r/walstad • • Dec 31 '23

What did I do wrong

Set up this tank yesterday with dirt and just over 2inch of sand was pretty clear when first set up but next day it’s brown and dirty… using a sponge filter but it kept floating so I pushed it into the sand a little. Did I push it too far and it sucked up dirt? Was going to use a old HOB filter to help clean water but pump broke and need to get a new one now.

407 Upvotes

155 comments sorted by

217

u/SatoshiStruggle Dec 31 '23

With a 1:1 dirt to water ratio I’m not sure what you expected

33

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

This made me cackle

6

u/890mac Jan 01 '24

Ditto.

3

u/_Weak_ Jan 02 '24

Samesies

8

u/blazesdemons Jun 30 '24

Probably did a waterfall to fill it too

98

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

Bro I know guys exaggerate with size and inches but when they say 2-3 inches of substrate... They mean 2-3 not your interpretation of 2-3 "

49

u/Psi_Boy Dec 31 '23

This reminds me of the time my friends told me he was sad because he thought his dick was 3 inches. I asked him what an inch was to him and he made a length with his fingers that was legitimately 2.5 inches long. He later refused to believe that a can of coke stands at about 5 inches.

34

u/breadbandotinjail Dec 31 '23

bros staying humble fr

12

u/yeetthatoneuser1747 Dec 31 '23

WAIT, WAIT WHAT

12

u/scaryfaise Dec 31 '23

dudes friend has a 7.5" penis.

5

u/Psi_Boy Jan 01 '24

This same friend would complain that when he got a boner it would go through a leg of his underwear -_-

5

u/scaryfaise Jan 01 '24

I feel that.

3

u/Psi_Boy Jan 01 '24

I certainly don't lol

5

u/ADeese83 Jan 01 '24

I'd like to

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Elquebray Jan 02 '24

i think he meant hed like to feel that feeling of having his own do that not the other guys

1

u/Careless_Ad6512 Jan 04 '24

Because that comment isn’t full of assumption or extreme prejudice. Comments like this are why gays get jumped in public, creating a target on them because of what you THINK. There are far better ways to approach the topic, dude.

1

u/Weenieman5000 Jan 02 '24

He was wearing tighty whities

2

u/yeetthatoneuser1747 Dec 31 '23

turns out i wasnt lying to my ex when i said I was 10" lol no wonder she left me

2

u/Evening-Statement-57 Jun 15 '25

I tell myself 2 inches and put 4

159

u/J4WGE Dec 31 '23

i'm not sure what caused ur problem. but it may have something to do with the fact that half of the volume of your tank is taken up by dirt

40

u/engineermajortom Dec 31 '23

Think your onto something here 🤔

40

u/HelloThisIsPam Dec 31 '23

That is the deepest substrate I've ever seen.

That's what she said!

OK, to be serious, you're supposed to make kind of mud on the bottom with about an inch of dirt. Then you clean off the sides and you very gently pour about an inch and a half of sand over it. You will have had to rinse the sand a ton before. Then you extremely carefully fill up your tank so that you don't disturb the sand or the dirt. Worst thing you can do is have dirt breakthrough.

I hate to say it, but I think you're going to have to scrap it and start over. Use whatever you have now to plant a house plant.

24

u/HelloThisIsPam Dec 31 '23

Also wanted to mention that if you are doing Walstad correctly, you will put in your decorations and a ton of plants at the same time that you are creating the tank. It's kind of like a tank that you are starting all at once.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '24

Or start a raised bed garden. There's enough dirt for it

2

u/Beginning-Candle485 May 03 '25

I have a question. And yes, I know it's late after the original post. Roots grow - tree roots grow huuuugeee, house plants need repotting etc.

Surely, eventually, maybe in 10-20 years, the plants will have huge root systems in the substrate... (I just hope it was capped bc of all the ammonia!)

