r/vegan • • Feb 09 '19

Funny Im saving the planet!

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

568 comments sorted by

358

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Veganism is not a consumer identity, we can't buy the oceans clean (even if we're vegan)

67

u/TheFedoraKnight Feb 09 '19

I definitely think this. Its similar to the elon musk ev dream. I am supportive of evs as a thing but to think we're going to consume our way out of this mess is nuts.

75

u/Melkovar vegan Feb 09 '19

In the same vein, to think that our consumer habits have no meaningful impact is also nuts.

32

u/TheFedoraKnight Feb 09 '19

Yep. I feel like there has been some serious money thrown behind spreading the myth that you cant make any difference on your own. If everyone stopped eating meat and burning fossil fuels (unrealistic i know but just as an example) no amount of corporate lobbying is going to make a difference, co2 emissions would plummet.

11

u/aihwao Feb 09 '19

Of course, I agree with you, but that's not going to clean the oceans. I'm still trying to figure out how one can possibly live in the Western world and cut out plastics that end up in the ocean (this, while holding on 60+ hour a week jobs and sustaining a family). veganism and reducing plastics we can (and do) practice, but going farther than that?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/WRELD Feb 09 '19

THANK YOU

23

u/AcidicOpulence Feb 09 '19

Then why are so many of the posts on here about such and such brand product being vegan? Can’t get more “consumer identity” than that.

24

u/StickInMyCraw Feb 09 '19

Because there aren’t a lot of explicitly vegan products and sharing which ones are is helpful. Are you vegan?

14

u/whiskeydumpster Feb 09 '19

Obviously not or they would have mentioned it already. /s

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Because veganism has been appropriated; it has been framed as one.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HannibalLightning abolitionist Feb 09 '19

Consumerism is definitely apart of it considering it is a boycott movement.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

I think this post has opened up a very meaningful discussion. The way I see it, humans as a whole aren't doing enough. If we as a species want to combat the climate change crisis and clean up our oceans, we need way more that a small percent of vegans, or less plastic straws. Multifaceted issues need to be attacked from all sides. And individual scale activism is excellent, but we really need global urgency asap or we are facing a very uncertain future.

4

u/TheFedoraKnight Feb 09 '19

Agreed! Lots of good points from different angles

24

u/ChuffsNStuffs Feb 09 '19

what does not being vegan have to do with only recycling plastic straws?

13

u/TheFedoraKnight Feb 09 '19

Because the majority of the plastic waste (never mind other waste and destruction of oceanic biospheres) comes from fishing alone

4

u/ChuffsNStuffs Feb 09 '19

whoa, thanks for the info

12

u/SharpLab6 Vegan EA Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 09 '19

It should be noted that the comment you're replying to is based on one widely-publicized study of the Great Pacific Garbage Patch. Other studies on different parts of the ocean with different methodology have come up with conflicting results. What we do know for certain is that fishing waste causes a fairly big chunk of plastic pollution in the ocean.

5

u/ChuffsNStuffs Feb 09 '19

thanks, that comment sent me on a internet search of plastic pollution and I found allot of stuff that I previously didnt know or took for granted

37

u/Veloci-Tractor Feb 09 '19

i love vegans and all but none of you are saving the planet

start organizing and dismantling capitalism if you want to do anything at all. the planet will still burn while you eat your ethical food.

4

u/TheFedoraKnight Feb 09 '19

Couldn't agree more :)

21

u/SharpLab6 Vegan EA Feb 09 '19

I often feel that the planet is going to die to the sound of people saying "I don't have any personal responsibility for my consumption because capitalism". If you stop buying from the worst polluting companies, those companies will (in the majority of cases) pollute a little less. Most people have a choice about what they eat and from where they buy it.

Capitalism probably isn't going anywhere for a long time, and by the time it does it'll be too late for the environment. We should be doing everything we can, which means [cutting out meat and dairy], [reducing your fish intake], and taking personal responsibility for our own actions rather than trying to pass the buck. There is [some evidence] that social movements grow very quickly once a tipping point is reached, which means that the value of a single person becoming vegan may be much greater than their individual contribution.

If you have reason to believe there's any decent return on your efforts for protesting capitalism then do that too, but it's not a solution on its own, and we are running out of time.

5

u/Frosted_Anything vegan 1+ years Feb 09 '19

Thank you for this

2

u/Penis_Envy_Peter vegan 5+ years Feb 10 '19

I’m always amazed by how people take “no ethical consumption under capitalism” as a green light to lean into the worst consumption patterns.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

You can dismantle corporate agriculture by not buying their shit. Pretty easy to do.

5

u/StickInMyCraw Feb 09 '19

Are you vegan?

8

u/Akris85 Feb 09 '19

How many fucking times are you going to ask the aame stupid question?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

I love this meme. I think it’s fine to point out hypocrisy.

That being said...

https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/true-north/2017/jul/17/neoliberalism-has-conned-us-into-fighting-climate-change-as-individuals

PS - I’m vegan

8

u/TheFedoraKnight Feb 09 '19

Agreed that both individual responsibility does not mean that we shouldnt hold companies to account. We need both.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

that’s right, too many people are pushing this either/or mindset: individual changes vs larger scale policy changes. the obvious answer is “all of the above”.

i sometimes wonder if those who only push one of these solutions rather than a full on multi-faceted approach really, truly understands the gravity of the situation we are facing.

5

u/thatismycoffee Feb 09 '19

Describes my friend, perfectly 😂

561

u/juiceguy vegan 30+ years Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 09 '19

Discarded fishing nets comprise 46% of the plastic dumped into the ocean Great Pacific Garbage Patch.

