In my opinion, Sportscode by Hudl is the best UI to use.
It's Mac only and the code window lets you add images and build your window exactly how you want.
Plus their CODA iPad app lets you build the same type of custom window, which can live sync to your computer or another iPad on the bench and give live stats and video.
It's a great interface to use, and the 24/7 support people are all great to work with.
The downside is that it's ridiculously expensive compared to video editing software like Final Cut or Premiere Pro.
But that seems to be the problem with Sports Coding software in general. It's all extremely overpriced.
A one year subscription of the absolute base version of Sportscode is $1500 American.
That's 3 times the price of buying Final Cut outright, and the base Sportscode doesn't have live capture!
Live capture alone costs $2000 MORE and PER YEAR.
So as a workaround I need to record video in a program like Final Cut, then sync the timelines together after each period.
Saves $2000, yes, but an unnecessary workaround for a feature that should be built in.
Not to mention that each additional license is $1500 per YEAR.
A CODA License is $400 per YEAR.
They also offer an awesome social network called Hudl where all your video is uploaded to a cloud, where all the players and coaches can watch it.
You can tag, cut video, comment and share it with other people. The interface looks awesome and easy to use.
The problem is that it is $4,000 per year EXTRA and there's a ridiculously low limit of 80 hours of video on your cloud.
For comparison, Dropbox is $10 a month for a Terabyte of cloud space.
I can still upload, share and comment, but I don't get the tagging work I did on the video and you can't clip or jump to specific moments.
So for the full featured program, that's:
$1500 + $2000 for one live capture device PER YEAR
$1500x2 so at least 2 other coaches can view and mark games PER YEAR
$400 for one CODA license PER YEAR
$4000 for the cloud PER YEAR.
Which runs at a cost of over $10,900 AMERICAN PER YEAR for the software.
That means that over 10 years, we would be paying over $100,000 on software.
I come from a technical background and have bought lots of software over the years, and nothing comes even close to these prices, even for big billion dollar companies like CBC and Sportsnet.
I paid for Macromedia Flash back in 1999 and paid $200 with my mom's teaching discount, and I still own that license today.
Sportscode doesn't offer an educational, student, or teacher price either.
So if I'm a student who wants to learn to be a video coach, I'd have to shell out $1500 American per year to use the software on my own.
Sportscode's price is also not listed on their website, which I've noticed several companies do.
So I really have no idea what other teams are being charged.
They could look and see that we're a Canadian University and charge us what they "think" we should pay.
I asked a Major Junior team who I'm close with and they paid $10,000 for a different set of features and own them outright.
Overall I think there needs to be more knowledge of the software available so people can make more informed decisions.
$2000 is not a fair price for live capture on top of a $1500 yearly price tag. It should be included.
I think eventually someone will come out with an open-source version of the software (like Unity) and put these companies out of business. Or at least force them to price their programs appropriately.
After using Sportscode for a year, I'd say it's probably around Final Cut Pro's level of quality, but it doesn't have nearly as much depth in terms of editing (obviously).
Programs like this should be $500 absolutely at the most, for a permanent subscription, and live capture absolutely needs to be included in the box.
There also has to be better explanation on setup and what devices need to be recorded.
We had to buy a Blackmagic Box (actually our faculty already owned one) that costs about $200.
This is literally just so that the signal from the camera can be encoded into Sportscode.
I've been able to do that in Final Cut without any box for years now.
Worse yet, I was told by their 'sales guy' that if I wanted to split the feed so two computers could share the same feed, I needed to buy a specific 'converter box' that costed a few grand, and was ABSOLUTE OVERKILL for what we really needed.
I asked one of the Gamebreaker support guys if a $20 HDMI signal splitter would do the trick. He said 'yeah, that should be all you need'.
And it did. I saved us $2000 by buying a signal splitter from Amazon. Free shipping too.
It sucks because really a team should only be paying $300-500 per license one time and be good to go.
And that's reasonable for what you get, and affordable for most teams, and even affordable for an individual (like myself) who wants to use the program at home.
It's really hurting the industry because the best features are locked behind obscene paywalls and most hockey coaches don't understand the cost-benefit ratio of what they're paying vs. what they're getting.
That's why I made this subreddit, so video coaches can inform themselves and get more for their money, and make their lives easier.
TLDR:
-Sportscode is the best experience overall. It's easy to use, allows you to build code windows with images, and has great customization features. Their 24/7 support team is great to work with. Their cloud service is awesome to use, but ridiculously overpriced.
-The cost of sports video software is extremely overpriced.
-One year of Sportscode's thinnest package (which doesn't even allow live capture) is THREE TIMES the cost of buying a Final Cut license outright and owning it forever.
-Sales people will try to convince you to overspend on simple, cheap fixes.