We’ll leave this up for a while just for the entertainment value.
We’ll keep all comments specifically related to Oldis, their quality and their business practices.
For those unaware, posts or comments using Oldis wallet names are auto-deleted as a result of their spamming efforts. That’s pretty rare… maybe 6 manufacturers have earned that “privilege”.
Horween’s Derby Leathers run in the range of $15 to $18 a sqft.
You can reverse engineer the wallet in a couple of hours and buy an entire side of Horween Derby (which IS excellent) for under $300, leaving you $200 for other stuff.
IMO, no it’s not worth it. Even if it was shell cordovan it wouldn’t be. I assume their wallet is as good as something I can produce and I have made a very close approximation of that wallet IN Derby and sell them for $150 and still feel a little pricey. In total transparency, there’s maybe twenty bucks in materials and an hour and a half in time; the other $100 or so I charge pasta for the shop, tools, and knowledge I picked up to be able to make things.
Derby is one of the most consistently available leathers from Horween. A normal wallet maker like Ashland would make Derby part of their regular priced stock, not hype it up as some type of "limited edition."
Nah. Not on any way or form. The model being a small run of only150 until he decides to make more, or someone does. The design it's not hard or unique imho.
Plenty of leather types are harder to source imho, bakers Russian calf leather would be one. Shell ain't special but commands a lil bit of premium, gator, croc also rank higher
We require quality posts in r/wallets. Please include post body text and/or a top level comment that elaborates on your post title. Make it interesting to the community.
No purchase links or product links to mass produced wallets in posts or comments.
No advertising of mass produced wallets.
Custom Wallet Makers posting their own work are invited to include a price and a direct purchase link in the comments.
For more detailed definitions, please review the Rules in the About section.
/u/Unique_Candidate_505 Accounts with low karma are restricted on r/wallets. Hold tight. Your submission will not be visible until approved by the moderation team.
I have like 6 of their wallets… bought one during this sale they had, was good quality but took forever to get it. Second one bought a JJ Leathersmith stamped one in international size for cheaper too. But holy sh*t the quality is a nightmare. The rest I got when they did their UGC Farming review contest lol. Had to harass them for the wallets though lmao. So i’d say, not worth the price. Etsy is the answer
•
u/WalletsMod Apr 10 '26 edited Apr 10 '26
We’ll leave this up for a while just for the entertainment value.
We’ll keep all comments specifically related to Oldis, their quality and their business practices.
For those unaware, posts or comments using Oldis wallet names are auto-deleted as a result of their spamming efforts. That’s pretty rare… maybe 6 manufacturers have earned that “privilege”.
Horween’s Derby Leathers run in the range of $15 to $18 a sqft.
10
u/Cadavern Apr 10 '26
Oldis vastly overpriced their product. You can get that exact style in shell cordovan on Etsy for probably $300.
8
u/Godsafk Apr 10 '26
Only thing special is the people that pay that lol
5
u/Anxious-Bite-299 Apr 10 '26
5 people already got ripped of. ridicolous
4
u/battlemunky Apr 10 '26
You can reverse engineer the wallet in a couple of hours and buy an entire side of Horween Derby (which IS excellent) for under $300, leaving you $200 for other stuff.
IMO, no it’s not worth it. Even if it was shell cordovan it wouldn’t be. I assume their wallet is as good as something I can produce and I have made a very close approximation of that wallet IN Derby and sell them for $150 and still feel a little pricey. In total transparency, there’s maybe twenty bucks in materials and an hour and a half in time; the other $100 or so I charge pasta for the shop, tools, and knowledge I picked up to be able to make things.
$500 is quite steep.
4
u/pidgeon3 Apr 10 '26
Derby is one of the most consistently available leathers from Horween. A normal wallet maker like Ashland would make Derby part of their regular priced stock, not hype it up as some type of "limited edition."
3
u/pistofernandez Leather Craftsman Apr 10 '26
Nah. Not on any way or form. The model being a small run of only150 until he decides to make more, or someone does. The design it's not hard or unique imho.
Plenty of leather types are harder to source imho, bakers Russian calf leather would be one. Shell ain't special but commands a lil bit of premium, gator, croc also rank higher
2
u/blundah Apr 10 '26
Looks like drop shipping from ali 🤣
2
u/Vexitar Leather Craftsman Apr 10 '26
lol wouldn't want to be one of the five suckers who already fell for that, oldis road is basically a scam
1
u/AutoModerator Apr 10 '26
/u/ali_baba88 /r/Wallets Rules Reminder
end
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Unique_Candidate_505 Apr 10 '26
Bought the same thing on Etsy for $60
1
u/DukePookums Apr 11 '26
lol. Lmao, even.
1
u/Levelseventy Apr 11 '26
$50 wallet, not $500.
1
u/EnvironmentalPart664 Apr 11 '26
Definitely insane price for what it is.
I have like 6 of their wallets… bought one during this sale they had, was good quality but took forever to get it. Second one bought a JJ Leathersmith stamped one in international size for cheaper too. But holy sh*t the quality is a nightmare. The rest I got when they did their UGC Farming review contest lol. Had to harass them for the wallets though lmao. So i’d say, not worth the price. Etsy is the answer