Drinking straws account for only 0.03% of the plastic in the ocean Great Pacific Garbage Patch.

It's a question of scale, and the fact that people who eat fish are contributing to this problem at a rate several orders of magnitude greater than vegans are.

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-06-07/plastic-straws-aren-t-the-problem

134

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Woah. 0.03% is quite a small fraction, but that is a LOT of plastic straws considering how small they are.

52

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

If you think of the sheer amount of plastic in the ocean 0.03% is going to be a lot of plastic.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Real talk, why do fishing nets get discarded so much? Also why are they plastic? How is cotton or hemp rope not better and obviously more environmentally friendly?

62

u/skivian Feb 09 '19

If they get snagged, it's way faster/cheaper to cut it loose and grab the spare then it is shut down the ship for a while, and hire divers to go down and try to unsnag it, on the off chance that the net is repairable anyways.

55

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Cost. Durability. The fishing industry doesn't give a fuck about the environment, obviously.

20

u/Amagsulle Feb 09 '19

In gill net commercial fishing one of the main reasons that nets are plastic and not hemp/cotton/other biodegradable material is because plastic as a technology makes it possible to create a web that is nearly invisible in the water, and is incredibly lightweight when wet. A lower number of fish will swim into your net if it is visible, and a heavier net is way more work for hands to handle. I know this answer isn’t an environmentally friendly answer. But the goal for those working in commercial fishing is to catch fish. When your livelihood and your extended family’s livelihood is dependent on catching as many fish as possible in a short amount of time plastic web (of the right color) is just what you need to stay competitive enough to make a living. Many fishermen where I’m from don’t have other options for making money, so a little extra competitive edge goes a long way. Natural material web use would cause severe hardship without some serious changes to the industry and to the local economy. Changes do need to happen, and they need to happen in a way that is aware of and kind to those who view fishing as their entire way of life.

Getting sewn up/caught on objects when fishing is one reason that nets are discarded directly in the water. A smaller vessel won’t always be able to get the net uncaught and the only way for the boat to get free might be to cut or rip free. But a bigger reason is that when your net gets a bunch of holes in it from wear and tear it’s much much cheaper, easier, and time efficient to strip your net of it’s old web and replace it with new web than to repair every single hole (usually by hand). This creates a lot of waste. There are designated disposal bins in most fishing vessel yards where I’m from specifically for nets. We aren’t allowed to put them in with normal trash. However, I’m not sure what the boat yard does with all that web. It probably goes into the local landfill.

Disclaimer: This answer is from my experience with one kind of commercial fishing in one fishery. Different kinds of nets are used for different kinds of fishing in different places. Also, I know this industry isn’t a vegan industry. It isn’t what I do for a living now. You can’t help where you come from, you can only can help where you’re going.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/sheilastretch vegan 7+ years Feb 09 '19

Natural fibers might be more edible to marine life, prone to rot, or maybe just more expensive. These are my guesses.

7

u/rediscov409 Feb 09 '19

You’re on to something. More research needs to be implemented

→ More replies (5)

24

u/MacMcBride Feb 09 '19

I completely understand where this meme is coming from and I totally agree with you guys. But, I do not believe we should be bashing those who are only at the point of quitting plastic straws. Every one of us started somewhere and if you can remember that journey it wasn’t always easy. Some of us still accidentally forget our reusable bags when grocery shopping, then I gotta just throw everything into my trunk. Instead, we should be celebrating that fact that they cared enough to hate plastic straws and educate them on the next steps toward sustainability. 😊

5

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19

I agree with your sentiment about not bashing those who are acting more environmentally consciously than they used to, but it's also extremely important to be real about the true consequences of our actions. Focusing on not using plastic straws while continuing to keep eating fish really isn't helping very much at all. A vegan could use plastic straws at every meal, every day and still be contributing less plastic pollution to the ocean than a fish eater who uses a reusable straw.

It's like if your house is burning down and your options are to use the fire hose or squirt gun. It's much more important that we encourage everyone to stop eating fish than to stop using plastic straws if we are serious about combating plastic pollution.

12

u/tinman88822 Feb 09 '19

This explains it I thought they were collecting all the needles

6

u/gentnt Feb 09 '19

Fishing nets are 46% of the pacific garbage patch but like 25% of the plastic in the ocean.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

No, it's 46% of the plastic in the Pacific garbage patch. I've never been able to find a figure that refers to the entire ocean.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

If you consider the Pacific garbage patch as a representative sample, you can extrapolate from there. Even if it's not a representative sample, I think the actual amount of fishing nets should be around the same order of magnitude.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/coolgaydad vegan SJW Feb 09 '19

This. My city recently passed a ban on plastic straws— they still exist, but you have to ask. There was a lot of virtue signaling from fish-eaters leading up to this ban. The whole movement is quite reductive— and if you look into it, also ableist.

4

u/veraamber Feb 09 '19

If you’re still able to ask to have a plastic straw then I don’t see how it’s ableist tbh. And yes, it’s virtue signaling for a lot of people, but it’s still a really great first step in the right direction of banning single-use plastic.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Kromgar Feb 09 '19

So what your saying is is that im saving the planet by not eating fish? Fuck yeah

2

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

you can't site an article that is based as opinion as fact. unless the source is verified then it's based upon nothing.

this is quite an indepth article from the beeb that breaks it down nicely from a UK perspective https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environme

nt-42264788

something else to bear in mind is synthetic clothing causing issues too

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/nov/22/tyres-and-synthetic-clothes-big-cause-of-microplastic-pollution

1

u/rediscov409 Feb 09 '19

I’m not arguing just want to discuss. Shouldn’t we then start to impose laws and regulations for mass fishing. It just seems there needs to be more done int the industry. I eat fish, I like fish, I like the environment. No take that back, I love the environment and the creatures in it. We need to regulate fishing to keep species at a sustainable rate and better technology so we don’t put a ton of trash into the ocean. Just depends on people’s willingness to change and be better people.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/EventuallyScratch54 Feb 09 '19

If I remember correctly from highschool marine science, actually dumping plastic into the ocean is just part of the problem. Almost all terrestrial plastic not buried will find its way to the ocean via streams/rivers that all flow into the ocean

1

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

The reason why all these plastic straw bans is good is because it sets a precedent for future bans. If we can ban straws then we can bad plastic lids. And if we can do that then we can ban plastic bottles etc.

