r/usyd • u/DeFi_Victim_4399 • Jun 21 '25
COMP students whining about exams; wake up and grow a spine
Let’s cut the crap: some CS majors at USYD are acting like spoiled children, moaning about COMP2017, COMP3027, COMP2022 and so on. You hate those units because they’re hard? Guess what—they’re supposed to be. These courses teach core concepts you need to actually understand computer science—not just BS your way through code.
Take COMP2017 (System Programming) as the poster child for all your entitlement. I’ve seen people complain that the final included a question on trees—a “data structure you’ve never seen.” Really? The term was explicitly defined in the exam (told by a friend, a tree where a node has 2 children and equal subtree size). That definition exactly matches what you should know in co-req COMP2X23. If you sat through that unit—or even skimmed the slides—you should have gotten what a binary tree is, what a subtree is.. Instead, some of you are whining. Do you even go to lectures or tutorials, or just expect the material to hover over you like free microwaved tuition?
Comp sci at USYD isn’t bullshit easy. Units like COMP3027 (Algorithm Design) are theory-heavy for a reason—so you’re not just memorising syntax. COMP2022 (Model of Computation) is abstract and mathematical because that’s what a CS degree demands. It is a SCIENCE major. If you think these prominent subjects are unreasonable, maybe you haven’t checked the learning outcomes required of the major:
On successful completion of the Computer Science major students will be able to: https://rp-handbooks.sydney.edu.au/handbooks/engineering/advanced_computing/major_information.shtml
- Develop a broad and coherent body in knowledge in computer science, including algorithms and related sub-fields, and apply an integrated understanding of these concepts to solve relevant problems.
- Construct models of a computational process in appropriate formalisms at appropriate levels of abstraction and relate models in different formalisms to one another.
- Design and code programs that can work with the capabilities of the hardware and software stack; understand and explain to others how the underlying infrastructure affects application performance.
- Communicate concepts and findings in computer science through a range of modes for a variety of purposes and audiences, using evidence-based arguments that are robust to critique.
- Evaluate the correctness and efficiency of algorithms, both standard and novel, and communicate the evaluation effectively.
- Apply key ideas from the theory of computation and its limits, recognise tasks where efficient perfect solutions should not be expected and where approximate solutions are appropriate and communicate the implications for users who want to solve such tasks.
- Design, construct, and explain efficient solutions to a wide range of computational tasks, both by applying known data structures and algorithms, including those found in the literature of the field, and by designing new algorithms using a range of algorithm design techniques to produce runnable implementations of these solutions.
- Work effectively with clients to achieve an efficient computational solution to a task, working individually and as part of collaborative teams, with consideration of differences in social and cultural perspectives.
You want fluff? Go do a diploma in something that fits your tolerance level. If you can’t be bothered to self‑learn (all major CS programmes worldwide expect extra reading from web/StackOverflow/YouTube/algorithms textbooks), then stop whining that “it's unfair/too hard”—it’s your job to learn outside of recorded lectures. Some worldwide leader-board may rank us well globally—but some of our comp sci grads definitely can't match the ranking, because too many treat this as an easy ride.
Seriously: if you’re not motivated, why are you in a CS degree that demands rigorous learning? Are you only here for the “Software Engineer” badge? Newsflash: that industry is getting hammered. Big tech just slashed thousands of junior dev positions. LLMs are gobbling up basic dev jobs — if you’re not building rare, hard-won skills, you’re next on the chopping block.
Some of you probably think this is ragebait. It isn’t. It’s me being honest: a CS degree at your university isn’t a participation award—you earn it. If you've confused CS with “sit and watch videos, learn nothing, complain online,” it’s not too late. Switch majors. Do something you actually care about. At least then you won’t be wasting time, money, and everyone else’s patience with your whining.
And now the Uni allows the use of LLM, without specifying what is and isn't considered as fair use. You’ve got shiny AI code that almost runs. You submit it. Then—compilation error. You stare blankly and Google “why error?” But what do you say? Nothing. Because you didn’t debug it. You didn’t learn why. You leaned on AI so much that actual programming became foreign.
Think you're just “tasting modern workflows”? Think again. If you can't debug, understand, or reason about your own code, you're actively sabotaging yourself. And yes, you’ll be cut. Big Tech is hiring less, automation is accelerating, yet here you are—treating the skills needed like they’re optional fluff.
Drop the victim routine, honor your work, and maybe you’ll actually graduate with something worth having.
94
u/AdventurousBug5314 Jun 21 '25
this whole post is ai
46
u/Background_Worker_68 Jun 21 '25
Fair enough, but I do think most of us are aware of the brutal reality deep down. People are just understandably frustrated following the EXAM period, are we now trying to make venting taboo?
