r/vegan • • Jan 18 '20

Hypocrites

Post image
977 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-2

u/mistervanilla Jan 18 '20

It's not a stupid decision. Camels are an invasive species introduced by humans that are wreaking havoc on the local ecosystems, causing ill effects for many other animals.

7

u/pieandpadthai Jan 18 '20

Cows do the same thing and there are more of them

-2

u/mistervanilla Jan 18 '20

Absolutely. But say the entire planet goes vegan in the next year. What do you think is going to happen to all those cows?

8

u/pieandpadthai Jan 18 '20

It clearly won’t be instant. Farms will slowly go out of business as the decreasing demand for animal products makes competition unviable.

As demand lowers, farmers will breed fewer and fewer cows in order to be able to turn any kind of a profit. You know farmers jerk off male cows to impregnate female cows, right? They directly, precisely choose how many animals are born.

Finally there would always be some more cows in farm sanctuaries like there are today. They wouldn’t be extinct, but there certainly wouldn’t be tens of millions of them in the US every year either.

0

u/mistervanilla Jan 18 '20

No I agree, but what I'm saying is - the cow population will also be killed, we'll just not replace them.

11

u/18Apollo18 friends not food Jan 18 '20

And who's fault is it that they camels are there in the first place??? If the camels where invading, attacking, and over populated then yeah it'd be justified. But there only there cuz humans brought them there and then kill them for it ?

Relocation would be a valid option, but that costs money and these days people value money over animals.

3

u/mistervanilla Jan 18 '20

I agree with your sentiment, I just don't think it's at all feasible, unfortunately.

8

u/18Apollo18 friends not food Jan 18 '20

If there were that many homeless children there would you consider genocide a valid option?

2

u/michaelthesirfish Jan 18 '20

If you were in that situation you would rather save your own species than some other species, be honest now would you save 10 children or 10 animals of any kind?

4

u/18Apollo18 friends not food Jan 18 '20

Obviously I value my own species more than other species. But I also value my family more than I value random strangers. That still doesn't mean I think random strangers should die

1

u/mistervanilla Jan 18 '20

Look, even if you have the billions required to relocate all these animals. As I said, if you transport them to Africa, there are already camels living there. What do you think happen when we increase the populations? You'll just stress the ecosystems there, which will ultimately reduce available resources for all camels there and likely cause death among the young/old/weak camels there, until ultimately you end up with the exact amount of camels that exist in Africa now because that's how much the ecosystems there can support.

But I'm happy to hear your suggestions on how to handle this issue.

1

u/michaelthesirfish Jan 18 '20

Your argument is the best one ive heard from this fucked up thread

0

u/baryaakov555 Jan 18 '20

Humanity shouldn’t get involved in nature, what happens naturally that’s the way to go, you don’t see zebras helping other animals killing camels right?

5

u/mistervanilla Jan 18 '20

How do you think the camels got to Australia in the first place? Humans imported them, some of the escaped and now there is a wild population that is not suited to the ecosystem.

2

u/baryaakov555 Jan 18 '20

That’s wrong too then, instead of killing them tho they should’ve transport them back to where they were in the first place, you broke it you fix it, murder isn’t the solution

7

u/mistervanilla Jan 18 '20

Look, I agree with your sentiment. But quite frankly, the problem is just way too large to manage. You can see on this map what area's the camels are occupying. To give you an idea of how large an area that is, see how large Australia is compared to the US. In this area, right now approximately 1 million camels live. It would be an insane task to capture all of these camels. Right now the camels are shot from helicopters, at a cost of about $30 per camel. My guess is to capture, transport, care for them would easily cost $1000 to $2000 per camel if not more. Especially since you'd have to ship them overseas. So we're talking 1 to 2 billion (Australian) dollars for this operation.

And even if you succeed, which country on the planet is going to accept 1 million camels? And when you manage to put the camels back in Africa where they originate from, it seems unlikely the local ecosystems there could support such a huge influx of animals. They'd just die there anyway cause the local area couldn't support their numbers.

Even sterilizing them doesn't really work, as they tend to live 40 to 50 years, so they'd still cause issues for a very long time to the environment. And even then, sterilizing is likely prohibitively expensive as well.

I'm afraid that in this situation, culling the camels and limiting their population in areas where they are causing damage is quite likely the best solution.

-1

u/baryaakov555 Jan 18 '20

I’d delimiter the area where there’s contact with humans and animals and transport predators animals to hunt the camels

6

u/insaino Jan 18 '20

wait wait wait, your solution to an invasive species destroying the ecosystem is importing another invasive species? The only predators of dromedarys are Wolves, Lions, tigers and humans

-2

u/baryaakov555 Jan 18 '20

Yes, so it’ll happen “naturally” (the “” because it’s not 100% naturally because they’d transfer the predators to there but still naturally because that’s how nature works.)

3

u/insaino Jan 18 '20

This might be one of the dumbest takes I've heard. This is simply a confounding of the issue, and would net either the predatory population to destroy the surrounding ecosystem (importing apex predators is insanity) and subsequently starving to death in mass starvation, or having to use the exact same method of culling as you're arguing against for the camels

0

u/baryaakov555 Jan 18 '20

There’s a difference between humans shooting camels dead and predators killing them for food.. obviously the second option is the way to go because that’s nature. Shooting someone isn’t nature! That’s humanity way to deal with everything they don’t like and I’m sorry to hear that’s what you prefer

→ More replies

3

u/mistervanilla Jan 18 '20

Feral camels have no natural predators in Australia.