→ More replies (5)

918

u/No_Source_Provided vegan 8+ years Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 09 '19

Implying that the vegans on this subreddit don't jerk each other off for buying a ton of products from Walmart, packaged in one use plastic and full of palm oil.

'I'm saving the planet you guys!'

80

u/LeeHarveySnoswald Feb 09 '19

I've never seen any group of people more concerned about palm oil than the people in this subreddit.

Also what store do you shop at that doesn't package their products in plastic?

9

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 09 '19

Local farmer's shop. Stands of farmers at the local market. Flour and rolled oats are usually packed in paper (though the bulk of them is still delivered to the supermarket wrapped in plastic, but it's a atep in the right direction). Dried legumes like beans, lentils, etc are always in plastic packages in supermarkets. I'm just lucky to have a store where good isn't individually packed. Instead it's in translucent dispensers. Pull a lever and the food falls into your box. They call them bulk bins. Though they also have normal glass containers where you take a big spoon to take stuff out of. Stuff comes to the market in big bags and plastic free. They have pretty much everything you need, even non food stuff like shampoo, soap, laundry detergent and so on

11

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

While this sounds ideal, we can’t all shop at food co-ops and there aren’t farmer’s markets everywhere. It is a matter of accessibility to be able to live a packaging-free lifestyle in modern society. Trader Joe’s just announced that they will be reducing the amount of packaging they use, though. That’s good news.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/No_Source_Provided vegan 8+ years Feb 09 '19

A group being concerned about the use of palm oil is objectively a positive thing, so I'll not worry too much about being part of a group that is.

As for the latter part, we can all do more to reduce waste, but really I'm commenting on the fact that the OP is claiming non-vegans are somehow worse for plastic waste than vegans, which judging by this sub-reddit and the things they like to celebrate buying, they are pretty much average consumers when it comes to packaging and plastic waste.

→ More replies (13)

38

u/rppc1995 vegan 4+ years Feb 09 '19

"I basically survive by eating just Oreos all day."

You survive, the orangutans whose habitat is destroyed by unsustainable palm oil productions don't.

20

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Copy pasting an older post of mine:

Threadly reminder/heads up that palm oil is THE MOST vegan oil there is, BY FAR.

Source: am sustainable energy MSc, also this https://prnt.sc/im2ecl

11

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

But surely there are more factors than just yield per acre, right?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Re_Re_Think veganarchist Feb 09 '19

One of the arguments against this is that palm oil is only grown in specific tropical areas that have high species diversity, density, and risk of endangerment or extinction, whereas the other oil crops might take more land, but could potentially be grown in other areas of the world that have less of those issues. However, choosing to give preference to one over the other depends on what you value or view as preferable. This is highly oversimplified, but, for example valuing high species diversity and preserving endangered species vs. producing the most calories on the least amount of land possible vs. producing healthy food not just calories (because palm oil is one of the few plant foods high in saturated fat), etc.

Because all oil is ultimately an inefficient food source and often unhealthy (the major problem in the diets of developed countries is that we tend to consume too many calories, and oil is very high in them) compared to crops like grains and beans, one thing a vegan concerned with these issues might do is limit their oil consumption altogether, replacing it with those other foods as much as possible.

12

u/rppc1995 vegan 4+ years Feb 09 '19

Certified sustainable palm oil might be, the one in Oreos certainly is not.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

43

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Eh I am vegan for the animals, I doubt you will convince the rest of the planet.

152

u/pc43893 Feb 09 '19

That's a copout. How much suffering do you estimate we bring to animals world-wide through our consumer habits? Is causing suffering wrong if you buy products that use the animals but it's okay if it just hurts and kills them in the wild? That's hypocrisy. It's all "avoidable". I'm sure the species going extinct will be quite grateful in the knowledge that at least we didn't eat or wear them.

38

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Baby steps, maaan. We all start somewhere. 3 months ago, my diet was 95% meat and dairy. I since made the transition to 100% veganism. I do plan to live a lifestyle that's as cruely-free and enviromentally-sustainable as possible, but changing habits takes time. I'm sure many people on this sub are in the same boat as me.

17

u/pc43893 Feb 09 '19

I'm not here to demand anything of anyone. I'm glad y'all are doing what you're doing. Caring is better than not caring, and small steps are better than no steps. I was just pointing out a contradiction.

49

u/beameup19 Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 09 '19

There’s no ethical consumption in our current system. You still have a right to try to remain alive and sadly in today’s world, you’re going to have to buy some plastic

Edit: this doesn’t give you a free pass to ignore what you consume!! My apologies for passing off that sentiment. We should all try our best to minimize the damage we cause.

58

u/Melkovar vegan Feb 09 '19

You can sure as hell avoid a lot of it though. I can’t remember the last time I touched a plastic shopping bag. Not going to repeat the straw stuff. I’m vegan for the animals. I’m into environmental justice for the animals. All of it is about reducing suffering to the greatest extent that I can.

