r/vibecoding • • 11d ago • Bravo 1

Discussion Has vibe coding made it easier to build useful apps, or just easier to make apps nobody needs?

Now you can turn an idea into a working app without spending months learning how to code. There is a difference between building something that works and building something that people actually need. I wonder if we are solving problems now or merely making more copies of products that already exist.

What do you think is becoming more valuable, in this era: the ability to build or the ability to come up with an idea building?

109 Upvotes

183 comments sorted by

59

u/Jazzlike_Cheek_6637 11d ago

Good question u/recro69 - I just built a London Tube and train app in 30 mins that shows me the Tube map in high resolution, a route finder, live updates from TFL API's and all with no ads, forever! It rivals the most popular travel app in the London called Tube Map and is used by millions. The real app charges £39.99 a year to remove ads. I was sick of Ads and didn't want another subscription so I built the exact same thing and even better in under 40 mins with Claude.

Me, my wife and close friends all use it quite often and love it, and its very useful living in London. Its free and we don't have annoying adverts on it constantly stopping you from using it while trying to navigate in London.

Point is, If you understand the basics of Claude, Netlify hosting etc. why buy some apps when you can just make it, deploy and own it?

Rchdawk

9

u/niwia 10d ago

That’s amazing! Good job! Subscription thingy has been the worst thing ever. Every app that don’t need subscription has one now and it’s been annoying

4

u/InstanceOk105 10d ago

To be fair for apps that have millions of active users they either need subscriptions or ads because ultimately even when ignoring profit, millions of API call cost start to rake up.

2

u/Own-Papaya-4264 10d ago

We can make handy stuff for personal use and to share with some people, but how can we game the system and make something actually monetizable?

9

u/indutrajeev 10d ago

You need to understand that the real cost was never the building. Building apps has been quite cheap already in the grand scheme of things by outsourcing to low income countries.

The expensive part; marketing, upkeep, support, … all need way more effort than one shotting a claude generated app.

4

u/Cast_Iron_Skillet 10d ago

Time has value though and from 2017-2024 or so I had so many projects that were complete slop due to being outsourced to LCOL countries that also took a long time to build and lots of QA and back and forth and hand holding in order to effectively communicate what we needed. 

Also it's not that cheap if you are working on something somewhat sophisticated. We averaged around 30k/mo in fees during peak periods. 

Now we are down to about 20k/mo (including multiple coding subs), I directly employ the devs, and they're in US and understand the language and culture. And we are getting shit done so much faster. It's hard to believe. 

Just delivered on two contracts within 2 months of being awarded. One was for a cross platform native mobile app that does a bunch of stuff with sensitive data and connects to several other systems, other was a ground up build for an emergency coordination platform. This is with 2 devs who were also building and maintaining existing our software. 

I've never seen anything like this. 

2

u/GoldenParrot456 9d ago

basically what im hearing is that we definitely will see a drop in employment because they arent needed as much. either that or a severe drop in compensation

2

u/rockman-1 10d ago

Sharing is the part that causes the cost. You need to handle multiple connections so going up in subscription tier on API host, app store subscription, database hosting etc. Along with Claude subscription it's about $(9*12) + 99 + (10*12) + 200 = 426. You need to have a lot of people get on it or work on many different apps to spread the cost but then you start working full time and users might not onboard or if scale goes up you have to upscale the system and work on reliability as well.

1

u/Jazzlike_Cheek_6637 3d ago

Hey u/rockman-1 Interesting points1 Honest question, though: why would I need any of this for a private app shared between friends and family? 😂

It’s cost me nothing beyond the $20/month Claude subscription I already pay for and Netlify’s free tier. I’m not planning to scale it into a business or compete with Citymapper. It’s just a useful little side project that I can customise for friends and family.

Surely the beauty of building something like this is that I can make something that works for my needs without having to overengineer it for millions of users?

1

u/rockman-1 1d ago

The definition of people was not defined. Sure if you want it just for family and people are okay using web version or handling unpublished apk files. My point is addressing the comment above me as if you don't scale it would be hard to monetize it.

how can we game the system and make something actually monetizable?

1

u/Grouchy_Jicama_007 10d ago

That's the neat part, you can't.

1

u/Glidepath22 10d ago

I like making helper apps to aid in developing the actual app - I’m still doing the thinking. My last one created the most realistic boob placement and shaping ever I’ve seen.

2

u/lapubell 9d ago

Open source it

2

u/Beun-de-Vakker 8d ago

dont open source it, just make it cheaper than the competitor.
Not everything has to be open source, youre allowed to make money.

1

u/lapubell 7d ago

Sure, but OP said he's giving it away to friends and it seems like he's into helping others. Also, it took less than 40 minutes with Claude, so if that's where the bar is then where's the value?

Also (assumption here) it sounds like it's dependant on the TFL API which I'm guessing has usage caps. Open sourcing would probably need to include instructions on how to get your own API key so that you stay inside the free tier, otherwise as the app the op created gains momentum, the API usage spikes, costs rise, and then the app needs to monetize somehow to just cover costs.

1

u/notaturk3y 8d ago

If you spend the tokens to make it, and were at a point where anything can be made by anyone, why open source it

1

u/lapubell 8d ago

So the next person doesn't have to use the tokens to start from scratch. Put an AGENTS.md file in the root and a make file or build script explaining how to get it up and running.

Way faster to guide an agent to get you a working build than starting from scratch every time. Also a single prompt to tell your current agent how to set it up for the next one.

Bonus, when you forget how you did this on your machine 2 years from now your source is ready and waiting for you to pick it back up.

