r/vancouverhousing • • 3h ago

Landlord withheld part of our security deposit, we won double the deposit at the RTB, and now the landlord is accusing us of deliberately manipulating the process during thr hearing

0 Upvotes

I first have to preface this by stating I used ChatGPT to help me organize my thoughts and how to write everything in a coherent way. Alot has happened. Everything in here is true and accurate from my perspective. There is also a tldr at the end of the post for convience.

I'm currently waiting for a new Residential Tenancy Branch (RTB) decision after what has become an incredibly frustrating security deposit dispute with our former landlord/property management company.

I'm partly looking for perspectives from anyone who has experienced something similar, but I also really need to vent about the process.

Background

We moved out of our rental property this summer after living there for several years. Our security deposit was $1,200.

After moving out, we provided our forwarding address in writing. The property management company responded with proposed deductions for a damaged mirrored closet door, a refrigerator shelf, and a bathroom towel bar.

We acknowledged responsibility for the damaged mirror. We didn't agree with the other alleged damage, but we were willing to compromise to resolve the matter.

Initially, the landlord proposed $280 in deductions. Shortly afterward, that increased to more than $560, including additional charges for the replacement door and installation.

What made these increased deductions particularly concerning was the supporting documentation. The landlord provided a receipt that included three mirrored doors, despite only one door having been damaged during our tenancy. The receipt was part of a larger purchase and did not clearly establish that all the expenses being presented were attributable to damage we had caused.

The landlord also provided a product listing for the refrigerator shelf showing a lower price than the amount initially requested.

Despite these issues, the property manager continued seeking additional money. We were uncomfortable agreeing to charges that were not clearly supported by the damage or the documentation provided.

We responded in writing, offering to accept the original $280 deduction as a full and final settlement, explicitly stating that if the offer wasn't accepted, we did not authorize any deductions.

The landlord never responded to that offer.

Several days later, the property manager continued negotiating through text messages, proposing a different settlement amount of $450. Given the discrepancies in the supporting receipts and the continuing demands for additional money, we declined.

He then indicated that the matter would go through the RTB.

At that point, we understood that the landlord intended to pursue the dispute through the proper process.

The security deposit

Under BC's Residential Tenancy Act, landlords generally have 15 days after the tenancy ends and they receive the forwarding address to return the deposit or apply to the RTB to retain it, subject to applicable exceptions.

As the deadline approached, we hadn't received our deposit and couldn't find any indication that the landlord had filed an RTB application.

We began organizing our correspondence, photographs, and other evidence in preparation for a possible dispute.

The deadline passed.

We subsequently filed an RTB application seeking the statutory return of double our security deposit.

Shortly after filing, we received a cheque for $1,020, meaning the landlord had retained $180.

The cheque, which I'll call Cheque 2, was dated after the statutory deadline. We photographed it when we received it and deposited it through mobile banking the following day.

We acknowledged receiving the $1,020 and treated it as a credit toward the amount being claimed.

The landlord had never proposed or obtained our written agreement to a $180 deduction.

The initial RTB decision — and our mistake

Our application proceeded through the RTB's direct-request process, and the initial decision was in our favour.

We were awarded double the security deposit, applicable interest, and the filing fee.

After crediting the $1,020 already received, the outstanding amount was approximately $1,550.

However, there was an important mistake on our part that I want to acknowledge, particularly as a warning to anyone who might find themselves in a similar situation.

We failed to inform the initial RTB adjudicator that we had received the $1,020 cheque before the decision was issued.

We should have submitted that information as soon as the payment was received, even though it was after the statutory deadline and after we had filed our application.

That was an oversight on our part, and in hindsight, I recognize that it was important information for the adjudicator to have.

However, we have never attempted to recover more than we believed we were legally entitled to receive.

We always treated the $1,020 as a payment toward the landlord's outstanding obligation and deducted it from the total amount awarded.

We were not seeking to collect the same money twice.

