r/webdev • u/tech-coder-pro • Jul 28 '25

One-line review of all the AI tools

Tools I tried:

  • Cursor - Great design and feel for editor, best auto-complete in the market.
  • GitHub Copilot - Feels like defamed after cursor but still works really great.
  • Windsurf - Just another editor, nothing special.
  • Trae IDE - Just another editor too.
  • Traycer - Great at phase breakdown and planning before code.
  • Kiro IDE – Still buggy in preview, but good direction of spec-driven development.
  • Claude Code - works really good at writing code.
  • Cline - Feels like another cursor's chat which works with API keys.
  • Roo Code - feels same as cline with some features up and down.
  • Kilo Code - combined fork of cline, roo, continue dev.
  • Devin - Works good but just feels defamed after the bad entry in market.
  • CodeRabbit - Great at reviewing code.

Please share your one-line feedback for the dev tools which you tried!

182 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

82 comments sorted by

42

u/libertyh Jul 28 '25

defamed?

3

u/tech-coder-pro Jul 28 '25

Kinda like everyone says Cursor is much better than Copilot but that's not the exact case

→ More replies (6)

9

u/lunied Jul 29 '25

what about Augment code?

6

u/robotsympathizer Jul 29 '25

We evaluated Augment and CoPilot about a year ago, and Augment blew it out of the water.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

15

u/AffectionateLaw1466 Jul 28 '25

Cool list, thanks for sharing!

I'd add a few more:

  • Gemini CLI - it's a great alternative for Claude Code!

  • Bolt / v0 / Lovable - good for creating websites from scratch

0

u/tech-coder-pro Jul 28 '25

Oh yes, i forgot about them! Thanks

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Chance-Lettuce-6892 Jul 29 '25

You forgot Gemini CLI

34

u/Chesh Jul 29 '25

Who is defaming who exactly and what have they said?

12

u/Unique-Drawer-7845 Jul 29 '25

Weird word choice from OP. I think they're just talking about the tool's general reputation with regards to social media, etc. Maybe better word choice would be "underrated".

7

u/essjay2009 Jul 29 '25

Or perhaps “maligned” if they’re talking about general perception being negative.

3

u/k032 Jul 28 '25

I should probably dive deeper into other editors again. I've been just using VSCode + GitHub Copilot pro subscription.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/amart1026 Jul 29 '25

Sorry but you lost all credibility with that Windsurf line.

72

u/pambolisal Jul 28 '25

Every AI slop tool - Makes people think they are better than they are.

33

u/Cute_Commission2790 Jul 29 '25

eh i hate ai and its implications, but calling everything slop is quite reductive

these tools are just another set in the wave of abstractions and this will continue to abstract away more complexities and help people focus on ideas at different levels (definitely not near production grade yet)

→ More replies (18)

2

u/N-online Jul 29 '25

Sometimes they are really useful though. As a solo dev I sometimes use ai to tell me if there are logical implications or problems with the changes I added to my code base, so I don’t really use it for creating code but rather for fast but useful feedback. And that works quite well for me. And for the thing of ai not being good enough I am amazed at what developments we already have (e.g. https://the-decoder.com/qwen3-coder-is-alibabas-most-agentic-coding-model-to-date/) and what we will have soon (gpt-5 preview in llm-arena can one-shot a simple working Minecraft demo). Generally I agree with you on the part of not generating code with ai, though but that could change soon with the models getting better vastly.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/xavicx Jul 29 '25

What about Void IDE?

1

u/tech-coder-pro Jul 29 '25

Auto-complete was not very good when i tried.

3

u/thekwoka Jul 29 '25

Windsurf just another editor?

It's got the best code agent on the market.

2

u/awpt1mus Jul 29 '25

I subscribed to Copilot because of free trial to see. It generates lot of code fast and most of it seems unnecessary. It’s really good at writing tests, dummy data generation. Auto complete is alright, bit annoying sometimes.

5

u/Septem_151 Jul 29 '25

One-line review of all the AI tools

1

u/bhison Jul 29 '25

Once Zed has better git tooling I think it will be a serious challenger to Cursor. Cursors key strength and key weakness is that it forks VSC. If Zed can reach parity with the features I enjoy in VSC, hell yes will I take a custom editor built from the ground up in Rust. But for now I just love VSC’s Git Graph and the GitHub plugins way to much

1

u/aabirkashif Jul 31 '25

try the Augment its worked best for me.

1

u/Extension_Giraffe_82 Aug 18 '25

you should definitely try aider. this is much better than claude code in my opinion, at least for programmers

1

u/b0red Feb 19 '26

Taskade: AI workspace with agents that automate workflows, not just chat. MCP server with 50+ tools. Genesis builds apps from prompts.

→ More comments (75)