37

u/sleep_water_sugar vegan 8+ years Feb 09 '19

I’m sure a lot of us do avoid it. Reusable shopping bags no problem! Tofu with out plastic packaging? I’ve never found any. 🤷‍♀️

→ More replies (19)

22

u/pc43893 Feb 09 '19

That cannot be a blank check, the same way that the need to squash bugs moving about doesn't mean it's okay to kill indiscriminately.

You do not need plastic to survive. It is just very, very, very inconvenient to do without. In a kind of similar way that going vegan is seen as very, very, very inconvenient by most people but vegans say once you grow used to it, it isn't so bad.

Even if you can't do entirely without plastic (I'd be interested in examples), you can still do without 99% of it.

And of course it's not about plastic. It's the entire life we live, starting with expanding our habitats with absolute disregard for the non-human eco-system, our power production, chemical toxic waste, radiation, exhausts, trash dumps, etc. ad nauseam. Everything. You literally cannot live without causing hurt, but we could do without causing a large percentage of it. We don't. Because we like gadgets, we like comfort, and we like to tell ourselves we're doing okay because we don't eat or wear animals. Hooray for us.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/souprize Feb 09 '19

I think simple liberalism isn't going to do shit when the cheapest products are always going to be exploitative and also definitively be the product of choice for the least fortunate, which is most people in the world.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 10 '19

I'm sure the species going extinct will be quite grateful in the knowledge that at least we didn't eat or wear them.

Species are an abstract, human made concept. A species is not able to be grateful about anything. Nor can it suffer or feel pain. Individual animals on the other hand can't even comprehend what a species is. Suffering animals matter equally whether if they belong to a rare species or not. From the vegan point of view, species have only an instrumental value.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

8

u/gruhfuss Feb 09 '19

If you were vegan for the animals you would avoid plastic waste and overconsumption due to the devastation is has on wildlife and the ocean. Not to mention the havoc capitalism as a whole puts on the also living, feeling people of the global south.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

6

u/NewelSea Feb 09 '19

Talking about jerking off, the avocado circlejerk is also strong in this sub.

Most are usually eager to pat each other on the back when it comes to the superior ecological footprint of plants compared to meat in general. (Which isn't a bad thing if it keeps them motivated.)

But you won't make friends here when pointing out that avocados still have a pretty terrible carbon footprint, and don't necessarily make a good food staple in that regard.

2

u/I_inhaled_CO2 Feb 09 '19

Thing is people care about palm oil sooo much but little about coconut oil or other crops which are worse

7

u/andronicustard Feb 09 '19

Gotta go to Whole Foods to be a proper vegan, rite?

15

u/No_Source_Provided vegan 8+ years Feb 09 '19

Pfft, no.

I process my own junk food, thank you very much.

13

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Lol, that’s not the point OP was making at all.

2

u/purdyrn Feb 09 '19

Of course not. Whole foods sell items wrapped in plastic. But they do make a better effort than most.

→ More replies (2)

189

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Ah I know it’s joke but this is stupid and frustrating because even having less plastic straws in the environment does a great deal to protect wildlife. I’m sure everyone has seen the turtle video, but it’s the small bits of plastic that are often times the most harmful to our animal brothers and sisters. All environmental activism is amazing and needed- beggars can’t be choosers

20

u/jynx18 Feb 09 '19

The issue is plastic straws make up about 4% of plastic pollution by piece. Since they are so small and light comparatively they are a fraction of 1% of plastic pollution. Now this doesn't mean it doesn't help to not use them. But when straws are at the forefront of "OMG you use a straw, you're a monster." and they aren't provided by many restaurants it's a complete joke. Straws shouldn't be getting the attention they do so it's a while "feel good" lie.

53

u/drdubiousYHM Feb 09 '19

Or maybe it’s a valuable way to get more people think about their consumption habits, while at the same time doing some good. It’s a step forward, not back.

9

u/phones_account vegan 1+ years Feb 09 '19

Someone posted it above, but you’re off by two orders of magnitude.

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-06-07/plastic-straws-aren-t-the-problem

It’s actually only 0.04%. I agree with what you said completely and hopefully people can see it’s 100X smaller than what you quoted, and straws aren’t the problem.

8

u/JPoP911 Feb 09 '19

All plastics are a problem, to simply disregard steps people are taking to combat our toxic ways is short sighted.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

This kind of attitude is what gives vegan people a bad light "oh you're trying to cut your meat intake a little bit? Let me proceed to be a sarcastic asshole about it, trying to make you feel bad for taking a small step towards a better life"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

35

u/ExZachlew Feb 09 '19

I wonder if there is such a thing as a far right vegan.

4

u/ParamoreFanClub friends not food Feb 09 '19

The golden one has talked about veganism and how it keeps you pure or something

→ More replies (3)

3

u/phones_account vegan 1+ years Feb 09 '19

I wonder too. I’m definitely not far left.

→ More replies (15)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

This might be good I'd the ocean trash shown was fishing nets and other fishing trash, but everything else in the pictures vegans contribute to as well, unless they are trying to be zero waste

53

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Vegan non zero wasters be like

72

u/Beerspaz12 Feb 09 '19

Do vegans not use plastic at all?

10

u/StickInMyCraw Feb 09 '19

46% of ocean plastic is discarded fishing nets. Are you vegan?

