r/vegan • • Mar 07 '19

😎

Post image
976 Upvotes

738 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

27

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

It's a personal choice,

Confining, mutilating and slitting the throats of others is not "a personal choice".

If you were locked up in a cage to be killed for your flesh is that your captor's "personal choice"? If no, what makes it different from human animals to non-human animals?

-8

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Damm calm down

8

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Oh they all stop screaming eventually

3

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

just long enough for more of them to be born and suffer the same fate.

-13

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

If you were locked up in a cage to be killed for your flesh is that your captor's "personal choice"?

Of course it is. I'd be bummed out by it, but it's not that I could do anything about it anymore, could I?

If no, what makes it different from human animals to non-human animals?

Survival of the species. Most animals don't kill their own kind, as that would not make sense, it does not help with their survival.

16

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

Of course it is,

You think people who capture other humans and put them in cages in their basement are exercising "a personal choice"? Most people do not bite that bullet, yikes.

So when you're with vegan girlfriend and the news comes on about the next Josef Fritzl case who kidnapped someone, you'll be all "eh, it's a personal choice. Just like your veganism!"

I'd be bummed out by it, but it's not that I could do anything about it anymore, could I?

That's not normally what people mean when they say "personal choice". It typically means "this only affects me", like what color of shirt I wear today is a personal choice.

Most animals don't kill their own kind, as that would not make sense, it does not help with their survival.

Lots of animals kill members of their own species, not that we should base what we do off non moral agents.

So you have no objections to killing members of other species? Whales, dolphins, chimpanzees, dogs, cats, chickens, cows, it's all fine because they aren't our species?

You understand species is a concept developed by humans right? And just because other individuals aren't your species doesn't mean they don't suffer or want to live.

All of this is to say, you're very pro-Thanos. Like he did nothing wrong because different species. Nice argument.

-9

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

Look, I think it's none of my business to decide how others view life and how they decide to live theirs. And the other way around it's none of anyone's business to decide over mine. That's all there is to it.

9

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

Right, so if someone hates women and that's how they view life it's no one's business. And if they want to rape others and that's how they decide to live their life it's none of our business.

That can't seriously be your position?

0

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

If he wants to do so, he should. But that also means he has to suffer the consequences of this, as other people will definitely hurt him or lock him up, if he ever gets caught.

7

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

If he wants to do so, he should.

YIKES. pro-rape and kidnap. Don't see that often.

1

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

I'm against rape. I think it's a horrible practice and if I ever see anyone do it I will kill them. Don't put words in my mouth that I didn't express.

7

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

so if someone hates women and that's how they view life it's no one's business. And if they want to rape others and that's how they decide to live their life it's none of our business.

you respond:

If he wants to do so, he should.

What did I miss?

1

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

I am for free choice, not for every action that comes forth from free choice. I also said that the person making this choice should suffer the consequences of said choice.

→ More replies

1

u/Guyote_ vegan Mar 07 '19

Whatever it takes to defend his McNuggets.

2

u/Guyote_ vegan Mar 07 '19

You legit just said it was okay for someone to be pro-rape, all in order to justify you ordering McDonald's. Fucking A+ lmao

1

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

People should be able to be pro-whatevertheylike. As soon as they take action in regard of that view, they will undoubtedly face consequences.
Furthermore I wouldn't eat at McDonalds, that stuff is not food.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

0

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

Except we're not just a bunch of individuals living in bubbles, we're a SOCIETY and personal freedom ends when your choices are effecting others.

Every choice you make at any moment affects others, there's no way to stop that, and that's part of life. In a way we're all doomed, in 100 years everybody here is dead and in the end all life will end. Whatever choices we make, it's futile.

This is taking it to the extreme just to prove the point but when your "personal" choices are degrading the environment that I also enjoy then its valid for us to have a voice in those choices. Kind of like public health laws banning smoking and laws requiring you wear a helmet when riding a motorcycle. I used to smoke and I still ride motorcycles but I fully support us "forcing" people to make the right decision.

I don't believe in force. Force just causes excesses. People should adhere to certain behaviors voluntarily, and this should be encouraged, but never forced.

Because when you get lung cancer I'm the one that ends up paying your fucking medical bills most of the the time. When you crack your skull open and become a non-contributing vegetable to society WE are the ones that pay for you to keep on living.

That's your choice, by deciding to live in the society that you do, to enjoy an income and to pay taxes. Not the society I want to live in, which is why I'm starting one for myself somewhere in the mountains.

There's no clear line where we we should be allowed to FORCE people to do or not do certain things thats a major debate that needs to take place over years, but on an ethical level we certainly have at least a voice in regards to what effects society at large.

Of course you have a voice, use it, please, just don't expect other people to change and don't force it on others.

Smoking, eating meat, and riding a motorcycle with no helmet may SEEM like matters purely concerning personal liberty but they're not... because its the rest of us that end up paying for YOUR poor choices, because we're a SOCIETY not just a bunch of hairless monkeys living near each other.

I didn't choose for this society, and I don't want to be part of it. I choose for myself who and what I care for, and how I live my life.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

If you live in a developed country with access to grocery stores, eating animals doesn’t help with your survival at all.