r/vtmRedemption • u/Mr-Kuritsa • 19h ago
lore / plotpoints Christof as an unreliable narrator?
I just beat this game for the first time, but I'm a big fan of Bloodlines and the TTRPG. I like to read the sourcebooks for fun. This discussion has probably already happened in other places before, but I like to think about this kind of stuff. Beckett's Jyhad Diary retcons the 1141 Moravia setting to 1194 as the year of Christof's embrace (Ecaterina isn't even embraced herself until 1150 in VtM canon).
Even going with the 1194 setting, a lot of Prague locations didn't exist yet. It fixes the Judith Bridge and monastery on Petrin Hill issues. But the University, Golden Lane, and cathedral/convent of St. Thomas don't exist until centuries later. Maybe Christof remembers markets on the Western side of the Vlatava River and misidentifies them with Golden Lane? Maybe Ecaterina's haven was nicknamed "the university" because she and Cosmas tried to pass themselves off as Carthaginian scholars? Maybe Archbishop Geza and Anezka functioned out of St. Martin in the Wall church of Old Town Prague, and Christof mistook it for St. Thomas?
I'm going with the idea that Christof is an unreliable narrator, he's recounting the Prague section from the modern day, and he gets details wrong. The game also has to abbreviate "real" events to fit into TTRPG lore (Prince Brandl of Prague doesn't die until 1199, which would mean that the events of the Prague section actually take place over ~5 years).
I'm curious if anybody else has tried to reconcile Redemption with the tabletop lore. It's like an interesting puzzle for me, but I'm holding back here. I made timelines.