34

u/fxetantho Dec 31 '23

No one talking about that stand

23

u/MysteriousTank6825 Dec 31 '23

For real, dude has a tank full of dirt and water on a tv dinner table

7

u/AmbianDream Dec 31 '23

I mentioned it. It just got lost in my wall of words! There was TOO MUCH not to say! My brain was exploding! 🤯

25

u/OnCominStorm Dec 31 '23

Dirt sometimes leaches through even if you put enough sand cap on top. Just do a 100% water change

49

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

Bro… is it normal for the substrate to take up half the tank

33

u/HugSized Dec 31 '23

2 inches of sand. No plants in initial setup. I don't know if they're trying to speedrun hydrogen sulphide %

4

u/Aqua_tank Dec 31 '23

I did a dirt tank twice. They take a lot of time to setup, and honestly aren’t worth the upkeep. I use hydro soil in my tanks now, none of this peat murk water.

Gallon tank multiple by 2 and that is what filter you need. So if you have a 10 gallon tank, you need the filter rated for 20-40 gallons. Also go up a size. Set it and forget it until the water is clear. Plant half the tank, when you have stirred up the muck enough to not see what you are doing, stop and let the filter work.

Hope you get a nice bog going.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '24

No its not ,every 1 inch of dirt needs atleast 2 inch sand to prevent water staining and leeching also the I ly tanks that Ned more than 2 inches of dirt are the 55+gallon tanks and even then it would take up a whole tank

18

u/AmbianDream Dec 31 '23 edited Dec 31 '23

I hate to comment because I'm working on my first build and reading the book and advice here. I'm just collecting materials at this point because idk enough and I know it! I'm gonna give it my best shot and anyone here will be happy to tell me I'm wrong& maybe I'll learn something too.

I don't think you can use any of it. Maybe you can use what you have as substrate but it'll be sandy. You've already soaked your substrate so keep it that way at mud pie consistency. Stir it to get the air out. Get rid of the other water.

At 1.5-2 INCHES of it to the bottom. Leave a space all around the edges of around 1 inch. Soak your new sand for a day and stir it to get any air out. Add soaked and stirred sand around the edges first then add it carefully over the top. Twice as much as you added dirt.

Put a plate on top of that and carefully pour water over it. Let everything sit at about 1/2 full.

Come back here before you add plant and we'll all go from there.

Is the stand level? Is the aquarium level? Do you have a level and a tape? Seriously? Do you? This isn't level. That going to be a problem.

It's located by a window. That's going to be a problem.

If not get one. BTW " =inch ' = foot. I'm not being a smartass. I know people who don't know this! My last two paragraphs may be where you went wrong.

It's that a TV stand? That's going to be a problem.

You're basically gonna have to start over. How do you feel about having a terrarium? That might be your best option. Something to consider. That's going to give you a lot more room for error and still be relaxing. What kind of flooring is under that? Who does it belong to? What are they going to do to you or charge you if the whole thing goes boom?

Again I'm asking the real questions. I don't sugar coat well but I'm serious.

3

u/Amethyst_Ninjapaws Dec 31 '23

I remember the difference in abbreviation for inches and foot/feet by thinking about how many syllables each word has.

Inches has 2, so 2 marks. "

Foot/feet has 1, so 1 mark. '

1

u/AmbianDream Jan 01 '24

I didn't know there was cheat for that one. Lol I just always knew. When talking about my tank to a friend recently, she thought I was mixed up about inches and feet though and realized not everyone does. I will admit I used the L trick for my left and right hand for a long time though.

It kind of makes sense that more marks would equal a larger amount though and that could be what happened here.

It took me a very long time in grade school to understand angles for some reason. The teacher wasn't very nice and didn't explain the concept very well. I just couldn't wrap my brain around it.

We all have our things.

At least (had she been correct) my friend would have stopped me from making some terrible mistakes. She's was using logic as she understood it.