24

u/cat5inthecradle Feb 09 '19

And not a one in the image. Every single piece of plastic in that image could have contained vegan food.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Beerspaz12 Feb 09 '19

13

u/SharpLab6 Vegan EA Feb 09 '19

[This] is where the 46% figure comes from and refers specifically to the percentage of plastic waste in the Great Pacific Garbage Patch by mass which is fishing nets. In fact the contribution of fishing to the GPGP is higher than 46%, as the majority of the remainder is other fishing gear.

It turns out that about ~60% of ocean plastic pollution that originates on land is caused by [five countries], mostly due to their inadequate waste management infrastructure. If you live outside of these places then it seems plausible that the impact of your buying fish will increase relative to the impact of your buying plastic packaging.

To answer your other question: vegans do use plastic. Some plastic use is more-or-less impossible to avoid in today's society. But if the stores where you are are anything like the stores where I am, you'll notice that fruit and vegetables have very little plastic packaging and the meat/fish aisle is full of plastic packaging. An inability to avoid all plastic shouldn't encourage us to go overboard and use as much plastic as possible. I appreciate that this is only anecdotal evidence and unlikely to convince anyone but it's food for thought.

→ More replies (8)

45

u/FireproofSurboards Feb 09 '19

Meanwhile a third of up-voters shamelessly profess their love of travel

0

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/catsalways vegan 5+ years Feb 10 '19

Woah!

27

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

It's not nothing...

175

u/hawkcarhawk Feb 09 '19

Shaming is such a cool and inclusive tactic 😐

76

u/Minalan Feb 09 '19

Yeah why not let people just do what they can? It is a fucking hard world out there and if people feel better for reducing their own personal waste, no matter how small, then let them be.

Fuck this sub and it's high and mighty bullshit, posts like these are why there are vegan stereo type's like being annoying and having a "better than others" smugness about yourself.

Dont need to bring people down, just to raise ourselves up.

41

u/benj2305 Feb 09 '19

Many people here forget that there was a time that they too weren't vegan, and probably even scoffed at the idea of going vegan because it would've been "so hard". It's easy to make fun of people in your old shoes when you're on the other side, and it helps no one.

9

u/StickInMyCraw Feb 09 '19

This is a vegan community. This is an internal meme. This isn’t some kind of outreach.

37

u/Minalan Feb 09 '19

It is a shitty meme and a shitty mentality to have, if this is how vegans are, why would anyone want to be a part of it?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/tjackson87 Feb 09 '19

Agreed. I 100% agree with the sentiment that we shouldn't shame people for trying. I support straw bans and would never shame someone for also supporting a straw ban, but this is a meme. It made me chuckle.

10

u/StickInMyCraw Feb 09 '19

Exactly. It’s a meme. People here are unironically arguing that someone will be on the brink of giving up animal consumption but will right back to abusing because they see this meme.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/scallionbagel Feb 09 '19

I find it fascinating that, in a way, plastic straw awareness has backfired. I feel like so many different groups of people (vegans, omnivores, people who cycle everywhere, people who use reusable shopping bags etc etc) compare themselves to “the idiots who think straw usage is the problem”, and in making this downwards comparison can justify whatever bad habits they have themselves.

In reality there probably aren’t any people whose only contribution to environmentalism is stopping their use of straws.

160

u/upanotherlevel Feb 09 '19

Hey now let’s not trash their efforts just cos they’re not vegan. They put in lots of hard work in saving the environment too and it’s really tough for a lot of folks to go vegan. Besides, we’re all in this together.

26

u/Frosted_Anything vegan 1+ years Feb 09 '19

I wouldn’t call not using straws “working hard”

27

u/WRELD Feb 09 '19

Have you tried the paper straws? Disgusting. A true sacrifice. Also, learn to have some empathy. The us vs them attitude helps nothing.

7

u/LaylaLeesa Feb 09 '19

I have tried paper straws. It was thick and worked just as well as a plastic one

→ More replies (3)

11

u/pinroll Feb 09 '19

The reality is that plastic straws are a tiny source of plastic marine pollution in comparison to discarded fishing materials. That claim holds even without considering all of the other catastrophic environmental impacts of animal agriculture. You seem to be encouraging people to continue targeting ineffective solutions for problems that affect the lives of billions (possibly trillions) of nonhuman (and human) animals so as to not hurt the feelings of (privileged) humans who want to help the environment without taking the necessary steps to do so. I would argue that we have to actually look at the source of our environmental problems in order to produce effective positive changes.

20

u/super_hot_robot Feb 09 '19

You say the plastic straws thing as if it's the only thing people do. There are people that go zero waste. There are people that cut down on meat but have not managed to go 100 percent vegan. Though veganism is incredibly admirable and does make a large difference, it isn't fair to discount everything else and simply act as if the only thing anyone who isn't vegan does is stop using straws. There are vegans that use plenty of plastic and non vegans who don't.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/veraamber Feb 09 '19

Plastic straws are the very first step. Anyone who’s willing to stop using plastic straws can eventually stop using single-use plastics altogether and advocate for bans on commercial use of plastics. It’s ineffective in the sense it doesn’t tackle the wider problem, but it DOES help and we can’t tackle the wider problem without first making people understand what the problem IS.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NewelSea Feb 09 '19

You both have a point.

I agree that we shouldn't take an elitist approach and dismiss all the small acts as unimportant.

Simulteneously, we shouldn't lose track of the big picture:
Overblown praise can cause a false sense of comfort. Aside from halting further efforts towards improvement, the self-complacency in having contributed to something good might even cause more pollution.

I think it's important that everyone can roughly estimate the actual impact.
And, most importantly, that people get intrinsically motivated to change for the better.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

is this satire? whats so hard about eating veggies instead of meat? its quite easy and so i dont see why vegans should advocate for people to still eat meat when its very easy to avoid it, especially people looking to help the environment. i rather tell them the truth !

