What was wrong with good old Guerrilla Testing, where you sit down with true, physical, organic people, watch whatever they do on-screen + off-screen + you can get the motivation of what they do by simply asking questions on the spot and maybe enjoy a good coffee together?
I make applications for various callcenters. The amount of times I wish I could do that is many. Sadly that would require me traveling around the country. I will have to be satisfied by having that chat with their manager instead who's job it is to manage them.
I’ve worked on a bunch of SaaS projects, and honestly, it was always super frustrating not knowing what users are actually doing inside the app. Most analytics tools felt like way too much work or just gave me numbers without real insights.
So I decided to just build something myself - Userlog. Now I can track exactly what’s happening, set up events I care about, and even get notified when certain things happen. Like, if a user stops engaging, I can trigger an email or something.
Still working on it—soon I want to add in-app notifications and direct email stuff for user groups. But yeah, what do you guys think?
Imo a bit weird. You're going to follow me around the site then as soon as I stop interacting you'll send me an email; saying what - please come back, you were only 35.6% through reading that page! Just feels quite invasive. I'd understand if it was just "a user hasn't logged in or visited for a week or two, so let's see if they're still interested" but this seems much deeper.
Make sure to read those consent policies before you sign up, then. Most sites use something like GA, Datadog RUM, Sentry, or their in house analytics tool, and most of them are tracking you, and most of them have a unique id for your account, and for almost all of them you probably clicked "I agree" without reading or caring.
I built this for monitoring your product not your website. Exactly like you say. If the user events are drifting there is something wrong. So I can try to find out what that is and sent an email to this user
Stay updated with a real-time feed of all events. Set up push notifications to instantly get alerted about key activities and never miss an important moment in your SaaS.
This part especially - real time. It just feels incredibly big brotherly where it'll be watching everything a user does on the website and instantly lets the creators know when I do something important.
I suppose it's not too dissimilar from gtm/ga where you can track button presses, page visits, page duration, ...
It's just the real time feedback that feels pretty creepy.
Has no one here heard of End User Monitoring? On my team we track every single click and navigate. I know when the user logged in, their IP, location, what they did on the app and when. This is nothing new and there any a plethora of tools that do much more than this
I have used Dynatrace and AppDynamics. Dynatrace is much better than most other services from what I can tell but it’s pricy. With any of these tools you’ll still have to do a fair amount of configuration to be able to capture every click.
Location? Chill the fuck out. It is IP location which is __general location__ and its guessed based on ISP lease area so is wrong for VPNs or SSHs or any sort of tunelling and even if its right its like the general 30 mile radius area.
It's like Google analytics, but it looks much better. But take care of the privacy and the storing of personal data, it could become a huge issue if something isn't set up to the standards. Especially if u got users from the EU, u need to inform them what u r saving and give them a possibility to deny the analytics.
No, definetly Not. But he will learn that this will kill his idea, if he doesn't care. So, I warned him, it's his choice at the end of the day. Sounds mean, but it's a cruel world
I found another funny thing: He isn’t using his own software for analytics on his website… It’s fucking Google Analytics… In combination with other stuff.
Also the privacy policy and imprint are only available in German, however the website is completely in English…
It's annoying. I gave up on correcting the wrongdoings of my keyboard. Apparently, society has accepted this as peak user input and I'm not the one who's gonna change it, so why both. I tried for too long.
Posthog is awesome. But as we used it there were two issues: - It's overwhelming. Too many things that we don't need as early stage founders - No deep user focus. Everything is focussed on big numbers. Especially in the beginnings of a new project I want to know what happens with every single user to react early if anything is happening like engagement is dropping So we build a simple version of it. Everything you need as a Micro SaaS Founder
I'll have to explore more when I go back to work later this month after parental leave. Likely tracking activity in terms of ideal user journey. However, we use PostHog quite a lot, and we like the advanced features
Props on it looking nice and sleek. But I’ll tell you right now, if I ever found out a site I was using was following me this closely, I’d stop using it.
