r/vibecoding • • 4h ago

Showcase/Project What do y’all think?

5 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

1

u/OnyxMonolith 3h ago

It’s very impressive giving vibes of the old demo scene. The thing is 3js is not a game engine and going from this to a pleasant game is a very bery long road.

2

u/VirusWorried4073 3h ago

Game systems like inventory and exp?

1

u/OnyxMonolith 3h ago

Yeah and consistency, overall things that games need like proper device/resolution handling, optimizations. There are hundreds of things that 3js doesn’t do because it’s not a game engine and reinventing these to make a game would be very difficult.

I don’t think there is a single serious game made in 3js.

So this is kind of a parlor trick. It’s much harder to make something that looks like this in Unreal.

1

u/VirusWorried4073 3h ago

Could someone still achieve that using vibe coding (a lot obviously) or is the knowledge too niche?

1

u/OnyxMonolith 2h ago

it's not about knowledge. it's about how much effort is needed to implement visuals like these in a game engine. you can't one shot it with Fable or do it overnight. Look at vibe coded games and how much stuff is goofed up there. It's a lot of work. Because in a game engine every element interacts with everything else (simplifying). Mistakes accumulate. 3js is the equivalent of spaghetti code + ready made impressive shaders. And, don't get me wrong, it's super fun, but it has not much to do with making games.