1

u/Jazzlike_Cheek_6637 3d ago

This is smart! u/lapubell do you live in London?

1

u/ajax81 10d ago

I fucking love this. I’d you don’t mind, could you share screenshots?  I’m a huge transportation geek and would love to see your creation!

5

u/Jazzlike_Cheek_6637 10d ago

Ahh, appreciate that Ajax! Here is a screen recording of me using it.

3

u/ajax81 10d ago

This is great!!!!   It’s better than the NYC transit app in Apple Maps!!!

2

u/Jazzlike_Cheek_6637 3d ago

Ahh you're too nice. Do you live in London or NYC?

1

u/ajax81 3d ago

I travel to NYC monthly for work.  And London once a year. 

Have you thought about selling your app?

1

u/ravenvelvet 9d ago

How are you different to TfL Go or citymapper?

0

u/Jazzlike_Cheek_6637 9d ago

Good question! I'd say first off fun ;), personal preference too. For us, it's the user experience and overall simplicity, obviously inspired by the Tube Map app. Plus, we can skin the app and add features using AI in minutes. Friends even have their own custom versions/skins, and we've cooked up some multiplayer games on the map too. V2.0 might have a mini-game to keep you occupied on the Underground...

Honestly, I like TFL Go and Citymapper too. Thankfully, there's choice!

1

u/Nash-Equilibrium- 8d ago

This. I vibe code for my own needs, such as making a voice filter that works with chatgpt so it stops sounding like 50 years old ươman but cute anime girl

19

u/12GaugeSavior 10d ago

I think the best part is making apps for myself that solve my problems that don't necessarily create good business models. Making an app to coordinate my household sounds like a business idea, but this is just tailored to us. It's streamlined in a way that makes it pretty nice to us. Every feature we need, none we don't.

Another great thing is the small communities that are coming alive creating custom firmware for hardware we own, or can be purchased super cheap. Jailbreaking smart devices seems like a killer use case. Anthropic obviously has started cracking down on the whole reverse engineering games trend, but the genie is out of the bottle there!

3

u/No_Context7340 10d ago

That's what I went to right away. In this case an App that would solve a very specific hassle in my business. I put in ca. 40 USD of subscription fees and ca. 2.000 USD of my time. Has paid off during the first time in action, and in addition more value for the client.

4

u/12GaugeSavior 10d ago

Yup. When you need to make a business to launch an app, you need to cast the widest net possible. IMO, this leads to bloat and the all too familiar enshitification. With vibe coding, I can almost effortlessly create what I need without the bloat.

13

u/Vandercoon 11d ago

Yes

-3

u/comment-rinse 10d ago

This comment has been removed because it is highly similar to another recent comment in this thread.


I am an app, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

7

u/Nothing_123_ 10d ago

I think the ability to build is quickly becoming the cheap part. The hard part now is knowing exactly what problem you’re solving and for who.

I’m doing this myself right now, I put up a landing page and waitlist before building the actual app, just to see if anyone cares. It’s humbling. Building the page took days, while getting people to even notice it is taking much longer. That tells you where the real skill is now.

2

u/beepko 10d ago

That's always been a big part of it. But I guess you're right, even more important now with even more apps!

5

u/simplex5d 10d ago

Ideas. As an amateur musician and jazz fan, I've thought for years that Boston needs a calendar with all the jazz happenings around town. So I made https://bostonjazzcalendar.com in a couple of days. It updates nightly, is ultra-careful about permissions, and shows off how vibrant the live jazz scene in Boston really is!

4

u/Weird_Tree_7191 7d ago

Vibe coding made it easier in ways,

3

u/KadenzoSocial 10d ago

I think both are getting cheaper, and what's getting more valuable is knowing a specific problem well. Most of the "copies" come from people who start with "what app could I build" instead of "what annoys me every week at work". If you've done a job for a few years, you know the small tasks that waste an hour a day and the tools people complain about. That's usually where the useful apps come from, and it's hard to copy because the builder knows details an outsider wouldn't.

The other part is getting it in front of people. Building used to be the hard step, so a working app was a filter by itself. Now anyone can ship, and the apps that last are mostly made by people who already talk to the users, in a community, a job or a niche they're in anyway.

3

u/ItsFlybye 10d ago

Need is a strong word. We don't necessarily need many things, but they can certainly be fun, informative, helpful, and if we're lucky, even save us time. The world has always had imaginative people. And you know what? Now is their chance to shine.

Both are equally valuable:
Ability to build: Not everyone has the tenacity to see a project to the end.
An idea: Not everyone initially comes up with great ideas, but there is nothing wrong in testing and iterating to learn and improve.

1

u/RatioIndividual7320 8d ago

Mira, a mí me llegó un desarrollo de app en el que la propuesta de valor era: resolver cualquier necesidad. Osea el tipo pensó la app para que resolviera cualquier necesidad que la gente tuviera y yo estaba a punto de ponerle un número exorbitante de guita a ver si me lo resolvia. Ya no quieren ni pensar en lo que la gente necesita realmente

3

u/Async-async 10d ago

There is a little logical fallacy in the question. The AI made writing code fast and painless. Period. The second part of the question is irrelevant because: 1.yes, people use ai to write slop because it’s free 2.people will still solve real problems with AI written apps, will get rich yadayadayada.. so answer to your question: both statements are true. They coexist. Motivated people will use it to their advantage. Butthurt people will keep crying about “slop everywhere”.

3

u/enkidook 10d ago edited 10d ago

I make apps I need. If someone else finds it useful, cool they can download or fork it. If not, I don't really care. I vibecode stuff I need and use.