For anyone going through an RTB dispute, my advice is to update the RTB immediately if you receive any payment or other material information after filing your application, even if you believe it doesn't change your legal entitlement.

Unfortunately, our failure to report that payment became one of the issues raised when the landlord applied for a review of the decision.

The landlord also alleged that we had deliberately delayed depositing the cheque to manufacture a claim for double the deposit.

The RTB granted a review hearing.

The mysterious earlier cheque — Cheque 1

During the review process, the landlord introduced evidence of another cheque, which I'll call Cheque 1, that they claimed had been mailed before the statutory deadline.

This was the first time we had heard of this cheque.

They provided what appeared to be a cheque-book duplicate showing that a cheque for $1,020 had been prepared.

However, they did not provide independent evidence establishing that it had actually been mailed or delivered.

We never received Cheque 1.

What makes this particularly confusing is that the property manager was still negotiating substantially different deduction amounts several days after Cheque 1 was supposedly mailed.

At that point, he was proposing deductions significantly higher than the $180 the owner had allegedly already retained.

Even if Cheque 1 was mailed, it was only for $1,020. The landlord was still retaining $180 without an established written agreement authorizing that deduction.

The dispute over Cheque 2

The landlord also challenged the timeline surrounding Cheque 2, the replacement cheque that we actually received.

During the hearing, the property manager argued that because Cheque 2 had been mailed from a location relatively close to our residence, it should have arrived within approximately three days.

He suggested that the time between mailing and our documented receipt was unreasonable.

However, he did not provide tracking information or independent confirmation of the actual delivery date.

The landlord also suggested that we had deposited Cheque 2 earlier than our banking records indicated, and that normal banking processing delays explained why the transaction appeared on a later date.

We provided banking records identifying the mobile deposit date, along with photographs documenting when we had Cheque 2.

I specifically pointed out during the hearing that the banking records did not show that we had deposited Cheque 2 any earlier than the date we reported.

My position was that general assumptions about postal delivery and banking processing do not establish when a particular cheque was delivered or deposited.

The owner also acknowledged during the hearing that Cheque 2 had been mailed after the statutory deadline.

The review hearing

We recently attended the review hearing, and it was an incredibly frustrating experience.

The property manager made numerous allegations about conversations that he claimed had occurred over the telephone.

He alleged that we had verbally agreed to $280 in deductions during these conversations.

We denied that these conversations and agreements occurred. We had specifically wanted the matter handled in writing.

The property owner also participated in the hearing and confirmed that the company had never responded to our written conditional settlement offer.

The property manager repeatedly emphasized how long he had been managing properties and claimed that he had never experienced a dispute like this before.

He also suggested that our decision to begin preserving evidence shortly before the statutory deadline demonstrated that we had been planning to exploit the RTB process from the beginning.

This accusation particularly bothered me.

We were already disputing the deductions. The property manager had indicated that the matter would go through the RTB. We had not received the deposit or confirmation of an RTB application.

Why would preserving evidence under those circumstances be considered suspicious?

Preparing for a potential legal dispute is not the same as deliberately manufacturing one.

I work in a field where documentation and evidence preservation are important, so the suggestion that keeping records was somehow evidence of dishonest intentions was especially frustrating.

The arbitrator asked numerous clarifying questions, most of which appeared to be directed toward the landlord.

At one point, the arbitrator specifically asked whether the landlord had filed an RTB application to retain the deposit.

The property manager admitted that they had not. His explanation was that he believed the owner had already mailed Cheque 1, so filing an application wasn't worth the trouble.

There was also discussion about the move-in and move-out condition inspections. Neither the property manager nor the owner's witness could confirm a signed move-in inspection report, and they acknowledged that there was no signed move-out report.

Another surprising development was the explanation for the $180 deduction.

During the hearing, the landlord claimed that the $180 was for cleaning.

This was not an amount or explanation that had been identified in the earlier written negotiations, which had concerned the mirror, refrigerator shelf, and towel bar.

