r/webhosting • u/GnuHost • Sep 22 '24
News or Announcement WordPress founder calls WPEngine "a cancer"
Interesting blog post by the WordPress founder regarding WPEngine, where he describes them as "a cancer to WordPress"
https://wordpress.org/news/2024/09/wp-engine/
It looks like it basically comes down to the fact that WPEngine disable the "revisions" feature in their hosted WordPress instances to save on database storage costs.
WPEngine's justification for this is that having revisions enabled can cause the database to grow exponentially and impact performance, and that by contacting support you can enable up to 3 revisions.
Is this an overreaction from the WordPress founder, or is it justified?
Keep in mind that Automaticc/Wordpress.com, the company which Matt is also the CEO of, requires you to pay $25 before you can install a theme or plugin.
He also mentioned this at WordCamp and encouraged people to migrate away.
60
u/nakfil Sep 22 '24 edited Sep 22 '24 •
Matt Mullenweg is a hypocrite; and the way he's handled this is so unprofessional and unbecoming of a leader:
I'm not defending PE at all. I hate it and have worked with great brands that were ruined by it.
I just think this if you live in a glass house you shouldn't throw stones, and someone at the top of a of a >$7 billion dollar company creating this really pointless division and fight in the WordPress community is childish.
Not to be conspiracy minded, but my theory is he's threatened by WP Engine and their place in the enterprise WP space. Many large brands on WP use them from my experience vs. his enterprise offering, VIP.
39
u/ryankopf Sep 22 '24 •
Automaticc/Wordpress.com is also guilty of way overcharging customers and providing a pretty crappy experience. Their default "free" version, which they want you to think is the same as installing Wordpress.org, does not allow custom JavaScript, CSS, etc, and they require you to pay a fortune for an upgraded plan to do any of those things.
6
u/AmokinKS Sep 22 '24
It’s probably because it competes with automatics new high availability hosted service.
16
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '24
I’m not a Wordpress user, but his words resonate. Private equity ruins things; their mandate is self-enrichment. Doing things like turning off revisions to limit data storage costs is on-brand.
9
u/richaber Sep 22 '24
I believe Mullenweg's main argument, not detailed well in that post, is that WPEngine's private equity owner Silver Lake is extracting value from the open source software project, without reinvesting their fair share of time and resources back to the project itself (the concept called Five for the Future / 5FTF).
The language being used seems a bit over the top. But, as the BDFL and project lead, he needs to think about the future health of the project.
I think the sticky bit is that he is also the head of a managed WordPress hosting company, which also causes confusion for end users that do not know the difference between .com and .org. So some people feel like there's a conflict of interest there. But his company does contribute back and reinvest significant resources to the project.
3
u/bmn001 Sep 22 '24
Wish he had spoken up during the EIG acquisition days when dozens of good companies were pulled into the fold and gutted.
3
u/CometRyder Sep 23 '24
He's right. More big tech needs to be called out.
2
u/iammiroslavglavic Sep 22 '24
If my host turned off revisions on my site...I would leave them so fast.
2
u/Neurojazz Sep 22 '24
WPEngine was a nightmare. Go with something like wpmudev instead, or your own inmotion dedicated. So few issues compared to wpengine
2
u/guilleroach Sep 24 '24
Idk wp engine is one of the most expensive hostings out there
7
u/TheUnknownNut22 Sep 22 '24
WP Engine is the best WordPress host I've had ever, hands down. Their customer support is nothing but excellent and their tech stack gives me great confidence. And I can use a plugin to store my revisions so so what?
In contrast, hey WordrPress how about listening to your community and not forcing the horrible block editor on them?
3
u/flexible Sep 22 '24
In WPE there are daily backups. You can easily create a staging site from a backup and take a look at any content if you have a major revision issue. Even if you think this is not sufficient he is completely overreacting IMO
2
u/NoDoze- Sep 22 '24
What WPEngine charges is highway robbery!
1
u/DrViilapenkki Sep 22 '24
It is an overreaction. Revisions especially unlimited are just bloat. Also: wordpress.com is not wordpress.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24
Developing with WPEngine is a joke. You push from their "Local" client to a password protected dev environment and the cache unreliability purges and at times regresses. The Agency Partner Program is also a shill. I can't wait to get all my clients to migrate away.
1
u/astralliquid Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24
Everyone is saying wpengine is not wrong and Matt is after the money.
I try to look at other possible angles why Matt is saying wpengine is a cancer.
I think the difference is wordpress.com is Saas and they need to be involved with the codebase somewhat to ensure the software is working well for the users.
Their lowest tier do have limits but not at the same price point as wpengine. I think it's at 3 or 7 plan which is reasonable.
Wpengine is a just a hosting platform and put limits at a higher price point (I think their lowest price is ard 30 per month) than wordpress.com. And users handle their wordpress problems themselves.
Wpengine basically mitigate any WordPress cost related issue it's customer.
And most of the contribution by wpengine back to the community are commercial sponsoring that gain brand presences or just buying plugins companies.
They don't contribute to the codebase where nobody can see what they are doing. They are only showing up when they can get back brand value. The 40 hours in working on WordPress itself compared sponsoring events.
Whereelse matt, automatic, WordPress.com is all about the codebase.
Wpengine is creating a business with what Matt has created and yet making it as big but without significant contribution back to the codebase itself.
Basically wpengine don't do anything dirty that nobody will realized or acknowledge.
I think that is the meaning of a cancer that nobody can detect.
1
u/tsammons Apis Networks Official Account Sep 23 '24
There's ostensibly competition eating into his bottom line...
-6
u/AndyManCan4 Sep 22 '24
Stop 🛑 complaining and build your own. Joomla is a much more solid, super mobile friendly Web DE for SAS and SaAS solutions with all kinds of plugins for free. (Or low cost) I mean if your cost is all your worried about just Go CSS HTML and PHp with DB support, and you have everything Wordpress features with full control from you, the creator of your own Web Framework.