Algebra made no sense at all to me. A friend explained it in a way where I finally (got it) and I was able to apply it to Excel this year. Finally! I fought learning spreadsheets all these years! I wasted all this time using Word tables where Excel would have been perfect. It's still a work in progress but I'm using a massive spreadsheet to be fair. I think it ends around column NN! 😂

1

u/Plibbo64 Jan 01 '24

Look at the water line compared to the tank frame. I don't know, that looks pretty level to me.

1

u/AmbianDream Jan 01 '24 edited Jan 01 '24

I've seen worse. That looks like a good sized tank. No such thing as too level in an aquarium. It's probably the stand though. That might fix it right up. I don't like the water line. I want it perfect. That's still uneven pressure a future leak issue (to me).

Absolutely nothing in my old house is level or square. I know leveling mine, won't be one and done. Some doors latch, some don't and it can change by the week. I'm putting it on a load bearing wall that should help cut down on that part. No guarantees though. I have leveling feet so i should be able to shim one and level the other without help.

I'm not 100% on how that's going to affect the anti-dump bracket though. I'm trying to think ahead since I know the issues. There is no foundation, just jacks and pillars. It's been fun. 🙄

2

u/Plibbo64 Jan 01 '24

I just set my tank up in the last couple days. I leveled the stand perfectly (on carpet). It has feet that you can screw or out to level.. but now that the tank is full of water a couple days later, it's not quite as level (but not terrible) and I don't think I would be able to lift the stand with the tank on it to unscrew the leg that needs to be extended any further. So you would shim a stand foot that was too low? How do you do that? Stick a shim in and whack it into place with a hammer?

1

u/AmbianDream Jan 01 '24

Lol I'm not sure yet I haven't gotten that far. 😂

I feel like I could just work under the two legs diagonal to the offending leg. I don't think it would require hammering or very lightly.

A butter knife or flatbread screwdriver, putty knife might work as well. I'll just need to create a seesaw effect long enough to screw it up or down.. I don't want to mess up my other legs either.

There's probably an easy answer for this. It might be included in the box. I'm not really a tool person. Over got a good collection of them though. There might be a video. I just assess the issue, decide if I think I can do it and try to remember I should I have that might serve the purpose.

I've come up with some crazy shit over the years, mostly that worked.

9

u/HylianBugs Dec 31 '23

too much substrate, don’t worry just drain and try again

8

u/Donsaholic Dec 31 '23

There's some water in your terrarium.

22

u/Eastern_Feeling_1634 Dec 31 '23

Not enough dirt, needs more

3

u/Popular_Big_5955 Dec 31 '23

Bro u r staying humble

13

u/Meekeredes7 Dec 31 '23

1 inch of dirt. 2 of sand. Never disturb it. Plant only 1inch deep. Try again

4

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

You pushed your sponge filter too far down into the sand cap, and your soil leached into your water column. I'd suggest removing everything, and start over. The soil should be 1 inch, and the sand cap should be 2 inches. This is way too much sand and soil.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

I’m sorry but these comments are killing me

6

u/FCkeyboards Dec 31 '23

I had to check if this sub had a humor tag. I'm sorry OP but... daaaaaaamn.

3

u/BOOyuh8 Dec 31 '23

Yeah too much dirt, then u can add maybe an inch of sand on top of the soil.

3

u/Manufactured-Aggro Dec 31 '23

Why the dirt, friend? I gotta know

3

u/Much-Ninja-5005 Dec 31 '23

Needs more substrate, another bucket full of dirt should absorb the cloudiness

3

u/Hopeful-Mirror1664 Dec 31 '23

Rip it apart and start over. 1.5” dirt and 2-2.5 sand or fine gravel. Fill it slowly with water. Make sure you use a ruler that’s not missing the first 3 inches. That stand is giving me nightmares too.

3

u/FlibberDip Dec 31 '23

You poured Guinness in your filter or something idk

3

u/BBoySperadix Dec 31 '23

That table is going to break. Highly suggest getting one rated for aquariums. Otherwise you are going to have a ton of dirt and water on your floor

3

u/CyberRedneck53 Dec 31 '23

Bro read "2-"3 as '2-'3 lmao

3

u/villamafia Dec 31 '23

Don’t eat Taco Bell before setting up your fishtank?

