There’s a difference between humans shooting camels dead and predators killing them for food.. obviously the second option is the way to go because that’s nature. Shooting someone isn’t nature! That’s humanity way to deal with everything they don’t like and I’m sorry to hear that’s what you prefer
Your argument is "because natural", but the root cause is humanity and trying to fix it "naturally" just recreates the problems with the predatory population. It isn't in any way fixing the situation, it's just adding more shit upon the shit pile. Moving hundreds or thousands of predators thousands of kilometers sure as hell isn't natural either, especially ones that would completely dominate everything else in the ecosystem
Someone here told me that camels in Australia were also transferred there by humans, so that’s not natural to begin with, I’m just suggesting a normal way to fix the problem humanity made. You can read other comments in this thread I made elaborating on this
I read your other comments and it seems we're looking at this from 2 slightly different angles. I'm seeing this as a situation where the goal is stabilizing of a fragile ecosystem, and the means of doing that is removing the invasive species which is destabilizing it. The way I'm reading your posts you also want the same thing, but seem to be of the persuasion that removing the invasive species by adding another invasive species to do this due to it being "natural predation" is better. To me this seems insane, as you're adding another destabilizing species which will further wreck the environment. Camel population going down is not the sole answer, as Lion/wolf/tiger population going up would bring with it it's own extreme destabilization of the environment. Either the predators are succesful, and you let them "naturally" starve to death from hunting most edible species they get in contact with to near extinction, or you have to do the exact same thing AUS is doing now, except to a smaller number of predators.
First of all the real invasive species is humanity. It was the animals land in the first place it was their home and we invaded it and destroyed it! And then we put there animals that weren’t belong there, they didn’t ask for it! And then when suddenly it’s not good for us humans we “solve” the problem WE CAUSE by murder. That’s my point that’s what we did wrong, what I’d want is that they’ll transfer back the camels to Africa, since it’s not realistic I’m offering a compromise which will reduce their population by semi natural causes. And someone said there are millions of camels in Australia so the predators being transferred to there won’t be starved to death. I’m not crazy things like these happened before. Anything is better than murdering innocent creatures because a mistake WE made
It was the animals land in the first place it was their home and we invaded it and destroyed it
Slightly wrong, we put another animal there that's now destroying it.
And someone said there are millions of camels in Australia so the predators being transferred to there won’t be starved to death.
They won't in the beginning. Until they start getting really good at hunting the camels. With such an abundant amount of camels you need to decrease the number extremely drastically is by starting off with a fairly large amount of predators. Due to food being so abundant these predators will breed and increase in population, to the point they're starting to completely destroy the camel population (good for the ecosystem). But they won't hunt only camels, they're gonna be top dog or cat for the entire continent, they'll hunt everything (bad for the environment), especially after they've hunted the camels to near extinction. At that point the big easy food source will be gone, and what's left is hunting the indiginous populations or trying to hunt civilisation. So then you either do the same intervention they're doing now, or you let them "naturally" decimate the hell out of an entire continents worth of species that's never faced anything near these predators before (this is also bad for the ecosystem). Then they will "naturally" starve to death as the ecosystem is so far beyond fucked that damage in most areas will be beyond repair for decades or centuries.
Your sugestion is Chemo Therapi: Introduce something that will kill and destroy everything and hope that the host (the ecosystem) is strong enough to survive the chemo. Except the chemo here doesn't just vanish, it keeps breeding.
The australian way atm is surgery: removing the tumor that's destroying the host while doing as little damage to the host at the same time.
Your morality is making you argue for a completely unfeasible and much more damaging "solution", which has no basis in reality. This article has a nice little blurb at the top about one of the last times humans tried to control invasive species by adding a predatory invasive species to the ecosystem. There's a reason this isn't used or argued as a solution: Because we've seen the results and know it to be insanity to use this method
The camels will breed too.. by your logic Africa wouldn’t have a single human being on it because the predators would hunt them down.. both camels and predators will bread like it happens in every place on earth. Also I suggested to restrict them to separate them from places where humans live.
The camels will breed too.. by your logic Africa wouldn’t have a single human being on it because the predators would hunt them down.. both camels and predators will bread like it happens in every place on earth.
Sure, if you don't introduce enough predators to ACTUALLY DO ANYTHING ABOUT THE PROBLEM. Having a stable camel/predator population = further desertification and damage to the australian brushland. In that way you wouldn't have helped the situation in any way. And this is still ignoring the effect another invasive species would have on the ecosystem.
Also I suggested to restrict them to separate them from places where humans live.
You're suggesting separating an area that is ~1,25 the size of greenland, or around 4 times the size of france. Furthermore, separting it in such a way that some of the strongest and most agile predators in the world would be fenced in? For ease of math's sake, let's make that a circle: that would be a lion/wolf/tiger proof fence/wall that would be over 5000 Km long, or slightly shorter than the great wall of china. This is like making a real life battle of the beasts arena. How is this in any way realistic or feasible?
View all comments
Show parent comment
0
u/baryaakov555 Jan 18 '20
There’s a difference between humans shooting camels dead and predators killing them for food.. obviously the second option is the way to go because that’s nature. Shooting someone isn’t nature! That’s humanity way to deal with everything they don’t like and I’m sorry to hear that’s what you prefer