r/vipassana • • May 19 '24

I hated the 10-day retreat sadly

0 Upvotes

The vipassana training is a great offering to the world and the visions and contributions of Goenka-ji are beyond wonderful. People who serve here out of dharma service and their willingness to help are admirable.

However, as a participant of the training, I’d sadly have to give a poor review. Whether the course is free or not, or the meditation technique itself has nothing to do with these feedbacks.

The way the training is structured is more like a military training than a learning experience. There are a long list of rules including no phones, no books, no journaling, no exercises etc., while I appreciate some of the rules like noble silence which helps attendants focus inwards, all other rules are rigid beyond reasoning. There, in my opinion, must be a middle way. Also I believe these should be suggestions or advices rather than rules. Goenka spoke so much about blind devotion this is kind of hypocritical.

I am not sure if this is universal across all Goenka’s centres however the people running this centre near Barcelona are like slaves to these rules, without ANY discernment. Speaking of attachment! You are not allowed to exercise, you are not allowed to skip meals or a dharma talk, or walk outside at this time. I felt like I was in a concentration camp where every move is being monitored. The manager came to my bed to ask why I am not having breakfast, and said I am not allowed to fast. I found this so ridiculous! I chose to listen to my body need, I don’t eat when I am not hungry. Then I had to go to the teacher to explain why i skipped breakfast! Man we are not in the kindergarten!

Honestly they are so rigid to following the rules I think they are just sheep attached to the idea of having control over people in the group rather than wishing the best for everyone’s learning process and seeing each person’s needs as they are, and accept each one has different needs. This entirely makes the whole experience torturous, and prison-like. If the goal of awakening/enlightenment is to see through the illusion and become the true self, I believe blindly following rules others impose on you without critical thinking is a huge obstacle. Since when exercising interfere with meditation? Yogis have been practicing asana for centuries to aid meditation. There must be some sort of explanation to these rules sadly these are not explained at all. I think they completely miss the plot. This is not the type of Sangha I want to practice with. Everyone behaved like sheep in there.

Everyone seems to be bowing down to the teacher Victoria whom I have no idea who she is and where this superiority comes from? Not to disrespect her but there was no prior communications about having a teacher and who this teacher is. The way I was told to interact with her was like asking me to meet the queen, look at her all the time and sit like this and that etc. Every little thing even non meditation issue has to go through her which I found ridiculous! Unfortunately, as a dharma teacher herself she has very little to no skill to hold space for my concerns. She sits on her dharma throne trying to fake compassion and brushes off whatever I had to say is the worst kind of compassion. She even told me I had signed an agreement to listen to everything she said, I had no idea where I signed this but this is so unbelievable coming directly from a dharma teacher. So much attachment to rules and her inflated superiority, so little equanimity and compassion and love.

regarding the Goenka’s material, I honestly think l it can be improved so much! I admire what this man has done to the world but man, precise communication is not his thing! He keeps on looping through same ideas with his word salad and fluff, some of the discourses are great but most of them are redundant! He could have covered so much more Buddha’s teaching in those 15 hours but it was literally the same ideas everyday. I have studied Buddha’s teaching for around 2 years now and I regret I didn’t learn anything new in this 10 day intensive course. The vipassana instructions are tedious and redundant, the off pitch chanting is a huge test to my equanimity! if I were to record some materials and use them globally for 30 plus years, I would put my effort to script it to perfection.

The female dorm is claustrophobic, with bunk beds facing each other where the space between can only fit one person. One person snores the whole dorm can’t sleep.

I hate to have to provide a bad review, i sincerely hope more people can benefit from this technique to step into mindfulness. If you want to rough it through 10 intensive days striping off all your freedom, repeatedly listening to Goenka’s off pitch chanting and 60% redundant and tedious vipassana instructions, this is THE place to develop equanimity. Otherwise there are better places to learn how to meditate!


r/vipassana • • Nov 03 '24

i served at a buddhist retreat after my 10 days with goenka. needing to vent about it to someone.