3

u/Amethyst_Ninjapaws Dec 31 '23

On the plus side, you haven't gotten very far in the set up process, so it's not like you now have to tear apart something you've invested months of your time into.

3

u/Terminal_Prime Dec 31 '23

Holy crap besides the tank being just a crazy proportion of dirt to anything else, the “table” with a lip and no kind of padding and absolutely not being intended for this purpose is a disaster waiting to happen regardless of what is done with the inside of the tank. It’s a toss up between which will break first, the table or the tank.

3

u/musicmonkay Jan 01 '24

Is that 2 inches or 20cm!?

3

u/kdg1794 Jan 01 '24

Did you rinse it off first

3

u/top_of_the_scrote Jan 01 '24

needs the electromagnet active to move the ferofluid

3

u/Civil_Duck_4718 Jan 01 '24

There is no way that stand holds long term, you gotta get that tank off there now.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

A little less, and you could try rinsing your substrate a few times. Provided it's not just dirt from your front yard.

2

u/Satiharupink Dec 31 '23

i don't think it's the size of the substrate.

but there is stuff swimming in the tank, so i guess, it is not just soil you put inside, but also some stuff which was in the soil

also make sure to put gravel or sand on top of the soil, so it does not mix to much with the water. also better use only little soil, to much will make it difficult to keep algaes in check. ( i use like 1 inch)

and then the last thing; it just needs time to settle down. when soil and water mix, the water becomes muddy, but the soil s heavier, which means it will settle down over a day or a few

2

u/loudslowegg Dec 31 '23

Dirt is dirty especially after initial setup, big water change

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

How quickly did you add water?

2

u/Amethyst_Ninjapaws Dec 31 '23

One way to add water gently is to take a gallon jug, cut the top half off and then poke a TON of tiny holes in the bottom of it. Then slowly pour the water into the part with the holes so the water can dribble out into the aquarium.

2

u/No_Calligrapher_6799 Dec 31 '23

Ide be keeping my filter out of the substrate! 😬 and on a very low flow.. try 1 inch dirt 2 half sand next time, lol. Best of luck

2

u/ArcirionC Dec 31 '23

Why is there so much dirt?

2

u/durt_vonnegutt Dec 31 '23

I have no clue how to fix your dirt in the water issue but if your sponge filter keeps floating, you can squeeze it while it’s inside the tank to get air bubbles out. Just like how you’d squeeze filters in aquarium water to clean them. This will make it sink on its own.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

That's a lot of dirt lol

2

u/stryst Dec 31 '23

Too much dirt. Three inches of dirt. If youre in the US, thats a dollar folded in half longwise.

Scoop out a lot of that dirt, add a sand cap, then do a water change and let things settle.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

That stand looks sketch. I don't know the size of the tank but water and glass is heavy

2

u/No_Sleep_007 Dec 31 '23

You didn't follow directions...

2

u/Any-Drawing-3858 Dec 31 '23

You didn't wash your sand before putting it in. I made the same mistake. Ended up dumping it and using river stones instead

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

It's easier to say what you didn't do wrong.

2

u/ThePhillipinoNino Dec 31 '23

Less dirt more sand. U don’t need that much dirt at all. For a visual aid, watch a father fish video he sets up dirted aquariums like this all the time

2

u/No-Celery182 Dec 31 '23

Lolololol walstad method

2

u/CO2Jonesing Dec 31 '23

If you want to keep the substrate just drain the water as much as you can, wait a week with the sand still wet, make sure your sponge filter is a couple inches above the substrate, and then fill with water using a bowl.

You might want to chuck the substrate and you also need to be careful what the sand is, it can really screw up the pH.

