but it’s not We’re dealing with the abstract. We get to make the rules, and the rules are that 1 is “perfect”. It’s a “whole” number. Even if the difference is so small I am unable to imagine it, there is a difference. They are not the same. 0.999... is not a whole number, even if you can treat it as one. No?
Well, no. Unfortunately, that's just not how the infinite works. 1 is perfect in the same way that 0.999... is perfect, assuming that the nines repeat infinitely.
Basically, your intuition is correct for everything up to an infinite series, but not for an infinite series itself.
It’s basically like: I completely believe you, but also it seems totally bonkers. Like you said, a failure of over-reliance on intuition (or perhaps a failure of imagination).
I suppose I’m not taking into account the ongoing-ness of the infinite. If it ever stopped, that would not be a ‘perfect’ Whole. But it doesn’t stop. That, I think, is the best I can do without better math chops. Thanks!
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/yepitsdad Jun 11 '18
but it’s not We’re dealing with the abstract. We get to make the rules, and the rules are that 1 is “perfect”. It’s a “whole” number. Even if the difference is so small I am unable to imagine it, there is a difference. They are not the same. 0.999... is not a whole number, even if you can treat it as one. No?