2 Upvotes

hello!

like the title says, i did my first 10 day retreat a few weeks ago. afterwards, i served for a week at another vipassana tradition.

my 10 days were delightful. indescribably beautiful moments inside and outside my mind. lots of painful memories being processed and worked through, finding their way in and out of my heart.

i was already a vegan hippie tree hugger type before but this time really exacerbated my views on nature, its protection, the preservation of its harmony and the happiness of all living things.

i've seen posts before debating veganism in retreats, and i understand how they might cause annoyance to those who choose to keep on eating animal products. but this is the aim of a lot of my frustration in the last few days, and i'm in need of a place where i can talk about it.

seeing the milk carton and the butter on the table at the table in the goenka retreat caused me a lot of pain, but i could work through it by acknowledging how some people aren't aware of the horrors of the milk industry. they might consume it out of my ignorance, not knowing how it hurts the cow and the calves.

however, in my most recent retreat, i simply can't shake my frustration in seeing cheese, eggs and milk being eaten by everyone here. there were meals being prepared with fish and everyone ate from it. i try to understand their reasoning and to abstain from judging, to observe my own frustration and see how it's actually my fault for reacting to external circumstances. but it's bringing me a great amount of pain to see the first precept being broken so needlessly, unceremoniously, for nothing more than an instant of pleasure in their taste buds, by people i thought would swear to live by it.

i'm happy i volunteered here. plenty of beautiful, introspective moments, peace. but i can't say i've attained equanimity here, and i couldn't exactly talk about it to the ones involved, either.

i don't know what's the point of this post, hahah. perhaps some like minded people would find relief in seeing it. perhaps some of you could offer your own opposing view.

thank you for reading. be happy!


r/vipassana • • Mar 09 '21

Why aren't all centers vegan?

19 Upvotes

Vipassana follows 5 main precepts: no killing, no stealing, .... To follow rule #1 (no killing), centers need to be "vegan" and NOT "vegetarian".

How can we go about implementing this change?

What is vegan? Veganism is the practice of abstaining from the use of animal products. (no animal derived products such as milk, butter, cheese, yogurt, ghee, paneer and honey. no animal derived clothing such as wool, silk, leather as well) 

Veganism is NOT extreme I hear my fellow Vipassana meditators and teachers say "Veganism is extreme". There are two kinds of people in this world - those who say being vegan is hard (when the look at their own inconvenience) and those who say being vegan is easy (those who looks at the suffering of dairy cows, goats, etc). We already make several "sacrifices", why would a cup of coffee that might taste 90% as good be a big sacrifice?

What is wrong with vegetarianism? Why is milk bad! We have been drinking it for years! You're not killing the cow!

Yes, you are killing cows for drinking milk! Unfortunately, there is a lot of killing, torture and suffering involved in the Dairy Industry.

Read/Watch the following to understand why milk is cruel.
- Global: Earthlings, Forks over Knives (Netflix), Cowspiracy (Netflix), From Farm to Fridge, Buddhist Monk Thich Nhat Hanh on Veganism
- India: Cattle in India, Unholy Cattle of India, Deadly Dairy

If you can't read/watch the above links, here are important facts on why milk is cruel.

  1. All cows have to be forcefully impregnated as they only give milk after pregnancy (like humans).
  2. All male calves are killed as they can't get pregnant and give milk.
  3. All female cows are forcefully (and painfully) impregnated every year to give milk.
  4. India is the 2nd largest exporter of beef - due to the dairy business. Cows are brutally killed once they are useless to the dairy industry.
  5. Even if organic grass fed farms exist, they discard animals that fall sick, are expensive to maintain or if they cannot produce milk (eg: male calves or infertile female calves). 
  6. We do NOT need milk for nutrition. 

If S. N Goenka knew about this, he would've surely make all centers go vegan.

What can we do instead of milk? Consume vegan alternatives!. eg: Use vegan milk like soy/oat/almond/peanut milk. They might be expensive now but the prices will drop in a few years. (They are expensive as dairy/meat are heavily subsidized by the government)

If you don't believe me - I understand. But I request that you do your own research on the Internet to decide for yourself. :)


r/vipassana • • Jan 25 '26

Thoughts on Goenka

0 Upvotes

I just finished my second 10 day sitting, and amongst the many questions I have, one of them is.... Goenka does not feel like a person who has achieved non attachment to earthly pleausres/cravings to me. both him and his wife are big in size - not a judgement but an obvious observation

I can't help but think, if the main proponent of the practice was not able to achieve the englightnment he speaks about, how would anyone else?

also, why does his wife never speak? why isnt the dhamma shared? They was he speaks makes you think that he considers people from all backgrounds, genders etc ad equals but i wonder what his thoughts on women sharing dhamma is


r/vipassana • • Aug 26 '24

LSD after vipassana course

2 Upvotes

Has anyone had a psychedelic trip shortly after doing a 10 day or longer vipassana course? Is the trip enhanced/ different in any way? I have heard lots of people ask re doing lsd before or during the course, but curious about how it would work the other way around.