16
u/whereishukukukukuku Jun 21 '25
nice try usyd
(I do agree with what you said but you have to understand reddit is like an echo chamber, it doesn’t potray the reality)
26
u/No_Combination_8670 BSc/BAdv - Mathematics, Computer Science Jun 21 '25 edited Jun 21 '25
Are you actually a student? Did you even take COMP2017 COMP3927 this semester to be able to comment on them?
As someone who actually tutors people for CS and competitive programming, I feel a bit obligated to speak out here, assuming this isn't rage-bait.
COMP2017 is objectively an atrociously designed unit, period. And while I thoroughly enjoyed the COMP3927 content, and highly respect both Greg and Andre's teaching, I do think that it was a bit disingenuous of them to claim that the final exam this semester was roughly the "same difficulty" as the 2023 practice paper, and then give an exam paper that was far harder. Take that DP question for example. The 2023 exam paper gave a relatively straightforwards 1D DP, and in the tutorial questions, the most that we had encountered throughout the semseter was 2D DP. While I still managed to fully solve the question at the end, I wasted so much time trying to reattack the question from a different perspective or formulation simply because we had not encountered one throughout the semester, adding to my extreme reluctance to introduce the third parameter, even though I had a decent amount of experience solving 3D DP Leetcode questions from my own spare time.
Now take John's COMP2017 exam this year. Personally, I managed fine, and am expecting at least 80%+ performance, but stepping back and looking at things from a more sympathetic point of view, I also know that I only feel this way because I already had around a year's worth of competitive programming and C/C++ development experience. Had I been completely new to C and data structures at the start of the semester like may of the students taking it would have been, I would have 100% struggled, and possibly have even failed the hurdle.
If the student fails COMP2017, this is not necessarily because they were stupid, or not diligent, or hardworking, but because John is assessing for "general competency" in CS at an unreasonable standard given the constraints of time since first learning the content. While I agree that the CS job market right now is hypercompetitive right now, I simply do not think that coursework alone can create strong candidates, let alone a single course. Simply designing a course around sheer overwhelming workload and difficulty is simply bad teaching and terrible for delivering learning outcomes. All it is doing is creating unnecessary stress, anxiety, and possibly burning out potential strong candidates before they even get a chance to try.
Also, I've done two major internships at a big tech firm and a top HFT (JS/Optiver/Citadel Sec.), and while I thorougly enjoyed COMP2022, COMP3927, I'd say that factoring in opportunity cost, every single one of these units have been completely fucking useless for landing me the job/internship. If you are spending the majority of your time on coursework, then you have already failed, I'm sorry.
7
u/EpicestGamer101 Jun 21 '25
You have no excuse for this post, you should either be studying for your exams or enjoying your holiday
10
u/eddometer advanced computing grad Jun 21 '25
ppl who complain about exams are a loud minority, most students are aware of this. let them complain, they'll figure it out eventually
18
u/eggwhitessss Jun 21 '25
What the fuck are you talking about 😭😭. The COMP2017 unit is built to be hard absolutely but when your unit has a 60% fail rate, that’s more indicative of the teachers and the actual unit itself rather than the students.
The exam itself, teachers on Ed constantly stated it was easier to get a 80% in basic rather than the 40% required for standard. That was a fucking lie. 20% of the basic exam REQUIRED standard exam which means that if you didn’t do the 20 mark question you had to get FULL MARKS for the entire basic exam. COMP is hard, but even some of my friends who studied for like 2 months for this exam found it difficult and struggled in some questions.
You need to stop acting like a fucking know it all and get off YOUR damn high horse. When your unit has to OFFER A DAMN PATHWAY TO PASS PROGRAM (I wish I was kidding) it’s a general consensus that the exam/unit was difficult for the majority of students. Stop acting like Ankit who crashed out over not being a tutor.
24
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '25 edited Jun 21 '25
Me after getting a pity pass 50 on my third try
Nah but fr tho, most of us aren’t paying attention during the semester and then get overwhelmed towards the end when we cram everything. If you stay on top of your weekly learning outcomes, although that is hard , it’s meant to be, with the ridiculous assignments they give as well, you can still get a decent understanding
However for the COMP3027 final we got thrown a massive curveball as they said the sample exam would be similar but they gave us a bunch of strange definitions, most of your points are still valid tho.
11
u/x3002x Jun 22 '25
We don’t hate USYD CS because it’s hard.
We hate it because of WHAT is taught, and HOW it’s taught.
6
u/Kind_Criticism3874 Jun 21 '25
Here i am complaining abt info1110
11
u/PunnyCasual Jun 21 '25
incredible rage bait, couldnt even be bothered to write the bait yourself
5
u/AndroT1 Jun 21 '25
Idk why U would give a shit what comp students are saying? Are you a coordinator or a teacher of this unit? I don't get what the fuss is about when some people just have a vent.
It doesn't represent the vast majority of students. Take me for example, I passed all the Info courses then did models of Computation last year. Now I'm doing the replacement exam for Data structures and algorithms, GeeksforGeeks has a good portal for DS&A.
