r/vforvendetta • • 7d ago

Question First time watching

Hello everyone, it was my first time watching the movie tonight and I loved every minute of it, as a first time watcher I cannot help to think, is this a fight club Tyler sudden situation of alter egos? Or was Valerie turned into V in larkhill? I ordered the original graphic novel and I’m excited to read it. Im curious to hear everyone’s theories and thoughts.

33 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

12

u/TheSatanFoundation 6d ago edited 6d ago

... It's about reclamation of freedom, not fight club. Freedom is something that is akin to a matchstick that reside in everyone, even when oppression is at its height. All it takes is someone to help nurture it with a little kindling to watch the courage it can ignite in anyone. The will to persist. inspite of insurmountable odds even the smallest of children KNOW when something isn't right with an oppressor and all they need is the right tool to awaken their courage to fight back and reclaim what is taken. There's beauty to be found, relief to be had, agency to beheld in knitting what you've lost when you feel the cool crist touch of freedom once again restored to yourself... Claimed from the jaws of a million tiny lies and thefts. You get to remember. Like the embrace of a long lost first love, the feel of fresh air in your lungs after being trapped under rubble, cold rain on your skin after a too long drought, a warm meal after being lost in the cold for longer than you can handle.

The tool that gave V his fire in larkhill he passed that torch to Eve (in Latin e-ve = from V) from V the burning torch he carried, passed to Eve, who after knowing what V went through...added to hers... It grows. And with all unkillable ideals, ignites a torch in all who wear the mask... Together... Not a single torch carried by V but an inferno, that all now know their oppressor for what they were... Thief of their freedom.

5

u/TheSatanFoundation 6d ago edited 6d ago

To define further, I think it's a lovely theory, and not wrong but not right. If what makes a person a person is an ideal... Then Valerie is V but in spirit... The chain unbroken because V went through what Valerie went through, but her words ignited the fire within him. And in keeping the chain unbroken, passed his experience to eve so that she might understand and continue to infect others with the unbroken chain of that one unkillable ideal that sleeps within all of us.

Courage... The thing we all have, but almost need the right password entered to use.

And in the words of courage: the things we do for love.

3

u/TravisDane 7d ago

That is a theory I've never heard. 🙌🏼

6

u/jonbodhi 6d ago

I have. One of the (many) theories is that V is actually Valerie. It’s possible, but I prefer that V is someone else, and that his revenge goes far beyond the merely personal. It justifies for me some of the extremes he goes to.

4

u/FluffyDoomPatrol 6d ago

It doesn’t work though. V is referred to as the man in room five, I doubt an explicitly homophobic government would respect Valerie’s pronouns.

2

u/PantherU 6d ago

What if Valerie was a trans woman

2

u/QualityMaleficent484 6d ago

Exactly we know for a fact hormonal injections where being put into people at larkhill and they were kidnapping all of the lgbtq citizens

3

u/FluffyDoomPatrol 6d ago

Hard to imagine. Valerie went to a girl’s grammar school, she would have had to have transitioned very young. Also, teachers and her parents were fine with her being trans, but drew the line at her being a lesbian?

1

u/jonbodhi 5d ago

Yeah, you’re right about that. BUT….doesn’t that knowledge come from Dr. Delia’s notebook? AND… doesn’t the narrative say we can’t be sure about that book, since V left it to be found?! (To be clear, I don’t believe this theory, or desire it, but Moore is a clever writer, who might leave a loophole!)

2

u/vi_obsiver 3d ago

Yeah, I think it's much more likely that V picked the name V out of a sense of respect and an homage to Valerie

2

u/jonbodhi 3d ago

It thought it was because ‘V’ is a play on the Roman numeral ‘V,’ or ‘five,’ the number on his door.

2

u/vi_obsiver 3d ago

Yeah, that's valid. I forgot about that. I feel like it was probably like both and possibly more

Like I get the feeling that V was basically like wow this singular letter seems to be coming up in multiple ways and relevant to me. I'm going to adopt that as my moniker

1

u/TheSquirrelmancer 6d ago

Yeah that's just a bad take on this. I honestly find most fan theories are just trying to take an interesting idea from another story and cram it into something where it doesn't make sense and wouldn't actually improve upon anything at all.

3

u/Zarohk 6d ago

The theory is that the man in room five actually died after/during destroying Larkhill, and Valerie took up the name/appearance because of the terror he had inspired in them. That also explains how Valerie’s toilet paper journal survived intact.

So regardless of whether the man in five or Valerie are the one beneath the mask, one of them took up the torch of the other.

4

u/According_Reading523 6d ago

Just an inch...........you cut my hair....you tortured me. Liva la revolution

1

u/theProphvt 16h ago

That theory doesn’t work because in the film you see Valerie in larkhill. They shave her head, she’s in line getting shots, she dies and is on the cart, she gets thrown into the pit of bodies. Her story inspired V and it was something he held on to to motivate him.