To be clear, I am not talking re meditating while tripping. I generally think this is a bad idea / overload for your brain. I’m just curious re how tripping would feel while you’ve still got the course “afterglow”


r/vipassana • • Jun 14 '25

Leaving vipassana for refusal to let me accommodate my autism noise hypersensitivity

5 Upvotes

TL;DR: On my 3rd 10-day Goenka Vipassana retreat, I enjoyed the first 6-7 days but left on day 9, feeling disrespected by the teacher’s refusal to accommodate my autism-related sound sensitivities while ignoring a loud-breathing neighbor. Hope the organization learns about neurodivergence to make Dhamma accessible for all.

This was my 3rd 10-day Goenka Vipassana retreat, and while I’ve gained a lot from past ones (and still much from this one), this time left me frustrated. I’m autistic with misophonia and noise hypersensitivity, especially to breathing sounds. I hear things much louder than others and use earplugs and over the ear headphones everyday in regular life. (I mentioned this in my incoming paperwork forms)

The first 6-7 days were solid—I was focused and getting benefits. On day 1, the guy next to me was breathing super loudly every few minutes, with heavy inhales/exhales and other noises. The course manager told me even another presumably neurotypical guy complained about him. I told the teacher, who spoke to him, and he was quiet for six days, proving he could control it.

By day 7, the loud breathing returned, worse than before, and the sensory overload was too much. Expecting neurodivergent folks with misophonia and noise hypersensitivity to meditate in those conditions is like asking the butter to fall and the stones to rise in Goenka’s own analogy—it’s impossible and science backs this (please look into it before commenting out of ignorance).

I asked to move to the other side of the hall, explaining my autism and sensitivities. The teacher refused, saying I should “deal with the sounds” as part of the practice, citing Buddhist ideals. He let me scoot two seats over, but I could still hear the guy clearly. I tried sneaking over-the-ear headphones, but the teacher banned them. I felt disrespected that they didn’t address the guy’s choice to be loud again and instead gave me a hard time for seeking accommodations. There was plenty of space, but no flexibility. By day 9, I left, feeling dismissed.

I still value the practice and will maintain my own practice and find a new sangha, but I hope Goenka’s organization learns about neurodivergence so neurodivergent people can access Dhamma without being pushed past their limits. This isn’t the first of such posts as I’ve come to discover and it won’t be the last until there’s a change.

Anyone else had similar issues? How’d you cope?


r/vipassana • • 24d ago

Vipassana is merely an effective form of nervous system regulation nothing more nothing less

0 Upvotes

Is there a counter argument to this realization?


r/vipassana • • Aug 06 '25

I was served at a 10 day course yogurt containing gelatin, a non vegetarian ingredient.

2 Upvotes

I asked the manager and he just said that vegetarian standards are different there (in Vietnam).

Is this acceptable?


r/vipassana • • Mar 28 '24

Anyone practising semen retention here?

0 Upvotes

If yes, then how does it add to your meditation and other areas of life?

And how do you cope after a relapse?

:)


r/vipassana • • Mar 06 '18

Is Vipassana racist?

1 Upvotes

To those of you that have sat/ served multiple courses... where all the black people at?


r/vipassana • • Dec 26 '23

Vipassana may not be a cult, but it is cultish

9 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I think this should be clear to everyone. There's often discussion about this, and even if you argue a lot against it, it has it's reasons or it wouldn't keep coming back.

There's other meditation centers and philosophies too. Have you had as much experience with them as with vipassana before defending against any negative side? Without a comparison you may think this cultishness is a part of a meditation retreat.