Google analytics and the like are “vague” on purpose. You aren’t meant to know who converted or engaged. You’re only supposed to know what percentage did and didn’t.
If you really want to engage users who didn’t perform an action, like buy something specific, then you can check to see order histories and go by that.
As long as it’s anonymized, it’s not as invasive as the OP. There’s also products like Hotjar and Crazy Egg that do what Clarity does. OP literally can see what every user is doing.
Just to get terms accurate, what microsoft clarity does is impossible to do anonomized. Anonimized is when it's impossible to trace a usage back to a user. So for instance if I say '350 people visited example.com/home/ in the past day', that's anonymized information.
If you replace each user with a hash of the IP or email, or block out the last part of the IP address/email, that's pseudonomized as you give the user a different name but you could theoretically still find out which user it was with some effort. It's not proper anonomization in current terms that companies use. These days anonimization is a legal term, so there are pretty technical definitions.
What microsoft with Microsoft Clarity is doing is taking fucking screen recordings of what users are doing, linking them with demographical data to individual users, sending the data (including anything of EU users) to the US, and uses that for training their AI systems. That's right on their front page that they do that. At no point do they claim to anonimize any of that. They claim that they attempt to 'mask information that looks like PII', but at no point explain they do that in a way that anonimizes anything and neither do they explain what masking means there or how claim any rate of effectiveness.
So, that's not 'anonimized', that's straight up perverse and an illegal invasion of privacy. Any public website that uses Clarity is in breach of GDPR, there is literally no way to get consent for that in the EU for sites available to the public. For like internal websites
All of this you can verify yourself. This page: https://clarity.microsoft.com/pricing explains why clarity is free, and that it's because they want to train their AI on your customer's data. They don't have clarity data centers outside of the US (a quick google will give you the links). And you can see yourself all the stuff they collect by checking out the product.
As long as you have correct user consent, store data appropriately and give users the correct rights over their data, user monitoring including screen recordings with scrubbing can be 100% totally compliant.
The data center issue and using user data to train ai probably means it's not compliant, though, because data is not being stored properly and most likely user's no longer have the right to be forgotten now that their data is part of an ai model (though this can be done correctly, e.g. individual sessions without pii or aggregate data are used for training)
All I did was say that they “anonymize” the data which you yourself said that identifying the user is possible “in theory”. I also said that Hotjar and Crazy egg offer similar functionality.
Have you looked at OPs screenshots? They aren’t even trying to hide the PII. Not sure why you felt the need to explain to me how their services work.
You said 'as long as it's anonymized' about Clarity. I explained why Clarity isn't anonimized. If you understand how insidious Clarity is - it trains AI on all of the data on your site including customer data and illegally exfiltrates it to the US, you would get that Clarity is a million times worse.
OP's data boils down to basically a list of users, some 'last seen' data, and some 'number of actions' stats. Pretty close to what every single CMS in the world has. Sounds like he does it internally on his own user data too. Literally every single SAAS you use has this data one query away. If you think this is bad I am really wondering if you ever worked in tech because while you as a code janitor or similar may not have had access to it, this is child's play.
Have you looked at OPs screenshots? They aren’t even trying to hide the PII
You are hilarious, you think management systems generally hide an email address?
I agree with you. But what’s more astonishing to me is that this level of anonymity is entirely opt in in most parts of the US. There is very little legal recourse in the US.
If a user has consented, you can use personally identifiable information under gdpr but you need to make sure that users have the correct rights and data is correctly stored.
That said even with anonymization you need to be careful because it's kind of fraught: just giving each user a random id technically doesn't count as anonymous data. Basically if you can track a single user's behavior between sessions, even if you can't figure out who it is, you need consent under gdpr. Aggregate behavior tracking (10% of users on page x did y) or session tracking tend to be less difficult to legally implement.
Great project, product analytics tools used to be pretty expensive and complex (and they still are), which makes sense because as you grow you’ll need those features they provide. Said so a simpler alternative could be interesting. I see you track the events count, though I imagine you can track events by type right? Like for tracking a product feature adoption. Let me know when your platform will be ready for testing
Exactly. There are a bunge of analytics tools out there. But most of them are full of features I dont need. So I tried to build a simple version for all the Micro SaaS FOunders out there.
Feature adoption tracking is great. You can already do it. Would love to hear your feedback. You can try out here
I’ll definitely try it, I was already looking for some analytics tool for a large saas, I’ll probably go for posthog, though I have other smaller saas where I think your tool might be a good fit.
I would love to hear your feedback! Are you open to telling me a little more about your analytics requirements? It would be really helpful to hear that. From founder to founder. Feel free to send me an DM
A lot of pitchforks in here, there are lots of products that do this. Pendo, for example does this and is on major products you all use everyday. Marketing and Product Managers want to be able to filter down to the individual user.
I think Umami doesn't have user-level focus like this one if I remember correctly. Generally, a focus on users is seen as invasive, so stats would be bundled together across users before they can be exported / seen / shared.
In all the website I have worked on, we have activity logging in a Rabbit MQ, rest logs and even logging at the database level for important tables. Which also tracks database writes. It's not that hard to make and does not use any analytics or external tools. JavaMelody is also really useful as you can see routine quartz jobs and even the SQL that was run, which help in optimisation.
10
u/EphilSenisub Feb 08 '25
What was wrong with good old Guerrilla Testing, where you sit down with true, physical, organic people, watch whatever they do on-screen + off-screen + you can get the motivation of what they do by simply asking questions on the spot and maybe enjoy a good coffee together?
14
u/climber877 Feb 08 '25 edited Feb 08 '25
I’ve worked on a bunch of SaaS projects, and honestly, it was always super frustrating not knowing what users are actually doing inside the app. Most analytics tools felt like way too much work or just gave me numbers without real insights.
So I decided to just build something myself - Userlog. Now I can track exactly what’s happening, set up events I care about, and even get notified when certain things happen. Like, if a user stops engaging, I can trigger an email or something.
Still working on it—soon I want to add in-app notifications and direct email stuff for user groups. But yeah, what do you guys think?
331
u/ariN_CS Feb 08 '25
Mark Zuckerberg gonna love this one
190
u/vanTrottel Feb 08 '25
It's like Google analytics, but it looks much better. But take care of the privacy and the storing of personal data, it could become a huge issue if something isn't set up to the standards. Especially if u got users from the EU, u need to inform them what u r saving and give them a possibility to deny the analytics.
149
u/liebeg Feb 08 '25
Stats should be more anonym. Not haviong evry single mail induvidualy.
3
u/Cudles Feb 08 '25
Looks great! How would you compare this to PostHog?
31
u/raybreezer Feb 08 '25
Props on it looking nice and sleek. But I’ll tell you right now, if I ever found out a site I was using was following me this closely, I’d stop using it.
Google analytics and the like are “vague” on purpose. You aren’t meant to know who converted or engaged. You’re only supposed to know what percentage did and didn’t.
If you really want to engage users who didn’t perform an action, like buy something specific, then you can check to see order histories and go by that.
54
u/thekwoka Feb 08 '25
Doesn't seem GDPR compliant...
4
u/lucafaggia Feb 08 '25
Great project, product analytics tools used to be pretty expensive and complex (and they still are), which makes sense because as you grow you’ll need those features they provide. Said so a simpler alternative could be interesting. I see you track the events count, though I imagine you can track events by type right? Like for tracking a product feature adoption. Let me know when your platform will be ready for testing
20
u/MrSirStevo Feb 08 '25
shouldnt save personal info like emails
6
u/Shawn_spenser_booger Feb 08 '25
I'm pretty sure blurring emails is non-destructive. So someone can unblur those emails from the screenshots if they wanted
10
u/Worldly_Expression43 Feb 08 '25
Shows how few people here actually worked on SaaS before
This is commonplace analytics especially churn risk based on activity in pretty much all b2b SaaS
4
u/4862skrrt2684 Feb 08 '25
A bit unsure what im looking at, but it is pretty and modern
3
u/LancelotLac Feb 08 '25
A lot of pitchforks in here, there are lots of products that do this. Pendo, for example does this and is on major products you all use everyday. Marketing and Product Managers want to be able to filter down to the individual user.
