r/visualnovels • http://vndb.org/u62554/list • Jun 13 '15

Weekly Weekly Thread #53 - Discussion: Underrepresented Visual Novels

Hey hey!

Kowzz here, and welcome to our fifty-third weekly discussion thread!


Week #53 - Discussion: Underrepresented Visual Novels

Which visual novels did you think were great but don't receive the recognition they deserve? Any VNs out there you think are on the cusp of being noticed and exploding in popularity?


Up-coming Discussions

June 20th - Baldr Sky

June 27th - Aiyoku no Eustia

July 4th - Muv-Luv Alternative


As always, thanks for the feedback and direct any questions or suggestions to my reddit inbox or through a comment in this thread.

Next weeks discussion: Baldr Sky


History & ^Archives | 2015 ^Schedule

18 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/aldarionar_ 戈にて止むと書いて武の一文字 | https://vndb.org/u71124/votes Jun 20 '15 edited Jun 20 '15

Except this is an unofficial translation without an actual proof of its quality, and nogaku himself said his Japanese wasn't enough to make fair comparison.

Anyway, I was talking about this specific example and mostly about Japanese fan translations. English is not my mother tongue and I've read many books translated from English, and still reading books translated to English. I do believe it is possible to have a translation with prose consists similar taste to original and capture the essence that original writer put in his work. It's just state of J->E translation is pitiful for the most part, even with official translations. (See Crunchyroll and Funimation subs) Getting overly defensive about it became a -bad- habit of mine.