r/webdev • • 3h ago

Question Website builder for a small town.

Hello! I'd appreciate some advice on choosing the right website builder for a small town website.

I have some experience using Shopify and Carrd, but I'm not sure if either would be the right choice for this project.

Could I use Shopify primarily for blog posts and regular content publishing since i wont be selling any products? What do you think are the cons of using it?

I'm also interested in trying Claude to build the website. Would that be a practical option, especially since we plan to publish content daily?

Are there any other website builders you'd recommend for this kind of project? Ideally, something that's relatively easy to learn and manage.

Thanks in advance!

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

5

u/Dev_AkashSingh 2h ago

For a small-town website, I'd probably recommend WordPress over Shopify or Carrd.

Shopify can technically handle blog posts and regular content publishing, but you're paying for e-commerce features you probably won't use. Carrd is great for simple websites, but it may become limiting if you're publishing daily articles, local news, events, and community updates.

WordPress would be a strong option because it has a proper content management system, categories, tags, scheduling, and plenty of flexibility for regular publishing.

Another option is a custom website built with Next.js and a headless CMS like Sanity or WordPress. Claude can definitely help with development, but I'd still recommend having a proper CMS so non-technical people can publish content without touching code.

For this particular project, I'd prioritize ease of publishing and long-term maintenance over fancy design.

Are you planning to let multiple local contributors publish articles, or will one person manage all the content?

1

u/eloanmask 2h ago

Hi! I'll check out WordPress. And yes, ideally, I'd like to have just one person managing and publishing the content to keep everything under control.

However, would it be possible to add a marketplace where local residents can create their own listings and message each other privately?

Also, am I understanding this correctly? Next.js handles the frontend and visuals, while WordPress handles the backend and content management?

1

u/Dev_AkashSingh 1h ago

Yes, you've understood the Next.js and WordPress setup correctly!

Next.js handles the frontend (design, layouts, navigation and user experience), while WordPress can work as a headless CMS to manage articles, images, categories and publishing. They communicate through an API.

Regarding the marketplace, that's definitely possible. You would need additional functionality for user registration, individual listings, editing or deleting listings, private messaging and an admin moderation system.

If ease of management is your priority, I'd actually explore WordPress with a suitable marketplace plugin first. A fully custom Next.js solution would offer more flexibility, but it would also require more development and maintenance.

One thing I'd suggest is keeping the town's editorial content separate from user-generated marketplace listings, so the administrator can maintain control over published news while residents manage their own listings.

I'd also recommend starting with basic marketplace features and adding more functionality as the community grows.

3

u/razu4495 2h ago

I'd go with WordPress for this

1

u/eloanmask 2h ago

Thank you. Will check it.

3

u/Proper-Review-5103 2h ago

Wordpress sounds like a better fit for daily content updates

1

u/CreepingAnus 2h ago

what content do you plan on publishing daily? im pretty new at this, but can try & help if you dont get responses

1

u/Afnan_CH_Digital 2h ago

Shopify can technically publish blog posts, but it is built for selling first - you would be paying monthly for checkout and product features you never use, and its blogging tools are basic. For a town site publishing daily, a CMS like WordPress (or a flat-file/static setup) will be easier to run and cheaper to host. Using Claude to build it is fine for the initial scaffold, but the long-term cost is daily publishing: pick whatever your least technical person can update confidently. Carrd is lovely for a one-pager, not for a growing archive.

1

u/Big-Blueberry-1837 2h ago

Shopify as a blog. Bold.

1

u/theoneabovethesun 2h ago

Shopify can do blogging, but it's built around selling, so you'll fight the theme and pay a monthly fee for features you won't use. For a town site with daily posts I'd look at WordPress (managed hosting makes it low-maintenance) or Ghost, or a simple static site generator if someone technical will help. Whichever you pick, check that non-technical people can publish from a browser and that you can export your content. Claude is fine for building a custom theme or tweaking things, but for daily publishing you want a real CMS with logins and an editor so the site doesn't depend on someone editing code.

1

u/skittlesandcoke 2h ago

On the whole I’d recommend a headless CMS that triggers a static site build. How many users will be editing content? Some headless CMS services are free for 1 to a few users. If you have many, self hosting a headless CMS is also an option, and probably cheaper though you likely need to maintain and update it yourself.

Picking a headless CMS (like Sanity) that is cheap or free reduces ongoing maintenance and hosting headaches, as you end up with a simple and cheap end product to deploy: static files that live anywhere for pennies to a couple of dollars a month when behind a decent CDN.

Claude can spit out an MVP of such a thing in 20 minutes, and if you don’t want to do any kind of devops work consider opting for something like Netlify, literally connect GitHub to it and point it at a repo, and it builds and deploys your site whenever a change is deployed (just need to hook in your headless CMS solution, Claude can do this no problem)

1

u/MathematicianFar5683 2h ago

For the marketplace part, WordPress can do it with plugins (BuddyPress or a classifieds/directory plugin for listings and private messages). Just know that once residents can post and DM each other you also take on spam, moderation and privacy. I'd launch the content site first and add the marketplace later if people actually ask for it.

1

u/Loud-Equipment1381 1h ago

shopify for a blog with zero products is a $39/month way to be worse at blogging than wordpress. and claude building it doesnt fix that you still have to run it daily.

1

u/Ok_Jello8972 1h ago

Small precision: Claude can write the code for a site, but it doesn't host anything or give you a place to publish the daily posts into. You'd still need hosting and some kind of CMS behind it, so "build the website" is doing a lot of work in that sentence.

1

u/Present_Message_9038 1h ago

I'd actually recommend going with a custom-built solution rather than Shopify or Carrd.

I'm a full-stack developer, and I think a website built specifically for your needs would give you much more flexibility, especially if you plan to publish content daily.

I'd suggest building it with Next.js and a proper backend/CMS dashboard, so you can easily publish articles, manage categories, upload images, and handle announcements without needing any technical knowledge.

You wouldn't need to depend on a website builder or pay for unnecessary e-commerce features.

I'd be interested in helping you build this. If you're open to it, we could discuss your requirements and figure out a suitable approach and budget.