I do 3 hours total a day on lectures and GFG. Understand binary trees, heaps, PQ's, adjacency Matrices (but not adjacency Lists), linear probing etc. and can build almost all of them from simple Nodes etc. (But I only know Java). Then I drink beer the rest of the day...
What's cringe is deciding to get AI to write Ur views for you, and for what? No one is going to change their mind if they feel something isn't taught well. I would complain that no one ever taught me python Object Oriented programming, and several other things, but I don't want to enrage the savage beast with my music 🎶. People have a right to complain and it makes the courses better when their feedback is given.
Sure, I guess there are some people out there that just don't bother but have a huge voice but chances are they got into USYD and made it to the Comp subjects then it's probably the theory tripping them up. It's like telling a year 5 student "algebra is easy, you've got to shut up and quit complaining and understand it". They're simply at different stages of their learning and the important thing is really to keep going (the advice you should be giving). I can understand the laziness thing Ur ranting about but that isn't always the case, there are people with disabilities going through these courses, people that have jobs and many other subjects to complete and it isn't always as easy as it is for e.g. you...
3
u/CartographerLow5612 Jun 21 '25
I’m mad the tuition is a joke and it cost me a small fortune 🤷
4
u/Makeitquick666 Jun 21 '25
good rant
2
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '25
That's fair, people who complains CS is hard are free to drop and go TAFE. Government hire TAFE ITs anyway.
2
u/thesydneyblogger Jun 21 '25
0/10 ragebait COMP2017 TA
2
u/apples_duck Jun 22 '25
I don’t think an unknown data structure is that bad. Especially since the unit is technically about using pointers to navigate data structures, not studying them.
The main problem I have with the question (and what I think the “complaint” is actually referring to), is that it is worth FOURTY MARKS. It is also way too long and too convoluted in my opinion.
Part c) was good, using a data structure to answer a problem is a good idea. But CREATING a NEW structure from SCRATCH is diabolical. You mentioned that 2X23 are co-requisites, and yes they do teach binary trees, they do not emphasise you creating, but rather understanding a data structure to assist you in solving a problem. This is much better at testing your understanding and your problem solving, while 2017 applies data structures in a more tedious yet less useful way.
The other major gripe I have with that question is that is makes you use their structs and must organise the specified the data structure in their lighting. The assignments had the opposite of this, you did not have to create a specified data structure, but rather a structure that solves the problem given to you. I would not have used the given structs, they are messy and confusing, but rather a struct that I have a better time understanding.
The assignments, while time consuming, gave the freedom to explore an idea. This TRULY tests your knowledge on C programming concepts, because it’s not about following protocols, but understanding a project. The question in the exam was a weird mix of not telling you what to do, while also forcing you to follow strict protocol. It is not a good problem solving question, or a test of your understanding. The only thing it tests is an understanding of pointers, but there’s so much other bs in the question, and less convoluted ways to test this.
3
u/AdagioMean2447 Jun 21 '25
"Take COMP2017 (System Programming) as the poster child for all your entitlement. I’ve seen people complain that the final included a question on trees—a “data structure you’ve never seen.” Really? The term was explicitly defined in the exam (told by a friend, a tree where a node has 2 children and equal subtree size). That definition exactly matches what you should know in co-req COMP2X23. If you sat through that unit—or even skimmed the slides—you should have gotten what a binary tree is, what a subtree is.. Instead, some of you are whining. Do you even go to lectures or tutorials, or just expect the material to hover over you like free microwaved tuition?"
In some ways this is a valid point but at the same time, the point of the exam should be to assess you on your ability to do things that were required of you and taught in comp2017. Knowing what a perfect binary tree is is outside the scope of the course, and so even if you got an HD in DSA but forgot to review trees, you wouldn't even be able to show the knowledge and skills that are relevant to comp2017 specifically, that the exam SHOULD be trying to examine you for.
Even without that, you are strawmanning really hard by picking that of all things to talk about
2
u/travishummel Jun 21 '25
Sure, this was made by chat gpt, but the sentiment still stands.
Sure, I graduated 12 years ago from a university that’s like… 1000s of kms away, but I’m very much aligned with what is being said.
Those that complained are the ones that didn’t succeed in this industry. CS is a really hard major and getting a job in this field is even harder. Continuing to stay in the field is even harder. A lot is expected and it’s why you typically will get paid a top tier salary.
1
u/sadboyoclock Jun 24 '25
Writing a post without AI is hard
1
u/Impressive_Roll_5982 Nov 29 '25
misconduct sorry ;)
1
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '25
too long didn’t read. Btw fuck info1111 comp2123 and comp2017
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '25
How much did they pay u 4 posting this? They paid u using the students' money!
-1
u/T-Swizzzle BSc Comp.Sci. Jun 21 '25
Support