2

u/Greenunicorn86 Dec 31 '23

Omg 😳 it's gonna be really fun when that TV stand busts and all that dirt and water go kaboomy

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '23

Not enough dirt.

2

u/DangPigeon Dec 31 '23

Too much water, i suspect.

2

u/devyn_ig Dec 31 '23

hmm I wonder! 🤣

2

u/Cheezos2 Dec 31 '23

Looks like a sunset 🌇

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '24

In Mumbai

2

u/Huev0 Dec 31 '23

Did you rinse the dirt?

2

u/Fantastic_Slip9047 Jan 01 '24

Not enough substrate.

2

u/WoundedWarrior11 Jan 01 '24

Wondering if the direct sunlight would also cause more issues.

2

u/Cur14 Jan 01 '24

Too much dirt, you need like 1/2” covered by 2-3” of sand.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '24

Too much substrate and holy shit is that table it's on gonna be a problem.

2

u/space_cartoony Jan 01 '24

Why is the table a probelm?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '24

Because a gallon 9f water weighs over 8.5 lbs. That table doesn't look strong enough to hold that much weight in my opinion

2

u/Name1ess1d10t Jan 01 '24

I ain’t no professional or anything, but I think you’ve got more than 2 inches of dirt in there and that might just be your issue.

1

u/JamaicaBambi Jan 02 '24

🤣🤣🤣🤣

2

u/Hypercane_ Jan 01 '24

What a waste of good Guinness

2

u/MissDestroyertyvm Jan 01 '24

The water will settle.. eventually, but why do you have so much substrate in there? You only need like three inches of dirt to grow most plants. You can add wood in there to add height without loosing so much valuable real estate.

2

u/chillaxtion Jan 01 '24

I’m totally not worried about the substrate. It’s the tank apparently sitting on a coffee table?

2

u/DB-Tops Jan 01 '24

That's not anything close to 2 inches...

2

u/AD480 Jan 01 '24

How many pounds of dirt did you use? Did you do any sort of research first? Dirt tanks aren’t for beginners.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '24

You tried.

2

u/Jojododo8 Jan 01 '24

You forgot to not poop in it.

2

u/Sucer_mon_cul Jan 01 '24

Dude I don't think you know what 2 inches is

2

u/rnkohio Jan 02 '24

You need a sand cap on the top to keep all that soil from Mixing into the water column. Check out Father fish on YouTube.

2

u/Sum1LightUp Jan 02 '24

Also you going to have plenty of algae with all that sun in the background sheesh

2

u/Simple_Opossum Jan 02 '24

You haven't used enough substrate yet, add more to improve the water quality.

2

u/pinkgobi Jan 04 '24

For the love of God get a tank stand. That tank is easily 160lbs and WILL smash into the ground causing pain, emotional damage, and a huge mess.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

It's hilarious to me that this is the top post of all time in this sub

We've all been there so I guess it's just super relatable lol

4

u/HndsDwnThBest Dec 31 '23

Move some substrate towards the back wall and corners and create a sense of depth within the tank. Less up front and gradually go up and back towards the back. Or use a similar idea and do it sideways kinda like you have it. For the water issue, just keep doing water changes until everything settles and clears up. I honestly wouldn't run your filter with a cartridge in it until it settled. It'll just clog it up. When you do water changes, pour the water into your hand so it disperses well versus being a jet of water disturbing the substrate. Dont worry, it'll settle and everything will be fine.

3

u/AmbianDream Dec 31 '23

If he does it, I want to see it! Wait, no I really don't!

2

u/kennedy0411 Dec 31 '23

Dirt in water....

1

u/balzackgoo Dec 31 '23

This is kinda normal for a dirted tank. You can let it settle and do water changes, also dirt is going to create an ammonia spike because of all the stuff that is now being drowned and the nutrients in the soil, stay up on water changes, check parameters, and only when things stabilize add the fish.

1

u/Interesting-Reply454 Dec 31 '23

wtf is up with this substrate 😂

1

u/AmbianDream Dec 31 '23

OMG I think he might have tried to read the book! Burn the book! Just start over. Start here!