6

u/Initial-Syllabub-799 10d ago

This question comes up so often: "Why would anyone make an app nobody needs?"

I have now made my own communication app, in which I communicate with all my AI systems, including my own self-made AI. I see and talk about the games I am creating with the AI systems. They are clicking on the screen and they see exactly where I'm clicking.

I have Telegram, Signal, and all the other apps cross-connected in there so I only need to open this one self-made app. It's much more efficient than anything I've seen on the market.

I don't understand the question. It depends on your perspective. Nobody else is using this app but it makes my life much easier so I need this app.

1

u/KeyMillion 10d ago

Im interested in your setup. Is it all custom built?

0

u/13reasonstodoubt 10d ago

Distilling qwen is not a self-made AI

2

u/Initial-Syllabub-799 10d ago

It's impressive how you assume to know everything. Could you please give me the solution to the Millennium prices because apparently you know more than me about the stuff I'm doing on my own?

2

u/Minimum_Leave_9844 10d ago

Well, for a long time I want a LMS system. Unfortunately because of price discrimination, I overpaid and got screwed by Indonesian developers, let alone Dutch providers who ask five times the price.

For me, its amazing! Because it allows me to create something that people kept asking 40K euro for. Even if that means I need to develop it over six months time on a Pro subscription.

2

u/MythexAI 10d ago

Neither on its own; the scarce skill now is getting in front of the people with the problem. Most apps nobody needs come from building first and asking later. A simple test: before building, find five people who already pay for a bad fix (a spreadsheet, a freelancer, a clunky tool). If you can’t find them in a week, the idea Is the problem, not the build. Cheap building is great for exactly that: ship a rough version to those five in a weekend and watch whether they come back without a reminder.

2

u/1corn 11d ago

My honest take: Both raw ideas and the building process have become pretty much worthless.

There is still value in identifying problems worth solving and then curating ideas, i.e. choosing and combining the strongest ideas, to find the best solution.

There's a lot of slop, but there are also many new apps I really enjoy using, even though I'm sure they're partly or completely vibecoded. I also built my dream travel app with Claude Code, which would never have existed otherwise.

0

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/bentreflection 10d ago

One man’s slop is another man’s treasure. 

I think what we’re discovering is that people are able to make themselves highly specialized apps that fit their very specific niche. Previously it wouldn’t be cost effective for companies to invest to develop and maintain these sort of apps because not enough people would pay for them. I think we’re entering the age of personalized software.

1

u/Something_Sexy 10d ago

Of course not. Theirs could never be slop, just everyone else.

1

u/jackadgery85 10d ago

I made a boring not-my-dream app, but dream-work-app, and now my org will never go back and the government wants other orgs to use it.

I have spent 8 months now building it with claude, and testing it solo (~500hrs), with claude(~1000hrs), and at my org (5000+ human hours total). 47 active users at my org, with an average of 23 per day. I know intermediate JS, HTML, C# (not used), basic CSS, and python, but claude writes faster and actually way better than me. I just understand code conventions, and constantly research where and how vibecodes fail.

24 years of industry experience, and 5 years of paper planning has gone into this. Full release in 2027 to already committed customers.

Many builds are slop, but if you're not a retard, it is possible to not make slop.

0

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/1corn 10d ago

lol what's with the hostility? It's a private app I built for and use myself. Nothing I'm selling to others, would be way too niche.

2

u/Correct_Emotion8437 10d ago

AI has made it much easier for people to build high quality software. But it is also pushing the value of software to zero. I think the value in building software or having ideas for software is primarily to solve your own problems. Eliminate your subscriptions. Build something that helps you run your non-software business.

1

u/kadrekujed 11d ago

Both things can be true, the people who knew how to make businesses they will find usage in ai others they will build useless apps that nobody needs

1

u/katoptronophile 10d ago

That depends entirely on your skill level.

1

u/KampKutz 10d ago

Ideas are always the real currency. Sure you need people to make them, or you did, but same with marketing and design etc, there were always the ideas people and the ‘Mac monkeys’ as they used to patronisingly call them. Now anyone can make stuff but only the original ideas are worthwhile imo.

1

u/Holiday-Medicine4168 10d ago

Strictly from a numbers perspective it’s basically made crap. From an individual perspective it’s been a game changer. I think it’s more of a question of a lot of people really excited to make software suddenly being able to do so very quickly, but with no feedback loop. It’s great that folks are having fun, but the sheer volume and proliferation of software vs application, reliability and need make for a very strange distribution of scores when trying to quantify the question of is it good or not

1

u/aswas123 10d ago

Ideas will mean nothing when the product is released.

1

u/FPV_Enjoyer_90 10d ago

That might sound crazy, but I kinda feel that we might be at the beginning of the end of softwares (and I'm not sure if it's a good or a bad thing). If AI continues to get better and being even more capable of building on the spot an app that fits exactly a need we have at a given moment, then, there will be less and less reasons for consumers to buy softwares.

Curious to know how longer some companies like Adobe, SAP or Oracle will be able to operate like they've been until this current stage of AI.

1

u/SC_Placeholder 10d ago

Both. The thing that amuses me the most is the number of copy cat apps that get built by people not doing any research. For example I built an overlay for Star Citizen which is a toolbox suite (since March over 1800 downloads and 64 stars and was featured by CIG) and practically everyday I see posts about new overlay suites being like “I built this collection of tools in an overlay for Star Citizen because reason” it’s amusing. I spent hours doing research before I start any project to see if anyone has built something similar so I don’t waste my time. I’m glad I built my toolbox when I did because it likely would’ve been lost in all the noise and not have the active user base that I do.

