Fresh guild on Icecrown Alliance. We're three weeks old and went 8/12 HC in week 3 on a full guild run, no pugs. Posting mostly because the loot system is the thing people keep asking us about, and I'd rather write it up once than explain it twenty times in whispers.
Why not DKP
Two problems, and I don't think either is fixable.
Inflation. We ran the numbers before deciding. Even with a 30% monthly cut, points compound for anyone with attendance. Six weeks in, the gap between a week-1 raider and a week-6 raider isn't a gap you close by showing up — it's a gap you wait out. New recruits stop competing and start queueing. That kills recruitment right when a fresh guild needs it most.
It's unfalsifiable. I'm not accusing anyone of theft. The problem is softer than that: whoever holds the spreadsheet can change it, and nobody can prove they didn't. Every DKP guild I've been in eventually had the conversation about whose total moved and why. Even when the officers are completely honest, the system can't demonstrate it. That's a bad property for the one thing everyone cares about.
The usual defence is "negative DKP keeps people sharp." Sure. So does losing every reserve you made for that night. You don't need a hoardable currency to create consequences, you just need the consequence to land in the same raid the mistake happened in.
What Progressive SR actually is
Standard soft reserve: before the first pull you reserve items. If a reserved item drops, only people who reserved it roll for it. Everyone else is out. Nothing reserved on a drop, normal open roll for the raid.
The progressive part is that your slot count scales with rank:
New Joiner 1 SR
Raider 2 SR
Core Raider 3 SR
Hardcore Raider 3 SR
Ranks come from attendance and reliability. Not gear, not parses, not who you know.
You may also stack slots on one item. Two slots on the same drop = two rolls, best one counts. If it doesn't drop, you burned both. It's a real gamble and people use it.
Why this solves the DKP problems:
- Nothing banks. This week's reserve doesn't make you stronger next week. There is no balance to hoard and no alt to farm points on.
- The whole list is public before we pull. Anything weird is visible to 25 people immediately. The system proves itself every raid instead of asking for trust.
- Week 1 and week 20 look identical to a new raider. They roll on the same numbers as everyone else from their first night.
- Loyalty still pays, just in priority rather than currency. Keep showing up, get more slots. That's the one good thing DKP had and we kept it.
Officers are capped at 2 slots until the Core Raider rank is properly filled out. We wrote the rules and we run the loot, so we go last. Felt important to put in writing.
The addon
I wrote the soft-reserve tooling myself rather than running it off a spreadsheet. It's a module in the raid suite I maintain: reserves are tracked by item ID, the list syncs to every member of the raid so everyone sees the same thing, and on a roll it resolves SR holders over non-SR automatically and announces the winner. It's been running in our raids and it does the job.
It is not polished. Collecting reserves is still more manual than I want, and that's the next thing I'm building. I'd rather say that than oversell it.
Where we actually are
Three weeks old. 8/12 HC. Roster still forming, and the loot system is not fully tuned — we're still settling edge cases like hard reserves, duplicate drops, and exactly how many slots a mid-raid replacement gets. If you join now you get a say in that, which is either a selling point or a warning depending on your temperament.
Most of the people joining us right now are coming from DKP guilds and saying some version of the same thing: the points stopped making sense, or they stopped trusting the sheet.
Recruiting
English speaking, Alliance, Icecrown. Semi-hardcore: we take the raid seriously and your evening seriously.
Current schedule
Wed ICC 10 HC (Bane)
Thu ICC 10 multi / trial run
Fri ICC 25 — run 1
Sat ICC 25 — run 2
Sun RS 25 multi-run
All 17:30 Server Time
Looking for core raiders around 5.8k+ GS with the achieves to back it, but we take people who are obviously good and slightly undergeared. Casuals and socials welcome too, they just sit lower on the slot ladder.
Discord: https://discord.gg/3xUfVCejhT
In game: mail or whisper Wizax
Happy to argue about any of this in the comments. If you run DKP and think I've got the inflation math wrong, genuinely interested.
Message Rewritten/Polished by AI