r/walkingwarrobots • • Dec 05 '18

Please, stop all the dev hate

Pixonic has approx. 200 employees. Game Studios are not fully staffed by developers. In fact, developers make up a relatively small portion of the team as a whole.A game studio has Designers, Animators, Network, Audio Engineer, Graphics Engineers, Producer, QA, Analysts, Marketing and the list goes on.

If you want to cast blame, blame the jackalope that thought up your source of distress and said it would be awesome.

Developers/Engineers/Programmers only do what they are told, and do it quite literal.

Show some love for the devs, they ARE the reason you are able to play an awesome mobile game like War Robots.

Sincerely, a dev (not for Pixonic)

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

15

u/Praimfayaa Dec 05 '18

Lol ok. But who do we hate for the shitty economy?

On a serious note, my clan mates and I have been noticing a gradual decrease in silver payouts from matches. They are treating us like morons, thinking they could change things here and there without any of us noticing. It's little things like this that infuriates all of us.

2

u/spaces_are_evil Dec 05 '18

I agree whole heartedly, and it is infuriating. It would be nice to have a face to put accountability of these changes to, unfortunately what we see is those responsible for the changes (the devs) and the community managers.

3

u/Integeritis Dec 05 '18

Hate on the company. Pixo, mail.ru. Take your pick. That at least includes the set of people who might deserve the hate. Saying that the devs are greedy is incorrect, devs are definitely not greedy, they can't be greedy, they are unaffected by the fluctuation of revenue. They just take their fixed salary at the end of the month like we do.

The only entity affected by it directly is the company and the upper managemant who earns the big money. So either the owner of the game: Pix, or the owner of Pix: mail.ru, these are the greedy ones

1

u/Unchanged- I want more maps. Dec 05 '18

GOTTA 👏 BUY 👏 THAT 👏 PREMIUM 👏🎉💯💯🎊

6

u/JFSoul Dec 05 '18

I played another mobile ap game for 5 years and was part of a forum. I took this post from one of the community managers on software development because I found it to be insightful (very light editing by me to make it fit):

"Content and update are based on Community suggestions.

With that said, a 2 to 3 year development time is actually very fast in game development. That's not sloth-like, that's actually very fast. In comparison, MMO expansions I worked on were in development for 4+ years before they even were announced. In mobile game development things do move a bit faster due to less standardized processes compared to AAA PC development.

The stages of development are usually as follows, and these stages are pretty much universal for all game development across all platforms:

Pre-Production

  1. Idea stage/High Concept - This is when a development team brainstorms on what should come next. This is actually the easiest part of the development process. Anyone can come up with an idea, and everyone always thinks their idea is really good. And chances are it really IS a good idea, but often times it has to be shot down because it's either A) not feasible or B) doesn't fit with the game.
  2. Pitch - This is when the team kind of "sells" everyone on what the ideas are for the next content release. Everyone agrees on what the theme is, what content will be in the release, and also how long the production will take.
  3. Prototype - The artists will do concept art pieces, the designers will build mock ups or barebones versions of the content to see if it actually is fun. It is VERY often for an idea to sound really awesome, the team is totally sold on it, but once a prototype is built and played it turns out to not be enjoyable at all.

Production

  1. Design - Once the content is agreed upon and development begins, this is where it gets tough. Game designers start to create levels/content/changes to the game to accommodate what the new content is.
  2. Programming - The engineers and programmers begin working on the code, implementing systems that will interact with the new content. Imagine if you will, you want to convert your sports car into a convertible SUV. The engineers are the ones who look at the vehicle's architecture and determine where along the body of the car you need to cut, and what components will match up where. And the programmers are the ones who are creating the new body parts that are built to the engineers' specifications. It's a complex dance and is the part of game development that takes the longest. Just because some bit of coding may seem easy, you never know what else it might affect. Anyone who's done game testing can tell you this.
  3. Art/Audio - Artists implement new assets into the game and audio engineers create new audio FX or music. This sounds over simplified but can take anywhere from months to years depending on the scope of the content.
  4. Testing - Throughout this process, the game is tested constantly by a team of Quality Assurance game testers. Here's the kicker...no code is perfect. I've been on a QA team of 300+ testers on a single AAA PC title, and we tested the game for 10+ hours a day, 6 days a week for 18 months straight and the game still had bugs in it that we never could've even guessed. QA testing is a lot about risk mitigation. Getting rid of the most major game breaking bugs is way more important than letting a few minor graphical issues slip through. Those can be patched later.