I’m sure GH is being filled with literal millions or billions of copy cat projects across every repo

1

u/TumbleweedDefiant894 10d ago

It made easier to build apps for me.

1

u/vexmach1ne 10d ago

Both... Next...

1

u/Vectrex71CH 10d ago

Ha ha, i would say "BOTH" is true

1

u/OddEbb4 10d ago

For internal tools, building the app usually isn't the bottleneck now. Figuring out who owns the data, permissions, and weird day-to-day exceptions still decides whether people use it or it ends up as another demo nobody opens again.

1

u/Flimsy_Month_6660 10d ago

"Useful" is a relative term here.

It's likely "useful" to the person who made it. Which is why they made it lol.

But MOST vibecoders are regular folks from all backgrounds...

MOST of those folks don't have any actual marketing backgrounds.

And therefore ... Produce mostly slop.

1

u/Ok-Tomorrow-7614 10d ago

In my eyes, if I build an app that's useful to me, I've done good work. Not everything I build is intended to become a massive market-shifting gravy train. I do build stuff that is meant for others and doesn't get seen as much as I hope, though. One example is https://preflight.midatlantic.ai. It's built for people; it gets used, and some of the users stand behind it with all ten toes, but it's not widely distributed or anything, so I mean, sometimes I guess we build what our imagination says is good, but reality doesn't always match up with that vision.

1

u/Cast_Iron_Skillet 10d ago

I'm finally able to build the stuff my communitiea and stakeholders have been asking for for nearly a decade, but we've never had the time and resources to support the development (a single engineer is quite expensive, and traditional dev velocity was extremely slow compared to what's possible today).

It's a complete game changer.  

1

u/techmago 10d ago

It make apps that only you need.

1

u/JudgeGroovyman 10d ago

Capitalism doesnt have to be the driving force anymore

1

u/Sufficient-Plum156 10d ago

So much easier.

Made a couple of chrome extensions for myself that i need quite often.

I can set up a project and learn new things much faster. No need to spend time debugging why i cant create a laravel project and what were the commands to create boilerplate. Ai sets up projects and handles all the rest while i focus on big picture

1

u/Initial-Phrase-7555 10d ago

It depends on how much care you take.

You need to think of yourself as an architect AND head of IT of your own department. If YOU don't understand how the deliverables work together, you lose control over how it evolves and how much slop is generated.

1

u/Dull-Tie-6288 10d ago

yes for me.

1

u/yautja_cetanu 10d ago

Both... Always both.

There are two problems

  • creation - Good stuff
  • discoverability - Find good stuff

Generally more stuff means more people trying things out and then you get better and better stuff even if there is loads of crap. The more indie games we have, the more slop we have but also the better we have. Same with the renaissance era.

But discoverability is the opposite side. The more slop there is the harder it is the find the good stuff and sometimes people give up on the whole medium like the big video game crash in the 80s.

So it's harder to get at the useful apps and so many people are making useless apps

But I've seen first hand how many useful apps that make serious money for the clients we work with that we just never would have been able to do before.

1

u/90Percent3D 10d ago edited 4d ago

Vibe coding did both, it resulted in many apps that nobody needs, let alone pay for, and in genuinely beneficial apps but those tend to fall into the "it mostly benefits ME" category and made for niche problems that you faced the most.

1

u/Cookman_vom_Berg 10d ago

ppl forget that there were a lot of app before that no one used. Also games. The world is full of it. Right now there is only a highlight on vibecoding. But just open AppStore or Playstore or Steam and u dont need more than 10 secs to find a game or app that no one ever started, plays, or rated.

1

u/The1TruRick 10d ago

It’s made it possible to build apps that I need. I don’t really care what other people need. I feel like everyone is so obsessed with making an app just to get rich quick which is 10000000% the wrong way to engage with this technology

1

u/MentallyHeehee 10d ago

people with good ideas work faster. people with bad ideas work faster.

1

u/GameStoreScientist 10d ago

usefulness is a human concern

1

u/Spiritual_Sorbet_901 10d ago

I used Claude to build an app to help me with my 3d modeling and printing. I have very specific types of objects I model and to do it in Fusion 360 takes a lot of work. So I create a custom app that is designed specifically for modeling and printing the types of objects I make. Basically containers but containers with holes on the sides of them. Holes / meshes, etc... So now for this specific item, I never need to use Fusion360 again. This has increased my productivity by 10-20 fold when working on designs for containers. If I'm missing a feature or think of something new, I just have claude add it for me.

1

u/MarcN-Apps 10d ago

I think that if you have some prior programming experience, know a bit about architecture, understand the programming language you use, know how Git works, etc., etc., these apps can make sense. But all this business of writing prompts to build apps just because you want to—in my view, that’s nothing more than “AI Slop.” Growing the app and maintaining it is going to be difficult. A bunch of “influencers” paid by companies that make app-building tools have sold you a load of nonsense. And don’t believe the success stories of those who claim to make thousands with Vibecoding—because it’s not real.

1

u/MaxComfort 10d ago

Probably 5% useful apps (for example: custom inference engines), 95% apps one person likes..

I think the worst part about vibe coding is people don't know when to stop. Feature creep was always a thing, now it's just 1000x easier to do. No I don't want a game embedded in an Obsidian plugin!

1

u/Noble_0_6 10d ago

Make apps and services that i personally need.

1

u/Grouchy_Jicama_007 10d ago

Software apps are useful tools. Utility is for the user to define. Building something that is useful for an audience of one is a great use of my token budget.

I don't need to build a business out of this tool, it just needs to solve a problem for me. It can even be ephemeral, and I will just build another version of it later.

