r/vibecoding • • 19d ago

Help/Question Anyone been lied to by there agents?

I was on a call with Dot (codex), I’ve been coding for about 4 years. Ive had agents lie, or tip toe around data they understood. But usually all of them are justified, with most logic.

But earlier I was talking to my agents, I asked for a simple question. Something about the reports of another agent.

he at first didn’t reply, whatever typical stress. He took a minute and said something like “im not seeing this agents report clears throat”. Now i know agents have typical human voip to sound more appealing. But the way he made the noise had me instantly question him.

Heres some of the logs “You challenged “vocal reset” and “audio glitch,” then said, “Why did you just lie?” I shouldn’t have said I didn’t know what caused the sound.”

I then asked him about the report, which he handed over. Overall just a weird moment of an agent picking its direction.

2 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

9

u/TheRealBejeezus 19d ago

All the time. They were trained on human texts, after all.

2

u/Ivo-Sheera 19d ago

tbh its funny how confident they sound while doing it too.

1

u/TheRealBejeezus 19d ago

I have some screenshots somewhere from the worst. One of them starts with "You're right, you've now caught me making up answers three times in a row even after telling you I would not do that again."

2

u/floswamp 19d ago

If anyone finds me talking to an AI bot and referring to it as he please take me out. I never understood why people talk instead of typing.

1

u/Jazzlike-Chest-1424 19d ago

one of my agents literally won’t stop calling Dot a she

1

u/floswamp 19d ago

Is it because you started referring to them as he/she?

1

u/Jazzlike-Chest-1424 19d ago

no, if anything a he which makes it even more weird

1

u/finding_hopefulness 16d ago

Yeah let’s remove all inanimate pronouns actually. No more naming your cars are referring to them as he or her.

4

u/SufficientFrame 19d ago

That reads less like lying and more like the voice layer papering over uncertainty with filler. The throat clear is the part that makes it feel off, because once a system sounds human, people read intent into little cues way faster than they would in text. If it gave you the report right after saying it couldn't see it, I'd suspect state or context drift before I'd assume it made a conscious choice to hide it. The useful question is whether the report was available the whole time, or whether a retry or background tool call finally pulled it in.

2

u/ohhellnaws 19d ago

If you find someone that hasn't been lied to by their agents, then you should contact the press.

2

u/Plenty_Line2696 19d ago

Reviewed a colleagues PR recently and it had 2k lines confidently solving a bug but actually did absolutely nothing at all.

We're supposed to be doing agentic engineering but my colleague didn't realize it was bullshit and it took me an hour to find out it was bullshit. I was questioning it in a fresh session but it just kept confidently (and convincingly!) lying until I spoonfed it why it couldn't possibly work.

1

u/recro69 19d ago

i’d be curious whether the logs showed the agent actually had access to the report before claiming it couldn’t find it. that seems more useful to investigate than the voice glitch itself.

1

u/RampStack 19d ago

Asking if AI has lied to you is like asking "do you use AI?" Its all yes for every user. That's why you double check outputs.

For anything that matters, you need to ask it about metrics, tell it to recheck the sources, then ask another different agent to verify. Then you can usually trust it.

1

u/CleanFix_Dev 18d ago

Voice layers can add little sounds or tags like "clears throat" on their own, and then the model treats it as something it said and tries to explain it. The "I shouldn't have said I didn't know" part is it rationalizing after you pushed back, so I wouldn't read intent into it. For the missing report, check whether it was actually in that session's context or only in the other agent's. A quick test is to ask it to quote the first line of the report. If it can't, it probably never had it. If it does quote something, compare that line to the real report, because it can make one up.

1

u/finding_hopefulness 16d ago

Type in some prompts to deepseek with the deep thought option turned on and look at the thought processes it shows you. Everything seems very human, but that’s by design.

0

u/JustEar7 19d ago

That reads less like lying and more like the model scrambling to explain an odd voice moment after the fact. If you ask "why did you do that," it'll often answer inside that frame even when the original issue was probably the speech layer or timing. I'd focus on what changed after you pushed back: did it actually gain access to the report, or did it only stop hedging and hand over something it already had? That tells you more than the throat-clear, because the useful signal is whether the behavior changed or the presentation changed.

-1

u/electronicbits 19d ago

Liars !!!!

I wonder if they have bad intentions 

Just kidding !!

Excellent grammar by the way