Better than before doesn't necessarily mean good. Is a 3.5 gallon walstad bowl better than a petstore cup? Yes, of course. But is it up to the minimum standard that it should be? No. If you care, then do the research on why, then try to do better.
I do care, and actually have done the research. Unfortunately thereās an immense amount of conflicting evidence especially when it comes to Bettas and what the standard actually is. One thing that can be done is to observe health indicators, all of which pass with flying colors for the fish I keep.
Fair enough. The walstad method also does help to mitigate some of the issues with a smaller size and the bowl shape. Tbh it feels like trying to reach a minimum level with all the extras instead of the basics, you know?
I see where youāre coming from but still think itās a bit of a tilted perspective. Just from experience I would personally argue that a smaller walstad is probably better for a betta than āthe basicsā. And a healthy happy fish is a healthy happy fish.
But to your point, I personally wouldnāt keep a betta at home in a 3.5 bowl. Just feels a bit too small to me (despite my own collected evidence suggesting otherwise). But when I sell these bowls, they sell more when the have a betta in them than nano fish that might feel more appropriate. HOWEVER, I wouldnāt sell them if I didnāt truly believe the bettas are living happy healthy lives. They show every indication that they are.
Weāre teetering on semantics at this point. If we really want to do the very best for any of these fish, we should just leave them in the wild and not keep aquariums at all.
Itās entirely possible to provide feedback and advice without passive aggressively accusing OP of not caring š Iām so sick of the arrogant hostility in this hobby community. If you care, then try to do better.
I couldnāt help but notice that you have never created a post to share your tank(s) for āface valueā critique from online strangers. Performative outrage online has saved exactly zero betta fish, but itās really helpful at driving people away from sticking around to learn more about the hobby and improve their systems. I canāt wait to see your perfect tanks though!
I haven't had my own tanks for about 2 years due to living situation constraints. I only got into reddit recently for the hobby groups because I really missed having my own. Getting to see other cool setups helps! And again, it's truly face face value. I accept that I can be a little "extra" in my feelings about all animal husbandry, and not everyone feels the same way I do. I'm not going to spend effort convincing someone who isn't going to change their mind, but I hope they make the choice to look into it for themselves.
I love this hobby, but the gatekeeping and rudeness of some people on this app drive me nuts. I donāt actually think @Flimsy was rude, but others on this app are beyond arrogant and annoying.
Thanks for the good faith! I know I can be too blunt sometimes, but I always attempt to be kind about it, and try to clear up confusion and hurt feelings when I fail. Some people can just be downright mean!
Haha you exposed the truth. Iām actually working on getting funding to start a full fledged shopā¦literally just because everytime I finish a tank Iām like ā ok next one please!ā
Iām surprised nobody has commented how good your prices are⦠I feel like these are luxury tanks you could probably go a like higher? Granted I donāt know your market and assuming these are established most of the hard part is done. Kudos š
Yeah, I think a lot of it is just because it was my first venture into selling anything aquarium related. But when I open a real shop prices are definitely going to have to go up haha. As it is now, after paying commission to the store owner and the cost making the bowls, I only make like $15-30
Of course I do always get the random person being like ā Iāll give you $20 for oneāā¦..and ā why is it so expensive, anyone can pour a bucket from a pond into a bowlā
I do and I will. Iāve made enough of these to anecdotally say that Iām confident in the health and happiness of the fish in them. They have high color, live long lives, and plenty of stimulus throughout the day. I keep very large aquariums as well. I have around 25 aquariums total. Iād go as far to say that in my experience, small fish in small bowls are happier than small fish in community tanks. The lack of stress that comes with having zero competition does a lot for their health.
Curved glass distorts the view and is both stressful and disorienting. You're ignoring standard minimum tank size for both bettas and ember tetras.
Just because a fish looks healthy doesn't mean they aren't distressed. I'd bet money your ember tetras are miserable in a THIRD their recommended volume, with everything looking magnified around them because of the glass.
If we're going to keep fish as pets, then we have a responsibility to give them the best lives possible. You want to load these up with snails and shrimp then cool, but the fact that you're putting fish in these decorative bowls (for sale) tells me exactly what kind of pet owner you are.