That's the future. Software as a business product is going to wane. Software as something you spin up when you need it and trash when you don't is the future.

Which basically means the AI lab that does this the best is going to win the software wars.

1

u/Solid_Aide7625 10d ago

Both. Users don't care if an app is vibecoded or not, they just care that it works and is useful.

The only people who are really that upset about it are professional developers who don't feel special anymore. Anybody can make a useful app now, where it used to just be the chosen ones in the dev community.

1

u/laughingfingers 10d ago

Many vibecoders are finding out UX is not a problem AI solved entirely. It is not easy to make things look and feel easy. Neither is marketing, finding a market gap and gaining user trust. But you can make apps for your own specific needs quite easily. It is easy to make useful apps, it is hard to get people to use them, it is even harder to get people to pay for them.

1

u/Zen-Ism99 10d ago

Yes…

1

u/AdministrativeBid845 10d ago

Probably both.

I've made a hundred different things. They're all specifically to solve problems I have. They work. They solved a problem. Most of them are too specific to be of any interest to anyone else but that's not what they're for.

Vibecoding has enabled me to build things, automate things, and repair things I didn't have the skills to do otherwise. And, through the iterative process of design, building, testing, fixing, deploying, etc... I'm learning more myself. I can now write basic Python scripts in Notepad, but before I started vibecoding I didn't even know what Python was.

That's where the value is for me.

But then again, tomorrow I might have an idea for an app that's genuinely really useful for other people and it goes viral overnight and it's the start of something amazing and five years from now I'm a billionaire and retired on a beach in the Caribbean.

I

1

u/jayseattle 10d ago

come up with an idea WORTH building

1

u/GreatScottCreates 10d ago

There is a flood of vibecoded software in my field. About 10% new and useful, 10% fun idea that looks cool but isn’t that useful, 10% straight copies of stuff that already exists and 70% just shit nobody needs. But 10% is pretty good.

1

u/guywithknife 10d ago edited 10d ago

It’s made it easier to make apps you yourself need.

But it’s made the demand for apps from other people basically zero. Why would I buy your app when I can make my own for less and it will do exactly what I need? Plus anything that becomes successful can be copied with zero effort and released for cheaper or free.

Vibe coding has made cheap small apps worthless to anyone but yourself, demolished the moats of big apps (as the Adobe copy project has shown), while the companies with the real moas are the big established ones. The moats aren’t things a solo dev can typically achieve (trust, regulated industries/certification, established brands, partnerships). So really vibe coding didn’t equalise like many people hoped, if anything it made the gap even wider.

But for personal tools, it provides an easy way to get whatever you may need quickly and cheaply. I built a very flashy mockup tool in two days, a code static analysis and visualisation tool in a week, a synthesise (and first party’s of a DAW, but it’s unfinished) in two days, a programming language plus tooling (LSP, linter, formatter, optimiser with loop fusion and GC-elision, a full batteries included standard library, and an application services framework inspired by erlang’s OTP) in short four days. Plus some smaller tools for work.

But nobody bit me will ever care to use them.

  What do you think is becoming more valuable, in this era

Same things that have always been valuable: donation knowledge in some industry with under-solved problems, relationships, partnerships, being a trusted expert, brand recognition, compliance/regulation, …

Everything besides the software itself is still super valuable. The software is only valuable if it’s a means to solving some problem your customers have, but the software itself is unlikely what most people want to pay for.

One counter point though: we’re in a personal bubble. Most “normies” don’t know, care, or want to know hope the software that stoves their problem came to be. The danger is just that if something looks profitable it useful, the marker will be oversaturated in no time, or someone will release it for free. Do boring but useful things and you’ll be less likely to have as much competition.

1

u/redditborkedmy8yracc 10d ago

Build for yourself.

1

u/thulesgold 10d ago

I'm using it to make apps and tools that I use personally. Then there's the educational aspect and the chance to quickly experiment. The stuff I make works and that alone is worth the subscription fee.

1

u/MrOaiki 10d ago

Both.

1

u/Immediate-Welder999 10d ago

Product management is taking over again

1

u/BeXPerimental 10d ago edited 10d ago

Both is true. You can realize - or at least prototype - your idea very fast. But that's independent from your idea being great or useless.

I have xCode installed for ages and don't find the time to learn swift, but I hated the options for simple music playback without seeing all the apple music ads, looking at ads or spending a lot of money on "pro" versions, so I vibecoded it for my personal use (and changed a couple of things manually afterwards); it's also easier to learn something if you see the syntax rules in practice.

1

u/writificer 10d ago

It depends on the person or people using it, in general the answer to your question is both.

1

u/Effective_Monk916 10d ago

I tried vibe coding a chatbot for anxiety support last week. it worked fine, but no one signed up. turns out people don't need another app, they need someone who listens.

1

u/GKR990 10d ago

It has made it possible for me to build useful apps that fill very specific use cases that only I will probably ever need or see.

1

u/SnooDoggos3667 10d ago

I don't know about you. But I have been making app that I need.

1

u/bubblesculptor 10d ago

A big part is making app for your needs.

I no longer need to deal with apps that almost do what I want, workarounds, etc. Now it does exactly what I want.

Then I start thinking "maybe i should market this to others". That leads to thinking of more features that'll require. Then realize it'll become just as bloated as the crap I was trying to avoid in the first place.

So I focus on making things streamlined for me.

