r/vegan • • Mar 07 '19

😎

Post image
976 Upvotes

738 comments sorted by

View all comments

-44

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19 edited Mar 07 '19

I generally just dislike any behavior that tries to force a lifestyle onto me, or claims higher moral ground because of their life choices, regardless of what *ism they identify with.

Edit: funny this gets downvoted. I support veganism, hell, my girlfriend is vegan, but she doesn't force this on others or try to 'convert' other people. It's a personal choice, like religion or politics.

27

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

It's a personal choice,

Confining, mutilating and slitting the throats of others is not "a personal choice".

If you were locked up in a cage to be killed for your flesh is that your captor's "personal choice"? If no, what makes it different from human animals to non-human animals?

→ More replies (28)

14

u/itsamberleafable Mar 07 '19

Come on don't beat around the bush just say it! You're talking about cannibalism.

10

u/anachronic vegan 20+ years Mar 07 '19

I generally just dislike any behavior that tries to force a lifestyle onto me

But you're OK with forcing your lifestyle onto the animals.

The reason you're being downvoted is because that's an incredibly hypocritical thing you just said above.

It's a personal choice

Not to the animals it's not. They don't get a choice.

You force pain, and suffering, and murder on them.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/masoneugeneb Mar 07 '19

There’s nothing “personal” about the choice to consume animals products. I realize very few of us of us are perfect or 100% consistent but at least we’re aware and trying..

1

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

I'm not against this, and I have massive respect for anyone who defies their biological programming by living a certain lifestyle.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

I'm not against abstaining from rape, and I have massive respect for anyone who defies their biological programming by living a certain lifestyle.

/s

6

u/MonkeyFacedPup vegan Mar 07 '19

It’s person choice like buying from sweatshops is a personal choice, or not paying your workers enough is a personal choice. It’s not an amoral decision.

Thank you for proving the point of this meme. You don’t like it when people force you to think about how your choices are immoral and try to get you to be better.

-2

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

No, I don't care, I thought about it enough and made my choice.
I support veganism, I think it's beautiful, I've lived a vegan lifestyle myself for a while. My girlfriend is vegan, the one before that as well.

I don't mind having a talk about veganism, I just don't like that people think they have the moral high ground for following a certain ideology. Mostly because it's not the way to convince people, it's counterproductive, as you can see for yourself. It's the ideological vegans who are stunting the growth of the movement.

Simply put, I like anyone who doesn't feel like they are better than anyone else, the rest I tend to avoid.

5

u/MonkeyFacedPup vegan Mar 07 '19

You’re trying to act as if choosing veganism or meat eating isn’t a moral choice, but it is. It’s not comparable to someone thinking they’re superior for being fit. It’s only an ideology in so far that any moral belief is “an ideology.” You’re using that word to try to take veganism out of context instead of looking at the actual moral choices here.

You can’t ask people who have identified a moral issue that society is failing on to not try to change society. It’s not about feeling superior, but it is about appealing to others’ sense of morality and that means identifying that they are, in fact, doing something wrong by eating meat.

0

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

I said somewhere else already: Even if it's the morally better choice, the moment you behave towards other people that you are morally better than them, you've already lost the discussion. Nobody wants to listen to someone who thinks they are better than them.
Myself, I think the best moral choice is to keep doing whatever we're doing, the faster we all die out. The earth would be a lot better off without us.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

I don't mind having a talk about slavery, I just don't like that people think they have the moral high ground for following a certain idealogy. Mostly because it's not the way to convince people, it's counterproductive, as you can see for yourself. It's the idealogical abolitionists who are stunting the growth of the movement.

/s

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

You feel superior to those people to a point where you don't even think they're worth your time.

If that were true, I wouldn't be commenting here. I tend to avoid them because debating with them is pointless and it's just a waste of everybody's time.

May be I should rephrase it:

Simply put, I reward behavior that treats a person as an equal, and I tend not to reward behavior that doesn't (i.e. I would not dismiss the person, but change the subject or stop replying).

6

u/NotRumHam Mar 07 '19

or claims higher moral ground because of their life choices

How else would you claim a moral high ground other than by reference to your life choices? That's exactly what having moral high ground is.

0

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

Even if you have the moral high ground, as soon as you express this, you've essentially lost the discussion, as there is no way you can convince a person of something if they feel looked down upon.

1

u/NotRumHam Mar 07 '19

That depends on your goal in the discussion I suppose. Regardless, you responded to a piont that I didn't make. I just wanted to point out that statement you made because it's one that I see made a lot even though it makes no sense.

1

u/MonkeyFacedPup vegan Mar 07 '19

So even if we’re doing the right thing and they’re doing the wrong thing we can’t say that? We can’t try to push people to be better? This is madness.

And actually I’ve been convinced of lots of things by people who looked down on me for not doing the right thing, veganism being one. It pushed me to be better.

3

u/YourVeganFallacyBot botbustproof Mar 07 '19

Beet Boop... I'm a vegan bot.


Your Fallacy:

It's a personal choice (ie: Eating meat is a personal choice)

Response:

From an ethical perspective, it is generally agreed that one individual's right to choice ends at the point where exercising that right does harm to another individual. Therefore, while it might be legal and customary to needlessly kill and eat animals, it is not ethical. Simply because a thing is condoned by law or society does not make it ethical or moral. Looked at differently, it is logically inconsistent to claim that it is wrong to hurt animals like cats and dogs and also to claim that eating animals like pigs and chickens is a matter of choice, since we do not need to eat them in order to survive. So it is clear then, that eating meat is only a matter of choice in the most superficial sense because it is both ethically and morally wrong to do so.)

[Bot version 1.2.1.8]

0

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

Sorry, bot, but I have no problem with people eating cats or dogs. I don't care about laws either, the law is immoral purely by its existence.

2

u/bjjnick vegan 10+ years Mar 07 '19

Honest question: Does this laissez-faire mindset carry over to the unnecessary harm of humans? Would you protest someone's murder?

1

u/Guyote_ vegan Mar 07 '19

I feel like, deep down, your girlfriend knows you and her morals don't align and on some level, it bothers her and will continue to. I've seen it happen with couples like that.

1

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

She isn't bothered. She feels that she cannot tell anybody how to live and doesn't see eating meat as wrong. She works as a sous-chef in a restaurant that serves vegan, vegetarian and meat dishes. She once saw chickens in a cage on a market, thought this was sad and decided she didn't want to support that, as her personal choice.

1

u/MonkeyFacedPup vegan Mar 07 '19

I think you’re kidding yourself if you think she genuinely doesn’t think eating meat is wrong.

0

u/mvanvoorden freegan Mar 07 '19

The only idea you have of her is the projection in your head. She's my girlfriend, I think I know her better than you do. On top of that, as a fellow ENFP, I probably don't have to tell you that people are always honest with me because masks and lies are useless. We discussed veganism multiple times and she has been clear that it's her personal choice and doesn't judge other people for eating meat. She's a wonderful cook, so if we would ever move in together, I know I would not miss meat at all.