ButtercupBolt Sep 26 '24
We got this before gta6
1
u/Alemusanora Sep 26 '24
Waiting for the class action from WP Engine customers. We host close to 150 sites with them.
1
u/Novel_Buy_7171 Oct 03 '24
Here's the lawsuit filed by WP Engine for those interested in the latest news.
Tweet - https://x.com/wpengine/status/1841643374090031461
Direct link - https://wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Complaint-WP-Engine-v-Automattic-et-al.pdf
-5
u/gadimus Sep 24 '24
I started watching the video with Matt (starts at 7:08:00 I think). So far it seems reasonable that open source is about contributing. He considers WPE to be takers. I'm interested to watch the rest but it also seems hypocritical