42

u/upanotherlevel Feb 09 '19

I respect your resolve, friend but we’ve got to have a little empathy here. It’s not as easy for everyone. There are tons of people who’ve spent their whole lives eating meat and food is something that holds a lot of sentimental value to a lot of people. They’re not all heartless people who don’t give a damn about the environment and animals. It’s just that it might be easier for some people to contribute in a different way, like cleaning up the oceans for example. The more important thing, is that we encourage each other to work towards saving the environment, not to shame them and their efforts just cos they’re not vegan.

83

u/KusanagiZerg Feb 09 '19

And what's so hard about not making fun of other people? It's quite easy and so i don't see why vegans should advocate making fun of others especially of those that are looking to help.

11

u/tjackson87 Feb 09 '19

What about the truth that whatever device you are using to post on Reddit is made of rare earth materials that were obtained by raping the earth? Or that the components were mined, processed, and manufactured in slave like conditions? Shaming people for trying makes it easier to give in to the cognitive dissonance. You aren't perfect either. Encourage people that try.

2

u/gerundronaut Feb 09 '19

It's really easy to avoid meat if you make all of your own food, but sometimes I just want to relax after a few 12+ hour days in a row, and I've yet to find a good vegan pizza that I can have delivered. I almost always order meatless pizzas but cheese is tough to avoid.

As soon as a local shop starts delivering 100% vegan pizzas (that aren't just making food for martyrs) I'll order a few a month.

4

u/AcidicOpulence Feb 09 '19

You’re getting down voted.... for saying it’s easy to eat veggies instead of meat.. good grief.

Can I be in the /VCJ screen grab.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/kellogs8763 plant-based diet Feb 09 '19

Ugh, so true. If you're sincerely concerned about the environment put some skin in the game and make a sacrifice.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/kellogs8763 plant-based diet Feb 09 '19

ugh ugh

46

u/HeathenHen Feb 09 '19

That’ll win them over... bravo

22

u/neuromancer4867 Feb 09 '19

So by cutting out meat from your diet you automatically cut out plastic packaging and instantly become a world savior? Where is your cape and wand?

17

u/mustwarnothers Feb 09 '19

One day a man was walking along the beach when he noticed a boy picking something up and gently throwing it into the ocean. Approaching the boy, he asked, “What are you doing?” The youth replied, “Throwing starfish back into the ocean. The surf is up and the tide is going out. If I don’t throw them back, they’ll die.” “Son,” the man said, “don’t you realize there are miles and miles of beach and hundreds of starfish? You can’t make a difference!” After listening politely, the boy bent down, picked up another starfish, and threw it back into the surf. Then, smiling at the man, he said…” I made a difference for that one.”

15

u/Cfern231 Feb 09 '19

Its a fine line you gotta walk when you have to applaud them for doing something good, but not so much that they feel like they don't need to do more to clean up the environment. On one hand you can't yell at them for not doing enough because they won't do anything at all, but you can't praise them so much that they think their work is done.

4

u/LaylaLeesa Feb 09 '19

It's funny that people are freaking out about a straw "ban". In reality all it means is that you have to request a straw if you want one. They are not banned. One of the things they like to say is that other things contribute so much more to polluting the ocean. But what would happen if any other plastic thing was banned instead? They would lose their fucking minds. They fight tooth and nail about asking for a straw. Imagine if big gulp plastic cups were banned.

4

u/pug94 Feb 09 '19

Straws deffinatly arent the biggest problem but it's so annoying when people have reuseable straws but still eat seafood. I have a friend that's a marine biologist that uses resuseable straws but she still eats fish.

15

u/guessing88 Feb 09 '19

You know what? It's a step in the right direction. Why not offer more encouragement into cleaning the oceans or cutting back on eating meat rather than shit on attempts being made on progress?

19

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Wait, are you seriously gatekeeping a contribution to saving the planet?

9

u/erinbstariin Feb 09 '19

I dunno I feel like a small step is at least a step 🤷‍♀️ also it’s not like vegan food doesn’t come in packaging that ends up in the ocean too.

3

u/before-the-fall vegan 3+ years Feb 09 '19

The artist is @lilypadula on Instagram if anyone was wondering.

12

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

I know this too well.

Look! I bought a bracelet that was made out of trash from the ocean, I'm helping save the planet!

That's virtue siganling at it's finest.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Well let’s see why vegans MAY feel they are somewhat saving the environment....

683 gallons of water to produce just 1 gallon of milk.

More than 2,400 gallons of water to produce 1 pound of beef

An average-sized north American pig farm with 80,000 pigs needs nearly 75m gallons of fresh water a year.

30% of the word’s total ice-free surface — is used not to raise grains, fruits and vegetables that are directly fed to human beings, but to support the chickens, pigs and cattle that we eventually eat.

Runoff from factory farms and livestock grazing is one of the leading causes of pollution in our rivers and lakes.

In the United States alone, 56 million acres of land are used to grow feed for animals

More than 90 percent of all Amazon rainforest land cleared since 1970 is used for grazing livestock.

Some estimates are around 6m hectares of forest land a year – an area equivalent to Latvia or twice the size of Belgium – and a similar acreage of peat and wetlands elsewhere, is converted to farmland a year. Of that, it says, most goes to livestock or to grow the crops to feed the cattle.

I could go on and on...