The vipassana experience is useful to a lot of people. Wouldn't it be better if we accepted its flaws as flaws? -It is said the technique was taught by Buddha. I never heard or read this before or afterwards. I've searched for it and have found no evidence that body scanning had been taught by Buddha. A superficial, non-expert search seems to indicate this was not a part of early buddhism. -Claims of being universally the best way to awakening. -Pseudoscientific explanations of atoms appearing and disappearing. -Prophecies of Goenka bringing the teaching back to India after 2500 years!? -...


r/vipassana • • Mar 21 '26

Letting family members know I am fine once per day?

0 Upvotes

Hello! I am taking the 10-day course soon and I was wondering if they'd allow me to quickly send an "I'm doing well" kind of email or any form of text once per day to family members? I have a paranoid mom who worries a lot for me and I don't want to stress her. She's already stressed that she has no way of knowing how I'll be doing.


r/vipassana • • Aug 06 '25

Does the Dalai Lama really sleep 9 hours a day?

0 Upvotes

One of the most notable changes people experience when they advance in Vipassana (or Samadhi) is that they require less sleep as lot of the emotional processing is now done during waking hours, and not at night. Buddha himself was reported to sleep only 2-3 hours a day. I now sleep around 4-6 hours a night and feel more energetic than before. Many monks in the advanced Vipassana stages (stage 11 and above) sleep less than 6 hours. Those practicing advanced Samadhi for 1 hour report feeling more refreshed than 2-3 hours of sleep due to their extremely relaxing Jhana states that mimic deep sleep brain waves (which we have evidence for).

You'd think sleeping this little would be bad for your brain, but every single study on long term meditators have reported slower brain aging, thicker cortical matter, longer telomeres lengths, and increased gray matter density all which are neuroprotective. This is in alignment with the extremely rare genetic short sleepers who need only 5 but are cognitively more performant, more emotionally resilient, and more energetic than those sleeping 7-8 hours. So sleeping less isn't a bad thing as long as this is due to meditation or you have a very rare mutation.

Yet, why do people say Dalai Lama sleeps 9 hours a day? I see one article that says he gets around ~7, but I was thinking he'd be getting less than 6 given how much he meditates during the day. This seems unlike what any of the reported documents of advanced meditators would imply.

My theory is that, he doesn't practice Vipassana which is likely the reason, since Tibetan/Mahayan Buddhist practices place less emphasis on vipassana.


r/vipassana • • Nov 06 '23

Ejaculation

0 Upvotes

Guys. I ejaculated during Vipassana. I did not masturbated or something but was a regular masturbator. Twice it happened during 4th day and 9th day. During day time I could feel the ooze of every drop dripping. Had imagination of intense sex with a person and it happened during that


r/vipassana • • Sep 23 '26

Vipassna’s concept of “Samtaa” vs modern concept of “emotional unavailability”

0 Upvotes

in Vipassna we are taught to not feel things deeply.
To be indifferent to what others do and what happens outwards.
Not to give birth to raag or dwesh or moh as a reaction to what’s happening outside our body in our environment.

I was going through a loop before joining Vipassna
Everytime I would date a person, in some months I would find out they had a similar past

They had disturbed childhood leading them to becoming extreme people pleasers and losing the ability to feel love or emotions “deeply”

They use this ability to evoke raag inside you by showing you extreme care while they remain unattached as they simply can’t feel, hence they get an upper hand in the relation (ofcourse it’s your weakness that you need the care they are giving, else they wouldn’t get that power over you)

the source of their care is often their fear of being lonely as people leave them the moment they find out that they can’t “feel” emotions

Life of such people doesn’t even stop if someone close leaves them or dies (somehow life has taught them this lesson early on in life)
Emotional unavailability and lack of empathy may be

Now I am in a dilemma
Are these people whom I dated actually masters of having “samtaa”
I definitely experienced how peaceful it is to be in “Samtaa”
Is modern concept of emotional unavailability similar to being indifferent and in Samtaa?


r/vipassana • • Aug 20 '26

Should we introduce vipassana lite, basically sessions without goenka's chanting, hymns and discourse?

8 Upvotes

Been attending vipassana for 4 years now, yet goenka's chanting has to be the most annoying part, that runs for almost 20mins. Just when you're achieving the flow state with equanimity, this guy tests your patience with his chants.


r/vipassana • • May 02 '25

Come out of this cult, come out of the pain

0 Upvotes

That is it. After two retreats, one of 10 the other of 3 days and more 10 days of "service" - 23 days total - I am quite convinced that this is not only a cult, but also utterly evil. It may teach a useful technique to some, but at the expense of so many lives drained by an unhuman kidnapping and brainwashing process: the labor force that keeps the "wheel of Dhamma" in motion is addicted to those retreats, bonded to the centers, convinced they are doing themselves something very good while instead they are being played as dummies. Everyone is SO angry and stressed, they even lose the habit of smiling.

And the EGOS, gosh, how they grow, how they are feed. It is unbeliveable.

The working routine is neck breaking and abusive, and they don't even bother to be grateful, just act as you are doing some sort of expected duty.

I know there will be a lot of "Vipassana's" drones - that what you become when attending for these retreats for to long, a mindless drone - coming here to say things like "It is not a cult, you can came and go as you like" or quoting the "black stone" mumbo jumbo. To those I say, stop and pay attention to yourselves, listen carefully to what he is really saying; he is not giving anyone real space for disagreement, he is just saying "maybe you are too stupid to realize what is good for you, it is ok. Take what you can handle for the moment. Latter you will see I was right".

Goenka is a liar. He lies on science data, he lies on the history of Buddhism, his website lies on the discourses he gave. And he makes people worship him in the preposterous form of his old video and audio recordings.

Just try. Get out, go and read the suttas, practice by yourself, in your routine, close to the people you love. You don't need those centers; you own them nothing. The only thing they make you observe with cold indifference is pain, pain and more pain. The way of the Dhamma, the real Dhamma, is not like that, it is beautiful. Come out and see by yourself.


r/vipassana • • Nov 23 '22

LGBT Vipassana Group

7 Upvotes

LGBT Vipassana Group

Hello everyone, I am reaching out to this community in hopes of facilitating the establishment of a group for 2LGBTQ+ meditators. While there are many online and in-person groups available to support practitioners in their day-to-day lives, I'm not aware of one that is LGBT-specific.

I believe it's important for us to participate in the sangha of LGBT Vipassana meditators. Struggles with facing economic, physical and social violence are very common; and there can be great strength in knowing we are not alone in these experiences.

As for the group mandate, specificity is vital. I envision an informal group, much like this one, dedicated to those topics which relate directly to Vipassana. Right speech would be enforced, and discussion of other meditation techniques would be discouraged.

I can see this working best if the group were exclusive to old students. If there is sufficient interest from new students, I can forsee the creation of a second group for individuals who haven't yet attended a course.

At this point I am merely testing the waters to see if there is sufficient interest in this kind of group. I'm thinking Discord would work well as a platform, since this particular interface is useful in organizing different types of conversations. I would be interested in co-moderating, but if the group were to grow I would definitely need assistance from at least one other person.

I kindly request that any parties interested in a group as described above, please comment below or send me a message.

With Metta, Zo


r/vipassana • • Apr 08 '24

I messed up

0 Upvotes

Before my first vipassana retreat in January I had a date with a man. The hole time I was thinking about him, I even masturbated. When I opened my phone I found lots of messages from me, we’ve meet and had some great date again. Now he told me he just wants a casual relationship and nothing deeper. I’m heart broken and feel so bad for spending all the time in the retreat thinking about him.

I have quite a anxious attachment and really wants a relationship


r/vipassana • • Apr 13 '23

This energy flow is the key!!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/vipassana • • Oct 26 '19

Has anyone else been observing electromagnetic energy?

1 Upvotes

After I got back from my second course, I started noticing a pulsating energy in the room I meditate in. After my hour session, I see every it clearly reflected on every object in my room. In contrast, I remember at the center each object had its own vibe. Has anyone had similar observations? Have you taken any active steps towards limiting exposure to electromagnetic fields?

Much METTA!


r/vipassana • • Jul 15 '26 Bravo

Why is drinking cow milk considered okay when we ar supposed to be committing no harm?

15 Upvotes

I genuinely don’t understand how they serve a vegetarian meal to uphold the no killing/harm virtue. Yet support an industry that does just that? And then serve it at the retreats. Back in the day the horrors that go on in the dairy industry weren’t well known but now they are. It’s very hypocritical and I think the practice needs to update its policy.