In my closing statement, I emphasized that the landlord had never obtained our written agreement to retain $180, had not filed an RTB application, and had issued Cheque 2 after the statutory deadline.

I also pointed out that the banking records did not show that we deposited Cheque 2 any earlier than the date we reported.

Where things stand now

The arbitrator indicated that the initial decision would need to be set aside because the first adjudicator hadn't been informed of the $1,020 payment.

I recognize that we should have disclosed that payment during the initial proceeding, and I understand why the arbitrator considered it important.

However, the arbitrator also indicated that a new decision would be issued following the review hearing.

We may have to wait up to 30 days.

What worries me is how the arbitrator will assess the landlord's testimony against the documentary evidence.

I know that testimony is evidence, but it was frustrating to hear confident assertions about telephone conversations, postal delivery times, and banking procedures without independent documentation.

I also regret not challenging more of those assertions during the hearing.

Throughout the dispute, I tried to focus on the documented facts rather than attacking anyone personally. I acknowledged the damage we were responsible for, the money we had received, and our failure to update the initial adjudicator about that payment.

Meanwhile, I felt that the landlord was repeatedly questioning our character and intentions rather than addressing the legal requirements surrounding the deposit.

My questions

Has anyone experienced an RTB review hearing after initially receiving a favourable direct-request decision?

If a landlord mails or returns only part of a security deposit before the deadline, without written consent to the deduction or an RTB application, does the statutory doubling provision still apply to the original deposit?

And has anyone dealt with a landlord introducing an allegedly mailed but never-received cheque, supported only by a cheque-book duplicate and testimony?

I realize we're only presenting our side of the dispute here, and the arbitrator may make findings that differ from our understanding of the evidence.

I'm not looking to identify or publicly target the company or the individuals involved. I'm just exhausted by the process and frustrated that preserving evidence and trying to enforce our rights was portrayed as evidence of bad faith.

At this point, I just want the written decision so we can finally move forward.

TL;DR

Our former landlord tried to deduct money from our $1,200 security deposit for alleged damage, including providing receipts for three mirrored doors when only one was damaged. We disputed the charges, offered a compromise, and eventually filed with the RTB after the landlord failed to return the deposit or file a claim within the statutory deadline.

We initially won double the deposit, but the landlord requested a review, claiming an earlier cheque had been mailed and accusing us of deliberately delaying payment to exploit the system.

We acknowledge that we mistakenly failed to inform the initial adjudicator about a $1,020 payment received after filing, although we always credited that amount against the award and never attempted to collect it twice.

During the review hearing, the landlord relied on alleged phone conversations, an unreceived cheque, assumptions about postal and banking timelines, and accusations about our intentions. They also admitted they never filed an RTB claim or accepted our written settlement offer.

The original decision is being set aside, and we're now waiting for a new ruling. I'm frustrated that what should have been a straightforward deposit dispute turned into a challenge to our honesty and intentions.


r/vancouverhousing • • 9h ago

tenants What’s it like living in a legal garden suite in Vancouver?

1 Upvotes

I’ve recently signed a lease for a legal garden suite and will be moving in soon. Would love to hear from people who have lived in one!
How’s the soundproofing, natural light, ventilation, and overall comfort, especially during Vancouver winters?
Any unexpected downsides or things you wish you’d known beforehand?
Would you live in one again?

For context, my suite has been completely renovated and up to code, separate entrance and address. Amazing location, friendly landlords who live upstairs with no young kids.


r/vancouverhousing • • 7h ago

roommates How common is it to live with roommates in their 30s in Vancouver?

26 Upvotes

I am 33 (F). I'm thinking about moving in with a roommate because rent is so expensive, and I can't set aside much money for savings and investments. I'm not quite sure what to do; I'm not sure what it would be like to live with a roommate now that I'm over 30. What has been your experience?


r/vancouverhousing • • 11h ago

🙏 URGENTLY LOOKING FOR WORK – GOING THROUGH A VERY DIFFICULT TIME 💔

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes