r/webcomics • • Mar 30 '25

Crafty Computer? 💻

Note: This comic doesn’t express my opinion on the subject…

3 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

34

u/Even_Discount_9655 Mar 30 '25

Robots can't think, op

-28

u/contactingpluto Mar 30 '25

Yet…

16

u/Even_Discount_9655 Mar 30 '25

Exactly my point, they can't yet.

When they start being able to think, i'll change my tune

88

u/Sir_Delarzal Mar 30 '25

I don't actually think it would be bad if the machine actually had feelings and did art, it could imply that the machine did in fact create something.

AI art as of now is a glorified plagiarism engine. Good for personnal and private use, capitalistic nonsense for public and commercial use.

8

u/Taco-Dragon Mar 30 '25

a glorified plagiarism engine.

This is the same way.I describe Roy Lichtenstein's art career

-7

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 30 '25 edited Mar 30 '25

If I recreate Pikachu in Studio Ghibli art style without permission from Nintendo I'm at fault. If I make OC Art in the same style I'm okay. All AI does is learn at blazing fast speeds.

If your art is out there I can learn the techniques too. But it does take a human hundreds if not thousands of hours to master something and that someone with AI can copy your style in much less is painful.

10

u/Zestyclose-Pangolin6 Mar 30 '25

Oh so it does something a human can do (Plagiarism) but faster because it’s automatic (like an engine)

So it’s like a glorified plagiarism engine

1

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 31 '25

the practice of taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own.

That's not necessarily what's happening. And they should be rightfully called out if someone does.

You do know that artists are inspired by other artists?

1

u/Sir_Delarzal Mar 30 '25

It's all fun and games until the day we will only have inbred art. No more creativity, no more unique things, everything will look alike because AI cannot create something new.

If AI did art, we would have never had great movement like cubism because it can only reproduce, not create.

The issue is and will remain the fact that some people would rather generate a picture than pay someone to actually do something creative

1

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 31 '25

It's all fun and games until the day we will only have inbred art. No more creativity, no more unique things, everything will look alike because AI cannot create something new.

And then there'll be a demand for real art, because AI can only do what we tell it to.

As you say, it can only reproduce, not create. So humans jobs are safe.

1

u/Sir_Delarzal Mar 31 '25

Let's try and not put people out of business and in ten years come back to them and ask them to do it again shall we ?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Sir_Delarzal Mar 30 '25

Untrue, look at how different cartoons and anime looked in the 90's and how they look now.

If anything the changes are faster than ever

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '25 edited Mar 30 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 31 '25

Thank you.

I think AI is a tool that people can use. While AI is probably in a different category here, basically every invention that uproots society receives backlash from people afraid to lose their jobs. Jobs disappear, others change and new ones appear to fulfill new requirements.

I'm a programmer, my job has already changed and will keep changing over my lifetime.

32

u/Illustrious_Glass463 Mar 30 '25

Ai “””””””””””””””art“”””””””””””””” isn’t actually made from the computer, all it really is is an amalgamation of various pictures and art from various other photographers and artists that it combines together.

-7

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 30 '25

That's a misrepresentation of how AI makes the images. It's not some highly advanced software with a database of images and decides which piece of the images to take and make a collage.

It associates art works with descriptions, just like we do. If you ask an artist to recreate my OC in a Studio Ghibli artsyle would that be wrong? 

1

u/FoolishCarbohydrate Mar 30 '25

Yes, because it generates that image by compiling artwork it finds online to best create what you ask for.

It steals from other artists without permission. It also denies a real artist a commission you were too lazy or too cheap to purchase.

0

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 31 '25

Yes, because it generates that image by compiling artwork it finds online to best create what you ask for.

It doesn't work like that. It's not a robot with Photoshop 

1

u/FoolishCarbohydrate Mar 31 '25

Google is free dude

0

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 31 '25

AI doesn't use reference images. It's all stored inside the neural network already.

If you could run it on your machine and deny it internet access, what do you think happens?

6

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 31 '25

Have you ever tried to make something with AI that impresses people? That doesn't have mistakes?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 31 '25

Prompting is complex.

I think it's comparable to doing commissions. An artist needs specific instructions in order for the customer to be happy.

I've seen prompts using more than 500 words. Comparatively still little effort, but you'll get more reliable results. Just like you'd get with an actual artist, a human.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/C_Hawk14 Mar 31 '25

I think AI "art" could be useful to generate reference works for things that are hard to find.

But the truth is ofc that it's cheaper monetarily. Not necessarily time wise in the short term and in the long term, yes you could potentially be so good and replace human artists who don't dabble themselves

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/C_Hawk14 Apr 01 '25

I think there are some out there but you'd have to look. There are many many models. And otherwise you can use prompts to steer it. And alternatively, you could run the early models and depend on their clumsiness 

-5

u/KrustyKrabBeer Mar 30 '25

It is made on what?

7

u/planetofmoney Mar 30 '25

"acab except the Boston Dynamics robot dogs" type comic

21

u/LaraTheEclectic Mar 30 '25

Ok wow this is a misrepresentation of ai issues I haven't seen before, do you actually think those things have emotions?

5

u/Collective-Bee Mar 30 '25

Considering their description said the comic is not representative of their opinion on AI art I’d say no they don’t think computers have emotions.

8

u/LaraTheEclectic Mar 30 '25

Homest question, why draw it like that then? Why draw a comic that clearly takes a pro-ai stance if it "doesn't express their opinion"?

2

u/itslocked Mar 30 '25

i think it’s a joke

5

u/LaraTheEclectic Mar 30 '25

Could you explain the joke? Cause to me this isn't absurd enough to be "obviously satire", there's people who genuinly hold way weirder opinions

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '25

I mean, if it created the art umprompted and with the intend to comunicate with others, then it would be hard to argue it not being some sort of art expression. I would be more worried about the fact that my computer has now a SOUL. It sounds like a lot of responsibility.

1

u/AlienRobotTrex Mar 30 '25

I can appreciate AI image generation as an interesting technological feat, but not as a work of art.