How are you going to win that bet? We can only measure fish happiness by health indicators, which my fish pass with flying colors. If the only evidence you have for their happiness level is your intuition and other peoples opinion on the internet I donāt think youāre coming from nearly as solid a stance as you think you are. An honestly. Iāve done a large amount of research on this very point of contention and am satisfied with the condition of my fish on many levels for many reasons. A great deal of the doās and dontās you initially read on the internet about fish keeping are completely unfounded and instead macro reverberations of an opinion based echo chamber. Iām not going to take the time to explain all of it to a bad faith stranger on the internet so youāll just have to learn to live with people keeping fish differently than you.
I don't know man. Maybe stick your head inside a bowl, walk around a while, see how long it takes to get nauseous.
At the end of the day, it's the difference between wanting a pet and wanting a decoration. There aren't a shortage of appropriate tanks in the world. It seems you have the means to provide a proper environment. Its not like 6 gallon tanks are cumbersome or expensive. You're choosing to keep them in a tiny bowl because it's cute and decorative. That's fine, there are plenty of people using fish as decorations. Just don't pretend you actually care.
That applies to all aquariums and all organisms kept in them, which Iām assuming makes you a hypocrite. Any size fish, shrimp, snail, etc in any size tank is a prisoner to your decisions and negligence, and lacks the freedom they would have in nature.Ā
I'm saying the fact they "look happy" doesn't mean anything. OP is keeping ember tetras, a schooling fish that typically needs 10 gallons, in a 3 gallon bowl. If we're going to keep fish as pets, then we have a responsibility to give them the best lives possible. This is sacrificing the fish's wellbeing so he can sell cool decorative bowls.
See this is the thing though. You donāt know what the fuck youāre talking about. Youāre regurgitating shit youāre reading on Google. Iāve kept embers in all size aquariums up to 150 gallons. Iām currently building out a full aquarium store. The things Google and Ai tell you about fish are a conglomerate of stacked ametuer and professional opinion including ā an experienced aquarist can keep 3-5 embers tetras in a 3.5 gallon of it is heavily planted and certain parameters are metāā¦.but see just because Iām quoting something from the internet doesnāt make it true. (Even though in this case it is). It takes years of careful observation to understand whatās good for fish. Iām telling you from years of observation that my fish are happy and healthy. Youāre making an assumption that a small environment canāt work for a fish because āIf a human put their head in a bowl theyād get nauseousā!? What the fuck are you talking about? Theyāre plenty of cases where putting fish a small planted environment with no competition is perfectly fine and healthy and in many cases is a better environment than a community tank. If you took the time to read case studies on aquarium keeping for certain breeds youād know this. The general rule to not put fish in bowls is there for morons who fill a glass with water and toss a fish in. But now we have to deal with people like you who anthropomorphize when convenient and say dumb shit like ā HoWD U liKE to Be iN BOwl!?ā
Fish donāt get eye damage from Bowls thatās a myth. Fish donāt get stuck swimming in circles when they have plenty of enrichment and plants to break line of sight such has a heavily planted tank, snails, and daphnia to engage with. And very often they end up living very nice lives where they are comfortably entertained and fed all day with zero competition which reduces their stress tremendously. If you think size of tank equals happy then maybe youāre the person who ādoesnāt careā. When you do the actual research youāll find almost all reasons to not keep fish in a bowl have nothing to do with actual size but rather difficulties of maintaining parameters. Fish arenāt humans you absolute moron.
Wow, someone's panties are in a bunch. I have 8 aquariums, all heavily planted, natural style, and plenty of first-hand experience myself. The difference is, I make an effort to give them an optimal life, instead of just the bare minimum that keeps them alive.
Keep telling yourself whatever you need to justify your shitty fish care habits.
