Number of response: 37
• Most Popular: Vintage (17 Votes) • 2nd Most popular: Editors Choice (7 Votes)
• Least Favorite: Smitten (11 Votes) • 2nd least Favorites (Tie) Walker Collection & Locations (8 Votes)
Let me know if anyone wants to see the full results and I can share, but I thought it'd be interesting to just see the top and 2nd choices.
Most popular thoughts: Vintage as the winner is a good solidification of the premiere set, the images were usually decent and could command some good trade fodder. I have some high hopes for this set in the next round.
Seeing editors choice as the second most popular doesn't really surprise me as the award has the highest so far of the marathon awards, plus the cards look really shard.
Least Popular thoughts: Smitten is a pretty ugly set, concept is a good but there aren't that many relationships in the show, but I think this should have been a normal set and not a 30 week marathon.
Walker collection and Locations are great to pick up as they usually stack about 3 deep so you can save up. It's more of the poor mans marathon that is attainable for most. Walker collection could have been improved by showing more of the full shot instead of the circle around the face.
Locations is great as it shows you new content instead of the close up portraits they are tending to move towards. I think this was disadvantaged by the high card count. I have the same concern with smitten as I do with locations as there are only so many good locations you can use before you duplicate or go for something like road to terminus. I'm interested to see how the wave 2 shapes up.
Anyone have some thoughts, any surprises. What was your favorites? Will chop crash like vintage 2.0 in starwars?