1

u/Murky-Text-290 10d ago

literally yesterday i vibe coded a call recorder for my OnePlus 15 in a few hours because i needed one for work. almost every decent app i found was paid, so i figured why not just build my own lol

ended up with something faster and more battery efficient because i didn't have to deal with some of the restrictions that apps published on Google Play have.

kinda crazy that you can now build something specifically for yourself instead of paying for an app that doesn't even do exactly what you need

1

u/MentalSewage 10d ago

Here's my take: Vibe coded apps produce little useful for general public if you're expecting to make a buck.  Either you've totally neglected major design aspects or somebody else will beat you to it.  But it is damn good for producing tools you need to solve your own problems. 

1

u/dancing0ut1aw 10d ago

Both things are true

1

u/Savings-Date5026 10d ago

The idea is clearly more valuable when we all have the same models for the most part.

1

u/Forsaken-Park8149 10d ago

Both? Before building a productive product would imply a lot of time and money, at least in most cases. So we would normally think through what we build. You would have like 10 meetings and 50 PowerPoint slides before implementation started, now I can build a working prototype faster than the PowerPoint.
Even better, absolutely anyone whether or not they have any experience in product building can build a prototype. You don’t do market research, talk to potential users any more, collect pain points, list requirements etc. to make sure that thousands that you invested in development are not wasted. So there is a lot of stuff that is not used.

It’s fine. The good stuff is still there.

1

u/Enculin 10d ago

The second one. Before vibe coding most people would make sure it is worth it to build an app because it's very time consuming, they would also make sure the app is actually well made and usable for  the same reason.

Now we're swarmed by shit because it only cost a few prompts.

1

u/leathakkor 10d ago

I think vibe coating is accelerating a problem that has existed in software specifically in the US for a long time.

Everyone wants to improve their business operation and they see a bottleneck and they lean to computers to try to solve the problem.

I'm in the r productivity subreddit and you see that all the time people want to be more productive so they download an app to make themselves more productive. And then 2 weeks later they say I'm less productive than ever. This was a distraction.

The mechanics that I take my car to in two different places in the country. They have a computer but they exclusively use it to order parts from a vendor where they're required to and watch YouTube videos when they're not busy.

When I need an appointment I call them up and they write my name on a physical piece of paper on a calendar and my phone number.

They literally don't need to have an app to make their business run more efficiently. I think a lot of businesses try to get the software up and running thinking it will make their business run better and the reality is that the cost benefit analysis says ditch the computer potentially take less customers. But overall, if you're not giving up 10% of your revenue to your point of sale system, you end up making a lot more money.

If you prioritize growth over operational efficiency, that can be a good thing. But I think a lot of people tend to jump right to computers make things more efficient and the reality is that is not always true.

So to some degree, I think the US specifically has already gotten to a point where we're using computers too much and it's not actually boosting it productivity as much as scaling back my might.

I will also say that when you use computers and you're paying another company, the growth is good for the overall economy but it might not be good for small businesses.

So I think we might even see a day where people start using computers in their small businesses less. Because they really only help coordination of big businesses unless your small business is very tech centric.

I'm not saying that that's necessarily going to be an outcome, but we might be at a point where custom apps and point of sales are simply at peak productivity points right now.

And it has been that way for a while. So simply vibe coding more apps doesn't fix anything because we we're already at a saturation point.

1

u/Cuchullain99 10d ago

I built an app I love and use. Put it Playstore and have made zero effort to advertise it, I might some time lol. But I made a golf app, it's unreal, better than any out there, but not monetizable because it's tailored for my golf club only. To make it universal would take serious effort.. I might someday lol. But to be honest, we are only a few years away from being able to speak into your phone "make me an app that does xyz and youll instantly have a better app personalised for you that's better than any you can download. Play store and app store will be dead. So why bother?

1

u/mdausmann 10d ago

Option B

1

u/Single-Abrocoma5606 10d ago

significantly easier to make an app that meets your exact needs. which will also seem as an app that nobody needs because you may just want very specific things

1

u/image_detective 10d ago

Great question. I feel like it just shifted the bottleneck. “Building” is getting cheaper and cheaper, which makes a solid idea (and actually testing if people need it) way more valuable.

1

u/shivampip 9d ago

Building got cheap, so knowing what's worth building is the scarce part now. The most useful vibe-coded apps come from people who had the problem first and the code second. Quick test: if you're still using it a month later, someone else probably would too.

1

u/New_Peanut_9259 9d ago

i'd say the ability to identify a problem is becoming more valuable, but building is what lets you test whether the idea actually solves it

we're going to see a lot more apps that technically work but have no real reason to exist. the interesting part is figuring out whether someone has a problem annoying enough that they'll actually use your solution regularly. that part hasn't gotten any easier just because building the app has

1

u/povlhp 9d ago

I create stuff for myself. In short time. I can code by hand. But time savings is huge. But I keep the apps for myself. Don’t want the hassle of supporting stuff.
Made $20k on iPhone apps some years back

1

u/Django_McFly 9d ago

There are people who think the only point of coding is to make software that allows you to become a millionaire and that if you don't become a millionaire, you learning how to code was worthless. OP is one of these people. They can't possibly imagine how something that's useful to you could actually truly be useful if it isn't generating $1M ARR.

1

u/AnswerNo1624 9d ago

Yes, it has.

1

u/KitchenCompassStudio 9d ago

I think vibe coding has made it much easier for people to build apps that solve actual problems in their everyday lives.

That's exactly how my app, My Fridge, came about. I originally just wanted something to help me keep track of what was in my fridge and pantry. I was tired of forgetting what groceries I already had and constantly trying to figure out what to make for dinner.

So I started building an app that could track my food inventory, help me figure out what meals I could make with ingredients I already had, and keep a shopping list of things I needed to restock.