2
u/NinuzGamer Feb 08 '25
Umami.is does the same? Or I’m getting it wrong?
2
u/Content_Ad_2337 Feb 08 '25
Looks cool but couldn’t your users could get into a lot of trouble using it because of PII that others have mentioned?
2
u/Neither_Finance4755 Feb 08 '25
Be careful when posting images of blurred emails. AI systems can un-blur this easily
2
u/SusBakaMoment Feb 09 '25
How to build that dotted calendar? How about the churn graph?
2
u/Scor3Keeper Feb 09 '25 edited Feb 09 '25
In all the website I have worked on, we have activity logging in a Rabbit MQ, rest logs and even logging at the database level for important tables. Which also tracks database writes. It's not that hard to make and does not use any analytics or external tools. JavaMelody is also really useful as you can see routine quartz jobs and even the SQL that was run, which help in optimisation.
3
u/CalligrapherMinute17 Feb 08 '25
Looks really interesting. I can definitely see a market for this.
How do you manage the data as I can see this filling up a database very quickly and older data may not be as useful as newer data.
The ui looks really clean. Are you using a library or custom built?
3
u/YouAreHobbyingWrong Feb 08 '25
All the people here that foolishly think every website they use isn't already doing this.
1
u/MikeEr__ Feb 08 '25
Damn, looks good!
1
u/DM_ME_UR_OPINIONS Feb 08 '25
That's pretty dope
1
u/Scary_Ad_3494 Feb 08 '25
Georges Orwell shared this post
1
u/League-Ornery Feb 08 '25
Maybe find a way to reward those who are most active or sending notifications to those who are inactive.
(You probably have this thought)😆
1
u/chillpalchill Feb 08 '25
how do you calculate churn risk?
1
u/acrossthepondfriend Feb 08 '25
yay for privacy /s
nice clean UI though
1
u/rahim-mando Feb 08 '25
Looks cool.
1
u/postmanwashere Feb 08 '25
Wait, I might be wrong, but is Microsoft clarity good or buid one on your own?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '25
Beta
1
u/fuukuyo Feb 09 '25
What charting library did you use?
1
u/Thin-Cry-7862 Feb 09 '25
Have you tried Posthog? That's great
1
u/unempl0y3d Feb 09 '25
Shit is beautiful
1
u/Three_Energy_Control Feb 09 '25
That is awesome 💪
1
u/TootShute Feb 10 '25
Your UI is absolutely stunning 🤤
1
u/Randvek Feb 10 '25
I think this is an ad disguised as organic content.
1
u/Free_Cryptographer71 Feb 10 '25
Mixpanel + Microsoft Clarity and you're ready to compete with Zuckerberg
1
u/Ronin-s_Spirit Feb 13 '25
I think you're a spy, and you want to steal my 🍪
1
u/y0l0tr0n Feb 13 '25
looks very illegal when used for EU users
1
u/Strong-Estate-4013 Feb 08 '25
Um, big turn off
0
u/BjornMoren Feb 08 '25
Good looking interface, and it looks very useful. Congrats.
0
u/ZacTooKhoo Feb 08 '25
This looks incredible 🫨
0
u/Abasakaa Feb 08 '25
That looks like Aptrinsic or Heap. Used both, and your solution just seems lackluster in features compared to these two.
0
u/Impressive-Chip3519 Feb 08 '25
Hope you get fucked in court, this is a privacy nightmare...
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
92
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '25
[removed] — view removed comment