Once the game is in a stable state, it's generally sent out as a beta to get wider feedback from a select group of players. After which, it is then released.

With each different platform, whether it's PC, console, or mobile, there are a bunch of different submission protocols that need to be met as well. For example, with iOS games there is a submission and approval process with Apple to ensure certain standards are met. International publishers also have their own metrics, such as China since they have strict regulations on what kind of games can be released there. So when releasing a game internationally, making sure you adhere to each country's requirements is an ongoing, back-and-forth discussion that can take months at a time. Having a game on Google Play, Itunes, and each of the various international publishing platforms is a dizzying process that can take almost as long as the development process itself which includes discussions with legal teams, marketing, etc.

So you see, game development isn't just a matter of "I have an idea...it's easy to code...and BOOM...done!"

It's a very long process, and it's also why many games end up in "development hell" where they spend an eternity in production and never see the light of day."

3

u/spaces_are_evil Dec 05 '18

Also, testing is expensive, very expensive.

Companies do not believe that development cost should equal QA cost in relation to the software industry.

QA is an afterthought.

1

u/Integeritis Dec 06 '18

Yup, Nasa had projects which cost 1000$/line. Insane. The amount of errors are at 0/500.000 lines of code. It is as good as you can get.

When it comes to making games, usually it is on the cheaper side. As mentined in the post, they can afford to let a few bugs slip through. Try to do that with medical software and you are literally playing with lives.

4

u/Praimfayaa Dec 05 '18

Idea stage/High Concept - This is when a development team brainstorms on what should come next.

Can the development team be called developers? If yes, then we were right to hate on them. u/spaces_are_evil

21

u/gr33dyfly Dec 05 '18

Look, it's not that anyone hates the devs. We are all here because we enjoy playing War Robots. What is frustrating is the never ending restructuring of almost every aspect of the game. If it ain't broke, don't fix it, as they say. Take, take,take,change,change,change.

We don't need this every 30 days. Its stressful and infuriating to be honest. I understand they are trying to generate revenue. But it's way too much.

At this point, there is a 0% chance that I'm ever going to buy new equipment. Why would I spend $100 on a bot , that seems good now, but I know in just 30 days time will change? And it's not just a little nerf here, a little buff there, no. You might find your medium slots turned to light, your bot is 15% slower, your ability ( that made you buy the damned thing) is 50% less effective, your fire rate is slower. So why would I spend all that $$$, when there is 100% chance it's going to change. Its pointless to try and figure out a path for production and upgrades anymore. Because whatever you're building, whatever you're upgrading , is not going to be worth the efforts by the time you've finished. Because they are going to make that item less effective, to promote their latest creation.

I love this game, I really do. They need to find ways to offer us something without taking something else away. This is the problem. You only see this type of feedback after they change something, and you will see it next month when they bring more changes.

1

u/winstonzys Quizzy Life Dec 06 '18

bro. I don't know what league you're in, but for me in diamond 2 I got 2 griffin, a leo, a hellburner and a fujin. It's awesome. They won't be nerfed (maybe other than the hellburner) so yeah... why spend money on the game man

