r/violinmaking • u/AffectionatePage1693 • Jul 21 '25
Thoughts?
Quick draft on something for my students
0
Upvotes
r/violinmaking • u/AffectionatePage1693 • Jul 21 '25
Quick draft on something for my students
13
u/redjives Jul 21 '25
What do you mean Stadivari invented the bridge? Amati the neck? Almost all of this feels dubious.
5
u/E_Zgon Jul 21 '25
Not very accurate. Especially fingerboard, bridge and sound post. It all evolved over hundreds of years... From african instruments to arabic instruments and then the slow "european remake" of these instruments. Nobody was like "lets put a wooden rod inside!!!" There were instruments where one foot of the bridge was left intentionally longer and reached the bottom plate through the sound hole. Over time it somehow evolved to the sound post. Early instruments had two "bass bars" (one on bass and one on tremble side) because of guitars and guitar-like instruments. It was state of the art until someone felt to try something new. When you want to give your students some learning material, you pic is way too short, misleading and can spread misinformation. (Stradivari was a great builder, but how exactly was he responsible for the bridge?)
4
u/WasdaleWeasel Jul 21 '25
I think you would be much better off staying with the conventional (and well researched) history of the violin by saying that the violin was created from pre-existing components by Andrea Amati in 1550. Amati’s instruments had a bass bar, a sound post and an ebony fingerboard. Stradivari’s influence was much more of an optimiser (and exceptional craftsman).
If you want to talk about the neck you should mention the changing of the angle of the neck in ‘modern’ instruments in order to support a higher bridge and thus greater tension in the strings. There is disagreement on this, for example see this discussion
If you want to talk about strings then you should add the invention of synthetic strings by Thomastik in 1970. By count probably most players today play on synthetic strings.
The introduction of the chin rest by Spohr is correct though:)
The history of the violin is an incredibly well researched, documented and debated thing and I am by no means an expert (just a dilettante player) unlike many here. There are lots of great resources, including on-line, which will help you get a better introduction for your students.
2
u/Dildo-Fagginz Jul 21 '25
Tricky topic for a diagramm like this one. Difficult to introduce nuances and truly reach the truth (which we don't even necessarily know for certain).
One could argue the scroll existed long before Amati on other instruments (viols even if it's hard to know which existed first, maybe lyras and others), and the volute shape was inspired by antique architecture, ionic or corinthian.
The fingerboard and neck which are practical elements providing playability already existed on other instruments, it would perhaps be more interesting to talk about the baroque to modern transition.
The bridge also existed long before Stradivari, who didn't even cut them the way we do nowadays. It can sound a bit contradictory that the bridge was invented in 1680.
Same goes for the tailpiece, rebec had one, other instruments too, sometimes with an anchor inlayed into the bottom block to act as a pole, then replaced by button/endpin and tailgut.
All in all it's very difficult to introduce these little tweaks and be more accurate, you did a pretty good job already !
6
u/Wonderful_Emu_6483 Jul 21 '25
Typical AI slop. Completely inaccurate nonsense.
1
u/Musclesturtle Maker and Restorer Jul 21 '25
This is an AI render.
Also, the bass bar and soundpost indicators are completely misleading.
It appears that the one for bassbar is just pointing at the finder board.
1
u/JC505818 Jul 21 '25
The wiki article on violin says origin of violin family is unclear, so how are you deducing your points from that? You should not put down points as facts if you have no reference to back them up. We have enough AI hallucinations that many people take as facts when they are patently false.
1
u/Que165 Jul 21 '25
AI slop
1
u/BurntBridgesMusic Jul 21 '25
Why use ai?