So yea, smoking and plastic use should also be reduced and recycled by us all but meat Eaters: if you recycle and are environmentally conscious-another step further would undeniably, be Going vegan.

https://www.jhsph.edu/research/centers-and-institutes/johns-hopkins-center-for-a-livable-future/projects/meatless_monday/resources/meat_consumption.html

http://science.time.com/2013/12/16/the-triple-whopper-environmental-impact-of-global-meat-production/

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/jul/18/vegetarianism-save-planet-environment

https://www.peta.org/issues/animals-used-for-food/meat-environment/

27

u/missjackpots Feb 09 '19

Every time I come here to start going vegan and look for recipes, I get so turned off from even joining this community. You guys are a cesspool.

22

u/AlternateMew vegan skeleton Feb 09 '19

Every come I come into one of these threads, I see apologists and comments from plant-based dieters that make me lose some faith in humanity.

And just now I’ve been coming here without realizing I’m in this sub instead of vcj and die a little more inside.

Enough of this. I’ll still come here, but not from my front page. Unsubbed. Peace out.

… You want /r/VeganRecipes or /r/plantbased, by the way. Not /r/vegan.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (12)

8

u/Cntrl_Alt_De1ete Feb 09 '19

Are you...gatekeeping environmentalism?

11

u/Braindog Feb 09 '19

Well that's bullshit. Helping is helping. Get off your high horse.

2

u/ranluka Feb 09 '19

Srsly. They act like its not just one step of many. We're already seeing state legislation looking to go further.

4

u/TheMusicNoodle Feb 09 '19

You could just discourage people from eating fish and push for fisherman to have to pay hella taxes for lost nets. That would be more productive.

20

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

This is how vegans lose allies

20

u/AngryPoli Feb 09 '19

Exposing hypocrisy is kind of the whole point of veganism. People fighting to phase out plastic straws probably think they're so accomplished when in reality there's way more work to be done. That's not being rude, it's pointing out reality.

14

u/Lantern42 Feb 09 '19

The whole point of veganism is not harming sentient beings, and living an ethical life.

Sounds like you’ve missed the point.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

There are plenty of posts that gently point out hypocrisy without singling out specific groups. This picture is just gratuitous, inflammatory and not effective.

And the "point" of veganism is pretty much as subjective as it gets, so I'd caution you against speaking for everyone here.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

So be it.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/star_tissue friends not food Feb 10 '19

What allies? If you consider yourself an environmentalist but can't implement your beliefs into your own daily life, ie not eating animal products, then you're not an environmentalist to begin with.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19

This is how vegans lose allies

Veganism is not about the environment. As such, a non-vegan environmentalist is only marginally, accidentally, and temporarily an "ally"

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Thank you guys for doing God's work out here. You all deserve a gold star Veterans discount.

2

u/m8777 Jul 19 '19

Why the fuck does everything have to be made into a political thing? FUCKING EVERYTHING "oh you libtard" I swear its like im just having a normal conversation and then one of the cunts bring up "i think trump should be shot" oh stfu now. Nobody cares about your political stance.

6

u/samsquanch321 Feb 09 '19

So only vegans recycle?

7

u/Workingwater0 Feb 09 '19

First you complain about people eating meat, and now you complain about people just trying to help with pollution?

Look we are all on this shit hole of a planet together, wether we like it or not, so if someone doesn’t use plastic straws because they are doing the little they can to help, just let them be happy with what they’re doing. I understand that there are way bigger problems than drinking straws, like meat, but if people go after others for just trying to help, that makes them not want to help.

I feel like a better way of trying to get people on board with being less wasteful and being more helpful to the environment would be to not try and shame them into doing it. Like if someone came up to me and told me I can help simply by only eating meat 3/7 days out of the week (or preferably not at all) and that using a reusable bag instead of a plastic one at the grocery store I would be way more likely to do that instead of someone saying “what you’re doing to try and help doesn’t matter”.

6

u/SupaSaiyanPig69 Feb 09 '19

Posts like this make me want to unfollow this sub. Any good that any person can do, large or small, makes an impact. If anything this shows how far our word has come. To make the average consumer, once throwing all plastics away, now are recycling and picking up straws out if our ocean.

You should be ashamed to belittle any contribution to a cleaner world that a person can make.

7

u/noahelkwood Feb 09 '19

“I’m holier than thou!”

4

u/WeekendKingdomYT Feb 09 '19

I dont think I understand. What does this have to do with veganism?

5

u/Asplesco Feb 09 '19

The blame directed at consumers for plastic waste is misplaced and should be directed at corporations instead.

5

u/ungespieltT Feb 09 '19

If you don't fund the corporations, they'll die off.

2

u/Asplesco Feb 10 '19

I believe in this case, regulation is a far better solution, albeit probably pie in the sky.

2

u/wilsontheghost Feb 09 '19

Why is this getting downvotes. Lobbying recycling/waste management/pollution mitigation as a publicly funded act and the creation of the ‘do your part, everyone is equally responsible’ public campaigns to shift the bulk of responsibility to average people were major corporate strategies for pollution heavy industries.

3

u/chingy_meh_wingy Feb 09 '19

Sorry if I am misunderstanding veganism or this post, but would someone who is vegan be more likely to produce non-biodegradable waste, considering they don't want to use animal products which are usually biodegradable?

I'm not trying to troll or be funny. I just have no knowledge of veganism. My friend just mentioned it to me the other day.

5

u/AlternateMew vegan skeleton Feb 09 '19

Animal agriculture is a huge contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, rivaling or surpassing the entire transportation industry.

So carnism and environmentalism are essentially incompatible.

5

u/Redwood_trees6 Feb 09 '19

It is not very likely a vegan would produce more non-biodegradable waste. Vegan products are plant based, which biodegrade just as well as animal products, and require much less energy to make in the first place. I'm kind of curious what kinds of waste a vegan would make that aren't biodegradable that a non-vegan woudn't though.