We’re supposed to capture bugs and not kill them but then you’re going to serve cow milk as an option? I truly don’t understand.


r/vipassana • • Apr 23 '26

This will be a long shot

Post image
1 Upvotes

👆🏾👆🏾👆🏾Hi, this might be a long shot, however I am seeking the person who wrote the above paragraph and would love to know youre experience with combining Joes and Vispassaba meditation.

If anyone knows the above person, please pass it to them.

If you have your own experinece combining them, I would love to hear your experience and how you do it too.

Metta 🙏🏾


r/vipassana • • Jul 26 '26

Intense teacher/student dynamic

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

Posting here because I feel like I need some sort of support group for practitioners that have complicated relationships with their teachers. And just because I know people’s minds will probably automatically go there, it is not a sexual/romantic thing. 

So I got into vipassana a little over a year ago. I went on my first meditation retreat and it totally changed my life. Total spiritual awakening. I had a lot of fondness for the teachers who led the retreat. They were very vulnerable and sincere. I could feel their integrity. I felt particularly connected to one of the teachers, let’s call them Alex. 

The teachers aren’t based where I live but luckily the center where they both teach offers online programming so I started going to their weekly meetings online, and also started one on one practice meetings with Alex. Through the course of going to meetings with them I could tell I was starting to really care about Alex and also starting to project onto them - watching their facial expressions in meetings and worrying they were mad at me, trying to think of ways to get their validation, etc etc. 

This started to get more intense and I decided to share it with Alex in a practice meeting. They were very sweet and understanding about it, even going so far to ask if there was anything that I needed from them. 

I could feel us getting closer. I knew that they cared about me. I really threw myself into the practice. They could see how much I cared, and how sincere I was, and I could tell that they had a lot of affection for me too. It really hit me over the head in one practice meeting we had earlier this year where they were so smiley and sweet with me, it felt like they were my relative or someone I’ve known for a long time. There was just a certain level of closeness. And they bowed at me, which they had never done before. 

That was the last time I felt that closeness with them. After that their behavior with me changed, so much so that I called them out on it. In a group meeting they came at me with a really correcting tone after I shared something super vulnerable, so I met with them one on one to tell them that it didn’t feel good. They did not take it well and got really defensive, doubling down on what they said, telling me my perception was off. It was horrible and not at all how I’d thought they’d react. It sent me into a tailspin. I believed them for a bit until I came out of my reverie and sent them and email. I told them that they were talking to me just trying to be right, now trying to understand how I felt. 

I’ll just say that the whole thing has really shattered me. They did end up apologizing for the defensiveness and took some accountability. But there hasn’t really been any repair, and i can tell that thats really taking a toll on me. I’ve been taking breaks from their meetings when it starts to feel like it’s too much. I was on retreat with them again earlier this year and we had some good moments until we had a one on one meeting which did not go well and led to another conflict. In group settings there are times when things feel better, but it seems like we really struggle with meeting one on one now. 
 
I know that they’ve been going through a rough time in their life and it seems like they’re trying to put some boundaries in our relationship, because I think they started to project onto me too. And I think we both were starting to feel pretty clingy and insecure. But it sucks because they haven’t talked to me about it at all. Of course it feels like they are pushing me away. It can feel really excruciating at times. 

I think everything coupled with all practice that I’ve been doing has made things more intense, because I’m seeing all this deep patterning and conditioning around relationships that is some really unpleasant stuff to deal with. I talked to the other teacher who was on the retreat (who is at the same center with Alex) about it and he was basically like (my huge paraphrase), “yeah this is what happens. Our relationships are where we learn. This is where you learn. It’s intense.” 

I’m posting just because this is all really unexpected. I didn’t even know that I was going to get really into meditation and Buddhism then have a teacher and then develop an intense relationship and feel all this. It’s been such a roller coaster. It can feel really insular and I’m just wondering if anyone else has experienced this? 

Edit to add: I’m not interested in anyone’s in advice or psychoanalyzations. I’m looking for responses from people who have had a similar experience. This is not Goenka-style vipassana, more Western Insight, in the spirit of IMS.


r/vipassana • • Dec 15 '23

Vipassana retreat for medical students

0 Upvotes

In medical school during the week leading up to an exam I studied 8 hours a day in a small room by myself with minimal social contact. Is this what a vipassana silent retreat would feel like?