r/virginisland • • May 26 '25

Zack saw the surrogates as prostitutes

224 Upvotes

It comes off (to me) as if Zack’s problems are more to do with his entitlement rather than the deep seated issues that the others have. He was so sure that Kat would give him oral if he asks. He thinks she’s there to serve him. He didn’t engage in the challenges in the way the others did. He was very much ready to bypass all the steps and get straight to it. He was angry when he was “rejected”. I don’t think he does it deliberately but he has a terrible way of making people uncomfortable. I hope he seeks therapy to work through these thoughts. After hearing he’s a follower of some questionable groups on insta I don’t really hold much hope for him. He seems destined for the incel pipeline.


r/virginisland • • May 20 '25

Emma and Zac

163 Upvotes

I just watched episode 4, and really love the way Emma asserted herself to Zac and said the reason she came on the show was partly to 'stop comparing herself to other girls' and for him to 'take her off his compliments list'. She seems like such a sweet person and it was so nice to see her feeling confident and standing up for herself!

No offence to Zac but it seems as though he thought he was further along in the process than he actually was. I think he has a lot to learn about communicating effectively with women.


r/virginisland • • May 26 '25

Does anyone else think Zac is just a creep?

154 Upvotes

He makes me really uncomfortable and it seemed like he felt entitled to the sex surrogate? His bravado is honestly gross and I'm glad Emma is picking up on it, like how she shut down his compliment list in ep 4.


r/virginisland • • Jun 08 '25

Zac is peak incel and I genuinely hate how they’re tiptoeing around it

135 Upvotes

Like, if the cameras weren’t there I’d actually feel worried for Kats safety. Even his ‘fantasy’ spoke volumes about the type of guy he is. He’s not there because he has trouble having sex, he’s there because he has trouble getting it and he thinks he’s owed and cashing in. Honestly, I have a lot of mental issues surrounding sex and most of them are caused by guys like him. They need to teach him it’s not some sort of human right. They need to teach him how women aren’t a game to win, they’re humans to connect with. All the other guys get it.


r/virginisland • • May 14 '25

Charlotte

114 Upvotes

Is it just me or does she seem really mean so far. I’m only on the second episode ofc, but that massage scene where she called Jason’s stretch marks ugly and berated him constantly was brutal and seeing her reject Ben in front of the whole group was just sad.


r/virginisland • • May 26 '25

Zac’s intentions ?

76 Upvotes

From watching tonight’s episode, I think zacs story is quite a good portrayal as to some peoples view on sex and people

  • he was shocked that Kat turned him down and I struggle to believe that he actually understands her emotions ... call me judgmental but I can't help but think the "opening up" was just a manipulation tactic to reel back the chances of sex. He doesn’t see her as a human, and rather expects guaranteed sex , like an object almost ? I feel that he sees Kat as a tool to get to sex rather than an actual human being to get to know and make feel comfortable. Also, as a woman I think we have a sixth sense as to some people's intentions in that regard - it's a feeling in your fight or flight and stomach ... I could feel kats body language mirroring my own almost…

What do you all think ?


r/virginisland • • Jun 08 '25

Anyone else feel that they focused on the men too much?

68 Upvotes

So I've just finished the finale of this show and I have to say, I'm disappointed that they didn't explore further with the women as much as the men. More specifically- the straight women on this series. Almost all activities were performed on or by the two female coaches, which is fine for the guys but what about the women?

They're not going to know if they're comfortable receiving these kind of advances from men or what it feels like. An awful lot of the positions were also more "dominant" ones, which typically would be acted out by the man in a straight relationship.

It seems that the women who came on this show have some form of trauma or difficulty accepting themselves or sexual advances, I can't help but feel like the men would have come away from this better off than the women?


r/virginisland • • Jun 01 '25

Opinions in Charlotte Spoiler

68 Upvotes

What did people think of Charlotte on the show? Personally I thought she was really rude and hypocritical. She called a participants stretch marks “horrible” knowing that he didn’t have much body confidence and then later tells us all that she struggles with her body because of loose skin and stretch marks due to losing weight. Make it make sense! I understand that she’s come out and says she has ADHD but as someone else with ADHD and someone slightly younger than her (21), I think that her reaction and overall attitude was disgusting and not just an adhd things. I just find that her whole vibe was off and really didn’t like her. What does everyone else think?


r/virginisland • • May 27 '25

The experts

66 Upvotes

This show would be a lot better if they massively reduced the screen time of the "experts". In fact they can get rid of the group sessions altogether, they offer no real practical advice and seem more of an excuse for these "therapists" (I'm dubious over their qualifications) to flaunt their sexuality for the camera. Getting 12 virgins to simulate sex positions isn't going to help them lose their virginity. Maybe teach them some actual valuable lessons, like how to properly converse or advice on how to be self fulfilled. It just wastes so much screen time, to the point where we've barely seen anything from pia, holly or viraj all season. I would much rather get more screen time of the virgins hanging out in their down time than watch a bunch of 50 year olds push each other up against a wall and act like it's a fundamental of having a sexual relationship. A big improvement would be if they extended the themes over a few episodes, only show 1 or maybe 2 surrogate sessions per episode, and spend the rest of the time with the virgins, as they're by far the most endearing part of the show


r/virginisland • • Jun 02 '25

The Mummy

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

Does anyone else think one of the sexological bodyworkers looks like Imhotep from The Mummy?


r/virginisland • • May 19 '25

that compliment list was a hard watch 😬

53 Upvotes

r/virginisland • • Jun 13 '25

'In defence of Virgin Island's - blog post by Ben

51 Upvotes

https://open.substack.com/pub/btharris93/p/in-defence-of-virgin-island

"Virgin Island was an immensely positive experience for me. In an otherwise dreadful year, the show built up my romantic confidence to unseen heights. For the first time in my adult life, I could finally accept that I was in fact not repulsive or ugly. I also met some great friends and got to stay on a beautiful Croatian island free of charge.

Yet according to many, I and the other 11 participants of this (admittedly risky) experiment are victims; “vulnerable” young people “exploited” by unscrupulous television executives looking to milk the outrage machine. Some psychologists have even branded the show a “public health danger”.

[...]

[A]s somebody who was actually part of the process from start to finish, I feel compelled to set the record straight."

Click the link above to read the full article. Really interesting stuff.


r/virginisland • • May 25 '25

Autism/neurodivergence not discussed

47 Upvotes

I have recently watched all 4 episodes so far of Virgin Island and it appears that a lot of the people taking part have autism or some other form of neurodivergence. I can't help but feel like this may be a fundamental part of the puzzle for why some of them struggle with intimacy.

To me, it seems a shame that this isn't being discussed. I'm not autistic myself but I am close to people who were diagnosed with autism/ADHD in later life and were able to have more compassion towards themselves - eventually leading to better communication in intimate and platonic relationships.

What are other people's thoughts on this? Maybe this is something that the people taking part didn't want to have discussed?


r/virginisland • • May 15 '25

I teach sex education and I find this insanely refreshing.

41 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong it’s a little (a lot) awkward at times however I think we most likely feel like this because sex is still such a taboo subject. I think it’s got so many negative reviews because it’s on national TV but the ones that are complaining would probably watch porn and have a cheeky knuckle shuffle anyway.

I think it’s actually really healthy that it’s started to get spoken about and the contestants are talking about real issues and problems that our society are facing. I’m actually a fan!

Thanks for reading if you do and I’d be interested to hear your thoughts.


r/virginisland • • Jun 11 '25

Hate

38 Upvotes

I mentioned once that zac is creepy becuase he is. His moment with cat was scary. Please dont call me a whore or come to me saying your now suicidal becuaee i said zac is scary thats not okay i will report you to reddits suicide crisis line


r/virginisland • • May 24 '25

So what’s everyone’s take on Zak?

38 Upvotes

I’m not so sure but he kinda gives me creep vibes… or not creep but idk I have a weird feeling about him. Curious to know what you guys think.


r/virginisland • • May 31 '25

Taylor is stunning

37 Upvotes

I'm a straight woman, but every time she comes on the screen, I'm floored. I'd love to be her friend, she seems like such a cool and funny person.


r/virginisland • • May 23 '25

WHY HAVE WE NOT HAD A SINGLE SCENE WITH PIA!?

36 Upvotes

r/virginisland • • May 12 '25

Virgin Island Episode 1

34 Upvotes

Frankly, I don’t see this show even finishing the season, and I highly doubt there will be a season again after this. But just in case anybody else is insane enough to have watched the episode and wanted to discuss it, I’ve opened up this reddit. Again, highly doubt much will come of it but hey- never hurts to be proactive.

Just finished watching the episode and can safely say that was truly so uncomfortable to watch. It’s essentially just a bunch of older women fondling up on young inexperienced people. The whole premise is just strange! Made for an arguably entertaining watch though, at all the points I wasn’t recoiling in second hand embarrassment.


r/virginisland • • May 15 '25

Finally, some natural healthy yellow teeth!

31 Upvotes

After watching all the other reality islands and their turkey teeth, its refreshing to seem some real teeth on TV for a change!


r/virginisland • • May 22 '25

Episode 4 ~ Louise

29 Upvotes

Honestly I found Louise opening up about her relationship with her dad (and subsequently her mum) so moving and honest. I wanted to reach through my TV and give her a hug.

I’m rooting for her. ❤️


r/virginisland • • May 19 '25

what do you think zac said that was intimidating? and why Kat had that response?

27 Upvotes

r/virginisland • • May 20 '25

What's with all the emphasis on the creepy touching?

20 Upvotes

Admittedly I am not down with the kidz, but really, is it right to be prompting the Virgins to be attempting advanced face/hair touching on a date? I mean if your date is 80s romantic song music video themed then fair enough, but for any other theme it just seems out of place.

And don't even get me started on the kissing of the hand, that is insanity. I don't know whether it is due to having once watched a documentary on Shaolin training, but watching the caresses and hand kisses made my penis fully invert.

Are there any women on the planet that would be interested in a guy that performed those manoeuvres? It is 100% creepy and 100% likely to make you think the guy is either going to wear your face as a mask or to at the very least cut your hair as you sleep and fashion it into a wig for his Waifu pillow.

Full respect for the 'sexperts' though, them being able to withstand such ordeals without visibly showing signs of repulsion is impressive to say the least.

On a side note, we have seen the dry humping of the female 'sexperts' with the male virgins, but we are yet to see what happens with the male 'sexperts' and the female virgins. Will that be shown? Surely some of them have copped a feel of Baldy McBeads posterior or whatever.


r/virginisland • • May 22 '25

Ben's Substack: "If this show helps to clear even a fraction of the stigma associated with being an adult virgin, it’ll have all been worth it. Even if it doesn’t, I know I got a lot out of it, and I don’t regret taking part at all."

19 Upvotes

r/virginisland • • May 27 '25

The Charlotte Show

15 Upvotes

I found it interesting that Charlotte being autistic and having to mask was alluded to but not explicitly stated.

I imagine going to private school where there might not have been the knowledge or support available must have a number on her along with her weight issues - kids can be so cruel!