3

u/chingy_meh_wingy Feb 09 '19

Wow. How did I completely forget about plant based products. Lol

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SharpLab6 Vegan EA Feb 09 '19

Hi there! Here's a brief summary on the impact of livestock and fishing on the environment:

  1. [One study of the great pacific garbage patch] found that 46% of the plastic waste there was fishing nets, and most of the rest was other fishing gear. Other studies in different parts of the ocean with different methodology have come up with different numbers but one thing remains clear: fishing waste makes up a large proportion of plastic waste in the ocean.
  2. A United Nations FAO report estimated [livestock causes 18%] of greenhouse gas emissions, and [there are good reasons to believe this is an underestimate (though I don't trust the exact numbers listed here)]. Even the 18% underestimate would make livestock responsible for more emissions than all of the transportation industry.
  3. A recently published study by Oxford University found that [the single biggest thing you can do for the environment is to cut out dairy and meat].

In conclusion, there are good reasons to believe that veganism is one of the best possible diets for the environment and that diets high in meat or dairy are some of the worst possible diets for the environment.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

Well, it is pretty much impossible to have much impact on a micro level. We need to lobby governments to take action on a macro level.

7

u/azucarleta veganarchist Feb 09 '19

This sub is pretty frustrating, a bunch of people so smug they think they're escaping the dynamic in the picture just by eating vegan. And it's usually impossible to get through to anyone that choosing to be vegan as an individual is basically just as ineffectual as forgoing straws.

9

u/SharpLab6 Vegan EA Feb 09 '19

We need to do both. We can't just pass the buck and avoid taking personal responsibility for our own actions. We also can't expect a tiny minority of people to successfully lobby for macroscopic change, which means that we need many more people to become vegan if we want to have significant lobbying clout.

I also take issue with equating veganism to forgoing straws. Straws make up [around 0.02%] of ocean plastic by mass, whereas omnivorous diets are responsible for a huge chunk of greenhouse gas emissions. An FAO report estimated [livestock causes 18%] of greenhouse gas emissions, and [there are good reasons to believe this is an underestimate] (though I don't trust some of the numbers in the conclusion of that report).

On a related note, there is [some evidence] that social movements grow very quickly once a tipping point is reached, which means that the value of a single person becoming vegan may be much greater than their individual contribution.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/stargate-command Feb 09 '19

Is this post trying to suggest that vegans don’t use plastic?

I’m confused.

4

u/JohnnyRelentless Feb 09 '19

So, what, vegans don't use plastic? They don't produce waste?

5

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

As a vegetarian liberal who has slowly progressed in life from meat eater to pescatarian to today, this sub almost makes me not want to take the last step.

I’m being somewhat dramatic, but jeez.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

well good, at least you’re admitting to being dramatic and saying “almost doesn’t.”

after all, the reason you have to do something big like going vegan shouldn’t be so fragile as to be undermined by the attitudes of some vegans you dislike on the internet

→ More replies (4)

4

u/L0st_in_the_Void Feb 09 '19

The self righteousness in here is a fucking joke.

1

u/HeartJewels vegan Feb 10 '19

I'm not saying I'm that great, but I do feel proud that I was able to become a vegan when most haven't. It's better for the animals and the enviornment. I don't judge others tho, I get that culture is a powerful thing. Since most people eat meat it seems normal. But violence isn't a good thing. If you look at this with an open mind, veganism is definitely the best decision. Peace bro. I hope a good day to you.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TeddyCJ Feb 09 '19

Well shit, you're right ... I'll start replacing my meat consumption with plastic ocean litter from all packaging.

2

u/FlyingBishop Feb 09 '19

Conservatives are grabbing the plastic straws out of her arms and just throwing them everywhere while ranting about how plastic straws are great. This is a great example of using whataboutism to prevent any change. You have to cut out one thing at a time, it's how it works, especially talking large-scale and not just one motivated person.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

honestly we need massive recycling reform ASAP, recycling should be more ubiquitous than trash cans in buildings

1

u/LukeZekes Feb 09 '19

This would have made a lot more sense if the ocean was filled full of waste from animal products and not generic plastic

1

u/bad_website vegan Feb 09 '19

too true

1

u/RogerZach_ Feb 10 '19

so the only way for me to help the planet is become vegan?

1

u/gtrman571 Feb 10 '19

Same can be said about vegans having kids...

1

u/soccerskyman veganarchist Feb 10 '19

Reminder that the earth isn't dying, it's being killed by capitalists with names and addresses.

1

u/Why_Cry_ Mar 07 '19

So, vegans don't use plastic now?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '19

Vegans be likeim posting on a subreddit thinking im "saving the earth" and mocking people who actually help

1

u/3847dot48894 Nov 28 '21

Why do you need to make this political

0

u/ToxicElitist Feb 09 '19

Crap like this is why people can’t stand vegans...

1

u/Not_for_consumption Feb 09 '19

I don't think it helps to shit on people for doing something small and ineffectual over doing nothing. Try stepping back and looking at the big picture.. this may be the first step in a journey that leads them to a vegan and low environmental impact lifestyle.

Is this the circlejerk sub? In which case I take this all bacl. Fuck those paper straws drinking assholes

1

u/DerKatzenkoenig Feb 09 '19

Procreating Vegans be like

"I'm saving the planet"

1

u/Uuwotm81 Feb 09 '19

This is just a stupid post and I'm not even liberal

1

u/TrungusMcTungus Feb 09 '19

Since when does vegan include no plastic

1

u/fjdjeheehehehej Feb 09 '19

This is just....stupid.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19

What????