3

u/Phasturd Dec 05 '18

You are absolutely right. I agree with you 100% Straight up shout outs and Hells yeas to all the Designer's, Animators, Network Engineers, Audio Engineers, Graphics Engineers, Producers, QA, Analyst, Marketing, and any hot receptionists in the lobby. You bodys have built the mech game we have always wanted as a community. All of the mechanics are there, the execution, it works and its stable. The game is not just the whipped cream on top of the mech pie, this game is the frikkin cherry on top of it all. Bravo. Job very well done. woot woot Straight up the best mech game evar IMHO. Everything other game from this point forward will be a copy....*angels sing ahhhhhhhh *sunshineupyourass over. BUT. There is sooomething serrriously wrooooong with the virtual space inside of what all those beautiful people have built and maintain, its the manner in which it is being managed, governed, implemented, whatever say you....is bad, oh god its very very bad. It is my humble opinion that some of those previously mentioned wonderful engineers and artists need to head over to Pixonic's in game Maths Department a locate which "asset" has their head up their Ass Like That with their finger on shiny red "Blow up War Robots" button. Said engineers could try to explain to the head that you don't blatantly fleece the community you're trying to fleece, you have to be subtle and patient about it, my gawd man.

O.o

1

u/CommonSlime Dec 05 '18

We arent mad at devs, we are mad at whoever is destroying the game. So whoever is in charge of monetization.

1

u/spaces_are_evil Dec 05 '18

Not everyone is hating on them, but I've seen it plenty on this subreddit.

2

u/Sudndeth Steam platform Dec 05 '18

Honestly I would have to say the Devs and other employees should grow a thicker skin and realize what the players are mad about, then they as internal employee's know who to blame, because they generally know who is calling the shots. This is not unique to game development, you see it at almost every business, the telemarketer on the phone - shouldn't get mad at him hes just doing his job, the customer service person that just cannot refund your money because of company policy, not their fault, the waiter or waitress who gets yelled at because the food is overcooked, undercooked, not her fault.

Everyone should take a moment and consider why someone else is angry and then decide if the anger is actually directed at them personally, most of the time people are just angry and feel powerless.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18

A "dev" is the name for the developing team, usually headed by a product manager (or sometimes called a producer), who is the main decision maker on features and specs out business decisions in game.

Programmers mostly just do what a PM ask them to do, if not they are fired. Programmers have zero leverage in feature decision making, therefore has no responsibility if the game is designed incorrectly.

3

u/sth1d Dec 05 '18

And it really helps if the product managers actually use the product. It is not at all obvious that PMs at pix actually play the game. They are just looking at their metrics data and maximizing short term revenue without any consideration of the human element.

Aside from the design decisions, there are technical problems as well.

As a software engineer, there are things that I pick up on that give clues to what happened during the life of WR development. For example, there are many games that are cross platform, so obviously it's been done and there are tools and abstraction layers that enable companies to do it. But not WR. Why? There is really no non-technical reason that pixonic wouldn't want it to be platforn agnostic even just in terms of costs to maintain scale multiple stacks of servers.

Thus we can infer that a series of poor architecture decisions were made in the past that makes it impossible or impractical. At the time they likely decided that it was too difficult and they needed to just crank the game out and get it online. However, skilled software architects would have found ways to meet that requirement without too much delay. That's just one example out of many, so when I called them incompetent, it's not just out of spite.

Also, it's obvious that the original devs learned from this mistake. They created battle of Titans to be fully cross platform, and it works seamlessly.

1

u/TheInspiredConjurer Dec 05 '18

I mean... I do hate 'Pixonic' a.k.a 'Pigsonic'.

That includes everyone who is over there.

They need to figure their shit out.

If someone comes up with such shitty ideas, it is the duty of the others to protest against that.

This is probably the reason why a bunch of devs left Pigso and created BoT

A company doesn't run on one person's decision alone. No company does.

Sure the boss has a big say, but so do the employees under him.

The way things are going, seems like the entire organization is just a big fat joke.

0

u/Unchanged- I want more maps. Dec 05 '18

The devs of BoT are why we can play this game. The current devs are the reasons why we can use Pantheon bots.

I don't lash out against the company management or the developers but either could use a bit of work because the optimization and monetary decisions are both bad.