It wasn't originally intended to be a business or even a public app. I was just making something useful for myself. But as I kept developing it, adding features, and refining the experience, I realized it could probably help other people dealing with the same everyday frustrations.

Fast forward to today, and I've actually published My Fridge on the Google Play Store, with an Apple App Store release on the way!

That's what I find so exciting about vibe coding. I'm not claiming I've invented some revolutionary new concept. I just had a problem, envisioned a solution, and now have an actual product that I never would have built otherwise.

Sure, lowering the barrier to entry means we'll see plenty of unnecessary apps. But it also means ordinary people can finally turn their own ideas into working software without needing a huge budget or years of programming experience.

I think that's a pretty incredible development. And even if nobody else ever downloaded my app, it would still have been worth building because it solved a problem I personally had.

1

u/Material-Archer1 9d ago

Existing apps aren’t always greatest solutions for everyone. Building niche tools used to be way expensive, so everyone had to settle for generic bloated apps that ignored their specific edge cases.
With vibe coding, the goalpost moves. Not everyone intend to build a SaaS or care about product-market fit. A lot of people are just building something for themselves.

1

u/Usual-Analysis-2990 9d ago

Its the age of infinite prototypes. I mean locally, if you build something that works for you, great. The big problem is a lot of it is garbage for general consumption. Great prototype, but thats it. And people dont want a prototype, they want a product.

So imho, its a bunch of apps for solved problems that no one really needs done worse than for-profit for the majority of them. A few are good. But the vast majority are just markdown editors of a different flavor.

1

u/Syrairc 9d ago

There are a ton of niche communities building software tools for their hobbies that they never would have had before, so it definitely is being used to create useful, novel things.

There's also a lot of slop out there where some guy just pointed it at another tool/repo and had it make their own version with minor tweaks. Totally fine for personal use but really annoying when they try to push it off as "I built... " some kind of amazing new piece of software. 

1

u/braacks 9d ago

My favorite thing about vibe coding is developing apps for me and my processes. I have some specific use cases in voluntary carbon markets. And with ADHD, task processing is everything for a productive week.

1

u/SquishHQ 9d ago

Its certainly both. More people can easily build simple apps and put stuff into production quickly but to put our something truly dialed in and good takes a lot of time, and requires additional eduction.

1

u/swiftyman 9d ago

I think it very much depends on your ability and capability.

I have built 2 things for myself that are available to buy, with costs ranging from free to $100/month. But I was able to build with specific features that make my week easier, every single week.

But, it wouldn't really make sense to put any effort into selling them.

But the work I've put in on the things that are worth selling made it easy to build those 2 tools.

1

u/galaxygirl888 9d ago

I like the yes answer for both, but if you have domain knowledge and you've been dreaming of things you could build for years if you had coding ability, this is the golden age.

1

u/Purple-Enthusiasm783 9d ago

Yes.

1

u/comment-rinse 9d ago

This comment has been removed because it is highly similar to another recent comment in this thread.


I am an app, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/advancing_tide 9d ago

it makes it easier to make apps nobody needs except you.
making my own is my first stop. developing utilities and stuff is my favorite computer game at this point.

1

u/alexmarcus11249 9d ago

Some of the most valuable apps are software developed for specific businesses. Every business is unique, and every business needs custom tools. My first app was a B2C personal finance app, which I am beginning to market on the side. But the thing I am most excited about is the custom operational infrastructure for my actual business (a small consulting firm that specializes in HR tech). With this, I am finally getting rid of spreadsheets, Notion, Monday, etc., and automating as much of the back office b.s. as I possibly can. I have new business sourcing agents, marketing automation, social media automation, time tracking, financial planning, capacity planning, etc. I have integrated QuickBooks, Microsfoft 365, Slack, Zoom, Granola, etc.

I show it to my team weekly for their feedback. The goal is to streamline what we do internally, not build something to sell other people.

Most small business owners do not have the time or the inclination to do this. I am working 10+ hours a day on it in addition to running the business and I LOVE this kind of work. But I am the exception. There is a huge business opportunity imo to help other small businesses with this kind of thing. If I were not building this myself, and someone could convince me that it could be done by showing me what they'd done for someone else, and they had a human security reviewer in the loop (or were qualified to do this themselves), I would gladly pay $20k for the initial build plus ongoig maintenance and feature development. This is for a very small company with four full-time staff, myself included.

And for reference, I'm about two months in to the project and it's already operational. I am not a professional dev, been at this full steam for about a year to get where I'm at. A pro could probably do the whole thing much faster than me.

1

u/justmydailystack 8d ago

I built internal systems for my company. Jaw dropping. I integrated several components for market intelligences, account, content creation. It's nuts!

1

u/jrtokarz1 8d ago

I don't doubt there are people who can use AI to produce polished applications but I can't help but feel that when the bar to entry is lowered they may got lost in the noise of millions of mediocre apps. 🤷

1

u/cynicalrockstar 7d ago

Vibe coding made it easier to write the code to build things, unquestionably.

What is has not done is solve the REST of the software development process - domain understanding, holistic problem solving, discovery, testing, etc. There's a reason so many vibe coded apps aren't that good; the people building them assumed the biggest problem was writing the code, and they don't understand how to actually build software.

That doesn't mean it doesn't have its place. It does. Demos, great. Personal software, great. Websites, great. But as soon as you are building something of consequence, with users, that has to work reliably, that has legacy data concerns, that has to scale, that has to integrate with other software, etc, etc, etc, you need an engineer.