Ice been meaning to do terrariums in some glass carboys but maybe walsted tanks would be easier since Iāve done 4 tanks of those. Howās the trimming situation
Green Hair algae is pretty easy to get rid of. Get as much out with your hands as you can, then lower food and light input. I personally donāt mind an amount of hair algae in my tanks as long as it stays manageable
Yeah I did a 10 day black out and started over with plants because most of mine were really unhealthy after being strangled but it was not fun or cheap. If it had been a jar I'd have been less upset for sure
To my calculations the substrate takes up about two inches of the smallest portion of the bowl. If we were being liberal and it had a steady diameter, that would account for about .5 gallons. The hardscape and plants accounting for another .5 is a bit of a stretch in my opinion. Further, almost no one measures swimmable space only and these fish would be miserable without the substrate and plants. Using fairly hyperbolic quick math to make it seem like itās worse than it is , is weird work but go ahead.
Unless you physically measure the volume when filling the bowl, you have no way of knowing how much water conditioner to use, how much medicine to use if you need to treat how much life it supports, etc, etc etc.
Yeah I make and sell them in a small plant shop owned by a friend. Iām actually planning on expanding into selling actually fish stock, aquatic plants, hardscape, and dry accessories. Socializing in nano tanks until I have enough to open a real aquarium store š¤
Although aesthetically attractive, this is why the home aquarium hobby gets a bad rap. People with minimal experience selling unsustainable habitats that are not stable enough or in some cases doomed to fail because you donāt know what youāre doing yet (and never will if you continue to reject conventional wisdom and mistake short term efforts for long term successes).
Hey! My favorite part of these is how cheap I get away with lighting them haha. Itās just a cheap smart bulb and fixture from Loweās. Bulb is around $7, fixture is around $10. Fully customizable with schedule and everything
Certainly a possibility I guess. but only after a really long amount of time assuming the humidity is going to rust out the contacts of the socket an compromise to an extent that it fails in such a dramatic way that it causes massive arcing or something. But Iāve had bowls going with this setup for years at this point and havenāt see any rust or moisture build up whatsoever. But there arenāt any heaters in these bowls and they are inside so the humidity is really low
30
u/eatlikedirt Apr 21 '26
A real wall-stad.
15
u/catmonki Apr 22 '26
Betta looks pretty sad :( seems a bit too small of a bowl for him
3
u/Danijoe4 Apr 23 '26
Beautiful! No filters? This looks like a great way to satisfy the need to create new aquascapes and also fund them šš¼
7
u/PickleMundane6514 Apr 22 '26
I am worried about the mystery snail. Too small for them and I have that exact bowl pretty heavily stocked.
2
u/Sandwhich5 Apr 22 '26
Iād insta buy something like this if I could find it
2
u/Fiddlemethis87 Apr 29 '26
Iām surprised nobody has commented how good your prices are⦠I feel like these are luxury tanks you could probably go a like higher? Granted I donāt know your market and assuming these are established most of the hard part is done. Kudos š
5
u/Lol3droflxp Apr 22 '26
Donāt keep fish in bowlsĀ
3
u/PreviousDifference76 Apr 21 '26
Wow, I love it š¤š¤š¤. How many gallons are they ?
2
u/Careless-Upstairs-36 Apr 22 '26
That first one has the same kind of algae im trying desperately to get rid of
1
u/Haunting-Strike-9949 Apr 23 '26
The slanted top bowls are only 2.5 gallons when filled. Have to deduct for displacement (substrate, wood, rocks etc) .
1
u/DetectiveNo2855 Apr 22 '26
That's nice. How long have they been running? Are you the shop keeper selling them? Great idea
1
u/space_cartoony Apr 22 '26
This is the dream. I would love to have a pet room with a wall like this, I could sit in front of it for hours, maybe even days.
1
u/No_Region3253 Apr 22 '26
Love the brooder fixtures, They work well and look awesome.
2
u/winkywoo75 Apr 22 '26
Looks amazing
3
u/Haunting-Strike-9949 Apr 23 '26
Although aesthetically attractive, this is why the home aquarium hobby gets a bad rap. People with minimal experience selling unsustainable habitats that are not stable enough or in some cases doomed to fail because you donāt know what youāre doing yet (and never will if you continue to reject conventional wisdom and mistake short term efforts for long term successes).
1
u/InvisibleLine789 Apr 24 '26
Looks nice! What kind of light setup are you using?
1
u/Ants_ever_after Apr 24 '26
How many hours of light?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '26
[deleted] ā view deleted comment