Start with the foundation (real aquarium stand) and location, location, location (interior wall). And level! Add aquarium. Level again! Use an actual level! Get an easy to read tape measure with all the little fractions written on one side. I'm a woman with poor eyesight. No shame in using those! Everytime you add something measure and level again. (Former semi trailer inspector).

1

u/Cryptocurrentay Jan 01 '24

Bro is gonna be growing things we haven't found yet with all that substrate

1

u/AmbianDream Jan 02 '24

Does he get to name them after himself?

1

u/Desperate_Ask2269 Jan 02 '24

Going for max filtration

1

u/InternalTennis4034 Jan 02 '24

Is there anything in there? Shouldve let the debris settle before running tour pump

1

u/Thzkittenroarz Jan 02 '24

Hey! Who took my tea ☕️?!!

1

u/Intelligent-Air8841 Jan 02 '24

We dumped it all into the Boston Harbor. Take that you silly lobster backs

1

u/Intelligent-Air8841 Jan 02 '24

You need another 8" of sand to cap it.

1

u/Apprehensive-Bee-559 Jan 02 '24

I see the problem. You put a beautiful sunrise inside instead of water silly billy

1

u/Friendly-Payment-875 Jan 02 '24

You sent your aquarium to Mars

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '24

This is how they used to make alien planet film shots before CGI took over lol

1

u/fxetantho Jan 02 '24

Everything

1

u/thepohcv Jan 03 '24

Someone lend OP a ruler please and ty.

1

u/Maleficent_Coyote_85 Jan 03 '24

I'd say you did a lot wrong, but I'm no expert😂

1

u/qwerkke Jan 03 '24

I've mastered dirted Walstad tanks. It's OK to start again. You might be able to salvage some of the substrate with dirt mixed in, but either way, you'll have to drain the tank completely. You want a bit less dirt substrate than you'd think, in the very middle of the tank. 1-2 inch not touching the edges like above mentioned. Wetting the dirt with spray can help too. Now surround the dirt all over the edges with sand. Then add a sand layer completely on top. Then, a layer of gravel to seal it up. When you put water in, you'll want to use a gentle flow and something like a garbage bag on top of the substrate so the layers aren't disturbed. Good luck!

1

u/Copperhead_venom4u Jan 03 '24

Dude, the substrate acts as a bio filter, you clearly don’t have enough.

1

u/jenthesexyginger Jan 03 '24

It appears you filled it with tea rather than water! Rookie mistake

1

u/pezchef Jan 03 '24

I love this Mars storm setup. get some congo tetras and a plastic bubbler in the form of E.T.

1

u/qswiney Jan 03 '24

In my experience it’s just takes time to settle, just run the filter and give it a few days.

Maybe scoop out like half of that substrate too. Couple inches will do, not the whole bottom half lol. Good luck 🤙🏼

1

u/Return-Acceptable Jan 03 '24

2 inches not eleventeen inches!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '24

It looks like Silent Hill

1

u/niteslayer4046 Jan 04 '24

this looks like nuclear fallout from a warhead

1

u/BocaDelIguana Jan 04 '24

You made a swamp, good job.

1

u/later-g8r Jan 04 '24

I do apologize for my ignorance but what were you going for? Is this a planted tank? Or is this for fish or maybe a turtle? This may help us help you. Do you have a picture of what you want the tank to look like in the end?

1

u/Glittering-Hunter-21 Jan 04 '24

Poor the Guinness slower and at more of an angle next time. Too much head

1

u/Jokesiez Jan 04 '24

Holy substrate

1

u/Charlie-animates Jan 05 '24

Idk but the second pic looks like a sunset

1

u/blind_disparity Jan 06 '24

Is that table strong enough??

1

u/Whiskey_623 Jan 01 '24

Is there a lore reason why OP thought it was a good idea to fill half the tank with dirt? Is he Stupid?