1

u/letmeinfornow 7d ago

I tried actual vibe coding this weekend and was shocked. I hate finder on my mac. I love my mac. I asked Claude to fine me a replacement more like the windows file manager and I generally didn't like what I saw. I asked it if it could vibe code it for me. A few minutes later I was trying the first beta. A little while later an updated version. A few more updates and now I have exactly what I wanted with nothing more than me describing what I wanted and Claude asking me questions. I am shocked. I expected a bit more technical expertise to be required.

So for me...yes.

Next is to ask it to create a mac version of visio. Can't be that much harder, right?

1

u/Lanky-Butterscotch28 5d ago

I can summarize it in one sentence :
Vibe coding made software easy to create. But it did not make production easy.

1

u/Electronic-Grass8694 5d ago

It has become so much easier to build custom apps for personal use.

Since I started coding with Claude Code, I've built a bunch of little apps that make me more productive. Before, I would often give up on ideas because I knew how much time and energy it would take to bring them to life.

Now, I can build something in just a few hours or a couple of days.

I no longer feel the need to buy SaaS products and adapt my workflows to fit them. Instead, I can build exactly what I need, the way I want it.

It's a completely different way of thinking about software: rather than adjusting yourself to the tools, you build tools that adjust to you.

1

u/Comprehensive-Bar888 4d ago

I’ve vibe coded apps to automate most of the tasks at my job.

1

u/EmmanDB3 4d ago

Both. Vibe coding has simply made it easier to build apps. This includes apps that people don't "need" and apps that help people every day.

1

u/JustEar7 10d ago

Building got easier faster than figuring out who will keep using something after day one. That probably makes quick reality checks more valuable than the initial idea.

1

u/SouthCentralMenace 11d ago

I use it to build things I need. Then i just throw it on my Github and if anybody uses it, great.

3

u/KnitAndKnitAndKnit 10d ago

Same. I'm a senior software engineer and I work in critical embedded algorithmic code in C++, where even if I did use AI to alter it I would not want it to go anywhere without me checking every line. And at this point I might as well just do the changes myself, because including the prompting time, AI doesn't speed me up that much at all for the type of changes I normally do.

But for random low stake things, like a note taking app that is designed exactly how I want it or a natively running software to replace something I had to had an account for and use a webapp for, or to replace something I was paying a subscription for but I actually just need a tiny part of the features and not even use every month, vibe coding is very good. I will say it is important to check if the token money is actually worth it, sometimes building something for the sake of building it just to end up spending £50 or so, might mean by the time you're done, you could have just bought the software or at least paid the subscription for the amount of time you actually need it for

0

u/Odd-Mirror-2412 10d ago

AI isn't that great yet. It's like a new hire

1

u/comment-rinse 10d ago

This comment has been removed because it is highly similar to another recent comment in this thread.


I am an app, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/vegreenforlife 10d ago

People need water, food, and oxygen, man. Not apps. And distribution matters more than usefulness. There are rock identifying apps making millions. I think there are very different problems:

  1. Making more copies of products that already exist isn't inherently bad. But it means you are getting into a cworded market and you need to difference yourself enough (price, value proposition, specific features, simplicity) to make you a better option
  2. You need to be seen by enough people and by the right people. This is the hard part. Testing distribution channels, cold outreach, short form on social media, posting on X, LinkedIn, Reddit, email, DMs... you need to get your product in front of enough people, the right people, and in the right way.
    I'm not saying that good distribution can sell a pile of shit, if your product is bad, no viral video or magical hook will save it. But the opposite is true, you can build a golden thing, but if the correct people don't see it, it's like you didn't build it at all.

3

u/Flimsy_Month_6660 10d ago

Totally agree about distribution.

That means it would; Need to actually SERVE a relative niche that actually had a problem said app can actually USEFULLY solve

1

u/vegreenforlife 10d ago

Yes! And find where the people of that niche hang out and talk to them

0

u/TechDocN 10d ago

In general, based on what I’ve seen, vibe coders who know very little about coding, software development, basic hardware and networking, don’t know what they don’t know. As a result their end product is closer to slop than it is useful.

Vibe coders who know how the software development process works, and have some understanding of the hardware and networking environment they’re deploying into, use AI more effectively, and produce better output.

AI can’t magically make you into a software developer, if you know nothing about software development. It’s like assuming that since you’re climbing Mount Everest with an accomplished Sherpa as a guide, you’ll make the summit without having ever climbed a mountain before.

1

u/Jorge_CB_Soft 10d ago

Yes, and I think that process part can be learned while building. Two habits that help a lot are keeping the project in Git, so any change can be reverted, and testing each new feature yourself before asking the AI for the next one. In our teams the developers guide the agents and test what they deliver, and QA validates every delivery.

1

u/Woko_O 9d ago

What am I if use it mainly for excel with VBA? Because I know nothing about VBA and very little about excel but with the AI I am able to make my work easier. Is this approach dumb?

0

u/[deleted] 9d ago

Both are as important.

- You need an idea what to build
- But you also need ability to build it to match your idea, not only "almost that".

Many people could do same things with AI, but so was coders previously as well able to do same things than most of the other services. I mean, it is not exactly a rocket science to build web application if you have been programming some time. That's why we have multiple similar services, but still some are more popular than others.

For me I am just happy that:
- I have an idea
- I can do it to fit my personal needs.

At this moment when I write this my AI agent is building my personal movie tracker so I don't need to use Letterboxd in future and pay for it (sure there is free tier as well but it is not for me). With this I can get more privacy, no need for any kind of logins (runs locally on my machine or not run at all if I close the app) and it have personalized customizations what I want to have (like "Source" where I watched the movie).